HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Aegean

420 karma · joined February 6, 2009

We virtualize Linux on our hypervisor for the ARM architecture.

bbalban@b-labs.com

submissionscomments
Aegean··on Ask HN: What do you want to tell Microsoft?
An operating system roadmap that promises to get leaner, smaller, faster on future versions.

Not to flame but I switched to Ubuntu after Vista and never looked back.

Aegean··on Rate my startup: Make stupid simple websites for work, play and life.
It's very neat. I had a minor issues with changing text formatting. I would make sure they're smooth.

Also the UI updates are mildly slow, e.g. when you press enter for a new line. Could make that a bit simpler/faster.

Aegean··on Threads without locks
I think that's not their point. What they advocate is based on Tony Hoare's CSP model. When you introduce locks and share data, your program suddenly becomes extremely complex to validate. Yes if you are skilled enough, you can lock things and it works (most operating systems would only rarely crash due to locking) but what this brings is true determinism.

The programs become provably stable and deterministic. Furthermore, the determinism can scale. E.g. If you achieve a safely validated program with 10 threads, you can consider that as a single block and replicate and connect it to thousands more, and yet your system remains safe from concurrency bugs.

The downside is that its overkill to separate the program into multiple threads just to make sure you don't have shared data.

But it has its merits, imagine you are developing a mission critical system. Its a powerful thing to claim you have a fully deterministic concurrent system with hundreds of communicating threads in it. Also note that cpus will multiply soon to 64, 128 ... cores, so might as well use some of them for something like this.

Aegean··on Bribing maitre d' to skip the line
My girlfriend looks at me in a way she hasn’t since I surprised her by uncharacteristically demolishing a friend on the tennis court.

That should have been fun.

Aegean··on [dead]
If you buy any new ARM related boards I might buy a few from time to time. E.g. beagleboard and accessories, gumstix, toradex and accessories.
Aegean··on Ask HN: Who's hiring? (September 2010)
Yes, please get in contact by email. I would be interested to hear about what you have done in the past and what interests you in this area.
Aegean··on Ask HN: Who's hiring? (September 2010)
Sure: http://www.b-labs.com/cdocs/b_labs_job_position.txt

This was for the experienced post, but for a hard working enthusiastic individual we can consider lesser experience. Also here's the project site: http://www.l4dev.org/

Aegean··on Ask HN: Who's hiring? (September 2010)
Linux Kernel Engineer, Telecommute/Flexible time/Anywhere in the world.

Experienced: Talented linux kernel engineer with experience on kernel internals, C programming and open source tools.

Graduate: Good C programmer, smart, hard working, open to learning and enthusiastic about kernel programming.

We virtualize Linux on our hypervisor for ARM architecture.

Aegean··on Rely your web startup on Rackspace Cloud? Think again
We had a similar problem with another vps provider. Some php script was remotely exploited and sending spam. They disabled the VPS. Our website and email was down for 24 hours. They enabled the VPS the next day for us to look at it. What's worse I was asked to reinstall the VPS and it took me some convincing for them to enable it so I get my data from the server.

Lesson learned? I think you should never have any operations where you don't have full control. This still holds true but it was a bit ironic because to have full control I ran everything on the VPS, effectively transferring full control to the VPS provider! It was the single point of failure.

Now I will transfer each different service to a different provider. Email to rackspace, websites to a host, git services to github and so on.

Aegean··on Ask HN: Online website creator?
We don't need a complex web application. We need a decent-looking website that describes the company, the products, possibly using rich content. A contact form, an integrated blog would also be nice.

But we need something more than a basic wordpress theme really. They look too primitive. So it comes down to adding a bit of your own design, but if you go for a fully custom design than it comes down to project managing and building a whole website. Therefore I am considering a website builder to be a solution that is somewhere inbetween.

Aegean··on Out of necessity, tech startups are changing the way workers are hired
For your "cooperative and preemptive multitasking" - it's not my question - see the link on the article: http://www.rethinkdb.com/blog/2010/06/will-the-real-programm...

They asked this on RethinkDB interview. I found a similarity and just mentioned it. FYI its a pretty common terminology.

I also don't care what you think about my ego. I made a candid post for a problem I am facing. If you criticize that's very welcome but try to make it a bit constructive.

Aegean··on Out of necessity, tech startups are changing the way workers are hired
You are laying out certain facts well; if you are doing rare work on an expert subject its unlikely that anyone with the expertise will risk their time and career with your work.

But I have not anywhere suggested that I am not willing to do the hard work. In fact it's exactly the opposite. I am doing all the hard technical work that is sometimes too much. So what do you do? You look to transfer some of it to someone else. The fact is however, only the smallest bit of hard work requires so much that you might as well do it yourself by adding an extra 1 hour to it rather than wait for someone to do it, communicate, and get it done in a week. So you look for expertise.

And you don't have to know the details of a specific kernel or a TCP/IP stack. A very good C programmer in general will do well enough.

The other trait that is highly acceptable is not knowing a lot, but being hard working and enthusiastic. We have one engineer like this who knew nothing and in 1 year he is a wizard in linking, build systems, python, locking, drivers ... I am all up for teaching patiently, but finding someone who has that vigor and enthusiasm is also very hard.

To your do-it-yourself suggestion. You need to acknowledge the problem of scalability and look for ways to expand your team because you are then a scalability bottleneck. I am not saying I know how to do it, otherwise I wouldn't be doing the earlier post. But I am at least considering ways to fix it.

Aegean··on Out of necessity, tech startups are changing the way workers are hired
It's exactly the same problem we are facing. When the job requires very high technical skills its a dead end. I am looking for talented kernel engineers. If I go for employing someone high caliber, the costs would be in the 100K >= range. Not a smooth option for a startup. Also it's still hard to attract them even if you pay well. If I go for contractors, there is the problem of IP disclosure. Contractors are probably worse; you disclose IP, pay more, and they disappear after certain level of training investment. You are back to square one.

If you get someone with lesser talent, (done twice, and parted ways after several months) it's also terrible. In this case you usually pay for nothing. E.g. a month of struggle with code, reaching nowhere, dumping their code. This happened a few times.

The hiring is also key. If you have 8 high-caliber engineers, it means you get many times more done. What you could do in one year is done in, say 3 months. A huge difference for a startup.

I have been thinking about hiring talented grad students like they did, maybe that's the best way to go. So its really a tough problem with no straightforward solution.

From the article: We try to ask about the difference between cooperative and preemptive multitasking.

I ask what is kernel preemption. Silence. A blocking mutex and a spinlock? Silence. I think a good candidate should know what event-based and threaded programming means, and even go further to explain the implications and best scenarios for both. Its not easy to get that far.

Aegean··on Science Only Has Two Legs
So lets define it, its a tool.
Aegean··on Thesis HN: People are now targeting blog posts at Hacker News
I think the reasoning behind upvoting for each reader is much more complicated than that.
Aegean··on James Gosling: Some more comments about the Oracle Java lawsuit
From a point where he goes slightly off topic, but I really liked it:

It's not so much that the game favors evil, but that the definition of "good" is really twisted: Good adj: anything which increases the stock price. Considerations about employees, products, customers and community are all secondary. They only enter the equation as ways to achieve goal 1. Morality or high principles have no place in the corporate discourse. They maximize the stock price, within the bounds of the law. Corporations like Oracle and Exxon tend to be perfectly rational. They "buy laws" because it's perfectly legal to spend money on lobbyists and political campaigns. While you and I might think that it is morally reprehensible to buy elections, like the recent case with Target, it is nonetheless totally legal. Given the rules of the game, it would be bad for a corporation to not buy an election, if failing to do so would negatively impact their stock price. I could rant for a long time on this one, but not today… The whole modern concept of a public company is deeply flawed. But the game is what it is.

Aegean··on Facebook is the first to jump into ARM servers
Who says ARM is going to be 32 bits? Rumors say they're going for 64 bits especially for servers. They will need to surpass 4GB limit on >=8 cores per chip.
Aegean··on Ray Kurzweil does not understand the brain
The article has a point that Ray Kurzweil's claims are nonsense, but lets not focus on his claims on genome-to-protein-to-brain cells mechanism. What's rather more important is how the brain does what it does and how that compares with today's computers.

There are 50 to 100 billion neurons in the human brain and the power of the brain comes from the fact that you can create many orders of magnitude more neural circuit combinations with those neurons. Each cell may be part of many circuits, and learning involves the forming of these circuits. Now, lets compare that phenomenal power with the power of the computer. It becomes especially laughable when you say its 50MB worth of information.

Aegean··on Our Git Workflow: Private Development, Public Releases
Excellent. We do open source development and I was about to write a complex script that moves patches around to be able to keep a few private commits and still stay in sync with the single-commit release repos.
Aegean··on How to Write an Operating System
I tried to build one from scratch based on my own L4 microkernel. Given the bloated nature of monolithic kernels and their irrelevance to embedded space, I had the thought that if I wrote something small and neat it could gain traction for embedded systems. For that I took the BSD virtual memory design, and implemented a complete VM system from scratch. Then I wrote a VFS layer but that one was partially complete. I had demand paging implemented and supporting calls like fork() execve() etc. It was challenging and fun - but an incomplete project, also my biggest error from a startup/making money point of view. Basically having a new kernel is a hard sell nowadays, no matter how neat it is. It was more of an intellectual challenge for me rather than a startup - but still I was in the expectation that it could be a success.

About exactly a year ago, I changed my direction to virtualization. I ditched about %60 of the software that includes all that VM layer and VFS for which I put loads of effort (many man months...). I realized I was out of focus, so I changed my focus to enhancing only the microkernel itself. I decided upon three specific goals: 1) Adding multi-core support for latest ARM cores (e.g. the ones that will be on most high-end mobile phones and devices) 2) Adding fine-grain security and control based on capabilities. (in short, having control over system calls) 3) Adding virtualization support for the linux kernel. Right now I am done with the first two, and about to get done with the 3rd one.

My interest has always been to create something new in the OS/kernel space. After doing much research I decided that L4 microkernel design represents the most promising work in this field. This is because a) monolithic kernels are mature and good for what they are doing b) microkernels can solve certain new problems like virtualization.

Eventually I was convinced that embedded virtualization would be the most interesting problem I could solve. In my opinion there is still room for systems-level work particularly in Virtualization. The APIs are not set in stone. Not many people know how virtualization works, let alone design an interface for it from scratch.

I think new areas like this will come up but its quite important to spot an unsolved problem because if you dive in to write a kernel its an expensive journey.

Aegean··on The shit finally hits the fan....(James Gosling on Oracle vs Google)
OK but it's not convincing to think Google would have thought, oh Sun is a company that is nice to open source, so lets base our whole Android operating environment on this open source friendly Java language and JVM and disregard any possibility of being sued. I would think such companies would think about the possibility of someone else taking over or generally anything else happening. Its unprofessional to base your business decision on something as vague as attitude. You need something more solid like an agreement - especially for something as big as Android.

So anyway my understanding is probably Google has some agreement or plan at hand for this situation. Ideas welcome.

Aegean··on The shit finally hits the fan....(James Gosling on Oracle vs Google)
OK but, did google not really think about this possibility? I think it was a very obvious risk and I would think they probably had a plan for this.
Aegean··on What Happened to Yahoo
I loved the last sentence on hacker culture:

"But there are worse things than seeming irresponsible. Losing, for example."

Aegean··on Stephen Hawking: mankind must move to outer space within a century
That which who downvoted me, did you actually read Hawking's article?
Aegean··on Ask HN: What Vim Plugins do you use?
Fugitive. Cscope. taglist

I also have NERDTree but very seldomly use it.

Aegean··on Stephen Hawking: mankind must move to outer space within a century
I didn't know about this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis

Aegean··on Minimalism Isn’t the Alpha and Omega of Design
The term 'design' is taken differently here, with more emphasis on art than engineering.

If you're engineering a piece of work, your design will surely be better if it is minimalistic. But if what you mean by 'design' is an artistic approach, certainly minimalism is not a goal.

Aegean··on How RedGate hired 10 geeks in five weeks
I was expecting to see a mixergy-style talent story where they got 10 geeks with intuition and little spending. I don't see the intuition or talent here.
Aegean··on Frenzy As Delicious Founder Joshua Schachter Raises Round For New Startup
An open source OS for UAVs? If he can do it just like that by throwing in some money I would be surprised. I think his venture is something else.
Aegean··on Red Hat, 16%. Canonical, 1% contribution to GNOME
I won't know about Canonical's claims but it is sure that they're perceived to have more impact on desktop than Red Hat, and that's a very fair perception regardless of the number of commits Redhat does on one particular piece of the desktop.

Linux has been starving of a good, stable desktop, and Ubuntu has provided that. Regarding free-ride, sorry but that's how open source software works. If Ubuntu credits itself for code that RedHat wrote that's not right, but if Ubuntu claims they changed the Linux desktop they have a very reasonable point regardless of who wrote what.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →