HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ajedi32

13,439 karma · joined January 5, 2015

submissionscomments
Ajedi32··on How much oil-market buffer is left?
Unlike wars, EV adoption is a slow, steady, relatively predictable process. I don't think it'll have a very noticeable impact on gas prices the way short term crisis tend to.

The much more noticeable factor will be reducing how many people even care about gas prices in the first place.

Ajedi32··on How much oil-market buffer is left?
That's the main issue, yes. But where was all that oil Iran was producing going before their infrastructure was destroyed? Are you claiming they only ever used it domestically and didn't export any of it? That seems unlikely.
Ajedi32··on America's Driver's License Breach Is a National Security Disaster
"such firms" being any and all IT companies?

They would still exist, just not in any country insane enough to pass a ridiculous law like this.

Ajedi32··on America's Driver's License Breach Is a National Security Disaster
Yes, there are some people who thrive on risk and will do things like jump off a mountain in a wing suit just for the thrill of it. That doesn't mean making that sort of personal recklessness legally mandatory for employment is a good idea.

This sort of personal liability OP is proposing would just ensure the security industry is dominated by highly compensated compulsive gamblers because nobody else is insane enough to take the risk. It's an absolutely ridiculous idea.

Ajedi32··on An update on Wayback Machine access
What if you're not charging for the content, but as compensation for the network bandwidth / server resources consumed by serving that content? The idea isn't to profit from content (the IA is a nonprofit anyway), just to allow the IA to continue to serve its purpose as an archive of public data without being overwhelmed by bots.
Ajedi32··on New $100k H-1B visa fee pushes tech jobs offshore
So lack of supply isn't the problem, it's the people who want a place to live who are the problem? Would you make this same argument if the increased demand was from people being born rather than immigration (because it is both)?

I think if you want to be able to block your neighbors from building denser housing on their property then that should only be enforceable if it was agreed to by everybody in advance when they bought the place (e.g. via an HOA contract or some similar type of restriction on the property deed). Otherwise this is tantamount to allowing Walmart to get a vote on whether to allow Target to set up next door.

Ajedi32··on New $100k H-1B visa fee pushes tech jobs offshore
> Or the local going rate for qualified personel were higher than you were willing to pay (which per def is true, if you had to bring in foreign work?).

Yeah, by definition this is pretty much always true, no? No matter how scarce local workers are, if you were willing to offer double the market rate you could probably find someone. Scarcity and price are two sides of the same coin, that's how markets work. Bringing in labor from another country when local talent is scarce both reduces costs/wages and reduces scarcity.

Ajedi32··on Silicon Valley is transforming the military-industrial complex? (2024)
I think saying you "refuse to work for companies that do military work" because you "don't want to deal with moral grey zones" is a pretty binary choice with not a lot of nuance, but whatever. I think both our positions have been made pretty clear at this point and I'm not that interested in continuing to debate the semantics of previous comments.
Ajedi32··on Show HN: What if the speed of light was 5 km/h?
Yes, in your reference frame. That's one of the basic tenants of relativity.
Ajedi32··on Silicon Valley is transforming the military-industrial complex? (2024)
The "I" a person. If a company has no employees, it ceases to exist in any meaningful sense, so if you refuse to work for such companies you better hope somebody else will do so in your place.

Just to be clear, the conversation so far:

> beloch: It's also completely fine to say, "I don't want to deal with moral grey zones" and refuse to work for companies that do military work.

> JumpCrisscross: Idk, there's something unethical in outsourcing ethical grey areas [working for defense contractors] to other people while reaping the benefits of the peace (or war far from your home) it brings.

> sophacles: "someone else will do it if i don't".... (aka your argument)

> me: That's not the argument. It's more like "if I don't [work for defense contractors] then I better hope somebody else will. [Because strict pacifism isn't tenable.]

You then somehow interpreted this comment as me saying "a nation taking actions off the table "will inevitably become subservient to a despotic regime"", which wasn't at all what I said, so I jumped back in correct that. Then the whole conversation went off the rails.

Ajedi32··on Silicon Valley is transforming the military-industrial complex? (2024)
This isn't about the nations taking actions off the table, it's about:

> Serious question: should companies not participate in contracts from their country's defense department?

I contend that unless you want your government to be toppled by a foreign invader, companies contributing to your nation's military capabilities is something you should generally be in favor of.

Ajedi32··on Silicon Valley is transforming the military-industrial complex? (2024)
> "someone else will do it if i don't".... (aka your argument)

That's not the argument. It's more like "if I don't do it then I better hope somebody else will, otherwise my whole country will inevitably become subservient to a despotic regime". Basically, the question is whether strict pacifism is a tenable national policy in the real world. All of modern and ancient history up to this point seems to suggest it is not.

Ajedi32··on Show HN: What if the speed of light was 5 km/h?
I'm using Firefox, can't re-produce. How did you navigate away without first freeing your cursor? I just pressed escape like the browser message said to, but then obviously at that point the cursor was already free so I couldn't test whether navigating away would free it. Closing the tab with Ctrl+W does also free the cursor.
Ajedi32··on Show HN: What if the speed of light was 5 km/h?
Because the doppler effect shifts all light coming from that direction to infrared, which your eyes can't see.
Ajedi32··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
Depends on how much you trust the government's ability to restrain itself once the capability for mass surveillance is out there and widely deployed.
Ajedi32··on LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby
My understanding is that this is difficult due to DRMd content refusing to work with Free operating systems.

Because yes, this nonsense would never fly in a world where Software Freedom enabled a competitive market for TV operating systems.

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
I'm confused. Are you saying Graphene doesn't implement secure boot? Or that you don't think requiring users to wipe their phone and install a custom OS build before exercising their freedom makes exercising that freedom harder?

> You're just whining because you wish you could have root access on your system

This is false, and I think it's intellectually unhealthy to use your perception of a person's motives as an excuse to avoid mentally engaging with the substance of their argument.

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
I said it's borderline not-free, not actually not-free so I don't know why you just wrote 7 paragraphs arguing against something I didn't say and have explicitly and repeatedly disclaimed.

Yes, GrapheneOS is free, but it has implemented features that are designed to make it harder to exercise that freedom, namely secure boot which puts it one short step (of baking their key in hardware) away from being exactly what that paragraph describes as not free.

(And I think you are the one misunderstanding the FSF's quote. They're mocking "secure boot" as perverse terminology for what the FSF calls "tivoization" or "lockdown". They're saying those things are one in the same. I personally wouldn't go that far, as I agree with you the software is still free as long as the key used for secure boot is not baked in to the hardware, and I think the security benefits of secure boot are real and not perverse. But the FSF itself is arguing against the whole idea, at least in this article.)

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
I'm not asking for anything, I'm telling you what they are doing, and what they are doing is going right up to (but not quite crossing) the line of blocking you from modifying the software on your phone.

To re-iterate:

> If the program is delivered in a product designed to run someone else's modified versions but refuse to run yours—a practice known [...] in its practitioners' perverse terminology as “secure boot”—freedom 1 becomes an empty pretense

GrapheneOS literally implements secure boot, using a key you do not control. So if you install GrapheneOS, the Graphene devs have the ability to push updates to the code running on your phone but you yourself do not unless you completely uninstall GrapheneOS and wipe all data on the phone.

The only thing preventing this from being actually anti-freedom rather than merely borderline anti-freedom is that if you choose to completely un-install Graphene and wipe your phone there's currently nothing that will prevent you from installing another OS built with a different signing key (aside from the inconvenience and technical difficulty of doing so). If there were, then this would be a textbook example of what the FSF explicitly calls "not free software" in that quote.

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
For what it's worth this isn't just my "personal taste". I think Richard Stallman and the Free Software Foundation, at least, would agree with my definition[1]:

> Freedom 1 includes the freedom to use your changed version in place of the original. If the program is delivered in a product designed to run someone else's modified versions but refuse to run yours—a practice known as “tivoization” or “lockdown,” or (in its practitioners' perverse terminology) as “secure boot”—freedom 1 becomes an empty pretense rather than a practical reality. These binaries are not free software even if the source code they are compiled from is free.

[1]: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html#make-changes:~:t...

I didn't say anything about what GrapheneOS devs must do. They don't have to do anything. I just think that some of what they are doing comes close to impinging on software freedom in the same way proprietary software does regularly (though again, Graphene doesn't quite cross that line, in my opinion).

Ajedi32··on Audacity 4.0
Best thing is it's not just a new coat of paint; there seem to be some very significant usability improvements in here.
Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
It's not flagged now. But yes, way too many people use flags as an "I disagree" button these days. I feel like that used to be very rare (even down-votes aren't supposed to be used that way) and is becoming more common, though maybe it's always been this way and I just hadn't been on HN long enough to notice the pattern until now.
Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
> Well GrapheneOS would still be free software?!?!? It's the software from those companies that wouldn't be.

I think I have a broader definition of software freedom than you do. In this hypothetical scenario, GrapheneOS itself may technically be "free software" in the sense that the source code is open, but it would still be cooperating in a intentional scheme to prevent you, the user, from modifying it to work the way you want. Same deal if they started selling locked hardware with their signing key hard coded so you can't install a fork. You would legally have the ability to fork the software, but technical measures would be preventing you from running it.

Granted, they're not doing that, but it's one short step away. That's why I say it's borderline anti-freedom, not that it actually is.

I don't think it makes a difference whether the means employed to make a piece of software non-free are legal (copyright law) or technical (DRM, remote attestation, hardware locks). It's still restricting your freedom.

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
> Software freedom is about being able to use the software the way you want

You can't use the software in the way you want if it uses hardware backed cryptography to block you from doing so.

> you get access to the sources, you modify them, build them and run them

This is completely infeasible for 99% of the population. If you technically have a freedom but have no practical way to exercise it, it may as well not exist.

You could argue "but someone else could modify it for you, build it, and make an easy way for you to install it", and normally I'd accept that, but given that installing that modified version would require you to completely reset your phone and install the new modified OS from scratch, I think it's debatable at that point whether you'd still be running Graphene, rather than a fork. And if exercising your freedom requires you to stop running Graphene and start running something else, is it really fair to say Graphene itself supports that freedom? Like I said, borderline.

If you're still not convinced, consider what would happen if companies started using remote attestation to verify you're running the official GrapheneOS build and block forks...

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
Thinking about possible ways they could retain the same security properties without impinging software freedom... maybe there's a way they could make the root of trust default to a signing key embedded in the device's own secure hardware? Then by default that key could sign Graphene's own signing certificate to allow them to push updates, but the user would retain the ability to revoke that signature and sign someone else's certificate instead (or their own certificate) if they decided they didn't trust Graphene anymore, or wanted to give themselves root.
Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
You can't grant yourself admin access with the official build. Only the Graphene devs have the ability to push changes to the OS on your phone. Yes you can fork the software and build a version with your own signing key, then wipe your phone and install your custom build and thereby take back control, but then is that really still Graphene?

I think it's fair to say that that's at least borderline anti software freedom, even if it's true they have good security reasons for doing things that way.

Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
On F-Droid that's just the entire store.
Ajedi32··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
Verified boot does indeed make this more complicated, but it's totally possible to build Graphene with your own signing key and get full control over the OS that way (i.e. https://github.com/schnatterer/rooted-graphene).

Looking at their public statements on the matter, it seems like the problem isn't exactly that they treat the user as a potentially hostile actor so much as that they treat the system UI and persistent storage as a potentially hostile actor (though I admit from a practical perspective that's nearly the same thing): https://www.reddit.com/r/GrapheneOS/comments/13264di/is_root...

I wonder how they'd feel about something like protected confirmation to enable sudo: https://source.android.com/docs/security/features/protected-...

Ajedi32··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
Google already allows web installs on Android, no regulation required. But yes, iOS allowing that would be excellent.
Ajedi32··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
> What are the alternative shops you're referring to here?

In this analogy, the alternative shop that is preventing you from buying stuff from its competitors without a 24 hour wait is the Play Store monopoly.

> but there could easily be a world in which your 'alternative' verifier would still make you wait 24h (or longer).

Then in this hypothetical world where there were a free market for verifiers rather than a single, monopolistic choice, I would choose another alternative verifier that doesn't make me wait 24 hours, or no verifier at all.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →