HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ajedi32

13,439 karma · joined January 5, 2015

submissionscomments
Ajedi32··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
From a user perspective I think F-Droid is really good too, mainly because it only allows FOSS apps by default, which cuts out a lot of the BS you see in Play Store apps.

You can go download a random, no-name app from F-Droid and be very confident it does what it says on the tin and won't be riddled with ads or spam you with notifications.

Ajedi32··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
It's honestly not that big of a problem. Probably some anti-trust legislation can/should be passed to make installing F-Droid and the like easier, but it's already pretty easy. If enough popular apps start requiring you to install them through F-Droid then that'll become normalized and Google will lose its soft monopoly in this space, which is an outcome I'm all for.
Ajedi32··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
What were they legally required to do after their research uncovered this "causal evidence" in your opinion? Shut down?

Cars get into crashes and kill people everyday, yet I don't think it would be appropriate to sue car manufacturers for this harm, solely under the grounds that they "knew about it and ignored it", even if they conducted a study finding a clear causal link between the existence of cars and roadway deaths.

In general, I think our legal system ought not to punish people or organizations for failing to do things that they have no clear legal mandate to do. This is a general claim that I don't feel I need to know all the details of the case to make, though you're certainly welcome to provide specifics if you think they would change my opinion about this specific situation.

> Do you think that the lawyers for meta, the courts and the plaintiffs would have gotten away with such throw away arguments?

No, because unfortunately our legal system doesn't work the way I'm saying it should. If someone feels you have injured them in some way, they can sue you even if you acted in good faith and broke no laws, and if they can demonstrate harm, even indirect harm, they have a good chance of winning. It makes for a very unstable legal environment.

Ajedi32··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
How? Certainly not by judicial fiat.

I'm not saying I'm against passing laws on this subject. My point is that no such laws currently exist, but a bunch of lawyers and judges just decided Facebook owes $17B for breaking these non-existent laws anyway.

Ajedi32··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
There's a law against that. There's currently no law against making a website so fun that kids will waste all their time playing with it if their parents let them.
Ajedi32··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
So if a person at your company claims you're "causing harm" in a vague, indirect way that's not explicitly against the law, you're legally obligated to both agree with them and change your whole business model to accommodate that? Apparently yes, but I personally think that's pretty dumb.

And no I haven't read all the details, it's an extremely broad settlement that apparently covers everything from vague allegations of harm caused by social media addiction to Cambridge Analytica's misuse of data obtained through Facebook's API. There are too many claims to investigate all of them individually in detail without making that a full time job, so I'm speaking in broad terms here about how I think our legal system ought to function.

Ajedi32··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
If you can get sued for $16B for not having age verification then it's already required.
Ajedi32··on Meta reaches $17B settlement over social media harms to children
This isn't regulation. If it was regulation, Meta could just read the regulation and comply and they'd be in the clear. This is the judicial branch making up and enforcing regulations that don't exist based on their own personal opinions about what causes "harm". No way to know what you need to do to comply until after you're already getting sued.
Ajedi32··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
Well, just off the top of my head... if you wanted to treat the increased prices caused by the spike in demand as an externality (and I agree that's not exactly the right way to think of it, but people seem determined to in this case and I can't really fault them for that given the practical effects of such price increases) I think the way to do that would be to give existing consumers futures contracts for water for the next ~10 years proportional to their existing usage.

People could then either use the futures contracts to keep the price they pay for water the same as it was, or voluntarily reduce their water usage and sell the contracts to the datacenter for a profit. Same deal for power.

This would of course be a bit complicated for most people to manage, so maybe instead of giving consumers the contracts directly you could have some intermediary manage the contracts for them with approximately the same result.

Ajedi32··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
I... agree? Did you even read the comment you replied to?
Ajedi32··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
You don't need a law to force people to pay for resources they consume; basic economics already ensures that. If there are externalities not already accounted for by that (increased demand for water/electricity driving up costs for others, noise, "eyesores", etc.) you could pass laws to ensure those costs are paid by the responsible party but that's not a datacenter-specific issue.
Ajedi32··on Adafruit USB Type C CC Resistor Fixer
It is needed for basic operation, because unlike with a A-to-B cable, power bricks plugged into a USB-C cable have no way of knowing whether the other side is also a power supply that will short out if you try to feed it power instead of drawing power from it. A couple resistors in the sink is probably the cheapest possible way of signaling this information to the supply. This isn't PD, it's just a basic requirement to allow having the same connector on both ends of the cable.
Ajedi32··on Anna's Archive Owes $340 Million, Lost Several Domains, but It's Still Online
Public libraries lend DVDs and Blu-Rays yet Netflix still exists.
Ajedi32··on Adafruit USB Type C CC Resistor Fixer
I don't think you understand the problem. Unlike a USB-A power supply, a USB-C power supply cannot just assume by default that the device you plugged into it is not another power supply. That would risk causing a short and potentially starting things on fire.

I suppose that instead of a $0.01 resistor to request power they could have mandated some kind of (probably more expensive) circuit breaker that detects the short and shuts things off before it causes a fire, but I suspect then instead of broken devices having missing resistors you'd get ones with missing circuit breakers...

It pretty hard (maybe impossible) to design a spec that still works when manufacturers randomly omit critical components for no reason.

Ajedi32··on Adafruit USB Type C CC Resistor Fixer
It's not the cable that's the problem here; it's the device you're plugging into the cable.

You don't need a cable tester to detect this problem; just plug the device into a spec-compliant USB-C power brick with a USB-C cable and see if it fails to charge.

Ajedi32··on Adafruit USB Type C CC Resistor Fixer
If you need this, it's not the charger that's broken but the device you're plugging into it.
Ajedi32··on MS Paint and Photos inivisibly watermark even locally generated output with GUID
Paint.net is freeware, but it is not open source.
Ajedi32··on AI boosted homework scores, then exam scores dropped: study
Okay, but this article isn't about that:

> The study followed 27,000 pupils aged 12 to 18

Ajedi32··on AI boosted homework scores, then exam scores dropped: Study
> The replacement is students maturing into functional adults

By what means? Have you got a magic wand that will turn 3rd graders into mature functional adults who will study on their own without homework?

Ajedi32··on AI boosted homework scores, then exam scores dropped: study
Seems this did effectively abolish homework if AI is now doing it all for them. The result seems to be that fewer students pass the exams, not more.

As with any skill, practice is necessary to achieve competence. If homework is no longer a viable way to force students to practice, you'll need to find some replacement, you can't just abolish it and expect there to be no negative consequences.

Ajedi32··on India has paved the way for charging merchants a fee on UPI transactions
"They could theoretically seize control of everything anyway, so we should just let them seize control of everything now without a fight" doesn't seem like a great argument to me.

Things like the constitution, separation of powers, checks and balances, and decentralized control of communication and commerce serve as bulwarks against tyranny. That they all could be dismantled in the future is not an argument against doing our best to preserve them now. Tyranny is not a binary state, it's a gradient with many steps along the path thereto.

(Also, "taking money out of the system" is not optional; payment systems cost money to maintain whether it's done by a private entity or by government.)

Ajedi32··on India has paved the way for charging merchants a fee on UPI transactions
You realize you're arguing for a monopoly, right? One where competition is not only non-existent but also illegal, and which has complete control over how you're allowed to spend your money.

I think arguing "but it's a democratic monopoly" is little comfort in this situation. Maybe you trust your government not to ever be incompetent or to use the powers granted by this monopoly in a way you disapprove of. Maybe in the short term you'd even be right to do so. But I think history has proven that over the long term that's a very foolish assumption to make.

Ajedi32··on I requested a copy of my data from McDonald’s loyalty program
If Five Guys' ingredients cost more in absolute terms, they can afford a smaller markup percentage-wise so that's not necessarily a good comparison. I think despite their larger mark up McDonald's is still significantly cheaper.
Ajedi32··on I requested a copy of my data from McDonald’s loyalty program
Regardless, it would be even more expensive without reductions in staffing. It's not like they could be hiring twice as many employees at half the cost each and are just choosing not to. Fast food is a highly competitive market.
Ajedi32··on I requested a copy of my data from McDonald’s loyalty program
It's fast food. The focus is on price over all else. If they maintained the staffing levels from back then, then instead of poor service you'd be complaining that a Big Mac costs $15.
Ajedi32··on I requested a copy of my data from McDonald’s loyalty program
What an awful article. Just spent like 10 minutes digging through a pile of ideologically loaded buzzwords and implied accusations of racism trying to find anything concrete the authors are accusing Target of actually doing. Closest thing I can find is a vague allusion to Target donating money to a city to fund security cameras?
Ajedi32··on As AI eats the web, the internet’s collective memory is disappearing
There are other people in those bubbles, it's not an isolated void. HN is one such bubble. Yes it's a smaller bubble, there's not nearly as many people here as there were watching broadcast television back in the 1980s, but it would be wrong to say there is no culture here. Same goes for the millions of other small communities out on the web and social media. But as I said, it's certainly true there are downsides associated with that diversity.
Ajedi32··on As AI eats the web, the internet’s collective memory is disappearing
Maybe we just need a standardized way to publish a dump of your content to BitTorrent? Remove the incentive to scrape.
Ajedi32··on As AI eats the web, the internet’s collective memory is disappearing
Those hosting content for ad views, or for fame or other personal gain.

Sites like Wikipedia or developer documentation pages which exist to distribute knowledge for its own sake don't have any reason to care whether that knowledge is consumed by a human or a computer being used by a human.

Ajedi32··on As AI eats the web, the internet’s collective memory is disappearing
If "getting the knowledge out there" is the motivation then it shouldn't matter whether the knowledge gets filtered through an AI or not.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →