HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ajedi32

13,439 karma · joined January 5, 2015

submissionscomments
Ajedi32··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
It worked great for the last several hundred years. The problem is that as government keeps expanding to control more and more of our lives, every decision it makes it necessarily imposes on everyone, whether they agree with that decision or not.

E.g. In a country of 100M people, if 60% agree with a bill and it becomes law, the country has imposed that law on 40M people against their will. That's just as true in a dictatorship as it is in a democracy. The more areas of our lives government involves itself in, the bigger this problem becomes.

Ajedi32··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
> I can also vote out my government.

You can't. Not if you're in the minority. Tyranny of the majority is still tyranny.

You what you as an individual most certainly can do is stop using Roblox. Not ideal, but way easier than moving to a new country.

Ajedi32··on Just Let Me Write Digits
I've seen cases where it was done well, but unless you're willing to invest great engineering effort into making sure it's done well, the built-in version (which already has had a lot of engineering effort put into it) is almost always going to be better.
Ajedi32··on Just Let Me Write Digits
Yes, for every time a bug like this is discovered and reported, there are probably hundreds of times when someone else just gave up or found a work around after much frustration.

I'm frequently astonished by how terrible and buggy modern software can get away with being and still survive. Working around bugs to accomplish what I need to accomplish is so normal to me now that I sometimes don't even notice how terrible the software is until I see someone less technically skilled than me try to use it.

Ajedi32··on StreetComplete: Fixing OpenStreetMap, one tiny quest at a time
Usually in OSM there are several different ways to map things, to varying levels of detail. (E.g. As you discovered, you can just tag a road as having sidewalks, or trace out the actual sidewalks themselves.) Generally, as long as the information you're adding is accurate, you're helping. Changing tagging schemes later is a lot easier than re-discovering that information from scratch. If you're really concerned, usually the wiki has good information on what is currently considered best practice.

Incidentally, I think for crossings StreetComplete now only asks about the actual crossing nodes, so no more duplicate quests.

Ajedi32··on StreetComplete: Fixing OpenStreetMap, one tiny quest at a time
Sort of. It was added in 2023. (https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/pull/5373)
Ajedi32··on CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps
Yeah a lot of these features exist, they're just very fragmented, which given that the OSM community is already pretty small makes it almost impossible for them to reach the critical mass necessary to actually be useful.

You can go look up pretty much any tiny, hole-in-the-wall restaurant on Google Maps and there'll be dozens of user-contributed pictures of the interior, the menu, etc, but on OSM you'll be lucky if the opening hours are accurate.

I'm not sure there's a good solution to this, but certainly more OSM front ends exposing the data and contribution tools to end users helps.

Ajedi32··on StreetComplete: Fixing OpenStreetMap, one tiny quest at a time
Usually if I need to add a footpath I use the "Create new track recording" feature to trace out the path with GPS, then come back to it later on desktop. Adding paths is pretty awkward to do on mobile, especially since there's no satellite overlay.
Ajedi32··on StreetComplete: Fixing OpenStreetMap, one tiny quest at a time
StreetComplete lets you place trash cans and benches too (among other things) using the "Things" overlay. IMO Every Door has a much more complicated UI, though it's also more of a full featured editor than StreetComplete. (Though still less so than something like Vespucci.)
Ajedi32··on AI can't be listed as inventor on patent applications, Japan's top court rules
> there continued to be people who decided what got built

The distinguishing feature of capitalism is that the people who decide what gets built are private individuals in competition with each other, and incentivised by profit to meet the demands of consumers.

In communism the people who decide what gets built are part of a single central authority with no competitors and no profit motive. That system doesn't work, which is why it collapsed.

Ajedi32··on AI can't be listed as inventor on patent applications, Japan's top court rules
I'd quibble with that. Capitalism is a choice, market dynamics are not. E.g. The Soviet Union successfully outlawed capitalism, and in response market dynamics made their country collapse.
Ajedi32··on Nano Banana 2 Lite
Okay, if that's what you meant then I don't think it's pertinent to this specific situation, since false advertising laws passed by the legislature already exist. They just need to be enforced.

Speaking more generally beyond the context of this specific situation, I agree representative democracy moves slower than other systems of government, but I personally don't think that's sufficient justification for ceding control of the legislative process to an unelected oligarchy. I think the overturning of cheveron was good push back against that trend.

Ajedi32··on NSA tries to weaken mlkem standardisation?
What exactly is the problem with the IETF publishing a standard that's theoretically weaker than another standard? They're not forcing anyone to use it, right?
Ajedi32··on Nano Banana 2 Lite
> The overturning of the Chevron doctrine removed the ability of the government to do many kinds of proactive enforcement.

How does stopping agencies from making up their own interpretation of laws do anything to prevent proactive enforcement? (Do you just mean they're now more limited in their ability to make up new laws and proactively enforce those? I'm pretty sure prohibitions on false advertising are actual laws.)

Ajedi32··on Nano Banana 2 Lite
Wouldn't that fall under existing false advertising laws, if you're putting fake/altered images in the listing?
Ajedi32··on Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities
I think it's unreasonable to post anything on a public forum and then expect to be able to control who reads it and for what purpose.
Ajedi32··on Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities
The vast, vast, majority of AI training data is not books. I wouldn't be surprised if there's more text on HN alone than every book in the history of mankind (most of which are also no longer copyrighted).
Ajedi32··on Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities
No, public data is not generally written by "experts expecting compensation".

By the way, I don't expect you to pay me for this comment. You can just read it for free. You're welcome.

Ajedi32··on What we call "age verification" is actually mass surveillance
So now I have to get permission from the government to browse the web? And they can revoke that permission at any time? And we need a great firewall to block citizens from communicating with foreign websites that don't comply with this scheme?

This idea is worse than facial scanning, by a lot.

(Better idea is OS level parental controls combined with government-mandated content tags to let the OS know what content is child-safe.)

Ajedi32··on What we call "age verification" is actually mass surveillance
The same system that blocks kids from downloading the Pornhub app would also block them from downloading the "Chrome but without parental controls" app.
Ajedi32··on window.showDirectoryPicker opens up a whole new world
There are a lot of things to like about the web as an application platform. The security model is a big one for me. There aren't many other application platforms out there where you can just download random apps off the internet and run them with zero worries they'll screw up your system. Plus the web is an open standard, works on desktop and mobile, and has multiple competing independent open source implementations.
Ajedi32··on window.showDirectoryPicker opens up a whole new world
I think the intended use case is for things like "give my music player access to my music library" or "open a project directory in this IDE", which wouldn't work well if every app were confined to its own directory.
Ajedi32··on window.showDirectoryPicker opens up a whole new world
All of them, unless they're also on the list of examples to exclude (like the Downloads folder).

I think the point is that as long as the user is sharing things on purpose and not by accident, it should be allowed. Selecting the root of the home directory would probably share a lot of things the user didn't really intend to share (because a lot of apps just dump random config files and stuff in there), but if they specifically select a subfolder they probably have a good idea of what that folder contains.

Ajedi32··on window.showDirectoryPicker opens up a whole new world
Yes, I think this modern trend towards storing user data in app/website-specific databases instead of in files has been bad for consumer freedom. Files are naturally portable and provide a interface for inter-operating with competing software in a way that data stored in the cloud or an app-specific database does not.

APIs that encourage websites to store user data in files are a positive thing.

Ajedi32··on window.showDirectoryPicker opens up a whole new world
> I don't keep my secrets in system directories

Root of the home directory is also excluded.

But obviously yeah, nothing's going to prevent you from giving a website access to your .ssh directory if you explicitly select it.

Personally I don't have a problem with that. The ability to upload files has been a thing on the web for forever and I don't think there's ever been anything that stopped users from uploading their private key. Possibly some users have gotten phished that way, but at a certain point you have to accept responsibility for your own actions, otherwise you start ceding control of your life to a corporate nanny state.

Ajedi32··on window.showDirectoryPicker opens up a whole new world
Root directory would be on that blacklist for sure.

Those "vague suggestions" actually seem to include some pretty specific examples.

> A user’s entire "home" directory. Individual files and directories inside the home directory should still be allowed, but user agents should not generally let users give blanket access to the entire directory.

Ajedi32··on Show HN: FablePool – pool money behind a prompt, and Fable builds it in public
> X% of any income

Any income from what? The code is free, right? X% of your company's total revenue? Might as well just say "companies can't use this".

Personally I like the idea of a "free as in freedom but not free as in beer" license. You have to pay for a copy of the software, but after that you're free to use and modify it as you please, and share/sell your modifications under the same license.

To turn that into a cooperative you could have a company own the code and pay developers in shares of the company for PRs or other contributioins.

Ajedi32··on FCC wants to kill burner phones by forcing telecoms to get all customers' IDs
Congress passes plenty of laws. 95 so far just since the last election: https://www.congress.gov/public-laws/119th-congress Last congress passed 274. It's really only the controversial stuff that gets gridlocked.

The problem is that our government is now so large and complicated that it's simply no longer possible for Congress to effectively set policy for all of it. (This would be true even if they weren't so polarized.) So instead they just keep delegating more and more power to the executive branch.

The Administrative Procedures Act, Congressional Review Act, and the recent overturning of Chevron are all good checks on executive/agency power here, but I don't think any of them solves the fundamental issue that the executive branch was simply never designed to wield this kind of power. I'm not really sure what the right solution is.

Ajedi32··on FCC wants to kill burner phones by forcing telecoms to get all customers' IDs
Ah yes I forgot, they're not "laws" just "rules" that the government will come after you if you break. Silly me.
Ajedi32··on FCC wants to kill burner phones by forcing telecoms to get all customers' IDs
> [Laws] are decided by (hopefully apolitical, public-good-oriented) specialists in the field of interest

This doesn't sound to me at all like how a democratic country is supposed to function. It feels like you're describing China rather than the US.

> Trump can do it at will.

Which is also not how our constitution is supposed to work. The executive branch (which includes both the president and his appointees) is not supposed to be able to make laws, only execute on existing law.

Yes, I know this is how the system works these days. I'm just lamenting how it went so wrong...

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →