HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ajedi32

13,439 karma · joined January 5, 2015

submissionscomments
Ajedi32··on Malicious npm packages detected across Red Hat Cloud Services
And even in the ones that don't, having to wait until the project executes to begin its attack is a minor inconvenience for malware.
Ajedi32··on Codex just found a "workaround" of not having sudo on my PC
That's why adding your user account to the docker group is a separate step that explicitly does not happen as part of the installation: https://docs.docker.com/engine/install/linux-postinstall/

> Warning

> The docker group grants root-level privileges to the user. For details on how this impacts security in your system, see Docker Daemon Attack Surface.

Ajedi32··on Bricks and Minifigs Stole a Man's $200k Lego Collection
In my opinion that would do little to solve the core problem, which is that adjuration is extremely expensive. It would just pass that high cost on to taxpayers and probably simultaneously 10x the demand because you just made it "free".
Ajedi32··on Bricks and Minifigs Stole a Man's $200k Lego Collection
You correctly identify the problem as an over-complicated legal bureaucracy in your first paragraph, and propose more government as the solution in your third?

The solution here should be to simplify the legal system so legal adjudication is more accessible to non-lawyers, not add more layers of government bureaucracy on top of the existing ones.

Ajedi32··on Iran will impose fees on subsea internet cables in Strait of Hormuz
That wasn't an analogy, it was a counterexample to your assertion that "If something happened due to your unprovoked action, it's your fault." That's simply not true when the "something" that happened is another person's doing.
Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
Okay, you're right, I'm overstating my case. Realistically though, in the vast majority of cases where that tag is used it's used for porn. Trying to re-purpose such a tag to label all content that isn't strictly kid friendly isn't viable. (And again, it's not granular, and a blacklist rather than whitelist, which isn't ideal for this use case.)
Ajedi32··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
Perhaps that could work in certain situations, but you don't even necessarily need digital signatures for that. A link to a reputable news site claiming they've verified the footage as real would be good enough in like 95% of cases, people just don't bother to check.

You'd also need close to 100% adoption for this to be effective, otherwise people will just assume the fakes were recorded with one of the cameras that doesn't have that feature, or that they didn't bother to upload the raw footage anywhere.

Ajedi32··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
Synthid is a watermark which indicates the video is AI-generated, not a digital signature indicating it's real. Completely different use case and threat model.

I'm not aware of any secure digital signature schemes that don't require the thing they signed to be bit-for-bit identical to pass verification. There are perceptual hashing algorithms that could theoretically be used to build such a scheme, but such hashes are not second preimage resistant, so someone could create a modified video that still passes signature verification.

Ajedi32··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
For pure entertainment maybe, but in the case of a history video how do you know whether the history you're being presented is accurate, or even has any basis in reality for that matter?
Ajedi32··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
Who posts raw output from cameras anywhere? This doesn't seem useful outside some niche use-cases (like security camera footage). At a minimum just about every recording is going to be re-compressed for streaming.
Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
There's no web standard for labeling content, so "subscribe to a whitelist" today means crappy page or network-level content blocks implemented by a third party tool that has no understanding of the actual content on the page or application. That's not at all what's being proposed in this thread.

With a universal labeling standard the UX would be much better, and there'd be a much greater incentive for website owners to participate (they'd be implementing a universal standard, not adding support for one particular parental control tool).

Ajedi32··on How Shamir's Secret Sharing Works
Yes, but a 3 of 4 SSS is not possible with the linked web page. It's also not user-friendly to expect non-technical users to manually go through multiple rounds of SSS in order to restore the original secret. Ideally it'd just be one page that clearly explains exactly what they need to provide and then restores the secret for them.
Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
That's incorrect. The existing RTA header is for marking porn as porn.[1][2] (In case English isn't your first language, "adult website" is a euphemism.)

An actually useful standard would need to be much more granular, and be designed as a whitelist not a blacklist, as I and previous commenters said.

[1]: https://wiki.whatwg.org/wiki/MetaExtensions#:~:text=Restrict...

[2]: https://webmasters.stackexchange.com/q/140733

Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
Once you have a content label header it's pretty easy to build more complicated systems on top of that. Like the site could send "compliant with x regulation" in the content labeling header, and then that would tell the kid's browser it doesn't have to completely block the page but can instead reload the page with a request header saying "filter out a, b, and c content" and expect that to be complied with.

That could be a fingerprinting vector though so maybe depending on privacy settings it just blocks the page. Really these are all solvable problems that web standards orgs have dealt with before; you just need to create the incentive for such systems to exist.

Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
Again, RTA header doesn't work because it's a blacklist, not a whitelist, and also because it's only granular enough to say "this is a porn website" and nothing else.
Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
The standard OP is describing doesn't exist. So whether it "fails to achieve most of the social goals" is yet to be determined. Blocking unrated content seems like a pretty desirable feature to me. Why wouldn't that be one of the "social goals"?
Ajedi32··on California moves to exempt Linux from its age-verification law after backlash
Maybe certain headers could be cryptographically signed. So like if your movie is rated PG by the MPA the MPA itself could sign a statement to that effect. Or a government could issue a social media company a license they could use to sign their pages as complying with some regulation and revoke their license if they don't comply.
Ajedi32··on What we lost when we stopped letting kids leave the front yard
Realistically, I don't think most people think that way. ("Don't build that apartment! The resulting increase in the local supply of housing will decrease my property value.") It's more that they don't want to live next to whatever is being built or don't want the character of the neighborhood they live in to change.

Which is somewhat understandable, but there's a balance here between the rights of existing residents vs the property rights of the owner of the property being developed (and future residents thereof). There are also regulatory burdens associated with any legal processes intended to give more rights to existing residents.

Ajedi32··on What we lost when we stopped letting kids leave the front yard
Higher household income doesn't necessarily have to mean higher property prices. It's a factor, but that's only one half of the demand/supply equation. Long term, the price of housing is driven by how much it costs to build more.
Ajedi32··on How Shamir's Secret Sharing Works
This is my favorite one yet, very user friendly. I only wish it was a bit more configurable. Ideally I'd be able to set up something like:

  3 of 4: A B C D
  - OR -
    2 of 3: E F G
    - AND -
    1 of 1: H
Or any similar combination. Maybe also with a way to name the cards so it's clear exactly what's needed when restoring.

Though there's something to be said for the simplicity of the current design.

Ajedi32··on Oura says it gets government demands for user data
GP is saying E2E encryption implies encryption in transit, because by definition "in transit" is not an "end".

I would agree with your definition that E2E means "operational intermediates cannot read it", but I would define intermediaries as people/organizations, not as devices. If my phone can read my data from my ring, that's not an intermediary because it's my phone. If a cloud server can read the data, then that is an intermediary because it's not my cloud server.

Ajedi32··on Breakthroughs for batteries could soon make them better
And if you want to get really exotic, antimatter is about 83.2 billion times more energy dense. We're not going to be running into fundamental physics limitations for energy storage anytime soon.

Though maybe it's a little unfair to call either of those things a "battery", they seem like fundamentally different technologies to me even if in theory they could fill exactly the same role.

Ajedi32··on Breakthroughs for batteries could soon make them better
> Just, write the _breakthrough_ article then, please.

When exactly though? When the price of the "new" breakthrough technology that's been around for decades at that point drops from $101 per kwH to $100 per kwH?

I totally get your frustration but it seems kinda arbitrary to say a new technology isn't a breakthrough until it's ubiquitous.

Ajedi32··on Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE
Anarchism as "an extension of nature" certainly does mean that, as least assuming you've got more guns/muscle than the other guy.

If you want to use a different definition of anarchism that includes a legal system and police force then that's not the kind of anarchism being discussed here.

Ajedi32··on Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE
Basically any system other than anarchy? In every civilized country I know of if your neighbor kills you then afterwards they'll be on the run from the law, not selling your house on Facebook marketplace the next day.
Ajedi32··on Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE
Capitalism is fully compatible with anarchism. (Though certainly it functions better under a system where your neighbor can't just kill you and take your stuff.)
Ajedi32··on We're testing new ad formats in Search and expanding our Direct Offers pilot
They could have ads alongside the AI response, in a completely separate section of the page (like search results are). That seems fine. But if they start including ads in the AI context window then it becomes impossible to tell what parts of the response are driven by advertisement vs organic results.

It seems like for now they are making an effort to keep them separate.

Ajedi32··on SpaceX punts Starship launch as investigation opens into Starbase worker's death
Yes. Starbase is an active construction site right now, so that's why I chose that as a point of comparison. But obviously there's also a lot of aerospace manufacturing happening at the same time, so it makes sense the number would be somewhere between those two industries.
Ajedi32··on SpaceX punts Starship launch as investigation opens into Starbase worker's death
Compared to what? US average fatal accident rate for construction is 9.2 deaths per 100,000 full-time workers per year. In oil and gas extraction it's 13.8. In agriculture it's 20.9. In manufacturing it's 2.4. What's Starbase's rate?

(Source: https://www.bls.gov/charts/census-of-fatal-occupational-inju...)

Ajedi32··on SpaceX punts Starship launch as investigation opens into Starbase worker's death
Headline is misleading. The launch is happening tomorrow weather permitting, and the delays that already happened are most likely unrelated to the accident that killed the worker. There's also no evidence that accident rates at Starbase are higher than at any other US construction site.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →