HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AkThhhpppt

253 karma · joined November 21, 2011

submissionscomments
AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
No I do not want to extradite anyone for hate speech; see, this is what's known as an _example_. What I would like is for the US to stop being quite so bullying in their dealings with the rest of the world.

And you're not The Enemy; I don't have any enemies. I'm Irish and therefore neutral and too small for anyone to care about. ",)

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
The UK has no criminal law about copyright. Whatsoever. The US is attempting to extradite this guy for the crime of linking to copyrighted material: http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2011/jun/17/student-file-shari...

I've been trying to find a case where the US extradited someone to a jurisdiction where they were accused of committing a crime not on US books. I can't.

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Yes, it's the first clause of the US Bill Of Rights. So? Still a clause in law.

And that's the point; the gp was, I _believe_, complaining about the perceived lack of equity in a relationship that has the US extraditing citizens of the UK for actions that are crimes in their jurisdiction but not in the UK, when it would never be considered to be allowed the other way.

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Ever hear of the "Overton Window" concept? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window

Demonizing an outgroup to turn them into acceptable targets is exactly what this law is to prevent (and there is something to prevent: see the British National Party).

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Half of the Brixton riots were triggered by someone dying in police custody. The other half were triggered by the Met shooting someone. The Met is regularly accused of institutional racism, so you can see where I'm going there.

The fact there was no right to free speech in English law until 1998 may also be related. (",)

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
The right to free speech is a negative right under the European Convention on Human Rights.

Why incitement to racial hatred might be an issue in the UK?

The usual figure given is 1 in 10 people living in the UK is an immigrant. This does NOT count descendants of immigrants.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brixton_riots

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Nationalist_Party

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Yes, but that's not racism being controversial; that's whether someone's statement is racist being controversial.

There is NO doubt the statements were racist in this case.

AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_and_Religious_Hatred_Ac...
AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Different strokes, different folks. Search "Brixton riots" for a pointer to why the UK is sensitive to racism.
AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Similar clauses in other countries' laws haven't prevented extradition the other way.
AkThhhpppt··on Racist Twitter user jailed for 56 days
Yes, but they're not directed at a public figure who was critical in hospital at the time. Some people responded by calling him on his racism, he apparently doubled down, and someone made a complaint to the police.
AkThhhpppt··on The pull-to-refresh patent
Have you read Charles Stross' Accelerando? The main character holds the patent for "using genetic algorithms to patent everything they can permutate from an initial description of a problem domain". I really, really hope it counts as Clarkeian prior art.

The book is here: www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelerando/accelerando.html

AkThhhpppt··on Google told to halt auto-complete
And if Google were at all willing to engage with users who have complaints, government wouldn't have to.
AkThhhpppt··on Google told to halt auto-complete
Why is direct mail marketing unethical, but ignoring the very real distress linking this man's name to suggested criminal history isn't? We have to consider the effects what we do has. When we only had local impact, if we did something silly or damaging we could guess the impact, and quite possibly see everyone affected. In these Internetted times, if a product can do something silly or damaging it may have spread around the globe before it's found out. We need to be aware of this.

(Note: not debating the morality of spammers; merely asking a Socratic question.)

And jlarocco was only using spam as an example of an algorithm; telling someone "I can't turn my spam-sending program off" is as silly as saying "I can't stop that autocomplete result showing." It's a difference of magnitude, not of kind.

AkThhhpppt··on Google told to halt auto-complete
I did put "vaguely related" in the rant warning, didn't I? :-)

Though news.google.com is what I was thinking of with the current affairs example, it generalizes to the whole Google edifice, and to Facebook too. I really suggest having a look at this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8ofWFx525s to see what I'm talking about, with actual examples.

Minor quibble: autocomplete isn't to aid in searching common topics, it's to help Google avoid failed searches through misspelt queries. ",)

AkThhhpppt··on Google told to halt auto-complete
What jlarocco said.

But more specifically...

Disingenuous: Because if you genuinely can't, you don't control your algorithm, you're just there to keep the lights on. I refer you to the joke about the autopilot computer, the pilot, and the dog.

Unhelpful: because it is. This is someone who is being deeply distressed by Google's actions in this small area of their operations, and their reaction is to tell him to take a hike. They don't have any obligation to him, but it's not good corporate citizenship. Vaguely related rant incoming; have some patience, please. (",)

We make algorithms, feed them masses of data, and have them suggest things to us based on our previous measured behaviour. This produces a positive feedback effect; in news and current affairs, you gradually get directed more and more towards news confirming your biases (see the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filter_bubble concept).

And we have psychological research showing groups without dissenting voices get more radical over time - see here: http://www.sciencemag.org/content/169/3947/778.

So naive implementations of news suggesters should be "considered harmful" to the public discourse. But those implementing these things don't seem to care, and often seem to show exactly the "it's the algorithm, not me" attitude displayed in this situation. We have a greater responsibility than that; if we're going to cause the (almost-)elimination of the job of newspaper editor, I'd hope we'd do it with something capable of doing at least as good a job.

AkThhhpppt··on Google told to halt auto-complete
Yes. The "nothin' to do with me, guv, it's the algorithm's fault" attitude is disingenuous and unhelpful.
AkThhhpppt··on Facebook will take action to protect the privacy and security of their users
Yes, but it is in Facebook's best interest to ablate your instinct to privacy; the more you share online, the greater value Facebook is to you, and the more value you are to Facebook.
AkThhhpppt··on Facebook will take action to protect the privacy and security of their users
Their only asset is their users' data, and they don't want anyone else getting at it for free?

/cynicism

AkThhhpppt··on Ever wanted to programmatically file a lawsuit? In Poland, you can.
Not mistakenly: it's in Accelerando - see the first comment.
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
See where I mentioned the implant "rolling over"? That was caused by someone waving a stack of over 20 of these type of neodyms (http://www.magnets2buy.com/acatalog/neodymium-discs.html) within an inch of my finger. Those are so powerful that splitting a stack of 8 and letting them re-attract rejoins the stack with such force it smashes the magnets that make contact. So while I'm sure coming close to one of those would _hurt_, I don't think I'd either end up stuck to the magnet or having the implant dragged out of me.

The implant is powerful for its size, but its size is _tiny_ (half a grain of rice is a good comparison). It's not going to be as strongly attracted as that.

AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
Thinkpad switch-mode power supplies give almost no sensation, but I have gotten a distinct (and pretty distinctive) "buzz" from a Dell power supply. I'll point out others seem to be much more sensitive than I, as well (see jaa's comment, below; he can feel power cables. I can't). So the answer is... it depends? ",)
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
I've read that paper, and I'd like to say thanks; being able to point at graphs that say I'm not imagining the sensation from my implant has occasionally been helpful. ",)
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
I was trying (badly, I admit) to point out that letting possibly over-simplistic answers sit is not equivalent to promoting creationism. Freehunter does much better above.
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
Metal fabricator of my acquaintance probably can't have an MRI, as he's got too many metal splinters floating around his body. So probably true, though I don't know about tattoos...
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
Quick! Were you taught that protons exist? If you answered yes, you're wrong, but many people believe they do, and the real answer is complex, and protons are a "good enough" answer that the entirety of chemistry pays very little attention to anything deeper. So protons and neutrons are still taught, and getting into quarks properly quite often only happens in college-level courses.
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
Before we start using them in those roles (and massively expand "install base"), we're going to have to solve the security issues http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/03/hacking_medica....
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
Integrating with nerves is have-you-a-pet-surgeon territory, and pretty much all of this stuff is done by piercers, or insane amateurs with no respect for their own bodily integrity (see the amazing Lepht Anonym). Few doctors will touch this stuff, for liability or Hippocratic Oath reasons.

The only people I know who _have_ done it are Dr. and Mrs. Warwick, who used it to do nerve-firing-over-IP from New York to Reading.

And your inner ear is fooled because the gloop in the organ-I-can't-remember-the-name-of suffers from inertia, registering false movements (or false lack of movement). Which is why spinning around in a circle for a while makes you dizzy; your ear is registering the movement continuing, your visual cortex is seeing everything staying still, and your brain has no idea how to integrate the two. ",)

AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
I'm sure it is, but apparently I can't see it, through either incompetence or measly karma. The short-form of my implant tale is here: http://discuss.biohack.me/discussion/comment/862#Comment_862
AkThhhpppt··on Body Hacking: Thoughts Regarding My Magnet Implant
You can feel transformers from a (comparatively) massive distance away: I can feel a 230-to-12V transformer from 5 to 10cm, which is generally bigger than the transformer is. So you'd know to steer clear. I mean, IAmDann said here, http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/g7lom/iama_24_year_old... that he can feel subway power transformers while walking down the street.

Demagnetizers... isn't the whole point to enclose the field? I'd also expect a warning sign or two, or for you to pay attention and know it's there. This is one of those "make your decision, and then live with it" things, and part of "living with it" is being aware of these things (and that acquaintances with more humour than sense might try to hand you magnets you can lift tables with).

Large electric motors... Dunno, have no experience of them yet.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →