HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AltruisticGapHN

484 karma · joined April 15, 2020

submissionscomments
AltruisticGapHN··on ChatGPT Should Not Exist
It's funny because you express exactly what the author said:

> As Abeba Birhane and Deb Raji documented recently, the responses of members of the Generative AI communities to criticism are, to put it mildly, less than generous.

Your view is as simplistic as you make his to be.

When you are unable to take the author's point of view, and read between the lines, and take things into context - then you do exactly what the author is worried about : you emulate AI, and lose your human nature.

When the author talks about "nihilism" I think he refers to the dangers that Ian McGilchrist has been talking about at lenghts, in "The Divided Brain". Very roughly, that we are dangerously going out of balance, over-using the left-hemisphere's view on reality, as a collection of "things".

Generative AI amplifies exactly all the issues Gilchrist has been talking in his books and numerous interviews you can find on YouTube. AI produces content that has no purpose, no meaning.

It IS nihilist if you think about it in the sense that it will soon feed on its own output, and therefore simply produce more and more extremist / "highlly specific" content. Again, the exact kind of issues Gilchrist has talked about : a view of the world as a collection of "things", and looking at things without sufficient context.

Art has always been something that engages the right hemisphere, and these more unconscious parts of us. For example, music affects us in way words can't. But that content is produced by humans for other humans to resonate with.

The real delusion here, is when you elevate AI's output as something equal or someday "equal or even better" to what humans can do, completely forgetting that AI would produce ZERO interesting results if it were not for the input. How is that not obvious at all?

THe author also has every right to call the attention on how, just like with Bezos and Elon and Bill Gates, etc. it is the richest people, with a certain kind of a view on the world, that pulls the strings. It IS really dangerous and concerning that software engineers tell the world how to see the world, since they already themselves have a great propensity to reduce the world to a collection of "things" that can be exploited... eg. Zuckerberg and all the Facebook shenanigans.

AI has some real and useful applications in helping code generation and whatnot, but it also has a ton of destructive potential unless people really see it for what it is and your initial reaction is not helping.

AltruisticGapHN··on ChatGPT, the Abacus, and Education
On a bird's eye perspective... you know as much as I love and enjoy crafting with css/html/javascript ... as I grow older I am not that entertained in having to learn yet another API to do the same thing that we did years ago, only "more elegantly/faster/with less code/etc".

The truth is, if I'm perfectly honest, that to KNOW those APIs in itself, is not real knowledge. It's just empty. Talk to your wife holding your newborn, about the latest tailwind version, or native Javascript additions. Seriously who gives a flying rat's ass?

At this stage of human evolution, we live in a reality bubble where we're told that a life "well lived" is one where you have a "real" job, and one where you "work hard". And your parents tell you to "become somebody"... well maybe it's because they have never know anything else?

Maybe the best thing that will come out of artificial intelligence, is to destroy all this supposed knowledge. All those mountains of nothing.

Imagine you create a new API for a service, and EVEN WItHOUT feeding any examples to the deep learning, it manages to figure out the best way to solve xyz problems using your API, and even highlights inefficiencies in your API. Now we're talking. Why would anybody waste their human potential writing the 1000th tutorial on how to use your API ? That's gonna be replaced by another better API from someone else in 5 days?

I love my work. I love CSS; JS .. I really do but honestly it's also all so empty.

Would I do it all over again? I don't even remember how I wrote in assembler on the Amiga and 486. How I used the copper/blitter etc. All vague distant memories. Everything shifting...

edit: I guess this comes off as a mini rant, simplifying. Not sure what my point is, frustrated with what "learning" means perhaps. Frustrated with the notion that knowledge is repeating stuff.

Actually here's a good question : are teachers really necessary or have we yet to envision a world where children, helped with AI tools, can learn whatever they want - as an innate ability? curiosity?

AltruisticGapHN··on Drowning in AI Generated Garbage: the silent war we are fighting
It's much more than just "being in a rut". You can clearly see how social media and "viral"-ism has changed the way movies are produced and shown. In recent years when I go watch a mainstream action movie, it's like a deafening blur of post process filters and carefully crafted scene after scene where everything is manipulated via the computer to a degree where you can no longer even look away from the focal point and discover details and enjoy watching a movie multiple times - because now if you look elsewhere than the producers want you to look, there is nothing there anymore. It's all CGI garbage or empty sets, covered by CGI made shadows/lighting/fog/whathaveyou.

AI in the movie industry will absolutely accelerate the race to the bottom, and make mainstream entertainment even more shallow and empty.

In fact it's probably why movies nowadays are like 2h to 2h30 when they used to be 1h30. They're so shallow and empty and filled with noise that they have to stretch them out so it feels like you actually watched something.

edit: on further thought, maybe you know, movies are over? I mean clearly as much as I hate it, tiktok's success is showing us that people get far more stimulation from watching feeds - or maybe it is indeed since COVID & Netflix etc there is even fewer incentive to sit in a dark room with lots of other noisy people munching on their popcorns and kicking your seat while to try to enjoy a movie.

My point being I doubt that the movie industry will recover.

AltruisticGapHN··on Drowning in AI Generated Garbage: the silent war we are fighting
> Those "artificial" creations are also uploaded on the Internet. Those artificial artefacts are now part of the statistical data.

> Do you see where it leads?

This reminds me of one of the philosophers cited as inspiration for The Matrix,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Baudrillard#Simulacra_and...

This guy sums up pretty much how I felt about this since when those images started poring on social media.

This will serve, once again, capitalism and it's absurd race towards the bottom, lowest common denominator.

It's not hard to extrapolate here and imagine that AI will be able to produce a full fledged "super hero" movie, starting from a storyboard & script. What do you put in the script? Well of course you just feed it all the keywords that gave maximized returns!

I for one, am not entertained at the thought of going to the movies watching the 1000th super hero movie but that's exactly where we're going.

Here's my somewhat prediction: the big picture is we are accelerating the end of entertainment as we know it today. We are going to make entertainment so shallow, so pointless, that we will eventually lose interest with it, and with it, as has been prophesized in many spiritual teachings, there will be a return to a more animalistic/spiritual kind of being. As technology improves our lives, we will no longer need to numb ourselves down in front of a screen after coming home from work, so we won't even see the point of even doing that. We will be able to live more in the present, more with the real and less with symbols and abstractions. The type of attention you may enjoy after a long silent retreat, will become the normal way of being... of course there is also the other possibility that Ian Mc Gilchrist cautions about... that our brains will get so out of balance that we will become stupid enough to collapse as a civilization.

AltruisticGapHN··on An X11 apologist tries Wayland
What tool could you use in Wayland to move and resize windows around, but custom? Sort of like a simple autohotkey script?

I don't like tiling apps. But I'd like something where I can press a key to have my current app window moved to exactly where I want it x1, y1, x2, y2, and then that way I can stack all of them in the center of my screen. It helps me focus.

AltruisticGapHN··on An X11 apologist tries Wayland
I am one of those people that has been watching Valve's support of Proton and Steamdeck, and already familiar with Ubuntu for development... and now considering leaving Windows behind for good.

So far my experience with both development and gaming is good, however I find that in order to control the NVIDIA GPU (a GTX 1080) - I need software like GWE to set the power limit, and fan curve... and for whatever reason these do not work in Wayland.

I wish I could use Wayland though - I did notice the desktop feels smoother.

Can we switch now? Are there forks of GWE for Wayland? Or do we still need to wait months/years until these tools show up?

PS: if I upgraded my GTX 1080 to an AMD card, would I have apps to control power limit / fans on Wayland?

AltruisticGapHN··on Figma Alternatives
My first thought is... how is this free if it's similar to FIGMA?

It sounds like they have basically bundled in a lot of their own icons/svg stuff and that's their business model? But even then building such an app seems like a huge investment if it's just a platform to sell your icons. So I must be missing something.

And how does it compare to Penpot?

AltruisticGapHN··on SpaceVim 2.0
Yep, VIM mode in Sublime Text, VS Code.

In VSCode extension, the VIM marks that opens a file has never worked for me.

As well, the ability to go back to the last edit in any recent files with `'.` doesn't work.

Other than that it does all I want.

AltruisticGapHN··on EU approves legislation to regulate Apple, Google, Meta, and other tech firms
> makes the shelf life of their products relatively short

I don't know if this really holds, when you look at the bigger picture.

As for me I've owned an iPad 3rd gen (the first "Retina" iPad) from late 2012 to late 2016.

Then I owned an iPad Air 2 from late 2016 to this day... and I've decided to wait to see if they redesign the base iPad model (not Air) late this year - and if not then upgrade to the new AIR.

So that's 2 iPads between late 2012 to late 2022. 10 YEARS.

Sounds pretty reasonable to me.

Considering how fast tech and software is moving these days if you can get 4-5 years out of your tablet AS A TECH USER that's pretty darn good.

If it was my Grandma, she'd probably still get to use my iPad Air 2 for another few years...

I don't see how it's different for other Apple products. The MINI's from 2012 are still being sold at a decent price and are very much sought after - Apple users love to use them as media servers. The M1 Mini likely will have a LOOOONG life ahead of them. Mine will probably resell in a heart beat even couples years from now.

AltruisticGapHN··on EU approves legislation to regulate Apple, Google, Meta, and other tech firms
I think there are good intentions behind it, but it also misses the mark by targeting big tech specifically.

The good that could have come of it, is a sort of open sourcing of tech companies... but of course none of that is going to happen.

Yet we have standards; like USB-C which are a good thing. Question is who should enforce creating more standards (to address eg the interoperability of the messaging apps cited in the article).

The big issue I see here is it is completely unfair to Apple because Apple is really in a league of its own. It's very essence, what makes Apple.. Apple.. is that they create BOTH the hardware and software. When I buy a Mac Mini, or an iPad I buy the whole package, that is the value of it...

It's like the EU telling Apple they know better how to design products and that Apple should redefine themselves as a company.. yet.. by finetuning and crafting software for their platforms Apple offers a user experience that is simply the best.

What the EU should have done instead is try to force big tech to work together?

I don't know how to feel about this but as a European I'm tired of being a peasant... and this is going to set us back even more. :/

AltruisticGapHN··on Meta VR prototypes aim to make VR 'indistinguishable from reality'
Not entirely fair. The Quest is a joy to use.

But I will admit that even though each time I take off the dust from my Quest I am wowed at the experience,

... each time I take off the headset I shrug and I'm like "cool".

Maybe we just need to come to grips with the fact that _as an entertainment or work_ device, it's friggin awesome - and as far as "reality" goes, it's pointless.

Now of course if it came to a point where you don't want to remove the headset.. but thankfully personally I don't have any worries.

A funny philosophical thought.. you reproduce the sense of smell, taste .. etc... Then people will be like, "umm, it's just like my real life now.. what is the point?" Other than being "transported" (for fake) and experience another place.

I think that's the main misconception with VR. There is the dream of "living another life". But it's just entertainment.

edit: I should also add that despite promising stories in the media, the ability of VR to heal trauma, to heal our nervous system, to make us better people... is still very much up in the air.. and as I am healing trauma myself I can see how VR could just as well unbalance the nervous system. I mean you're already seeing how "novelty" messes us up in social media (inifinite scroll etc)... why should we expect VR to make everything betteR?

AltruisticGapHN··on Meta VR prototypes aim to make VR 'indistinguishable from reality'
Imho right now the immersion is "good enough"... but what I notice the most is the lack of light. So HDR or some evolution of that is what's most lacking in my opinion.

Even with the crappy compression on YouTube, you can watch a scene where you are on the beach in VR. After all, isn't that the dream? Of course you can't feel the waves splashing on your feet, but you can definitely enjoy the feeling of being in that space. However, the lack of the bright deep blue sky is really noticeable.

Likewise in games. I definitely preferred Skyrim VR on Quest via a cable over the RIFT because the blacks are much deeper (oled), but on the other end of the spectrum, the sky is always lacking in brightness.

My hunch is this is going to be hard to solve... I mean most homes today don't even have any kind of lighting that remotely reproduces the outdoor lighting.. I doubt that the small screen inside the headset will be able to simulate a bright blue sky... I mean I don't think it's just a matter of "intensity".

But who knows I am clueless, it could be that the pixel density is what prevents the screen from giving the "bright blue sky" depth of light.

AltruisticGapHN··on Parents’ trauma leaves biological traces in children
Also relevant

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/21/study-of-hol...

Sadly extremely obvious for me.

Trauma is generational, it's within families; communities, countries, and eventually through all of humanity.

And likewise it is addressed at those many levels.

AltruisticGapHN··on Today’s JavaScript, from an outsider’s perspective (2020)
Good points.

> Webpack is an abomination to anything simple and clear, many dev hours are lost on it.

Check out Vite. It's basically Webpack with sensible defaults. Still the same bundling paradigm but it's been so much easier for me to use. Also way way easier to add plugins in Vite.

AltruisticGapHN··on Today’s JavaScript, from an outsider’s perspective (2020)
We just need all this tooling to go in the browser.. which is where it always belonged. That was the purpose of JS. To "just run" in the browser. It's getting there but very slowly.

As for my own rant, simply the fact that Microsoft, of all places are the ones who run TypeScript and now the proposal to add TS to native JS.. is part of the issue. MS has zero imagination.

JS needs native typing and it shouldn't be done by MS, and it should be a limited subset of TS with no particular intent to be compatible with MS's TS. Then and only then JS becomes its own thing again.

AltruisticGapHN··on Show HN: Little Procedural Pixel Worlds
As an aside would it take a lot more code if this was made with Phaser?

Just wondering what's the easiest way to do something fun like this (procedural generation with tiles, but also basic rogue gameplay perhaps).

AltruisticGapHN··on Why Google is so unbearable, and how to fix it
`site:` is great.

As an aside, anyone knows if you can still find "who links to?". I used to do this to hear how people feel about my site/app. I would do something like `link:foo.bar.com` I don't remember if it was link: or linkto: but it seems it no longer is supported? :(

AltruisticGapHN··on Meld for Macs
Thank you for Meld for OSX, love it.

Always used meld on Ubuntu as well. I love how simple and clear it is.

Small UX/QOL improvement on OSX could be to remember the window's position and size between launches.

AltruisticGapHN··on McDonald’s to Exit from Russia
It makes sense that they adapt the menu slightly for each demographic. Also that they need to source meat etc in a competitive way, not from across another continent so just by that mere fact it may be slightly better (I think I'm not mistaken that US has really refined meat production to the extreme...).
AltruisticGapHN··on McDonald’s to Exit from Russia
Wow thatt's pretty rough. Just recently I saw some old footage of when Russia opened to the West and all those 90's kids in Russia going to the first Mc Donalds opening there.

Then again McDonalds is a good example of a lot of things that are just plain wrong about western culture... so no loss for Russia I guess.

AltruisticGapHN··on Modern JavaScript Tutorial
Great resource which I'd like to use, I only wish the search would work like a command palette like on MDN or Tailwind docs... because if this is so complete this could be a great alternative for me from MDN, having more "tutorial" text and examples, not just specifications.

So I'd like to be able to hit Cmd P or Ctrl K or the like, enter "nullish" and then find the article on nullish coalescing op.

AltruisticGapHN··on Modern JavaScript Tutorial
A lot of laziness has come from these newer rest/spread syntaxes (something to do with functional programming patterns too?).

As a oldschool Amiga/PCDOS/ASM/C developer who moved on to the web ten years later... it always feels awkward to me to do things like arr = [...arr, ...arr2] because I'm always wondering just how effectively that is handled by the Javascript compiler.

AltruisticGapHN··on No Dislikes has officially ruined YouTube for me
Dislikes are so toxic.

I always felt that Reddit would be so much better if you can upvote what you like and simply ignore the rest. Wouldn't that work? The stuff that people like or find quality posts will rise, so logically the rest will be further down. So why do we need a downvote button?

Imho downvote/dislike buttons on social sites simply validates toxic behaviour, as well as those behaviour from people that wouldn't think of themselves as angry or toxic and yet feel like they need to "fix" the world for others... which almost invariably means they have anger they haven't "digested" yet and so they keep seeing it into the world; anywhere but in themselves. And crucially no amount of dislike/downvotes will make the world a better place - all they do is increase polarization.

AltruisticGapHN··on Speed boost achievement unlocked on Docker Desktop 4.6 for Mac
I've experienced freezes on macOS + Docker 4.6 + using Vite in a php/apache/nodejs container.

When these happened, I can't even do CTRL D in the terminal. The STOP button in Docker doesn't work. Had to restart.

Anybody else?

Otherwise it does seem quite q bit faster, like `vite` starts up almost instantly instead of taking a second or two (having been used days prior, so it has its cache).

AltruisticGapHN··on Speed boost achievement unlocked on Docker Desktop 4.6 for Mac
Thanks for the excellent explanation!
AltruisticGapHN··on Speed boost achievement unlocked on Docker Desktop 4.6 for Mac
Ok so you mean it's something that's lacking at a much more lower level of the OS?
AltruisticGapHN··on Speed boost achievement unlocked on Docker Desktop 4.6 for Mac
You seem to have a good understanding of these containers.

Do you know in simple terms why macOS doesn't have such "native containers"? After all isn't it more linux-like than Windows?

I saw this website that suggests Apple themselves are not providing such a feature... do they see it as a security issue?

https://macoscontainers.org/

AltruisticGapHN··on Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences
I wonder how usable those new Apple displays will be with PCs or Linux - as they add more and more builtin chips and software.

I have an old 27" LED Cinema which I used with a PC for many many years, and then with Ubuntu native... and now back to the mac on a Mac Mini.

I'm ithcing to replace it eventually with its "double pixel density" big brother, which is essentially what this new Studio Display is (exactly double of 2560x1440). Personally I love the glass pane, and I really dislike those "anti glare" bubbly/grainy coatings I've seen on PC displays.

AltruisticGapHN··on Ask HN: Has the iPad Won the Tablet Wars?
iPads are GREAT value. I can still count how many iPads I've had since I got into it:

- around 2011 I had an iPad 2

- resold it half a year later, granted, because I wanted the new RETINA version ... which I used until late 2016 !! It was still usable for anything but browsing, when browsing the the 512 MB RAM wasnt keeping up with the bloated web, and it wasnt holding more than one tab in memory so it was becoming a hassle, otherwise back then all my RSS apps etc worked just fine

- then I bought an iPad AIR 2 early 2017, which I am still using today! I could probably get another couple years out of this one

That's 3 iPads over 10+ years.

Nowaadatys the iPad is also pretty much a PC if you connect a USB hub you can use a keyboard, a mouse ...

AltruisticGapHN··on Tell HN: Twitter is growing increasingly unusable without an account
To be fair creating a random account takes a second on Reddit , after which you can turn off a bunch of things, and also browse from https://old.reddit.com to remove all the junk.
← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →