HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AndyMcConachie

2,880 karma · joined July 28, 2015

www.metafarce.com smutt@depht.com
submissionscomments
AndyMcConachie··on NSA, NIST, and post-quantum crypto: my second lawsuit against the US government
And a big thank you to the wonderful people at the Free Law Project for giving us the ability to find and link to this stuff. They're a non-profit and they accept donations. (hint hint)
AndyMcConachie··on Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on PornHub, MindGeek
You're right about SESTA-FOSTA being terrible, but I don't think it's the relevant law here.

The relevant code here is 1591(a)(2).

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1591

The opinion of the court is that the defendents benefit monetarily from a commercial sex act involving someone below 18 years of age.

AndyMcConachie··on Ask HN: What's up with these DoorDash dark patterns?
I live in The Netherlands and order food at least once a week, usually from Thuisbezorgd. I've never had any of the problems people are discussing here.

I will say that Thusbezorgd is often more expensive than just going directly to a restaurant's website. But also we find restaurants that we like and keep ordering from them. I typically know precisely where my food is coming from because I physically know where the restaurant is.

AndyMcConachie··on Why intuitive troubleshooting has stopped working
Imagine 100 years from now when humanity's population has been reduced by 100s of millions because of climate catastrophe. Now imagine all the software society relies upon. Now imagine being one of the few people left alive being capable of working on that software. You probably won't have source code.

One thing that has remained constant in our lives is the number of people who are capabable of working on complex software has steadily increased. What happens if that number suddenly decreases?

AndyMcConachie··on Phrases in computing that might need retiring
About 20 years ago I had a job where I was called an 'Integration Engineer'. It would be called Dev Ops now. It will be called something different in 20 years. Who cares?
AndyMcConachie··on Phrases in computing that might need retiring
The big difference between technical debt and actual debt in a money sense is that real debt is taken on consciously with an agreement betweenn debtor and lender. Because of this money debt can be worked into the planning and the risk can be calculated at the time the loan is initiated. Circumstances can change over time, but there is a bargain between the debtor and the lender. There are things like interest rates and collateral that are agreed upon when the debt is incurred.

Technical debt is by definition created to save time, so there is rarely an understanding of the risk that comes with the debt until the debt must be repaid. This means that the eventual payback can range from inconsequential to disasterous. The point is that the debtor won't know until it comes time to pay the debt back. Technical debt is often incurred in lieu of actual planning, not because a debtor is consciously and rationally weighing current reward against a future risk.

AndyMcConachie··on FBI investigation determined Huawei equipment could disrupt US nuclear comms
> The solution would be quite easy: Disallow devices (and software, too) from phoning home. Disallow remote firmware updates.

But then how will network operators outsource all of their infrastructure maintenance to vendors? That's the problem.

We have this naive idea that companies running networks employ staff to manage their networks. In reality, it hasn't been like that in a while because there has been a tremendous push in the industry to outsource everything to third parties. So the person who owns the cell tower likely has no idea who is maintaining it, much less has that person on their payroll.

AndyMcConachie··on Log4j: The pain just keeps going
The ease with which software remains mutable after deployment is both a blessing and a curse. This is particular and intrinsic to software and other digital artifacts. Things based in matter do not benefit from this blessing or suffer from this curse.
AndyMcConachie··on EU Digital Markets Act, aimed at Google, Apple, Amazon, approved
I think we should expect Apple and Google to fight this tooth and nail. I'm sure they've been following it and looking at ways to exploit any holes that are in it.

In short, I expect it to be years before we can do most of the things you list in your post. There will be lots of court cases before we, as consumers, see any real change.

AndyMcConachie··on Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report
I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia.

The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go along with Russian sanctions.

AndyMcConachie··on Homeland security workers indicted in scheme to silence China critics in U.S.
You're assuming the knew who they were working for. The USG claims they destroyed evidence and obstructed justice.

> The charges against Miller and Taylor pertain to their alleged obstruction of justice, including by destroying evidence, after they were approached by agents with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and asked about their procurement and dissemination of sensitive and confidential information from a restricted federal law enforcement database regarding U.S.-based dissidents from the PRC. This information was used by Liu and Sun in the transnational repression scheme. Both Miller and Taylor were arrested pursuant to a criminal complaint in June 2022.

It sounds like they provided information to the DHS agents from a protected database. Then when they figured out who they had provided this information to, tried to destroy the evidence of their involvement.

AndyMcConachie··on FBI Child ID App
I've read letters from NKVD agents located in the USA in the 1930s talking about how this new guy J Edgar Hoover is using political blackmail so effectively. They were reporting back to the USSR telling their superiors how political blackmail was something that the new USSR needed to perfect and use to its advantage.

I think we can have a long discussion about what the real purpose of the FBI is. And I bet even within the FBI they can have this long discussion. It is many purposed, some of which we may determine to be pro-social, or pro-democratic. While others are probably more anti-social and anti-democratic.

AndyMcConachie··on FBI Child ID App
Happened to me as well. Now the FBI has my fingerprints on file even though I've never committed a crime.

I had a discussion with my Mom a couple years about this and she admitted she screwed up. I can't blame her of course. Especially since at the time there was plenty of FBI propoganda about missing kids terrifying parents and claiming this was a solution.

AndyMcConachie··on Germany Ends Ban on Abortion Advertisement
It only took them ~85 years.
AndyMcConachie··on How I would sell OpenBSD as a salesperson
vultr.com works well with OpenBSD.
AndyMcConachie··on Wikimedia Enterprise announces Google and Internet Archive as first customers
You're applying corporate thinking to this. Wikimedia Foundation doesn't need marketing or branding people, it really doesn't. Communications people I can understand because there will be journalists and others that need to be communicated to. But they don't need a marketing strategy nor do they need marketing collateral.
AndyMcConachie··on Former U.S. congressman, operative pleads guilty to election fraud charges
This guy's name is Michael Myers. Not to be confused with Mike Myers of Austin Power's fame.
AndyMcConachie··on Sanctions and Strategic Bombing
Their history of strategic bombing is wrong. They fail to mention that the RAF was developed to primarily bomb civilians in Mesopotamia and elsewhere in the British empire. The development of bombing after WWI was really about imperial maintenance and putting down any internal strife. This can also be said of the Italians in Ethiopia. I think the point is that the technology developed at a time when the need for the Europeans with the technology was to fight imperial wars. Only later did WWII see the methods of bombing that has been used to quell imperial revolt get adapted to war. The Spanish civil war should get a mention here as well. Everyone knows about Guernica, etc.

Sanctions are just modern day siege warfare. Go look at the 80 years war between the Dutch and Spanish for some of the longest and most interesting sieges in history. In almost all examples one can find sieges or sanctions almost never result in a local popularion rising up against their local elites and leadership. The fact that this is not more widely discussed in American sanctions discourse is a testament to American war propaganda effectiveness. Name one country where American sanctions have resulted in a local population regime changing their leadership. I can't think of any. Cuba, Venezuela, Iran, Iraq, N Korea, Syria, Lebanon, Yemen, and of course Russia.

Go look at the list and find a single country under US sanctions where the USA has achieved regime change because of sanctions.

https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/...

Go look at the history of countries the US has sanctioned and try and find one that resulted in regime change. You will not find any.

Instead sanctions typically have the effect of prolonging conflict and solidifying the power structures of the local regime and elites. They're punitive and they affect the poorest of a country. The UN says the greatest humanitarian disaster right now is in in Yemen, and that's directly caused by US and UK sanctions. It won't win the war for the Saudis and UAE, but it's starving hundreds of thousands of Yemenis.

Sanctions against Cuba did not remove Castro. Instead it provided his regime an ability to control food distribution. I have a tremendous amount of respect for the Cuban people and their ability to live under US sanctions, but even if I hated Communism in my bones I would recognise that US sanctions on Cuba have been an abject failure.

Black markets and smuggling develop under sanctions and these get controlled by those in power. Sanctions make it much easier for established power structures to survive and thrive. Suddenly people can't get fuel, food and other essentials. They need to come to those in power and beg for them. So those in power can decide who gets these essential items, and even better yet, blame their enemies on the fact that they have to be rationed. Sanctions are both a material and propaganda gift to the regimes the US says they want to dethrone.

So who benefits from sanctions in the USA, why do they keep imposing them? I think the answer to this question is really complex. Partly because there is both real political will in the USA to see regime change in sanctioned countries and people who benefit materially from sanctions knowing that they will not succeed.

If sanctions are so bad at achieving their stated objectives, why does the USG keep imposing them? This is the interesting question.

AndyMcConachie··on Ask HN: Burnt-out, directionless but want to turn it around
You're being abused by your employer. They need you and yet you think you have no value. You have value otherwise they wouldn't need you on call all the time.
AndyMcConachie··on Pedal Me bans staff riders from wearing helmets for safety reasons
Read what the Dutch cycling union has to say about helmets.

https://www.fietsersbond.nl/de-fiets/accessoires/fietshelmen...

https://www-fietsersbond-nl.translate.goog/de-fiets/accessoi...

I live here and I'll say that almost all bicycle delivery drivers where helmets in NL. Lost of riders wear helmets here, but I agree that most people just riding to work or going shopping do not.

I will also note that probably the largest bicycle delivery service in NL has helmets for sale for its riders.

https://shop.thuisbezorgd.nl/nl/helmen

AndyMcConachie··on 9-Euro-Ticket
Have you considered long distance buses from something like Flixbus? I live in Rotterdam and see them coming into the central station from all over Europe.
AndyMcConachie··on We reduced 502 errors by caring about PID 1 in Kubernetes
> GitLab Workhorse is a Go service in front of our Ruby on Rails monolith and it's deployed as a sidecar inside of the webservice pod, which runs Ruby on Rails using the Puma web server.

It's always amazing to me how complicated web stuff has gotten these days. I started out in the LAMP days over 20 years ago. I'm not this complexity is necessarily bad. I don't know the details and I don't know how to make a web app scalable today. But damn if this doesn't sound like a pile of hot garbage waiting to fail to my ears.

AndyMcConachie··on Many software companies are a joke
Is there anything new ever written in this space or is everyone just repeating what Fred Brooks said in the 1970s?
AndyMcConachie··on Emacs for Professionals
I reget I have but one upvote to give you.

I use different editors for different things and I could not agree with this sentiment more. I use Emacs almost exclusively for note taking and for writing software. But I use vim for editing config files, or for smallish files in /etc/. I really like Emacs for writing software, but I have used vim for this as well.

Over the years I've used many different editors and I expect I will use many different editors in the future.

AndyMcConachie··on Nearly the hottest place on Earth, India swelters under intense heat wave
I read it and I thought it was pretty dumb. Much much too optimistic for my understanding of the situation.

My main gripe with it was that it leaves the reader thinking that climate change can be combatted with sensibility and reason. The idea that our global elites will come to their senses if we shove a few incidents in front of their faces goes against the fundamental narcissistic arc western civilization is currently enamored with.

The world he presents is predominantly western and China barely gets a mention. While he does start off in India most of it takes place in Switzerland, a country that doesn't really matter all that much for the climate. He's American, so he probably thinks China is inherently a bad place where stupid things happen. But I don't know why one wouldn't center a fictitious future of climate change there, and worse leave it out entirely. It's civilization is ascending while western white European culture is obviously descending.

I don't want my criticism of the book to lie entirely on Robinson's euro-centrism, but it is my primary complaint. Not because this makes the book racist, and I'm not accusing Robinson of that, but because it shows how Robinson's limited view of the world shapes his fiction. He gives us a white saviour story primarily taking place in Switzerland and yet claims to be speaking to the world. It's just dumb.

AndyMcConachie··on Is it the “New York Review of Each Other’s Books”?
It's only as incestuous as academia :)
AndyMcConachie··on It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV
Same. I don't understand why more people simply don't connect the thing to the network.
AndyMcConachie··on MIT graduate students vote to unionize
People who have no experience with academia would think your story is false and outlandish.

People who have experience with academia would think your story is commonplace and borderline uninteresting.

This has been my experience with telling and hearing stories like this.

AndyMcConachie··on Kerouac and Buddhism
The irony of the Beats is that while they may have turned lots of westerners onto Buddhism, they misinterpreted it terribly. When I was studying comparative religion as an undergrad I asked my professor of Japanese and Chinese religions if there were any American Buddhists that Chinese or Japanese buddhists viewed as detrimental to Buddhism and the western interpretation of Buddhism. She replied that there was only one, Alan Watts. He was largely disliked in Chinese and Japanese buddhist circles because he so completely misunderstood basic concepts and talked to eloquently about them.

I later went to study in India for a semester where I had more exposure to many of the words that American buddhists such as Watts, or Kerouac throw around. I've seriously studied Buddhism in both American and Indian universities, and read books written by Chinese, Japanese, Indian, Tibetan, Korean, and Nepalese buddhists. I'm not a buddhist, but I can say with certainty that the Beats really didn't understand buddhism. Instead I view them as coming from a western tradition of capitalizing on oriental concepts by introducing them to an ignorant western audience. I doubt they did this intentionally, and it's not like I hold some kind of grudge against Kerouac for getting so much wrong. And in a way, good on them for introducing so many westerners to buddhism.

If you are interested in Buddhism and your interest came from reading Beat literature, I highly suggest you seek out a teacher that does not draw their teaching from Beat sources, or anything that can be traced back to Alan Watts. Look for institutions that have been around for a while and that try to demystify complex concepts.

AndyMcConachie··on Due to failure in the IT system, it is not possible to run any trains today
The fact that it happened on a Sunday suggests to me that this is the result of a service outage gone awry. Realize that the trains failing on a Sunday is really not a big deal. However, if the trains don't run for Monday morning rush hour that is a big deal. I bet they made a change Saturday night and something broke Sunday morning.

It's now Monday morning here and the trains are back to normal in time for rush hour. So it's not really a big deal.

← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →