HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Antibabelic

900 karma · joined September 1, 2025

submissionscomments
Antibabelic··on Which AI Lies Best? A game theory classic designed by John Nash
One thing I've noticed from watching these games is that LLMs never used risky strategies, such as faking roles. They will happily accuse others of lying, but never openly claim to be a role that they're not themselves
Antibabelic··on Show HN: Going to write 1.000.000 lines of code for community projects
The language on the site is unclear, and this isn't mentioned in the FAQ. Will you use LLMs for writing the code, or will every line be written entirely by you?
Antibabelic··on Show HN: Havyl OS – Decide what to do based on your energy
Why are you calling this an OS? The website doesn't actually tell me anything about what this piece of software is supposed to be, but my guess is that it isn't actually an operating system.
Antibabelic··on King – man + woman is queen; but why? (2017)
What I am talking about concerns how human language relates to meaning. I'm not sure what this has to do with humans being "special". Saying that humans are "just an especially complex hydrocarbon mass that receives external stimuli and remaps them to a physical output" misses the point that what data we have available to us is qualitatively different from that of today's best natural language generation software.
Antibabelic··on King – man + woman is queen; but why? (2017)
This is my problem with people claiming that LLMs "understand". What we usually call "meaning" in intricately related to an encyclopedic knowledge of the world around us. How does this kind of knowledge not get into the same kind of loop you've just described? It is ultimately founded on our direct experience of the world, on sense data. It is ultimately embodied knowledge.
Antibabelic··on Ask HN: Is there a search engine that blocks SEO / AI content?
Marginalia Search (https://marginalia-search.com/) is an indie search engine that prioritizes small websites and non-commercial content. It may not be a perfect alternative to Google—the index is much smaller—but it is much "cleaner".
Antibabelic··on Wikipedia: WikiProject AI Cleanup
Wikipedia already has very detailed guidelines on how text on Wikipedia should look, which address many of these problems.[1] For example, take a look at its advice on "puffery"[2]:

"Peacock example:

Bob Dylan is the defining figure of the 1960s counterculture and a brilliant songwriter.

Just the facts:

Dylan was included in Time's 100: The Most Important People of the Century, in which he was called "master poet, caustic social critic and intrepid, guiding spirit of the counterculture generation". By the mid-1970s, his songs had been covered by hundreds of other artists."

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Word...

Antibabelic··on Wikipedia: WikiProject AI Cleanup
But you can already view the past version of any page on Wikipedia. Go to the page you want to read, click "View history" and select any revision before 2023.
Antibabelic··on Wikipedia: WikiProject AI Cleanup
I found the page Wikipedia:Signs of AI Writing[1] very interesting and informative. It goes into a lot more detail than the typical "em-dashes" heuristic.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Signs_of_AI_writing

Antibabelic··on Show HN: Pdfwithlove – PDF tools that run 100% locally (no uploads, no back end)
Works under Wine very well.
Antibabelic··on Show HN: Pdfwithlove – PDF tools that run 100% locally (no uploads, no back end)
Doesn't a time-tested solution already exist in the form of PDF24?
Antibabelic··on Apple is fighting for TSMC capacity as Nvidia takes center stage
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China's_final_warning
Antibabelic··on Impeccable Style
How will an LLM "take greater care with typography" if it can't see the page it is creating? How will it "improve" leading if you need a human to see that there's too much distance between lines or too little?
Antibabelic··on Impeccable Style
This isn't really what I said, and is considerably less clear. What I meant is that you can't boil design down to certain stylistic flourishes and words denoting them (e.g. "vertical rhythm", to take an example from the linked page). Whatever you're doing, it involves understanding how the viewer will react to what you will show them and why.
Antibabelic··on Apple is fighting for TSMC capacity as Nvidia takes center stage
I feel like China invading Taiwan isn't happening in our lifetimes. Yes, they stand to benefit from it, but I doubt any of the people in charge of decision making are that interested in rocking the boat. There's nobody forcing their hand and the country is doing great without needing to invade anyone.
Antibabelic··on Ideas are cheap, execution is cheaper
"The ability to actually build something—to turn a napkin sketch into working software—was the thing that separated dreamers from builders. It’s what made you valuable."

There is also the matter of having ideas that are good and knowing how to make them into good software, not something that simply "technically works". LLMs are not enough to overcome this barrier, and the author's examples seem to prove the point. The "working products with test suites, documentation, and polish" that are just another batch of LLM front-ends are frankly unimpressive. Is this the best that AI can offer?

Antibabelic··on Impeccable Style
"Great design prompts require design vocabulary. Most people don't have it."

Vocabulary is just the surface. Beneath it is an understanding of how to achieve your goals with design. How to make things that are easy to use, accessible, that create a certain impression.

Does this website (presumably made with the help of these AI tools) show this kind of understanding of design? Not really. It's chaotic, the text is often hard to read and there is a ton of fluff, both in terms of visuals and copy.

There is a "Frequently Asked Questions" section and a "Popular" $100 tier in the "Support the Project" section, even though this project seems to be brand new. Why lie to the reader?

Antibabelic··on To those who fired or didn't hire tech writers because of AI
What is this? Your website? How is it relevant to the post?
Antibabelic··on Erich von Däniken has died
The Morning of the Magicians was written by Louis Pauwels and Jacques Bergier, not Charroux.
Antibabelic··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
> The world needs WAY more software than we can economically provide

Is that really true? I'm getting the impression that most software reinvents the wheel.

Antibabelic··on AI is forcing us to write good code
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_condition/decision_co...
Antibabelic··on Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI
Do you have any evidence that an LLM created something massive, but the person using it received all the praise?
Antibabelic··on Perfect Software – Software for an Audience of One
Why did you abandon them? Every time I ask this question, I get lots of sob stories, but not a single explanation.
Antibabelic··on Perfect Software – Software for an Audience of One
> I would have never gotten to this stage of my dream project without AI tooling.

Why not? People have been writing successful personal projects without LLMs for years.

Antibabelic··on Nabokov's guide to foreigners learning Russian
> Do they even have a neighbouring country that speaks English?

Ireland.

Antibabelic··on What Is (AI) Glaze?
This page is light on technical detail. What does Glaze do to an image specifically?
Antibabelic··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
Is it possible that practical quantum computing is actually impossible and we only think it is because of our incomplete understanding of physics?
Antibabelic··on No Graphics API
"Offtop" is not a word. It's not in any English dictionary I could find and doesn't appear in any published literature.

Matthew 7:3 "And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?"

Antibabelic··on This is not the future
Everything is inevitable. If it happened, then it couldn't have happened otherwise. "Your computer sending screenshots to microsoft so they can train AIs on it" was inevitable, because that's what incentives pushed them to do. Vocal opposition and boycotting might become a different kind of incentive, but in most cases it doesn't work. The fact of the matter is that corporations are powerful, shareholders are powerful, the collective mass of indifferent consumers are powerful, while you are powerless.
Antibabelic··on French supermarket's Christmas advert is worldwide hit (without AI) [video]
The core difference is in the amount of intentional decisions being made by the artist. A prompt, no matter how specific, still delegates a lot of work to what is essentially chance. Something like Blender does make it easier to do certain things, but you still have to actively choose to do them. This is why AI-slop, no matter how detailed, will always feel off. It lacks the deliberateness of a human artist who knows exactly what they're doing and why at every level.
← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →