HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Antibabelic

900 karma · joined September 1, 2025

submissionscomments
Antibabelic··on French supermarket's Christmas advert is worldwide hit (without AI) [video]
I think it's debatable whether the principle that "any press is good press" is actually true. Especially for a brand that is already a household name. People will talk about you, yes. But is it a good thing that they're gonna be talking, and reinforcing the association in the minds of your customers, that you're putting out lazy, soulless slop? Of course, that's de facto what McDonald's is, but it's not like they don't benefit from at the very least an illusion that this isn't the case.
Antibabelic··on We Need to Die
Rather, confusing models (including computational ones) for the things they model is the very definition of magical thinking. Matter matters. There is nothing specific about "brains" that prevents them from "existing" digitally. The fact is that nothing material can "exist" in a computational substrate. A computer can only simulate: replicate the structure of material things in a useful to us manner using symbols.
Antibabelic··on Ask HN: Is it still worth learning a new programming language?
If you don't actually want to write code there's no reason to learn anything. The question is, if LLMs can write much better code than you, what does your employer need you for?
Antibabelic··on We Need to Die
> Put us in computers

I feel like this is a modern version of believing in souls. You are matter, not data. If you find a way to simulate yourself on a computer, this will not prevent you from experiencing death. And if that's the case, what's the point? Stroking your ego with the knowledge that a simulation of you will stick around for some time after you give up the ghost?

Antibabelic··on The closer we look at time, the stranger it gets
Would you like to share any details?
Antibabelic··on Manual: Spaces
I remember seeing some studies that experimentally show this to be true for Hebrew (another de/ascender-poor writing system), but can't find them at the moment.
Antibabelic··on Why I don’t root for the Many Worlds team
The author treats the Copenhagen interpretation as if it shows that there are no observer-independent things, when in reality it simply states that quantum theory is not about them.

"Bohr (1937), Heisenberg (1947), Frank (1936) and others explained carefully -- but did not prove -- that the theory makes no assertions concerning autonomous, i.e. observer-independent, things: that all its statements are about experimental situations. (This is why Bohr, and initially also Rosenfeld, stated that no special theory of measurement was necessary: they believed that quantum mechanics was already a theory of measurement.)" From Mario Bunge (1979) "The Einstein-Bohr debate over quantum mechanics: Who was right about what?"

Antibabelic··on In Northern Scotland, the Neolithic Age Never Ended
You can believe the references the Wikipedia article is based off, such as BBC Scotland:

"They surveyed hundreds of fish and chip shops in Scotland to find out if "the delicacy" was available and if people were actually buying them. It found 66 shops which sold them, 22% of those who answered the survey. [...] Annie Anderson, from the Centre for Public Health Nutrition Research at the University of Dundee, used to send her medical students out into the city to see if they could find somewhere that sold deep-fried Mars bar. "It was not much of a challenge in Dundee," she says."

Antibabelic··on How AI is transforming work at Anthropic
I'm yet to see a convincing example of LLMs producing anything substantially insightful.
Antibabelic··on Everyone in Seattle hates AI
They are also the people who are able to see the most clearly how subpar generative-AI output is. When you can't find a single spot without AI slop to rest your eyes on and see it get so much praise, it's natural to take it as a direct insult to your work.
Antibabelic··on Greeting Vocalizations in Domestic Cats Are More Frequent with Male Caregivers
I'm not sure I understand your distinction between understanding of language and general mental capacity. As I (and the other person responding, I believe) understand, the two are inseparably connected in humans.
Antibabelic··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
You can get the same output from different mechanisms, like in your example. Another would be that it's equally possible to quickly do addition on a modern pocket calculator and an arithmometer, despite them fundamentally being different. However.

1. You can infer the output from the mechanism. (Because it is implemented by it).

2. You can't infer the mechanism from the output. (Because different mechanisms can easily produce the same output).

My point here is 1, in response to the parent commenter's "the mechanism of operation dictates the output, which isn't necessarily true". The mechanism of operation (whether of LLMs or sunflowers) absolutely dictates their output, and we can make valid inferences about that output based on how we understand that mechanism operates.

Antibabelic··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
Human "thought" is the way it is because "electrical impulses" (wildly inaccurate description of how the brain works, but I'll let it pass for the sake of the argument) implement it. They are its mechanism. LLMs are not implemented like a human brain, so if they do have anything similar to "thought", it's a qualitatively different thing, since the mechanism is different.
Antibabelic··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
> The non sequitur is in assuming that somehow the mechanism of operation dictates the output, which isn't necessarily true.

Where does the output come from if not the mechanism?

Antibabelic··on Beej's Guide to Learning Computer Science
So the answer is "it's not a guide to computer science". It's like a guide talking about how to get better at mental calculation being titled "guide to learning mathematics", or a guide to language learning being titled "guide to learning linguistics".
Antibabelic··on UK Government plans new powers to label dissenting movements as 'subversion'
Notably, this quote makes actual historians cringe. But hey, if it sounds cool it must be the Truth!
Antibabelic··on Writing as Psychotechnology
I find the idea of having to pump out posts every day more questionable, rather than the length. In my experience, this is the model of content farms, not people who write things when they know they have something excellent to share.
Antibabelic··on Writing as Psychotechnology
> This month I’ve been doing Inkhaven — a writing workshop in Berkley, California where you must publish a 500+ word blog post every day or they kick you out

So the name of the game is quantity over quality?

Antibabelic··on Penpot: The Open-Source Figma
They are referring the Clojure, which is hosted on the JVM.
Antibabelic··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
You are making the false assumption that if output can be inferred from structure, the converse is true as well. Similarity in behaviour does not in any way, shape or form imply structural similarity. The boy scout, the migrating swallow, the foraging bee, and the mobile robot are good at orienteering. Do they achieve this goal in a similar manner? Not really.

Re: "I'm baffled that someone in CS, a field ruled by applied abstraction, has to be explained over and over again that abstraction is a thing that exists". Computer science deals with models of computation. You are making a classic mistake in confusing models for the real things they are capable of modelling.

Antibabelic··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
There is no level of abstraction to go up sans context. Again, let me repeat myself as well: the calculator and the arithmometer do the same things -- from the point of view of the cleric that needs to add and subtract quickly. Otherwise they are simply two completely different objects. And we will have a hard time making correct inferences about how one works based only on how we know the other works, or, e.g. how calculating machines work.

What I'm interested in is evidence that supports that "The more you try to look into the LLM internals, the more similarities you find". Some pointers to specific books and papers will be very helpful.

Antibabelic··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
Without a direct comparison to human internals (grounded in neurobiology, rather than intuition), it's hard to say how similar these similarities are, and if they're not simply a result of the transparency illusion (as Sydney Lamb defines it).

However, if you can point us to some specific reading on mechanistic interpretability that you think is relevant here, I would definitely appreciate it.

Antibabelic··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
They are doing "the same thing" only from the point of view of function, which only makes sense from the point of view of the thing utilizing this function (e.g. a clerical worker that needs to add numbers quickly).

Otherwise, if "the parts are all different, and the construction isn't even remotely similar", how can the thing they're doing be "the same"? More importantly, how is it possible to make useful inferences about one based on the other if that's the case?

Antibabelic··on Show HN: Stun LLMs with thousands of invisible Unicode characters
"How would this impact people who rely on screen readers" was exactly my first thought. Unfortunately, it seems there is no middle-ground. Screen-reader-friendly means computer-friendly.
Antibabelic··on RuBee
Aren't there manufacturers that only really target local markets that could profit from this technology, e.g. in China, ex-USSR or South America?
Antibabelic··on RuBee
Why can't the manufacturers market "smart guns" outside the US? Surely, the NRA's grip isn't world-spanning.
Antibabelic··on The Useful Personal Computer
By "back in the day" I was thinking more IBM PC era, rather than Windows 95 era. I agree that there's almost no qualitative difference between how personal computing was done 30 years ago and now.
Antibabelic··on Drawbot: Let's hack something cute (2025)
This thing is basically a small pen plotter for kids. Would love to see it do a more complicated design.
Antibabelic··on Spore
I'm not sure what this is tryibg to say specifically. That we should critique society?
Antibabelic··on The Useful Personal Computer
> Maps, messenger, banking app, taking/viewing photos, web browser, listening to audio (music, podcasts, audiobooks), taxi app, calendar/reminders

That's not really "little". Back in the day computers could only do a fraction of this. Today you have it all in your pocket

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →