HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ArneBab

494 karma · joined August 17, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/arnebab; my proof: https://keybase.io/arnebab/sigs/iOQAz_dGJHtEoZqEiy1Xn1ig9dUNH_OFKqgQgJM-Lu4 ]
submissionscomments
ArneBab··on First impressions of the Freenet network
The inactivity is due to index creators having stopped updating one year ago, so what you saw were old blogs — while missing the new one from the last year.

There’s a new index that should be part of the default entry pages in the next release: USK@5ijbfKSJ4kPZTRDzq363CHteEUiSZjrO-E36vbHvnIU,ZEZqPXeuYiyokY2r0wkhJr5cy7KBH9omkuWDqSC6PLs,AQACAAE/clean-spider/37/

I wish that next release were already released, but the changes in Java 16 and 17 have thrown rocks into the path of getting Freenet 1493 released. Spending the weekends fighting with a Windows VM to get a tray app working you’ll never run yourself is pretty annoying … but necessary to make this easy for regular users.

ArneBab··on First impressions of the Freenet network
I don’t understand why the installer was corrupted.

This just works for me:

wget 'https://github.com/freenet/fred/releases/download/build01492...' -O new_installer_offline.jar; java -jar new_installer_offline.jar;

ArneBab··on Code.gouv.fr: 9000 open source programs published by the French public sector
And social security, healthcare, job security, and pension are pretty good, so you don’t have to save as much as safety net for the risk of getting sick or being fired to have a decent life when you’re older.
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
This sounds like it tries to establish the notion of global respectability (see https://web.archive.org/web/20170628190710/http://www.advoga...). It’s something that I consider futile — part of the huge failure of clearnet moderation: To moderate billions of people, you have to give up on the notion of a global notion of who is always right.

It might be possible to establish for a given not heavily contested fact whether it is correct, but not to establish for a given person whether they are a crank. Just ask people around the world about the POTUS.

Freenet replaces that by personal trust. The only remainder of a global trust is initial visibility via seed-IDs. And that is transparent and can be revoked by every user.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
If you had read what the poster said you’d know that they are fixing the problem. And already did a lot to fix it.
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
To be consistent with that argument, you also need to oppose WhatsApp groups on ethical grounds. Do you?
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
You should investigate how this changes with the Web Of Trust plugin and FMS — both have been in use for more than a decade.

Both provide user-controlled moderation. They make it your responsibility as user not to boost people who post content you disagree with. And if it isn’t seen, it disappears automatically from Freenet, just as it does with a caching proxy.

Both are game-changers, and if it weren’t for them, I would have a hard time using Freenet.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
I’ll go through them:

- it splits data into chunks, encrypts it end to end → same as Freenet.

- uses a Kademlia DHT which removes the IP addresses after the first hop so no one can find all the nodes → same for Freenet, except that Freenet has many additional privacy protections in the protocol and uses node-locations on a ring like Chord, but with an inferred small word structure that allows efficient routing without the need to be able to connect to anyone but your direct peers.

- has consensus about the files and their evolution → Freenet has signed, user-controlled keyspaces, so no consensus is needed. Lifetime is given by access (what people access is kept alive) without actually having to track accesses, which is much safer for privacy than a consensus algorithm.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
That would be great — I’d love to welcome you to Freenet, where no one can watch you read!
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
I would go even further and say that people should be able (in practical life) to choose their own moderators to filter and curate content. And know that they work for them, not for some third party.

In today's media visibility is massively skewed by the platform's interest of "engagement" — which too often means enragement. That’s how fake news spread so fast (also in ad-click-financed newspapers, by the way).

They aren’t only exploiting human psyche, but also the proprietary, centrally controlled algorithms that drive social networks and the ad-financing of newsrooms.

If you log out of Youtube and then watch a talk about Java development, and then the Youtube algorithm suggests alt-right content in the auto-play-list, then something is wrong with the algorithm.

It is ironic that platforms that send the fake news your way in the first place then put a fact check underneath.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
What would be closer to pagerank?

Freenet ranks others by their distance to you and weights their votes from that before aggregating them.

And the up- and down-votes in the Web of trust are signed, because that is what happens automatically if you upload something under your key in Freenet.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Freenet currently takes the simpler route of suggesting to use the phones' IME (because that isn’t already proven to send all keystrokes).

It is likely that using Freenet in opennet-mode can get you on a watchlist — but you’re already on that if you wrote here.

There have not been report of actual tracking of Freenet in pure friend-to-friend mode, but there are too few people using it exclusively in that mode to be sure.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
(and already with a Pi4, those resource-hungry plugins are no problem anymore)
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Why do you think so? 99% of people would block someone who shares CSAM. And in Freenet’s moderation systems blocking automatically propagates to those who truts your judgement.

So normal people would expunge CSAM, too. Just by wanting to remove it from their timelines.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
But you are not safe to discuss anything on most Chinese smartphones regardless of the App, because common input methods in China (optimized software keyboards) send all your keystrokes to their servers.

Freenet actually warns you about that during installation.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Groups of people from very different backgrounds discussing politics for more than a decade without lifting their pseudonyms, in Forums that actually persist while most forums in the clearnet died?

For me that’s a compelling use-case.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
The release this year adds streaming video on demand over Freenet and fixes the pitch black attack.

And confidential Friend-to-Friend Chat over Freenet as Android App.

Last year saw Freenet ported to Android.

There are a lot of changes still in the pipeline to be released this year.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Which is exactly what Freenet provides, because it is needed to prevent censorship by spamming.

Along with pseudonymity that prevents people from pressuring you into voting as they wish.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
In the concrete case, Freenet runs quite well on a Pi3. Just do not activate the Sone- and WoT-plugin (they are quite resource-hungry).
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
There were also times in history when technology and knowledge got lost in religious zealotry. Some of it we are only now trying to recover. We don’t know how much is still missing.

If information is of real value — like vaccines — … do you see where I’m going?

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
A pull-request (or repo) with a flatpak recipe would be very welcome, too.

Though distro-packaging in Guix is still far superior to a flatpak, because it gives the freedom of flatpaks but integrates much better.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Yes to the first.

To the second no: In Freenet 0.5 there was a plugin for that, but for 0.7 this has not been written yet.

You can write that, but you cannot check what exactly it would block. Whom do you trust to censor you? The devs cannot make that judgement. And who will control the censors? You would need a list of all chunks to block (by their routing key).

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
That it faced little protest is not true. It only faced little protest in the streets, because most responsible people stayed at home during the pandemic. The protest online was loud.
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
The goal is to publish a story. Hiding the identity of a source is a way towards that goal.

The journalist does not need privacy or confidentiality to publish. The source does. And without the source, there’s no story.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Yes. That experience made me change to that. But “John Doe” will quickly be my IP address when there’s a Nazi in police (see the reports about organized Neonazis in police and military in Germany in the past few years who also leaked police data to other Neonazis).

I can use Tor or I can use Freenet. That’s it. I use both: Tor to google simple medical questions. Freenet to discuss. Because in Freenet — different from Tor — the Forums don’t die and the prevailing forums don’t block me with neigh unsolvable CAPTCHAs.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Freenet provides both: Secrecy of content and pseudonymity — both are required to enable confidential disclosure to a journalist on the (typically valid) assumption that the opsec of the journalist is far from perfect.
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
You could also ask, how TERREG could be consistent with European values.
ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
The balance has been that the cops can take you into custody when there is suspicion against you, but if you’re not suspected of a heinous crime, they are not allowed to read your diary.

In the past decade that has been shifting more and more towards “the cops can break open every device you have just in case you may someday do something illegal”.

But if they can install physical surveillance, all security is already moot. That is the balance that works.

But that is no longer enough. They want to have cheaper surveillance of everyone instead. Surveillance that is cheap enough to be used on everyone.

And they promise they will totally not abuse that. Or send your address to violent extremist groups that are pissed at you because you exposed their activities. As happened to more than one journalist in Germany who investigated Nazis.

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Yes. Nextgens has it planned and will be on it once he has the time.

If you want to file a pull request, that would be very welcome!

The new chat is https://web.libera.chat/?nick=FollowTheRabbit|?#freenet

ArneBab··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Or that you could have unencrypted data, that cops could xor into illegal data.

I bet you’re just using those unencrypted images to hide evil stuff with steganography! We found illegal content by xoring our totally not invented xor "keys" with the noise in your JPEGs!

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →