HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Attrecomet

309 karma · joined August 19, 2022

submissionscomments
Attrecomet··on How I ship projects at big tech companies
What is the alternative, though? This is an honest question, I really want to know: How would the "this is horrible, how can you deign to work that way?" crowd coordinate thousands of people on a project to create something that is bigger than what 5–20 people can create?

Because most of the answers I see here gloss over that part, or strongly imply that engineers will always decide better than business people what should be released. And I can sympathize, especially if you are in an MBA-led org, but I am also certain that if you think you know perfectly what the enterprise or customer needs, and anyone opposing you is a Pointy-Haired Boss, that you are most probably the idiot in that case: 90% of the time a single dev will NOT have better business intelligence than everyone else.

Attrecomet··on Jaywalking legalized in New York City
It was a fun evening with the guys from Bavaria in Berlin
Attrecomet··on Law Enforcement Undermines Tor
In actual fact, your proposal is too modest. Why should only electronic messages be so publicized? After all, relevant communication, either for our protectors in law enforcement (and secret services, don't forget their hard work for our prosperity) or for us members of society, happens via all kinds of mediums.

Privacy of correspondence might have had some relevance in the past, but today, with LLMs helping us work through the huge amount of data, every letter should automatically be scanned and added to a database for further consumption. Every telephone conversation. Actually, we should force phone manufacturers to turn their devices into permanent microphones and record everything they hear, gathered in public databases.

The best results from last week's search can then be read aloud in church or at community meetups.

Attrecomet··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
That is true, and don't get me wrong, I'm happy if that works for you -- people should make use of that possibility far more often.

It's not for possible for everyone, though, and the bar is not "is any IP loss realistic" but rather "what are the policies my employer demands", independent of if they are sensible or not. Make sure you're not getting caught breaking company policy, kids :P

Attrecomet··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
> We all have laptops and can go any where to work.

Well, anywhere I can be sure no external person can see what I'm doing on screen. So a cafe will work if I can sit in a corner with my back to a wall. And even then, I'm giving up my tooling to make work easier on myself and more productive, like a nice, large monitor. Coworking spaces let me alleviate the second part, but the first problem is even more pressing there: now, everyone around me must be expected to understand what I'm doing, and thus is a bigger danger to my companies data security.

Attrecomet··on Why Not Comments
> Other wasteful comments are added by some tools. I hate the one that marks every loop wiht a //for or //try comment.

Oh god, that's horrible, what kind of tool does that?!

Attrecomet··on Dutch DPA fines Uber €290M because of transfers of drivers’ data to the US
We don't say "Ponzi scheme" here, we say "disrupting traditional markets" and "investment opportunity"
Attrecomet··on Dutch DPA fines Uber €290M because of transfers of drivers’ data to the US
>The EU keeps moving the goalposts on what constitutes “safe” transfers (we’re on the 5th round of this)

This is a wrong phrasing of the problem: The US is not, and has never been, a safe haven to transfer personal data to. However, it would significantly impact trade (and policing) concerns between the EU and the US if that statement were to be treated seriously. This is why the European Commission and the Parliament have repeatedly tried to create a framework which allows transfer of data despite the US' insistence on secret access to the data without due process (aka secret courts, which cannot be due process by any reasonable definition). European courts, again repeatedly, have taken the stipulations in various laws guaranteeing rights to citizens seriously, and keep striking down the badly made frameworks. It's not "shifting goal posts", but rather "not willing to accept the political costs of respecting citizens' rights".

Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
We very literally do not have the resources to lift up every human on this planet onto US living standards. There is not enough oil, not enough uranium, not enough rare earths that we know how to extract to provide the whole world with the glut of energy that the average American requires for their standard of living. I most certainly do NOT need to wish for bigger populations in order to increase the bottom-line standard of living.
Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
No, you are misreading what I'm saying. GP clearly means the current birth rate when talking about "unsustainable birth rates". I am pointing out that the pronatalist position is the actually unsustainable one. It's not hard to understand, really: we do not have the resources on this planet to give everyone an acceptable standard of living, let alone a US one. Any effort to reduce the resource usage via sustainability measures will be completely eaten up if we insist on increasing the human population of this planet. That is quite unsustainable -- far more so than a country having a birth rate under replacement for a while.
Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
Another disingenuous argument ignoring what was actually said. It seems you know that many pronatalists are deeply racist ("we must secure a future for the white race and out children") and view women's agency over their own bodies and lives as a fundamental problem, but are unwilling to deal with it.

But luckily, you declared the argument closed before actually taking time to read the comment...

Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
And yet, we are discussing a movement that wants to artificially increase birth rates that have fallen too low for their tastes. It seems you don't actually need to force control birth rates, just give women agency over their own lives.
Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
Pro-natalism however does not care about sustainable world population (the relevant metric for resources in a globalized world), but "grow as fast as you can to outcompete the brown or Muslim people", as many pronatalists comments here remind us -- all the "societies that don't breed quickly are all conquered" comments.
Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
And now, thanks to increased control over the environment due to technology and science, there are new tools in our repository that our ancestors did not have, like actually sitting down and planning how to avoid an ecological collapse -- and waging war with advanced weapons that negate a pure "breed fast" strategy. It sure would be nice if we didn't have to return to regular periods of widespread starvation like they did back in the Middle Ages, when they were too uninformed to not remove all forests and powerless to avoid staying away from the carrying capacity of their world for any amount of time.
Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
What a petty response to efforts to avert an ecological and humanitarian catastrophe. Maybe you should just give up if that's the best you can do.
Attrecomet··on Pushing baby booms to boost economic growth amounts to a Ponzi scheme
By "unsustainable growth rates" you mean an ever-expanding population on a planet that cannot realistically offer up the resources for this population to live in moderate wealth, right?
Attrecomet··on 40 out of 60 German climate greening endavours fraudulent
Yes, in a museum's deep vault somewhere, since it's one of a kind.
Attrecomet··on 40 out of 60 German climate greening endavours fraudulent
>the credit system seems as reasonable as any.

It's fraud, pure and simple. I don't know how such a broken system could be "reasonable" for anything. But hey, at least polluters can lie to their customers and claim "their greenhouse emissions have been offset", so I guess capitalistically, it makes sense.

Attrecomet··on I built an ROV to solve missing person cases
>The proper comparison isn't the author's time versus the readers looking it up, but rather readers encountering a term for the first time having to look it up versus every other reader having to read overly verbose writing that reiterates basic definitions rather than getting to the novel points. If you're as interested in ROVs as you imply, well now you know for all of the other times you will read the term. If you're really expecting to never encounter the term again, I wonder why you're reading a technical engineering-adjacent forum.

This isn't a water hobbyists forum, nor one for all manner of remotely operated vehicles, so it's a bit optimistic to assume many people here will know "ROV" as a remote controlled submarine. Fact is, most of us cannot, from the title, figure out if we're interested, nor from skimming the first six (!) pages of a long article. Explaining ROV once at the beginning would, I dare say, not have impacted the enjoyment of underwater professionals very much, but saved me and most others on this forum some time figuring out if I want to figure it out.

Attrecomet··on Study finds 268% higher failure rates for Agile software projects
I think the hate stems from so many people working in environments where either the company has bureaucratized their nominally agile process to the point of absurdity or just having superiors that are in over their head, which makes any kind of methodology a farce; bad leadership can only be mitigated so far by processes, especially of someone has to take responsibility for said processes and that often by default is the mentioned in-over-their-head superior.
Attrecomet··on Study finds 268% higher failure rates for Agile software projects
I think you missed the invisible /s tags to those sentences.
Attrecomet··on Study finds 268% higher failure rates for Agile software projects
Not if the project succeeds because it was important enough for more resources and time to be allotted.
Attrecomet··on Study finds 268% higher failure rates for Agile software projects
>If you tried agile and it failed, it wasn't actually agile. When you show how it was actually agile, you didn't do it right. When you show you did it right - go back to argument 1. It's a really circular no true scotsman style of argument.

It'd be interested in seeing that argument in the wild. Mostly I see complaints like yours when people point out that an hour-long daily that the manager uses to harangue the developers isn't actually agile, and that is perfectly true. Or that a blame-assigning retro or measuring dev productivity using story points is not actually agile, which is at least true insofar that it clearly is forbidden in Scrum, and stupid in any case.

Though I find it interesting that you end with kanban -- an agile methodology. It seems you do like to use agile after all, just not scrum.

Attrecomet··on The Moral Economy of the Shire
Except it very obviously IS a medieval world. Not our Middle Ages, but a world that works very closely like how we understand Middle Ages to work. It's feudal, he understands Anglo-Saxon warfare to an amount surprising in an author of trivial literature, and he very obviously DID make a huge effort to make many details correct either in the "how we understand the past" way or to frame them in a way that is understandable for the people who read Beowulf and similar myths.
Attrecomet··on The Moral Economy of the Shire
ASOIAF however portrays a very clearly medieval society -- vassalage (badly used in the story, but obviously meant to be quite feudal), the general tech level with castles (not palaces!) and the language used are all meant to evoke a late medieval feeling. What Rome did with Carthage is pretty immaterial in this context, because no medieval European ruler would have either the inclination or the ability to enact such destruction.

I'd also point out that destroying an entire city is not total war. Brutality in war and targeting civilians isn't enough to be total war in itself, especially if it's limited to exceptional circumstances -- in general, Rome was extremely happy to conquer new populations to increase their ability to extract wealth.

Attrecomet··on The Moral Economy of the Shire
In a pre-industrial society, rich agricultural lands and even just this year's produce would count as something worthy to loot. Heck, they might do so now -- I'm sure Russia wouldn't be unhappy to be able to add fertile Ukrainian lands to their dystopia.
Attrecomet··on The Moral Economy of the Shire
This magnanimity is also something prized in Earth-medieval kingship, too. Many a revolt against a king ended with the king pardoning the vassals that rose up -- only a king very secure in his throne could depose or even execute rebellious vassals. Of course, it's important that it be a common member of the nobility for this to work consistently. Against commoners, brutality was far less politically costly. And heretics (read: Kathars), who risk the Wrath of God coming over the whole community, are even less worthy of protection.
Attrecomet··on Google lays off its Python team
Everybody tough with their job-dependent healthcare until they are let go because a chronic illness is too debilitating for the demands of the job and they are left with nothing but monthly medical costs of a few tens of thousands of dollars.
Attrecomet··on Google lays off its Python team
I would have expected countries like Poland to have a mature enough IT ecosystem that Google could have just moved there directly if they wanted. Why stop over at one of Europe's most expensive places to get talent if that was to goal?
Attrecomet··on Fixing all the bugs won't solve all the problems – Deming's path of frustration
Disagree. Architecture problems are different enough from software bugs that it's worth it to keep them separate words.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →