HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Banana699

845 karma · joined October 2, 2020

Hates Trannies, Hates Faggots.
submissionscomments
Banana699··on Cloudflare's abuse policies and approach
Ok, but your pressuring is not working. We're just trying to save you from wasting your time.
Banana699··on Cloudflare's abuse policies and approach
Yes you can, convince your friends to deactivate their social media accounts where\when they're harrassed or aggressively block those who harrass them. Teach them tips and tricks to bully back (bullying is really easy). Find them mental health professionals and services, and possibly help them financially with those services.
Banana699··on Cloudflare's abuse policies and approach
>They (KiwiFarms, Daily Stormer) would be better not on the internet.

That's not for you to decide, you're not the manager of the internet.

Banana699··on Why are deep learning technologists so overconfident?
>What are the top 3 things accomplished and implemented by the “extremely powerful” neural networks and machine learning?

Off the top of my head and in no particular order :

1- Playing human games at superhuman performance from raw pixels

2- Recognizing objects and people in images at human or better performance

3- Recognizing human voice in real world noisy environments and parsing it into text at human or better performance

>How significant are these top 3 things?

They generate billions of dollars of profit and beat human knowledge and expertise that took thousands\millions of years to craft and\or evolve with nothing but a GPU and a lot of electricity.

>Have you ever built a production model for a large company or have a tier 1 phd?

No.

>what are your qualifications for labeling a claim ridiculous.

I have a brain that can spot ridiculous hyperbolic claims, and experience-backed knowledge with neural networks and machine learning that can explain with examples why they are ridiculous and hyperbolic.

If you do have the qualifications you request, start with using them to support your claims. Here's a small challenge that should pose no difficulty to you.

Show me, with derivations and citations, how an RNN is "just" an obscure statistical model. Which statistician first published or applied it ? Is it taught in a statistics course you know of ? Which ones ? Are research statisticians publishing on it right now or ever ? In what sense is it part of the science of statistics like, say, the normal distribution is ?

Banana699··on Why are deep learning technologists so overconfident?
This is as ridiculous as claiming that a neural network is going to make Skynet.

First, statistics is not a small branch of math, proability theory is (not a small branch by the way, not by a long shot, just a branch, one of the fundamental and very large ones). Statistics is the art and science of dealing with data, it uses probability theory like physics uses math, but is far more than probability theory just like physics is far more than math.

Second, Neural nets and machine learning in general is an extremly powerful way of solving problems of certain structure and form, and it solves problems not encountered in statistics. Claiming it's a small branch of statistics is like claiming that the entirety of computer science is a small branch of logic.

Banana699··on Why Stephen Fry is arguing against political correctness (2018)
My counterexample list is not just myself, that's just the first and most obvious element. There is no point to listing all the people that hate your newfound religion despite being from the 'younger generation', almost everybody hates this shit, probably including your kids as well.

A free man should resist anything, whether it's a change or the status quo, if it's pushed by self-serving bullies and pathetic status seekers. The dominant religion where I live is 1400+ years old, it's a moral and intellectual disease embraced only by the scum and the naive.

I'm not being extra hard on your religion because it's good to be spiteful, this is just how I treat most religions. It's good to be spiteful to religions and their followers because that's what they deserve most.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
No, I didn't. How does this relate to my comment ?
Banana699··on Why Stephen Fry is arguing against political correctness (2018)
One man's immaturity is another man's "having a spine to stand up for oneself". Spite is awesome, I wish people had more spite in them, without spite you're just a chicken following whatever the nest is crying about, which is the sorry state of most of humanity most of the time.

Your delusions of a monolithic 'younger generation' on the 'right side of history' inevitably triumphing are pathetic. Not how history works, not how reality is; Prime counterexample include me for a start.

Banana699··on List of Creepypastas
If you hadn't already seen it, check out Vsauce's "Why Are Things Creepy" on youtube.

Be advised that the thumbnail of the video is creepy though.

Banana699··on Why Stephen Fry is arguing against political correctness (2018)
If your boy Mike, however, had a temper tantrum every time someone called him "Michael", or exerted public pressure on corporate HR and lawmakers to make it illegal to call him "Michael", I would indeed go out of my way to call him Michael, even if I don't actually know or care about him. It gives me pleasure to enrage entitled people demanding things they have no right to expect.

In order to have my respect and niceness, you have to ask for it with respect and niceness. Otherwise you're just begging for abuse, and you have nobody to blame but yourself when it comes. I suspect I'm far from the only one who see it this way.

Banana699··on Why Stephen Fry is arguing against political correctness (2018)
As long as they don't impede my own right to free speech? sure, go ahead, delude yourself to your heart's content.

Free speech advocates aren't the ones screaming hysterically about "dead naming" and 3rd person pronouns.

Banana699··on Why Stephen Fry is arguing against political correctness (2018)
Enforcing puritan language just makes you the new butt of jokes. You may think you're changing hearts and minds, but all of them are just humouring you like we humour kids having a temper tantrum. Independent minds, the ones that count, don't humour though, they will always just double down and use the language you hate further just to enrage you, because fuck you - really - who are you to tell me what to say and what to do? Ironically, the words you hate are now even more venomous and powerful in my hand because you fear and censor them so much.

You just reinvented a worse religion, all the uptightness and self-righteousness with none of the community or the forgiveness.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
Is this supposed to be a coherent answer?
Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
There is no such thing as "objectively harmful", all harm or good is decided through values, and those values differ. The exact same way you deal with paedophilia, is the way some countries deal with the LGBT.

It doesn't have to be governments only as well, the Middle East is majority Muslim after all, and muslims do get incredibly offended at LGBT stuff (a lot of Arabic insults are just variations on "gay"). So, according to you, those private citizens and corporations should be allowed to ban the LGBT, it's not censorship if the government isn't doing it right?

>I never argued this.

No, but you did argue for something indistinguishably similar, which is that because a news story is found on Fox then this news story is not actually censored. So, by that same unassailable logic, LGBT stuff is on Netflix and therefore LGBT stuff is not actually being censored. All objections you have against my satire argument is applicable to your real argument.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
Well, I'm very interested in Free Speech and the immorality of censorship, so I will take this.

First, I will point out that almost no government, ever and everywhere, isn't full to the core with corruption and lying, like a decaying and rotten fruit left for weeks in a garbage dump.

Some Westerners are deluded with the strange thought that it somehow makes a difference that those who are bamboozling them do it through convoluted interlocking systems of protocols and processes, commonly called Democracy, and not through brute force or other such barbarous means.

From a dispassionate analysis of raw results, however, considering just the outside blackbox behaviour of a country without reference to its internal algorithms and data structures, almost every single thing China or Russia can do to a citizen, USA and Canada and UK And Germany can (and does), just maybe not as frequently and not as publicly (yet).

This rather large caveat\objection aside, I will take the question at face value : what can a (supposedly benevolent) government do in the face of outside propaganda? A lot.

First, propaganda is easy, especially when you're a government. If a foreign country is paying X to propagandize your citizens, you can afford to pay 10X, discounted by all the natural advantages you have when you're propagandizing your own citizens (same language and culture, official capacity to make and enforce laws, privileged position when dealing with media outlets, etc..., you literally rule). Indeed, for the same reason that religions always need a devil and revolutions always need enemies, the foreign propaganda might be a boon to you, a thing to rally against in your own propaganda, food for your propaganda artists.

Second, talk is cheap, and the vast majority of people would rather rage than do anything in real life. So, let propaganda fester, like a harmless fever. This an unfortunate effect of large human populations, known at the smaller scales as the bystander effect. In essence, everybody just says "not my problem" and just keeps shouting (if they do even that), hoping for someone else to actually do something, but everybody is thinking like that so nothing really gets done. This is bad for the people, but it's good for governments, it means most Free Speech is harmless. (which is bad news for any serious Free Speech advocate, because the goal isn't Free Speech in and of itself, but Free Expression, which starts with Free Speech but must end with Free Action. But again, this is all normative land, in actual material fact, most Free Speech is pure thunder without lightning or rain, and nobody loses anything by allowing it unless what they're hiding is truly egregious.)

Finally, returning to the first caveat again, maybe just fuck you, the government? Maybe the foreign government is actually correct and the citizens should revolt and create unrest and become ungovernable till their demands are met?

In summary, don't worry about the poor little governments, they can manage very well, with all the monopoly on violence and money printing and whatnot.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
>censorship is not inherently bad

Then why do you get mad when China or the Middle East bans material they find objectionable? They simply have a different definition of what counts as objectionable, that's all, and it's well within their rights to enforce their different cultural values within their borders, just like you argue that a "democracy" has this right.

Also, when I go to Netflix and search for "LGBT", I see tons of material. So that must obviously mean censoring of LGBT is a pathetic lie, it's right there in one (very big, much bigger than Fox) media outlet so it's obviously not censored.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
Not as funny as when people link to publicly available content in order to demonstrate China is banning it.
Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
If your website is a corporation hitting all the legal prerequisites for fairness requirements (size, market share,...), then yes, you must accept my neo Nazi comment. You are allowed to make rules that ban views on other grounds than its content, such as being spammy or off topic to the conversation, but you would have to have objective and neutral criteria for those bans, and you should be obligated to justify yourself to your users with non-automated means, and the banned users should be able to sue you at little or no cost if they perceive unfairness.

The local Christian cake shop are not a corporation and, by the very definition of 'local', almost certainly doesn't meet the legal prerequisites for fairness regulations, so they should not be forced to bake a cake against their will.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
Why does it matter to you that your sexuality is depicted on screen? Sounds like a bizarre thing to worry about.

And US studios already has you covered for centuries worth of "representation" heavy film and TV, why is the Chinese allowing them important?

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
Corporations are not people outside of idiotic law speak. They should have no rights to freedom of association once they reach a certain (law-defined) size.

Banana699 has the right to block you or otherwise tell you to fuck off from their private property, the 10 million viewers Banana699^TM Inc Ltd does not. Media corporations picking and choosing the type of the story to serve is a very plausible reason for the intense polarization and Rage-As-A-Service ecosystem we are in.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
First off, opening a comment with "Hello Troll" has to be the most childish and reddit-like way of opening an HN comment I have ever seen. If you think GP is a troll, you can simply not reply, indeed you are practically obligated by the guidelines not to. Once you reply, you are obligated to at least pretend you take the claims that you reply to seriously.

Secondly, why are you responding to "Those topics are censored" claim with "Here are all the correct answers to those topics that my media tells me to believe"? GP didn't say whether they think there is a correct answer to a topic and what, if any, may that answer be, GP has simply observed that those topics are heavily and nakedly suppressed in legacy media and social media, often with hilarious results (e.g. Instagram banning Cochrane, a medical database of the highest quality, simply for mentioning Ivermectin).

Contradicting GP here would consist of bringing up evidence that those topics were, on the contrary to GP's claim, discussed fairly and found wanting. Talking about correct answers are irrelevant, we're talking about whether all questions and answers are allowed for discussion. Because Americans are often shocked that China hates things they consider elementary and bans them, GP is simply saying their own society frequently and obviously engages in this as well, often with cheering from those self same people.

Third, some of your points about masks are self-contradicting. If the CDC lied about masks once, why wouldn't they lie twice or third or tenth? You would be a fool if you trust a liar after the 1st time, and medical institutions have proven to be thoroughly partisan and rotten and corrupt during the entire crisis, anybody taking a covid-related claim from a medical institution at face value is a prime target for bridge selling.

Another point is that masks come in types, and only very few types protect adequately against the latest covid variants, and the vast majority of people don't buy those types (N95 or KN95) or don't wear them correctly. So masks, as worn in practice, are indeed very close to useless, as evidenced from the fact that they're not predictive of viral spread (i.e the fact that a country's population wears masks has no better than random chance correlation with whether it has lower infections, i.e masks are statistically useless).

This why your correct answers are wrong, at least in part, some of the time. This is why you need to be constantly questioning them, and not rushing to defend the censorship loving institutions and corporations who have no particular interest in you or your well being, and all the interest in Power and Money and Status.

Fourth, why the hell are you bringing up more evidence for censorship as evidence against GP? You're supporting them, not contradicting them. GP never claimed the censorship is done by only 1 party, only that is done. You're arguing for GP's claim while thinking you're arguing against.

Banana699··on The Big [Censored] Theory
This is called Common Sense. To the extent that it's right-wing-coded in (and, I believe, only in) USA is only a reflection of how wacko their pseudo-left has gone.
Banana699··on The silent majority in software
I will review your perceptions of HN bubbles.

>Entry level Web Developers are getting $200K per year working in FAANG or Big Tech. Non-FANNG are getting $150K anyway.

I don't browse job threads much and I don't pay attention to people mentioning salaries so I can't say.

>Ruby may be dead, but PHP is even more dead.

>Java may rule the enterprise, but you should not mention Java.

For PHP and Java, there is a very strong case to be made that "dead" means "utterly flawed and completely uninteresting and somewhat ugly\repulsive and only worth writing if the money is very very good", which is (in my very humble opinion) trivially true. It doesn't matter how much they are written, they are dead branches on the PL evolutionary tree, they won't have progeny or nostalgic mind share rooting for them as languages.

I don't know what people declaring Ruby "dead" mean, perhaps its about Rails falling off the hype train or Python eating a lot of its potential mind share and market niche. But Ruby is definitely nowhere close to Java or PHP in bad design, it's a descendent of Smalltalk (which Java aped badly) and Perl (which PHP aped badly), the union is very fruitful and the language is delightful.

And for what it's worth, I remember 2 times I was pretty heavily downvoted because I criticized java. Same goes for C++ and JS. I don't remember seeing anyone downvoted for hating PHP, but also none for defending them. Seeing bubbles is very correlated with what your own biases are.

>No one uses Oracle or MySQL, why would you want that? Postgres is the only DB forward.

Maybe Oracle Bad, that's real and very popular here on HN, for good reasons. I don't remember anyone seriously saying you can't use MySQL or only use Postgres.

>Everything should be Remote.

God no, that's aweful. This position has fierce opposition, including me.

>Communication should always be Async

Maaaybe ? I see plenty of opposition to this. My personal opinion is that good comm is not sync or async, it's exactly what it needs to be to get the message across.

>Oh, Ada is the second Forbidden Fruit on HN.

Not really, it doesn't get mentioned alot because it has miniscule online resources but whenever it's mentioned (e.g. in the context of formal verification with Ada\Spark) there is broad enthusiasm and interest.

>Facebook is...... OK I guess we shouldn't go there.

Haha, yes. Very true. But (like Oracle) also for very good reasons. But I agree that Apple, Amazon or Google aren't angels either, and it rarely get mentioned. In fact, if I can choose a single FAANG company to destory overnight, it would be Apple, their way of treating customers disgust me so much.

>USB-C will solve all cabling problems. Everything should be USB-C.

>5G is useless.

>AV1 and AVIF. The video and image standard to rule them all.

Interesting, I never even saw those opinions expressed once, and I'm fairly addicted to HN. I'm beginning to suspect there are "Meta-Bubbles", bubbles where your perception of what things are bubbles is itself bubble-like.

>Nothing should be centralised. Everything should be distributed.

Hmmm No ? There is an HN bubble against cryptocurrency, which should be impossible if what you're saying is true.

>You do not criticise The Rusted Holy Grail and the Riscy Silver Bullet

True-ish, especially Rust. But there is plenty of aweful criticisms of Rust that always go something like "Everything the Rust compiler can do my own custom home-grown linter tool can also do, nobody needs memory safety if we just be careful also smart pointers and RAII". There is plenty of bad things to say about Rust, none of it leaves C and C++ in good light.

Banana699··on An Intuition for Lisp Syntax (2020)
The key to solving the halting problem is realizing that you don't need to solve the halting problem.

Problem : Code C has to run in finite time T, Solution : put a call to a watch dog routine at every loop start, at every subroutine start, and every n linear instructions in C. If the watch dog decides T has passed, it never returns control to the program (calls exit(-1), throws a special uncatchable exception,...). This can be automated by the compiler.

This is why AWS can give you a limited time for a Lambda or why every single multi-tasking OS can terminate an unresponsive process. They are not solving the halting problem.

If the language C is written in is bytecode-interpreted, you don't need to modify the guest program itself to achieve the described effect, you can make the interpreter itself keep track of T and refuse to evaluate further when it runs out. If the execution environment is preemptively concurrent, you don't need to modify the host program as well, simply make the watch dog preempts the guest at T.

Banana699··on An Intuition for Lisp Syntax (2020)
>that's the price you pay for homoiconicity

Well no but actually no. Mathematica is homoiconic, and it has tons of special syntax and sugar that all boils down to lists when you quote. Elixir also does this with a ruby-like syntax on top. Those are just the 2 I know of. Making the compiler available through a programmer-accessible API from within the program itself is the big idea, it has nothing to do with what the text grammar happens to be.

Banana699··on An Intuition for Lisp Syntax (2020)
Who cares? Assembly is regular*, very much so. There is a single control flow construct, in conditional and unconditional flavors. There is a single language construct, of which the single control flow construct is but a special case. Code is Data and Data is Code. Everything is possible.

You don't need regularity or simplicity, you need automation. Programming Languages are tools to under-specify a problem\process\pattern\solution\structure and still get an executable that does something useful, meaning the parts that weren't specified were filled in by the machine (in any way necessary), meaning automation. In other words, "A low level programming language is that which requires attention to the irrelevant", per Alan Perlis.

In that light, lisp's syntax is awful, you're laying down the AST yourself instead of making a parser figuring it out from program text. You're paying precious attention to the extremely irrelevant, the fact that a function's body is nested under its name, the fact that a control construct wraps its code, instead of letting those trivial facts fade into the background of a nicely-designed grammar and actually focus on the code itself.

There is literally 0 need for making code-as-text reflects code-as-tree, Mathematica represents every single language construct as a nested list underneath, and yet it has an extremely rich and pleasant syntax, full of sugar and shortcuts and alternate forms. It can do this because it understands a very fundamental point that lisp syntax fans too often miss : text is irrelevant.

The string "(+ (* 4 10) 2)" is not an S expression, its the textual form of an S expression, the serialized form. You can't do anything useful with it without parsing, the actual S expression is a hierarchical object graph in memory, you can either get it from the text by quoting the text, or immediately evaluate it by entering the text directly into an interpreter (which gets the tree first). In all cases, there is no reason why quoting `while (cond) {exprs}` can't evaluate to the list (while cond (exprs)). You are already parsing the text anyway, quote is nothing but invoking the parser from within a program, so make the textual form convenient to humans while you're at it, a simplistic form benefits no one but the parser (a machine, the very thing that needs to work hard).

Lisp's big idea is just making the compiler's services available through an easy API, this has absolutely nothing to do with its crippled syntax, it can be done by any language of any syntax whatsoever, much better than the 1960s hack lisp fans has stockholm-ed themselves into loving. To the extent it's rarely done in mainstream languages, it reflects the designers' choice.

* : I'm assuming a remotely sane ISA, not the excrement known as x86.

Banana699··on Wren is a small, fast, class-based concurrent scripting language
State Machines. Objects are supposed to model state machines, each mutating method is a transition event that takes the current state and any number of arguments and transition the state machine to a new state.

In very simple words, each object in an OOP program is a virtual computer, its class define the instruction set.

"Objects are a recursion on the notion of computer itself"

--Alan Kay

Banana699··on “Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans”
Free Speech is obvious, doesn't require 200 IQ by a long shot, I regret to inform you it's you who are just a dumbass.
Banana699··on What to read to understand how economists think
The closest thing that I know of is Philip Tetlock, he made a 20-year-long experiment where he asked a variety of "experts" about political events like the fall of the Berlin Wall, and recorded the results.
Banana699··on “Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans”
You don't have a meaningful point to see.
← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →