845 karma · joined October 2, 2020
"Why are people mad when I want to censor science and make it worship my false idol ?? it's so unfair"
>These guidelines are very like existing ethics guidelines found at universities and research institutions around the world
Show me a respectable university that tells scientists to "Consult with advocacy groups" before they publish any results, and I will show you a university that used to be respectable but now isn't.
>If that causes them to second guess whether the research they are conducting is worthwhile
Ah yes, it's all them second-guessing themselves. This won't be used to censor scientists at all, those scientists will just, spontaneously, see the error of their bigoted and heretical science, and refuse to publish it by themselves.
>How about large scale human vivisection?
Nice try, but this is about research methodology. The posted censorship guidelines is dealing with the final results of research, the papers, not the used methodology. We had ethics board since the 1970s and 1980s, you're not inventing anything useful.
It's amazing how desperate some people are to try to justify their nonsense.
You missed this small little thing called Rule of Law, which - in any polity worth living in - bans vigilante justice and forming mobs to punish people without trial.
You also missed this other small little thing called the Internet, where you can publish a paper on arxiv for free without review, or post its PDF link on 4chan completely anonymously. Together "Red-Haired People Spread Disease" being a fact, and thus is almost certainly being discovered independently by several labs and institutions at the same time, this will ensure that the truth will come out, and much faster than you think. The only difference is if the public hears it from your institutions first, i.e. your legitimacy and credibility in the public eye.
No. This is really hilarious, but really though, No.
The whole point of science is no content-related norms. You can put content-related norms wherever you want. You can put them in your useless HR departments, you can put them in the brainwashing (uh, ahem, "orientation") of new hires. But the moment you start saying "All papers dealing with topic X are refused, regardless of supporting evidence or explanatory\predictive power" then you're literally not doing science. You're playing dress up.
Every single philosophy of science from pre-Popper onwards is very clear that good science doesn't give a single shit about the moral content of an idea and how politically-correct it is, only how well supported it is and how elegantly it explains existing data and how accurately it predicts new data.
Evolution says you're no better and no worse than rats, who are also your distant cousins btw, neuroscience says that what we call "you" is really just a bunch of electrochemistry that anybody can learn to manipulate and push to do things. Science doesn't give a shit about your panic that somebody can "misinterpret" those results, that's your problem, stop being lazy and find other solutions to it, don't censor science.
The same thing can be different categories. Black is social category, and is also a very well defined biological state of the most visible organ in your body, and is associated with certain genes. Instead of repeatedly stating the name of those different genes every time you say something about them, you can simply say the name of the most visible marker of them and still be correct the vast majority of time.
Fermi was probably talking about inevitable things, e.g. if climate is already worsening beyond human limits it's always good to know even if it's too late to do anything. But if knowledge (or our pursuit of it) would lead to new dangers, its perfecly reasonable to (try) to limit knowledge and its spread or pursuit.
The dishonesty of the -ve IQ people behind attitudes like the criticized is that they see danger in everything and use moral panic to enforce views. If the actual "dangers" they are freaking out about are legitimate, they would have been justified to supress (non-violently) science and technology)
In other senses, "beliefs" are an identity, and some people like to think theirs are more based on science than others. "Believing" in science amounts to adhering to a broad package of ethical and lifestyle choices that references science to various degrees, their followers believe this gives them more legitimacy than other lifesyles or ethics systems, but the actual degree to which they are justified by science varies enormously.
To take 2 extremes :
(1) Taking a stance against fossil fuel is "believing in science" because (good, credible) science says those increase carbon footprint which in turn disrupts the climate in a huge variety of ways, technically this doesn't necessarily imply to oppose fossil fuel as science doesn't have normative component (science doesn't care - in the strictest sense - if human civilization is destroyed or signficantly harmed), but with only an additional few, normally agreed-upon, assumptions you can get there.
(2) Taking a stance against biological-women-exclusive sports is "believing in science" according to the stance followers because a few studies of shaky foundations and questionable funding says there is no unfair advantage to those who had male puberty, although there are tons of other studies that disagree.
Those who say (loudly) they "believe in science" are usually using "believe" in the non-philosophical sense, and the viewpoints they love to push most are usually (2)-like rather than (1)-like.
And this is important because we're repeating this mistake even more gravely now with digital media. Terrible proprietary formats and protocols that are lost like tears in rain the moment the private entity maintaining them closes down, terrible dependency graphs that are never frozen or even properly described (e.g. "runs on Linux" is an implicit dependency that is never explained or explicitly mentioned), terrible culture of "movE fAsT ANd bReAk tHiNGs", and a false sense of security and durability ("The Internet is forever") that makes us increasingly generate information in native-digital ways and convert whatever is not digital to digital then discarding the original. All of this is begging for a mass civilizational amnesia on a scale never seen or imaginable.
And the "other countries are genocidal maniacs as well" caveat only works if the person who is pointing out that the USA is a genocidal maniac is fond of another country, but there is no mention of any country to praise in this thread, just condemnation of USA's actions against individuals. All countries are genocidal maniacs, but only one controls the US military.
Although when you think about it, those single-celled bacteria look awefully suspicious and up to nothing good.
On users. Any network is worth a function of the number of nodes in it (typically a quadratic). Social Media are networks that link humans, and there is a finite number of humans (or, more accurately, internet-connected humans with time to spare) that grows very slowly and inevitably will stagnate. That means a social network is in direct zero-sum competition with all the other networks, and a giant like twitter hurts everybody else by concentrating a signficant proportion of users into a single (aweful) place, destroying competition by the lock-in effects of network dynamics.
>There are not thousands of bakeries in any city
There are in my city, actually. Dialing the number down to the hundreds or the high tens doesn't signficantly change the validity and implications of the argument either.
> In that regard, the bakery will have an actual monopoly on baked goods to people living there.
If you can actually prove that in a court, and if you furthermore prove that the complaining party will incur significant costs to themselves if they try to seek another bakery elsewhere (by a resonable legal definition of 'significant'), then you have my full blessing to force people to bake your cake.
Until then, comparing an easily-replacable food product with tons of suppliers and publicly-available recipes to a proprietary service supplied by a corporation with thousands of servers, thousands of employees and tens of millions of users is ideologically motivated bullshit.
And whether a bakery serves your gay wedding or not is perhaps the most petty and inconsequential thing to be upset about. There are thousands upon thousands of bakeries in a large city. You can learn how to bake a cake in a weekend and home-bake your wedding cake yourself, or any one of your wedding guests can do this as a wedding gift. You can go to a no-gays-allowed bakery but simply not tell them you're gay, and take a finished cake from them then write your own name and that of the guy you will marry on it yourself. You can not get cake at all and instead get any of the thousand other types of wedding sweets and food.
It's almost like the whole thing is a hilarious non-issue that some people just invented to cry and act like victims about.
There is... there is lingerie for men ??
Let's say that people think MD5 is a good cryptographic hash function. The worst single possible thing you can do is ban-hammer the promoters of this idea away. This is extremely dumb "Kill The Messenger" thinking, the promoters of those idea are exposing real communication problems (namely, the use of "hash function" to denote roughly similar concepts but are also very different in very important details). What you do, if you really think this Md5-is-cryptographically-secure problem is serious, is that you treat the success of the promoters of this false idea as a measure for how hard you failed to communicate basic cryptography to software devs. Do a modification to your education\media ecosystem, then measure how successful the false prophets are, if their success goes up or stays constant then you still haven't addressed the real problem, if it goes down then you're successfully fighting "misinformation", repeat till you drive their popularity to the ground.
As a reader, I like substack. It promotes a healthy diversity in opinions unlike the increasingly ban-happy established social media and puts some power back into the writer's hands, at the cost of shattering the "For Free!" illusions of free beer social media.
What I just wish they do is realize how goddamn fucking aweful their rock-slow website is, how astonishingly user-hostile and actively infuriating it is to use.
Reminds me of another "Social Media Corp Gone Bizarrely Crazy" plot that I read recently, The This, by Adam Roberts. You won't anticipate how Crazy the social corp in question goes till you're halfway.
Now of course, HN is more domain specific and niche than other socials so I know it's a bit unfair to compare spam because of course spammers would be more interested in the more populous and general purpose social media, and it's possible that spam and bots on those other services would be even higher if not for email registration, but there's simply no data to support that : email registration is cargo-culted by any remotely user-oriented service without thinking if it fits.
And there is a very good reason to think that email registration is just a dumb lazy hack to delegate problems instead of solving them : come to think of it, email fights spam! How do they do it, by delegating to another email service? Email registration all the way down? Of course not, they just run a bunch of really simple stats on the text to reject the obvious 99% trash. Are reddit and twitter too poor to pay for markov chains running on every text submitted?
And public-private crypto & hash pointer data structures are both fairly advanced CS from multiple fields. Public Key Crypto was discovered in the late 1970s and only further explored in the 1980s, hash data structures only in the 1980s and 1990s. That's fairly young, most vanilla CS ideas date from the 1960s or before. Just because the public APIs of those things can be explained in an afternoon doesn't mean at all that they aren't advanced concepts: I can explain what a hydrogen bomb does to a 10 year old, but that wouldn't imply the Hbomb isn't advanced nuclear physics.
I think the first thing people need to get over to understand de-centralized currencies like bitcoin is that money is just an illusion, a big fat shared delusion, or more accurately an inter-subjective fantasy, a way of keeping track of labor\value by agreeing on some scarce valuable thing and declaring that it represents every other scarce valuable thing if everybody agrees to trade any scarce valuable thing they have against it. I don't think most people truly relize this at the gut level (and this is not an insult to the intelligence of people, it was mind blowing and deeply enraging\upsetting to me when I worked through it to the end as well). Concept #1 : Money is any (possibly artificially) scarce thing that people with things you care about want to trade against.
Next, you observe that a currency doesn't actually has to be an actual thing you own, it just has to be an entry in a trusty and available record of all the favors you did\was done to you. Physical things are merely a convenient way to maintain a distributed record of favors in real life, but in principle all of our paper money could be replaced by a huge paper spreadsheet recorded by an infalliable angel who never lies or cheats, recording in each entry who did what favor to whom, and the amount of "favorism" that was done (so that it can be traded against other favors in the future). If everyone had an always-updated read-only access to that spreadsheet somehow, then this is a perfectly good and perfectly secure money system. You "pay" by invoking the earlier favors owed to you, "paid" to you by others, invoking favors "spends" them : turns them into the ownership of the entity you are paying. New favors are created by the infalliable angel whenever they deem necessary, they simply write in the spreadsheet "I now own 20 more favors than before, by the sheer force of my will". Concept #2 : Money doesn't actually have to be a scarce thing, it just needs to be a trusty record of transactions, scarce things approximate that fairly well in real life but are not the only way. Money is simply any promise backed by trust, scarce things are just one way of implementing that.
The final push is actually the hardest. You can't understand bitcoin without understanding even the tiniest bit of distributed systems. The fundamental difficulty of distributing a soft record and yet still preserving it's append-only nature while the machines the record is stored on can tick at 4 billion times a second must be appreciated and truly understood in all its impossiblity. Distributed blockchains' delightfully bizarre solution must be appreciated in all its counter-intuitevity. I was stuck at this stage for a long long time, knowing hashing and crypto (public API wise) but finding it difficult to understand why can't I just make-up money as I please, who's going to stop me ? who's going to know ? How can bitcoin stop me or even detect me without a central authority ? Distributed Systems are simply magic, and crypto-currencies get most of their magic and brilliance from that component. But eventually you get there if you're motivated enough and manage to dodge\discard all the trash pop-sci false explanations. Concept #3 : Bitcoin utilized super-smart magic from several apparently-unrelated fields of CS to make the fantastical spreadsheet from concept #2 come to reality.
Anyway, all of that long rant was just to say I don't think hyper-focusing on the intricacies of hashing and public-private cryptography is actually helpful for people to understand the 'why' of decentralized currencies. I don't mean they're not important building blocks, they are invaluable of course, I just mean the vast majority of work in decntralized currencies is done by the decentralized blockchain they are running on, and those work because PoW is a piece of magic and also distributed systems and also NP-hardness.
>The suggestion that a mathematical problem is being solved (while not completely inaccurate) sounds a bit more elegant in my opinion than what is really going on.
That's a very human centric way of putting it, but I agree. If a computer is searching through the library of babel to find a treatment for cancer, the computer is still 'solving' cancer, it just doesn't do it by studying medicine. "Elegance" is a human value, and my personal philsophical belief about intelligence is that its all really Search, Neural Networks and Reinforcement Learning Agents and Evolutionary Computing and Human Brain Heuristics and Knowledge are all really more efficient way of searching spaces and trees. Medicine is just there to tell what branches not to search. So the library of babel computer is just doing intelligence a bit more naively and expensively than its more efficient artifical or natural cousins, but its still "solving" a problem, like all intelligences do.