I don't buy the lack of seatbelts argument in any car to be a compelling argument. Maybe consider that you or other drivers you're driving nearby are bad at driving.
845 karma · joined October 2, 2020
I don't buy the lack of seatbelts argument in any car to be a compelling argument. Maybe consider that you or other drivers you're driving nearby are bad at driving.
The problem Java experiences (not 'experienced') is that it isn't the 1990s anymore. People aren't easily hyped, not smart people at least. Programming language research, already way ahead of Java in 1995, moved far ahead some more. The internet and open source and free online education and social media means smart language designer(s) can now begin a baby project and put it on github and wait their luck for a corporation or organization that will support it, and they can wait a decade+ on hobby mode till the luck comes. Java's competition isn't C, I highly doubt it ever was, it's dozens of far superior programming languages that were born after 1995, and some of those that were born before but weren't very populer because internet and open source barely existed in the 1990s and they weren't made by a corporation.
Even if you keep overfitting the requirements function time and time again to gradually approach java (by adding "vast libraries" and "performance" to it, although neither of those things are specific to Java), you will eventually reach a very narrow niche with Java and Kotlin squarely in the middle, I know which one I'm going to choose if I'm willing to maintain my sanity and not drown in 'paper-work programming' that is the developing experience with Java. It's as easy as opening a source file in an IDE and naming it with a '.kt' extension rather than '.java', I'm in love with it.
Companies use Java extensively ? So it's a COBOL then: Old, everywhere, infrastructure-critical, but an utter failure as a programming language in every way that is not "runs my old program I'm too afraid to re-write". This is forgivable in the case of COBOL because it's a literal proto-language, one of the earliest of the species. It's not forgivable in the case of a language designed when Smalltalk and ML and Haskell were around.
The history of Java is the story of a corporation stumbling upon the idea of a VM (1960s stuff) and deciding that it's so good that they need something like this under their name right now, and not giving the slightest shit about the design of the language that sits on top of said VM. And they were right, the idea of a VM is really so fucking good that Java's aweful design was tolerated, until somebody relized running on the JVM no more means writing Java than running on x86 means writing x86 assembly, and wrote the first non-Java JVM language. And because VMs are so fucking beautiful, you get all Java code for free.
>doesn't copy everything Java does VM + GC
Come on, write those 2 words on any half-decent academic research repository and you will get hits from the fucking 1960s. Java is younger than Lisp, Smalltalk, Self, Haskell, Python and the same age as Ruby. All of those languages do VMs and GCs. Java's hotspot is taken from Self, that's documented stuff. And "Copying" isn't copying if it's a better implementation of the interface, JSON didn't "copy" XML, they reimplemented its interface better.
Mathematical mental artifacts are special stories with incredible mutation-resistent properties, memes which compel their host with astonishing power and insistence to interpret and extract from them the same conclusions and patterns and behaviours that other hosts infected with the same meme did\do, or at least prevent one host from interpreting or concluding the opposite of what most other hosts interpreted\concluded.
That is, Mathematical Reasoning is a distributed mind-consensus 0-communication algorithm, a way for minds (instantiated in brains, silicon chips,spacetime foams,...) to agree on something while never actually explicitly arguing or debating or handshaking in any way. The set of all objects and states Mathematical Reasoning is capable of agreeing on is by definition Mathematics.
Discovering sentient aliens would shed much light on this.
The amount of work you would spend to think and implement workarounds for all of this is better spent thinking and implementing language-, OS-, and hardware- independent specifications and VMs that are minimal and long-lasting, to better support a huge variety of the software and media and languages that make up our cultural heritage now, C being just one language among many.
-------
You mention in an aside that a C interpreter would better suit preservation efforts than a heavy-duty overkill like today's optimizing C compilers, that's a good idea, naive interpreters are easy, much more so than complex compilers or runtimes. BUT, C is horrifically full of undefined behaviour and implementation-defined behaviour, and the spec is a natural language document so even if a behaviour is defined it's not really *defined* in the mathematical well-behaved sense, because you know how natural language is, you're always one tricky test case away from a bug. This is important, you never know you're depending on this or that behaviour until the applications fails or runs very strangely when running on another toolchain.
That's why I argue we need formal specifications and VMs, and minimal ones at that. Indeed, we need a hierarchy of such specifications and VMs, becase hierarchies are efficient at compressing an otherwise-exponential amount of data (think of deep neural networks or search trees, why are they so efficient?). A sequence of bootstrapping minimal VMs is better and easier to preserve than one large heavy VM, eggs and baskets and all. Furthermore, designing new VMs and specifications specifically for preservation would force us to think about the framework we use to formalize and talk about them : maybe we can use $HOT_NEW_THING fresh from CS academia, or maybe we can use a natural numbers- or a boolean circuits- based approach, as those things are not fancy and easier to explain when you don't have a lot of shared context, they are - in a sense - the "bare minimum" you need to understand or talk about computers.
You need a format other than text, text is extraordinarily inefficient and lossy at anything that is not declarative factual information. There has to be artifacts.
And paper is distributed, hard to counterfeit and long-lasting in ways we haven't figured out how to replicate in electrons yet.
Imagine a civil engineer walks into the office and asks a colleague about the plans for the new housing project, and the colleague replies that the concept of a "house" is a rich and socially constructed idea that both reflects and influnces the social zeitgeist in subtle ways and is intimately tied to notions of community and private property. They are not wrong, and the civil engineer would probably learn new things if they let the colleague finish instead of laughing them off or firing them, it's just that there is this implicit shared context in the workplace, that "house" is not a subtle idea and our job is to plan and build them not talk about their history or philosophy, that the colleague is violating or ignoring.
This is a useful analogy to understand why a remark like GP's, very useful and very true and would drive you into despairing madness and perhaps the brink of suicide if you think about it honestly and deeply, is not welcome in a thread like this. There is an implicit context in the comment section (formed haphazardly in a distributed non-explicit way, unlike that of the analogy) that you have a bunch of latent opportunities that you can take for granted and build off them to new frontiers, and that those opportunities are more or less a "critical mass", you can make them into whatever outcome you want given a fair amount of work. This is non-trivial for a huge portion of humans, and yet the self-help context always assumes it without proof, and any pushback is interpreted as doomer nay-saying or unhelpful pedantry.
That would imply I want him to win, when in reality I just want twitter to lose. I don't particularly care what happens to Musk, I just want him to deal maximum damage to twitter, at whatever cost to him it takes.
>It's fine to have your own personal bias here. We all do. But at a minimum, discussing why we hold those views is beneficial for both of us.
I did say why I hate twitter and want them to lose this case: they are a bunch dumb anti-free-speechers who coddle certain groups and ban others arbitarily, and on top of that their terrible poisonous platform is not conducive to intelligent speech.
>why Twitters argument here is wrong and why you think they'd lose this court battle.
I don't have a particulary strong expectation that they will lose, indeed if anything their legal position is stronger than Musk, as the experts are fond of saying. My hope is that they will underestimate Musk and do something dumb that will hurt their position and force a favorable concession that will hurt them more. Even if they win, that might anger or humiliate Musk so much that he destroys twitter out of anger, this is still fine by me.
But the topic of the super comment we're both arguing in reply to is "Who could possibly be on the side of Musk", i.e. a question about the relative sympathy both sides of the legal dispute evoke. My reply to that, the one this entire sub-thread is a reply to, is that Musk evokes greater sympathy, because of how twatter abuses their power and position as a social media monopoly and how much this harms online conversations. So, in this particular scope, you're the one who is actually off-topic, my reply was about who I'm more sympathetic to.
>Do you have something relevant (not necessarily correct, but at least __relevant__) to the stated topic at hand
Do you mean the bot issue ? it's probably bullshit. Every social media cesspool is full of bots, some more, some less. There is no reason to think twatter is any better or worse on that particular front. It's probably instagram who's the filthiest bot playground.
I think its pretty obvious that Musk will try to milk every single point, fair or not, to improve his position in the court. Bullshit or not, it ties up important resources out of twatter's legal team and gives legitimacy to his claims (because if you spend several lawyers trying to debunk bullshit, then you at least take that bullshit seriously, which gives legitimacy to the bullshit).
So I don't understand what to discuss, Musk bullshitted ? no shit, he's billions-of-dollars committed to the case now, off course he's going to bullshit and do whatever it takes to win. What's interesting or novel about that ?
Your statement was "If you're not interested in the legal minutia", and I replied that I'm neither interested nor disinterested, *in the legal minutia*.
I'm mildly interested in the outcome of case itself, namely my preferred outcome is that of Twitter losing as much value as possible and its users lose as much of their time and peace of mind as possible. I don't particualrly care how much Musk loses or wins.
This still doesn't need to imply I need to be interested in legalities. You can perfectly well be interested in your health without being interested in medicine and biology, you're interested in the 'what', not the 'how'; in the ends, not the means. I'm interested in a prticular outcome for a legal case, but not interested (and not necessarily disinterested either) in the legal intricacies of a country I don't live in when I'm not a lawyer.
>that you should at very least _PRETEND_ to have interest in this case
I don't need to pretend, I *am* interested in a very narrow thing about that case, namely that of twitter losing or signficantly suffering damage at least. I don't have to be interested in every single thing about that case to participate in the discussion, I mostly care about 1 thing and stated it very clearly all of my comments.
>All I'm asking is for you to be interested enough to seek the truth in the case before you write up a post.
I did read up 1 expert talk about Musk's legal chances posted here about 2 weeks ago, and he did give Musk low chances of winning according to several reasons I found convincing, but - like a true expert - he also acknowledged that he is (1) Not Musk's legal team or any one of them (2) Not in possesion of the full facts since he is not a party of the dispute or the judge (3) That there is enough stake on the matter, billions of dollars and reputation, that the judge can significantly hesitate and not be as straightforward as her history implies.
So that's enough for me to still have reasonable hopes that my preferred outcome is going to happen.
Do you have a link of an example of what you say ? Were the people in those linked example not banned at the time? On average, how many people calling your precious "trans people" pedophiles and groomers are banned vs. how many of the trans people themselves get banned when they say things equivalent or far worse ?
It's mindblowing to me how the most coddled and put-on-a-pedestal group in public discourse is complaining about censorship and unfair treatment. They literally ban people for not using pronouns. It's honestly laughable.
>If you're not interested in the legal minutia
How can I be interested in that which I don't even know ? I'm neither interested nor disinterested, I simply don't know. This doen't require a big brain to understand.
>The legal arguments for this case so far
Those are not arguments, what you listed are the facts of the case. Some of them are even 'future facts' that have not happened yet, but are scheduled to happen with high (but not certain) probability. All of those facts are and will be subject to the experience and argumentation of a team of lawyers who spent the last decades learning and practicing how to extract the most favorable interpretation out of any set of facts, and dismiss and trivialize those facts which can't be interpreted favorably.
Here is a game you can play with a person you know : Tell the person to select N public cases at random from a source you are not allowed to read. For each case, the person should tell you the facts of the case but not a single argument from the trial, the facts include anything known about the case prior to the trial. See if you can guess which party will win the case. How many cases out of N you think you will get correct on average ? You will not exceed 40%.
>All of these items are publicly available to you and me.
The entire history of China is publicly available to anyone with an internet connection, can anyone be a foreign diplomat to China ? A vast trove of medical and biological information is publicly available to anyone, can anyone be a doctor or even an assistent to one ?
Facts are not knowledge. Books are not knowledge. Records are not knowledge. These are "String Representations" of knowledge, crystallized and ossified remains of true knowledge, which are the mental representations inside the brains of people who studied and thought hard about the domain. You're not going to replicate those mental representations simply by reading their dead remains, you can say something, it's just not going to be very useful or truthful.
You mean you don't view any of those 3 people I mentioned as heros? Ok, This still doesn't change anything, unless you're radically anti war in a way very few people are, there is someone you idol who killed far far more than Ted can ever dream of.
>You don't think a cat kills 7 birds and/or rodents a year
I concede this point, see my reply to your sister comment for why its just a bad phrasing of what I meant to say. I give an alternative phrasing there that better makes my point about why humans are uniquely evil.
>It destroys your statement that ...
But doesn't make a difference beyond that.
>I don't see any possible way for you to have a consistent position here
Here is a very consistent position for you : I want to destroy all sentient life or remove sentience from it, whichever is easier\faster. Failing the ideal goal of doing that to all life, a lesser goal is to do it to all humans, because :
(1) they are my own species, their evil and immorality is more my responsibility than the evil or immorality of other species.
(2) they have the tools and awareness to be not evil and moral, unlike most animals, and yet choose evil and immorality.
(3) their number and power are unparalleled and far beyond anything on earth now, so their evil and immorality is a huge proportion of all evil and immorality.
And while non-human carnivorous animals kill their prey purely by hunting, which is 'fair' and limited in a sense, humans kill animals by cowardly and genocidely herding them and breeding them to be docile. This scales far more horribly : a predator can't kill a certain percentage of its prey before it becomes hard to find a prey, reversing the trend, while humans can simply breed more prey and use horrible industrial farming techniques to kill far more than any predator species, with 0 risk or consequences.
And while obligatory carnivores like eagles or whales literally can't survive without killing their prey, humans are equal parts carnivores and herbivores, we can survive equally well on plant diet and non-meat animal produce. We choose to kill for no reason but pleasure.
Those 2 goals are aligned.
Reality is not harassment. If somebody is upset they can't control someone's else words or perception, they can go to therapy about it. This remains true even if you invent a couple of dumb words to describe the words or perceptions that upset you, like 'deadnaming' or 'misgendering'.
There is a difference between deliberate selectivity based on ideology, clearly and nakedly what twatter does, and simple errors and human variability.
Yes, I'm entirely free to think anything I want and disparage any website or any other group\institution of people for not agreeing with me, and being happy that dumb anti-free-speechers are dragged to court and toyed with for months. What I don't understand is how your dumb role-playing of an imagined strawman of me in your first reply says anything about me or my opinions.
If you're not a lawyer, this has 0 value. If you're not a highly paid team of several top lawyers, this has less than 0 value. Their entire profession is to spin circles around common sense or naive reasoning, so just wait and see. Law is harder than you think. Don't Dunning-Kruger your way into a highly complex domain, it never works.
>What kind of "surprise legal twist" do you think will happen over the next 2 months
By my own admission, I'm not a lawyer. So I don't understand why you think you or me can answer or predict this question better than those studying for decades and highly paid for months to think about it.
Correct. This is something I say myself in the comment, if you bothered to read carefully.
>You condemn Washington, Lincoln, Roosevelt, and Truman, because they killed people. And then you come out with the above sentence. You're a bit self-inconsistent here.
False. I don't condemn any of those people (not because they killed anyway), I point out your own hypocrisy, and that of most people, when they worship those mass killers, and oppose Ted because he killed 3 people.
>Kaczynski didn't deserve to live, because he didn't kill nearly enough people.
Because he was stopped short, and because he, like many of us, had delusions of convincing people peacefully.
>Eagles. Cats. Whales. Seals. Snakes. They all do this.
They kill their own number 7 times per year ? I call bullshit. And if it's true, it doesn't change anything.
And doesn't the US legal system allow for escalation to the Supreme Court, which can override lower courts? So technically whatever the Delware Court is not the final say on whatever happens.
>Trial date set to October
This is so so awesome, I will get to see Twatter defenders rage and fume for 2 more months? ^__^
Every one of those people killed far more than Ted ever ever dreamed of or imagined.
One of them fought personally in wars of colonization and was responsible for the death of countless original inhabitants of the land his country stole, before leading the fighting in a war that, besides killing a hundred thousand person (in an era before humanity hit its first billion, 0.01% of the all humans dead in a single war), set in motion the ignition system for one of the bloodiest and most brutal revolution the world had seen at the time.
The second one ignited the first industrial war in history, and brought a wave of destruction and death upon his own country so terrible its effects was felt, is felt, a century later and beyond.
The third pair, among their many achievements, had developed a weapon of indescribable power, and unleashed it on a bunch of civilians to own a geopolitical enemy. That weapon remains a permanent guillotine over the head of civilization, patiently waiting for an executioner who will release it.
If you hold any one of those people as a heros, no, if you hold any one of those people as anything less than the devil himself personified, then you already understand the fundamentals of what Ted had in mind when he did what he did, you merely disagree with his premises.
Ted killed a measly sum of 3 people (according to my rusty memory of the wiki article I'm too lazy to re-read), this is laughable by the standards of a hero. Look at your own superhero movies, look at the sheer amount of destruction and mayhem that the hero releases on his own city to rid it of bad guys. How can the culture that produces these movies, that idolizes Washington and Lincoln and Truman, that is responsible for Korea and Vietnam and Iraq, how can it not forgive a man for an honest-but-misguided effort to steer humanity away from the slavery it inflicted upon itself ?
I'm not saying those 3 people or the 20-or-so he injured are not important and significant moral costs, I'm just amazed by the standards you impose on Ted, standards that you reserve only for Ted.
You already accept far far more than what Ted did, you already accept hundreds of methods that put his methods to childish innocent shame, you just accept them in contexts that you are told\brainwashed are worthy.
>If you're willing to deliberately, actively, persistently attempt to blow up innocent people
The good\bad thing about civilization is that its a distributed system, a massive distributed system based on tyranny, slavery and suffering. You can't disable a distributed system without damaging at least some of the nodes. Your statement applies perfectly to every single war hero americans (and every people on the planet with their own war heros) idol, go ahead, see how many of your heros blew up to shreds innocent people and killed and maimed. Count the bodies honestly and fairly.
Humans kill 70 billion animal a year, every day a human spends not killing or blowing up humans is a sin, a day lived by an immoral coward who doesn't deserve to live. That includes me and you. There is no species on earth that kills its own number 7x+ times each year. Every single innocent soul of those animals slaughtered and cannibalized is blood all over your hands, your body, your mind, your conscience. You live in blood, you thrive on it, you build your life and that of your loved ones on suffering that makes Hitler a Saint and Stalin a harmless Grandpa.
Ted is the best and most moral of us. May he rest in peace and love.
Any sane person will also not touch BCIs and similar technology with a 100 lightyear pole unless the designing company reveals every single fucking silicon atom in the hardware design and every single fucking bit in the software stack at every level of abstraction, and ships the device with several redundant watchdogs and deadmen timers around it that can safely kill or faraday-cage the implant on user-defined events or manually.
Alas, humans are very rarely sane, and I come to the era of bio hacking (in all senses of the word) with low expectations.
Incidentally, I write all 3 of C, C++ and x86 assembly, which is why I understand how braindead and unfit for human usage they are.
PS. the worst C++ code is still a hell of a lot more safe than the best C code. This is easy to convince yourself of by noting that C++ mostly supersets C and only deviates to add more safety and static checking, not less. So it's a strict improvment over C, not by a lot, but an improvment nonetheless.
Here are other examples for VMs not written in any of those 2 braindead languages though:
[1] Bun : JS runtime in Zig. https://bun.sh/
[2] Squeak : Smalltalk VM written in Smalltalk. http://www.vpri.org/pdf/tr1997001_backto.pdf
[3] PyPy : Not actually a single VM but an entire framework\toolchain to write VMs, most famous of which is one for Python. The language used to write VMs for the framework is a subset of python called Rpython. https://doc.pypy.org/en/latest/
[4] Maxine Virtual Machine : a JVM written entirely in Java. It's not the only one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxine_Virtual_Machine ; https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15733645
Modern VM research is far beyond the 50 year old assembler that thinks itself a programming language. The future is here, just not very evenly distributed.
False. It's a pretty reliable proxy if the Establishment is known or plausibly suspected to benefit from falsehood and\or misrepresent truth. If you have a reliable predictor of falsehood, then something which always opposes it is a reliable predictor of truth. I don't know if the statistics Establishment is one such example (probably not), but the trans-activism and war-media Establishments certainly Are reliable predictors of falsehood, and have been shown to be on multiple occasions.
That's why I like the author's opinions on those topics more than on statistics, even if I'm not necessarily certain of their truth. He's going in the rough general direction of truth.
>hyperventilating culture warrior attitude. It speaks poorly of ability to humbly and dispassionately analyze topics, regardless of which side it comes from.
False Again. Plenty of smart people have this attitude, the notorious example off the top of my head is Nassim Nicholas Taleb, incredibly arrogant and quick to ungraciously fail into combat under criticism - yes - but do you actually want to take him one-on-one in statistics? For a more distant example, see Newton's hilarious pettiness in dealing with rivals. Your heuristic yellow flag would have lead you to dismiss him faster than you can say "Universal Gravitation", and we both know you would be utterly and irredeemably wrong.
If you are talking about his statistics opinions, I don't understand enough statistics to know if it's right or wrong or not even wrong. But his other claims gives him a substantial respect-boost regardless of whether he's right or wrong. I simply like contrarians more.
Alas, the article is badly written and unprofessionally laid-out, and, ironically given the title, isn't written with a non-statistician in mind.