HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Barrin92

35,157 karma · joined February 4, 2016

md6kuq86r@mozmail.com
submissionscomments
Barrin92··on No signs of AI payoff outside the tech sector
>but if you think it hasn't affected CRUD feature work you would be wrong.

the mythical man month lesson holds for CRUD apps as well. I'd be careful to equate churning out lines of code with the health of a piece of software down the road, even a relatively straight forward one.

Keep in mind in any real world software what matters is maintenance of a system, not just how many features you can add, regardless of human or machine generated code, some badly glued together codebase that's rapidly growing is going to haunt you.

Which is also why replacing sound dev tooling and with a magical prompt genie is incredibly irresponsible and short-sighted. You could cheaply produce code by outsourcing it years ago.

Barrin92··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
>which are government officials, like for example ambassadors and other diplomats are as well.

No. Kushner in this second term, unlike in the first, isn't a government official of any sort. He is now purely a private citizen which the government itself has argued this month when a watchdog group sued Kushner exactly because he's exercising authority of diplomats and ambassadors, which requires approval by the U.S Senate which he hasn't got and which would indeed subject him to ethics rules.

https://apnews.com/article/jared-kushner-crew-lawsuit-trump-...

Barrin92··on Jared Kushner Hacked Phone Reveals Secret Negotiations, Millions in Transactions
I also feel people are missing the forest for the trees in that discussion in that Jared Kushner is a private citizen and the son in law of the president who somehow is negotiating with foreign heads of states despite having no mandate from the American people to do so. Forget a hacked phone, why is a nepo baby running around negotiating on behalf of a country without holding any office
Barrin92··on When Do We Become the Person We Ought to Be?
You're likely thinking of Origen although people question whether it's true.

>Maybe that's the smart thing to do

Nietzsche, Twilight of the Idols:

"The Church combats passion by means of excision of all kinds: its practice, its “remedy,” is castration. It never inquires “how can a desire be spiritualised, beautified, deified?”—In all ages it has laid the weight of discipline in the process of extirpation (the extirpation of sensuality, pride, lust of dominion, lust of property, and revenge).—But to attack the passions at their roots, means attacking life itself at its source: the method of the Church is hostile to life."

Barrin92··on EA is shutting down BioWare
also people shouldn't sleep on Housemarque. Both Returnal and Saros were fantastic. Don't want to spoil Returnal but the narrative and symbolism that tie the game together if you go through everything after you've finished it and have a grasp of the story is incredible. And the gameplay is extremely fun.
Barrin92··on Why Windows 11 still ships with Windows 95's memory manager hidden inside it
are you implying the fact that they proactively threw in a custom heap manager for a game is supposed to be a bad thing? The fact that almost any 25+ year old executable runs on Windows to this day is fantastic, they're seemingly the only guys who take backwards compatibility seriously.
Barrin92··on Ask HN: How to deal with shipping AI-written code you don't understand?
Short-sightedness is quite literally the reason people are using these systems to begin with. If you care about the health and integrity of your code base years down the road you wouldn't be shipping endless amounts of slop you don't understand, Fred Brooks taught us this half a century ago.
Barrin92··on Ask HN: How to deal with shipping AI-written code you don't understand?
>How are you handling this?

easy, don't write code with LLMs. If my job forced me to do so I would quit.

Barrin92··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
>I'm not convinced humans will be better at this than LLMs.

they don't need to be. Any scientist is already surrounded by tools that are better than they are at anything. A scientist from 200 years ago would have the same existential shock if they see how a modern scientists works.

But that's to misunderstand what science is for, which is to expand human knowledge. And a tool by definition can only ever change how you do this, not that you do it because you understanding it is the point. When people say learning to program is now useless, what they really mean is it might not make them any money, or using the AI is faster as an instrument. But if you care about programming itself, about you understanding programming, nothing has changed, it never can. And the smartest AI in the world can always assist you, but only that.

Barrin92··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
> AI has destroyed a major source of "life's meaning" for many people who pursued mathematics.

I studied mathematics and don't agree with this at all, for several reasons. For one the entire point of maths is that it describes a formal system in which one can 'shut up and calculate'. Mechanizing maths goes back to Leibniz and Hilbert. Nobody should surprised that the big formalism with explicit rules you invented is the first thing to yield to automation, that's why it exists.

Secondly research, including maths for a long time has been a collaboration of people, institutions, machines and processes, even maths does not consist of Faustian heroes in caves having revelations.

And thirdly just because a machine produces a 500 page proof doesn't mean your job is done. Science produces knowledge. Knowledge is information made legible to understanding by people. So there will be endless work for humans to go over machine proofs and turn it into something we understand. Just like chess computers ultimately expanded human chess.

Barrin92··on NY announces game ownership bill requiring ownership rather than licensing
that seems silly, I'm not supposed to be able to rent an apartment or a movie? There should be transparency of course and no misleading labeling but I see no reason why people should be prevented from transacting money for whatever arrangement they please
Barrin92··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
with the next change of administration there needs to be an investigation into every single one of these techbros and a Roosevelt treatment of the tech sector and corporate power.

You've got to hand it to Thiel, at least like other people of questionable political persuasion he's already fled to Argentina, gonna get crowded there in the future

Barrin92··on Butlerian Jihad
>You can't exactly have Timothee Chalemet waving a crysknife around and yelling "JIHAD!!!"

honestly I wish he did. The films are already incredibly on the nose, much more so than the books, that Paul is not to be understood as a hero. Practically half his dialog is directly talking to the audience telling us how he's going to kill billions of people. Chani got a very different role, and we start and end the movies from her perspective to stress it even further.

If you're already doing this you might as well have not chickened out on the language, it was one of the few things that genuinely irked me about the film.

Barrin92··on eBay Restricts Listings of Radio Equipment, but Exempts Ham-Band-Only Gear
>while computer hacker is more about cyberpunk "if I could do it, then it's allowed".

This was always a media caricature. If you go back to some of the cultural cornerstones especially when you're talking about technical work it's not that different, see Eric S. Raymond's What is a Hacker? http://www.catb.org/esr/faqs/hacker-howto.html

"If you want to be a cracker, go read the alt.2600 newsgroup and get ready to do five to ten in the slammer after finding out you aren't as smart as you think you are"

I blame Mitnick or random script kiddies for this image, when in fact your average hacker is a guy named Bob with an .edu address submitting kernel patches and emacs fixes

Barrin92··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
>basic necessities like food, housing, and medicine have become dramatically more expensive across the board.

they haven't. In the early 1900s an American household spent roughly 50% of its income on food. And mind you food didn't mean an exotic fruit you flew in from the other end of the world or pounds of meat per week.

Today an American household spends 9% of their income on food, the 'dramatic increase' may have bumped that up to 10% by some measures. The size of the average house of the average American family in the last half century has doubled while the family size has halved. In the 1960s 12% of households had AC access, today it's over 80%. Generics of basic medicines cost virtually nothing, you've just started to consume more sophisticated medicine over time.

If you're an ordinary guy you are already living in luxury, you just don't notice it because you kept moving the goalpost on what luxury is. Which isn't per se wrong but you ought to be at least aware of it

Barrin92··on I know why the mathematicians weep
> LLM systems are strongly predictive

No, they're not predictive at all. They're generative. A prediction is a forecast based on a theoretical model about a state of affairs in the world. Making a guess what the weather tomorrow will be is a prediction, and a prediction can be true or false. An LLM generates text based on certain parameters, and output it generates aren't true or false, they're simply whatever the system is tuned to produce.

LLMs are terrible at making forecasts or world modelling precisely because they don't actually operate on much of any model or theory, they have no notion of truth or falsehood, they simply generate whatever you want them to generate.

Barrin92··on Muse Spark Open
threads has roughly ~150 million DAU. That's roughly on the same scale is twitter. Also checks out on play store downloads at like half a billion.

I'd say that's pretty damn large given the tone in places such as this.

Barrin92··on One in ten people are older than 65. Three in four live under a leader who is
>Yes, a person votes in his own self interest - that’s how that works

No, that's not how that works, some Rousseau might be in order. What early Republicans still recognized is the concept of General Will. That a polity is not just the sum of its individual interests but requires an orientation of each member towards the shared common good. A democracy that is governed by self interest, in which simply put each vote is bought is a democracy in decayed state.

That this doesn't even register with people any more and is perceived as the norm is exactly what I'm talking about when I'm saying that most current democratic nations are at the end of their life. If young people are a demographic minority and each person votes only in their selfish interest the future of the nation is, by definition, dead.That they opt out in that situation is actually rational.

Barrin92··on One in ten people are older than 65. Three in four live under a leader who is
>Yes, in general people place a lot of value in the wisdom

I don't think that holds as an explanation given that 1. there's not a lot of wisdom going around among the geriatric leaders of the world, 2. this is a pretty rapidly increasing trend, not some fact of history.

Historical leaders used to be younger, including after accounting for increased lifespans. Just look at the founding of the American Republic. It's much more a sign of two things. Increased decadence and civilizations that are themselves at the end of their rope, and in democracies in particular a geriatric population that keeps voting itself into power based on their own interests.

Barrin92··on Americans' social activity has steeply declined in the past 30 years
there's diners and bars in every corner of middle America. What's changed, I think, is the level of striverism among young people.

In this thread you have multiple people saying they can't go out without paying 200$ or ordering 8$ beers. If you're in your 20s or 30s just go bar hopping in whatever the rundown part of your town is like people used to instead of going fine dining.

A movie ticket, inflation adjusted, costs the same as it used to for decades. Normal people just took it for granted that they had to smuggle some beers into the cinema rather than turning the whole evening into some hundreds of dollars spending spree.

Barrin92··on Suicide rates highest ever among middle-aged men
>Nihilism is a dead end (or political cynicism/fatalism, whatever you want to call it).

Nihilism is a popular, vague pejorative today but philosophically it's a serious answer to exactly the manipulation, engagement-bait and juvenile techno-optimism of our age. Whenever you're at the end of some moral or social period active, not resentful or passive nihilism, is a palate cleanser and necessary condition for revaluation of all values.

The kind of middle aged men that tend to fall into despair or suicide in these times are usually people who rely on some identity provided to them that then crumbles. Job, money, house, status, 'how to be a man' etc. There's something they're supposed to be like and they're not, stability they took for granted just stops.

And we're in a period like this across many dimensions, political, technological etc. And if you want to be sane a dose of nihilism is fairly important so that you can go on and construct some sovereign answers to all these issues.

Barrin92··on Fire at Starlink site in Bulgaria after suspected sabotage in Poland
>I don't know why it should be the governments job to secure private properties of corporations against vandalism/arson.

because this isn't 'vandalism', this is an act of war by a foreign adversary that is now happening on European and NATO soil on a daily basis, and instead of responding accordingly we talk about this as if a drunk kid laid a fire somewhere

Barrin92··on OpenAI engineer arrested in bugging of executive conference room
in addition to the whole crime thing, an 'openai engineer', apparently engineering lead according to his linkedin, having to ask chatgpt to tell him how to set up a recorder or how to encrypt a sd card is something. Truly the cream of the engineering crop at those top AI labs
Barrin92··on The United Kingdom generates less electricity per person than in the 1970s
there is some irony in the growth ideology, which is barely more than a century old, to claim that every other species on the planet, ecological thinking and most human life is somehow alien to existence here, when they are more fanatic than just about any religious cult

the logical terminus of the growth fanatics is to literally want to leave the planet so I think we ought to reserve the label 'alien' for them

Barrin92··on 'AI' Is Not a Tool by Rich Hickey
no, I think he's quite right to say that there is no such thing as an indeterministic tool. As he says, what defines tool use is precision, mastery and intentionality.

One wields a tool, but you cannot wield a set of dice or a slot machine, a chatbot, or a call center worker. That's not tool use, that's outsourcing or delegation of work. If I play Claude, or I pay a salary worker somewhere else, I have ceased to work, my skills are going to atrophy, my knowledge and my control is, the opposite of what genuine tool mastery implies.

If something's a tool, the more you use it, the more you improve not just narrowly mind you, but in all your faculties. Using an LLM has the exact opposite effect. At best you improve at only one thing, typing text into the LLM, while you atrophy everything else.

The logical terminus of the habitual LLM user, and that is really why 'industry leaders' love them so much, is the worker becoming a Tayloresque factory ape doing nothing but pushing the same button over and over again.

Barrin92··on Bitwarden Dual License Model
you just listed all the reasons why you don't need to self host yourself
Barrin92··on Yandex Takes a Second Data Center Hit in 48 Hours
of course that'd be fine, under the Geneva convention a civilian object loses its protective status when it makes effective military contributions and its destruction confers a military advantage.

What's supposed to be the argument against it, inconvenience for American shoppers during a war of aggression?

Barrin92··on A statement on the Tor Project's relationship with Mullvad
Africa, Latin America excluding Argentina, South East Asia, most of the Middle East and Central Asia and on most dimensions India.

The US is still a fairly homogenous place. Only 20% of the population is bilingual compared to over 60% of the world, only 7% follows non-Christian religions.

Brazil, Nigeria, Indonesia, Singapore, the 'stans', Lebanon, the UAE of the top of my head places where within probably an hour of arriving you'd notice you are in a much, much more diverse place.

Barrin92··on A statement on the Tor Project's relationship with Mullvad
The United States is unusually ethnically diverse for a European colony but globally just about the middle of the pack. Most of the world is more ethnically and culturally diverse.

What the Swedish party in question is proposing, mass denaturalization and deportation of citizens (i.e. ethnic cleansing), is a human rights violation and violation of international law and wouldn't be done even by otherwise intolerant or autocratic nations. This harkens back to the darkest days of the Soviet Union and expulsions by Communist regimes towards the end of Yugoslavia, or early 20th century regimes.

Barrin92··on OpenAI annualised revenues $20B less than previously signalled
>VC money is why the US has been able to win the past 20 yrs, you realise that?

win at what? 98% of Americans aren't going to care if a meteor drops on SV tomorrow. The day FAANG is done I'm throwing a party. I wish that incestuous industry would finally kick the bucket, 95% of American programmers don't even work there.

Do you seriously think anyone's shredding a tear if Zucc's net worth drops to zero and that privacy nightmare of a company is gone? Don't threaten me with a good time

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →