HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

BillFranklin

1,691 karma · joined April 15, 2014

Blog: https://bilbof.com Bluesky: https://bilbof.bsky.social LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/franklinbill
submissionscomments
BillFranklin··on Anonymous Source Shared Leaked Google Search API Documents
FYI, it's much easier to read the linked GitHub code via the published docs at https://hexdocs.pm/google_api_content_warehouse/0.4.0/api-re...
BillFranklin··on Show HN: LogsQL – opinionated query language for logs
As an addendum, I think the main flaws with Loki is log presentation in the Grafana UI, rather than necessarily querying syntax (extracting data from log lines with regex etc/pattern matching is gross, and if you're doing that you have a bigger problem).

With the Grafana Loki UI the main issue is if you log perfect JSON / logfmt and Loki parses it, the Grafana UI can struggle a bit with rendering views of logs in the way you'd want. Kibana's columnar views with nice filtering UX is much easier to use. I think Elastic still has this over Loki (that, and the capacity to build big expensive indexes if you have the stomach to manage them).

I wrote a custom CLI for Loki to work around this, because the Loki CLI has a similar problem. All that said, I'd still recommend Loki, it's really good IME.

BillFranklin··on Show HN: LogsQL – opinionated query language for logs
Interesting to see a new approach!

You wrote that you don't like Loki's LogQL, but it looks quite similar (Victoria's LogQL first):

  log.level:error _stream:{app!~"buggy_app|foobar"}
  {app!~"buggy_app|foobar"} | "log.level:error"

The pipes are arguably a bit noisy in Loki queries (compared to spaces in Victoria's), but I find they do make the queries a bit more readable, and it's easier to understand under the hood how the queriers will handle the query, and coming from PromQL I found Loki's approach quite intuitive: https://grafana.com/docs/loki/latest/query/.

Maybe I missed something fundamental though, interested to hear more about the differences, since I only read the couple links you shared!

BillFranklin··on Optimizing your talking points (2018)
I don't disagree that some engineers have bad attitudes! Everyone is capable of writing bad code, and there is something to be said for the argument that all code is bad and a liability.

This article is an interesting companion to "No more pink mustache" [1] wherein Lyft is described as "broken at a scale that is hard to believe" - often the explanation for quality is the org, not the human in the chair :-)

[1] https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2020/02/29/poof/

BillFranklin··on Apple supplier Foxconn among firms asked to cut power use in Vietnam
Generally I view things like this as under-investment in energy provision, rather than 'overusage' by businesses.

There was story last year in the UK, where the power usage of data centres in west London were blamed for a lack of housing development. This turned out not to be true and an exercise in blame-shifting [1]

[1] https://www.computerweekly.com/news/252523510/Datacentre-sec...

BillFranklin··on 2023 was the hottest summer in two thousand years
> We're not going to get out of this by making more money.

I absolutely think we are going to get out of this by making money.

The incentives preventing action on climate change are not moral/ethical, but economic.

Countries and individuals use fossil fuels because they are cheaper, and are unwilling to make decisions that put them in a worse position relative to others.

While de-growth naively sounds appealing, the results are horrendous – countries with approx. the same GDP that they had 20 years ago are not places you would want to move to.

You might also point to the ozone layer issue in the late 80s and argue an accord will fix our current problem, but fossil fuels are far more fundamental to our way of life than CFCs were.

BillFranklin··on 2023 was the hottest summer in two thousand years
Also well worth reading -- https://www.institute.global/insights/climate-and-energy/rei...

Tl;dr = Climate change is best addressed by producing technology that makes things more efficient and/or that helps the developing world decarbonise.

If anyone is working on something gamechanging please hit me up -- I'm happy to help out on the dev / infra side pro bono.

BillFranklin··on 2023 was the hottest summer in two thousand years
PSA to the hardware engineers on here --

Y Combinator is actively looking for founders starting climate tech companies: https://www.ycombinator.com/rfs#climate-tech

BillFranklin··on Slack AI Training with Customer Data
Slack has been using customer data for ML for years. Look at their search feature - it uses learning to rank, a machine learning approach that tracks content, clicks etc.

It sounds like the worry is this overfit generative AI will spew out some private input verbatim… which I can see happening honestly. Look at GitHub copilot, it’s almost a copy paste machine.

BillFranklin··on What are third places? How do I find one?
It's a nice article actually;

> If you do hope to stay, expect to keep spending. The low-cost luxuriating necessary for healthy third places isn’t considered profitable.

A lot of people struggle with this after college and a social club (sport, dining etc.) is usually the best way to keep your social life going. But yeah you usually have to value and invest in it, which maybe people aren't doing so much as prices have increased in the physical world while prices for entertainment over the wire has decreased.

I also think communities (third places FTA) that enable these friendships need to be, to some extent, closed or invite-only. I feel like as a social network grows each individual edge is a little weaker, which is the reverse incentive of developers of social networks and explains why socialising over the Internet feels the way it does.

BillFranklin··on Ask HN: Are there any open source forks of nomad and consul?
Doesn't look like it.

* https://github.com/hashicorp/nomad/forks

* https://github.com/search?q=nomad%20fork&type=repositories

* https://www.google.com/search?q=hashicorp+nomad+forks

There are products that do similar things of course.

BillFranklin··on HN who is hiring ratio (job seekers vs. jobs posted)
Haha, you’re welcome to change the code. I was more interested in the change in ratio rather than the raw numbers
BillFranklin··on HN who is hiring ratio (job seekers vs. jobs posted)
I was curious since it looked like there were more people posting requesting a job lately.

Code: https://github.com/bilbof/whoishiring-ratio

BillFranklin··on The Earth is getting greener
The article is a bit all over the place.

> So, yes, greening is complicated. It’s not inherently good. Sometimes it’s very bad. Context, it turns out, matters a lot.

The tone suggests they're afraid of the change, but the article can't articulate why since the reason for the change and result are both possibly good and bad, but we don't really know yet.

The NASA MODIS project is ongoing and produces data that people are using to measure "greenness" (which the article indirectly cites) and has been going for 20 years https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moderate_Resolution_Imaging_Sp... - it's definitely an interesting dataset.

Didan seems to be leading the vegetation research for MODIS and the data set has been cited thousands of times (https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=TxQK6U8AAAAJ&hl=en...)

BillFranklin··on Launch HN: Danswer (YC W24) – Open-source AI search and chat over private data
> It is what it is sadly.

This is what I mean -- previously I built a similar search engine on top of slack, notion, etc., but didn't launch the product because I thought that requiring users to constantly add bots to private channels would be a subpar experience. I thought this would be a blocker for good UX, so didn't go further, but maybe you'll find a nice solution!

Searching over public internal data is addressed by a few existing tools, but it's the private aspect which is pretty difficult to handle and disastrous to get wrong when managed ad-hoc - e.g. someone accidentally adds the bot to a private slack group called #layoffs :) so you'd want this handled properly and centrally.

I guess you'll also need to handle privacy well, ~maybe it's OK when run as a SaaS for db admins to have access to ingested data, but if it's OSS then the people that run it probably shouldn't be able to read the private data that's ingested, so now you need to handle search over encrypted data, which is a fun problem :D

BillFranklin··on Launch HN: Danswer (YC W24) – Open-source AI search and chat over private data
Good luck folks! I'm glad there are projects trying to solve enterprise search.

I guess the main problem is the "private" aspect, if I've understood your goals correctly. Since most SaaS products lock down the private data unless you pay enterprise fees for compliance tooling.

For instance, if you want to ingest data from private Slack channels or Notion groups, you have to get the users in those groups to add your bot to them, otherwise there's no way of your service getting access to the data. It's possible, just a bad UX for users.

That said, built-in search for most SaaS products built after 2015 is generally quite good (e.g. Slack has an internal Learning to Rank service for a while now, which makes their search excellent: https://slack.engineering/search-at-slack/), so you'd be solving for companies like Webex and Confluence where their internal search is not great. At companies like Google they have internal search across products, which is the ideal end state, but have the benefit that they own the source code for most of their internal products.

BillFranklin··on Don't build AI products the way everyone else is doing it
This is a nice post, and I think it will resonate with most new AI startups. My advice would be don't build an AI product at all.

To my mind an "x product" is rarely the framing that will lead to value being added for customers. E.g. a web3 product, an observability product, a machine vision product, an AI product.

Like all decent startup ideas the obviously crucial thing is to start with a real user need rather than wanting to use an emerging technology and fit it to a problem. Developing a UI for a technology where expectations are inflated is not going to result in a user need being met. Instead, the best startups will naturally start by solving a real problem.

Not to hate on LLMs, since they are neat, but I think most people I know offline hate interacting with chat bots as products. This is regardless of quality, bots are rarely as good as speaking with a real human being. For instance, I recently moved house and had to interact with customer support bots for energy / water utilities and an ISP, and they were universally terrible. So starting with "gpt is cool" and building a customized chatbot is to my mind not going to solve a real user need or result in a sustainable business.

BillFranklin··on TCP-brutal: Congestion control algorithm that increase speed on packet lost
I’m not sure if much more research has been done here from this team. I was able to produce similar results in my dissertation, also not in a production setting.

Regarding your second point, the way congestion avoidance algorithms typically work is to punish the local client for the state of the global congestion. If Remy can do that in a more efficient way (ie greater throughput or fairness for the local client) then it would be beneficial to use the algorithm before others switch.

BillFranklin··on TCP-brutal: Congestion control algorithm that increase speed on packet lost
If you're interested in recent state-of-art improvements to TCP congestion control, check out the Remy project, it's pretty amazing https://web.mit.edu/remy/.
BillFranklin··on Why Cities: Skylines 2 performs poorly
The model LOD issues described in the article can be fixed without changing engine. It's slightly easier to hire Unity devs to work around Unity issues vs hiring Unreal devs because there are many more Unity devs (Unreal has 13% of the market). Plus Unreal takes a 5% royalty fee on all sales, vs a flat fee for using the Unity engine.
BillFranklin··on Global CO2 Levels
You would need a few pipes the width of garden hoses constantly flowing, suspended by helium balloons, near the Arctic where the stratosphere is 1km closer.
BillFranklin··on Global CO2 Levels
Yeah it's mentioned in Stephen Hawking's last book: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_inject...

“The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change concludes that it is the most-researched solar geoengineering method, with high agreement that it could limit warming to below 1.5 °C”

There’s a risk it’d affect the ozone layer. But Paul Crutzen, who won the Nobel Prize for his ozone research in 95, said the sulfur plan is “the only option available to rapidly reduce temp rises and counteract other climactic effects”.

We’d also need to add shockingly little SO2 to the stratosphere. We currently emit 200m tons per year (25% is humans, rest is volcanos and other natural sources). We’d need to add an extra 100k per year.

Edit: I think one of the Microsoft co-founders was looking into it, the problems of proving it would work were political - not engineering-related.

BillFranklin··on Ask HN: Lessons learned from implementing user-facing analytics / dashboards?
When I used to work with D3 I found object constancy to be quite an important principle. Transitions between state are often neglected (a full state refresh is easier).
BillFranklin··on Ask HN: Lessons learned from implementing user-facing analytics / dashboards?
As someone who has made a ton of grafana dashboards over the years, be prepared for users to hold it wrong. Data visualisations should fail/degrade in clear and expected ways. Users are often surprised when dashboards/charts hit some limit (eg they write a non performant query). The big query design (async first, fair queueing) is best if you’re letting users write their own queries on their own datasets.
BillFranklin··on Breakthrough Starshot Nanocraft open engineering challenges
I read about this today in Hawking’s final book. The crafts would travel immensely quickly, passing Mars in less than an hour and Pluto in a few days, and could reach Alpha Centauri in about 20 years. Importantly there can be a flyby of Proxima B, an exoplanet, which might be the first planet humans could truly colonize.

Of the two options for sustaining human civilization (AI singularity/human-computer integration and space exploration) colonizing other planets seems to me more fun and less likely to fundamentally alter/end humanity.

I’d be curious if anyone here is working on these challenges

BillFranklin··on Mac OS 9
The A-10 attack game works! Controls are at http://www.sierrahelp.com/Documents/Manuals/A-10_Tank_Killer....

Also, you can still get EV Nova on a Mac as far as I'm aware. The price hasn't decreased in about 20 years though.

BillFranklin··on Ask HN: Best Engineering Blog Posts?
I run Blogosphere (https://bilbof.com/blogosphere/) which aggregates blogs from independent engineers, and uses a recommendation system to find you new posts. This isn’t quite what you asked for as you wanted tech company blogs, but I often find independent engineers have really interesting, original, and more personal stories/style that you wouldn’t always get on corporate blogs.
BillFranklin··on Show HN: Blogosphere – Discover independent technical blogs
Thanks for your feedback. I appreciate the tip on the LSH filter. One thing that has helped so far is restricting the content manually and with heuristics, as it prevents clickbait/controversial/malicious content. If I can implement collaborative filtering in future, I'll need to think about how to weight 'stars' from users to prevent malicious behaviour and improve recommendations, but I am getting ahead of myself :)
BillFranklin··on Show HN: Blogosphere – Discover independent technical blogs
Hi Adnan! Sorry for the delay, I've added your blog: https://bilbof.com/blogosphere/blogs/33759.
BillFranklin··on Show HN: Blogosphere – Discover independent technical blogs
I had a crack at that with the blog directory (https://bilbof.com/blogosphere/blogs), but it's pretty limited!

One thing I thought would be cool would be an API for similar blogs or articles, pretty much opening up an internal part of blogosphere. I think one could use that to provide a webring.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →