HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

BlackJack

1,949 karma · joined July 5, 2011

email is aayushu [AT] [GMAIL] [DOT COM]

Group Product Manager at Google. Before that, PM/PM Manager at Facebook, CoinTracker, and Google.

submissionscomments
BlackJack··on The Rise and Fall of French Cuisine
I think you want to say California has the best restaurants/food vs. "California cuisine is the best cuisine".

Of course SF/Bay has some of the best restaurants in the world with French Laundry, Atelier Crenn, Benu, Saison, etc.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_cuisine

California cuisine is a food movement that originated in California. The cuisine focuses on dishes that are driven by local and sustainable ingredients with an attention to seasonality and an emphasis on the bounty of the region

BlackJack··on Show HN: Trump to Text (Natural Language Generation)
Hey HN!

As a side project, I used the GPT-2 OpenAI NLG model and trained it on Donald Trump speeches. You can type a sentence and it will generate a few paragraphs that sound like Trump completing the thought.

I used https://github.com/minimaxir/gpt-2-simple and some other stuff to re-train, with Starlette being the python web server. I'll write up a blog post later on what I learned and issues I faced.

The text generation is pretty slow right now (~20 secs), but I didn't optimize anything since this was just a fun side project. Would love thoughts/feedbacks/funny texts :-)

BlackJack··on Scaling from 2k to 25k engineers on GitHub at Microsoft
They should've said "using" instead of "on" so it's unambiguous. I was confused too.
BlackJack··on A Teen Programmer Built a Tool to Generate Fake Lyrics for Your Favorite Artists
This is awesome, very cool! You mentioned OpenAI in another post - it's not that hard to use the GPT-2 model. Check out https://github.com/minimaxir/gpt-2-simple for a quickstart. Would be curious to see how the music generation goes if you re-train your data set against gpt-2.
BlackJack··on They Were Promised Coding Jobs in Appalachia
We can discuss code camp pro/cons all day, but the article spells out that there was little coding being taught here.

Instructors with little tech experience, high rate of firing and stuff turnover, students being told to "google it", operating without licenses, all while the founder has fancy offices in Chicago with rapacious and alcoholic parties.

Amanda Laucher, the founder, essentially stole funds from governments and made false promises and is now going to Law School in Chicago. Meanwhile, these people quit their jobs on false hope and now are unemployed or have to rejoin at the bottom of the rung.

Assuming the article is fair, this is a sad situation and Laucher should be prosecuted.

BlackJack··on The sour science driving James Harden's vexing genius
Put some respect when talking about Skip To My Lou ;-)

Agreed with your commentary - Steph is one of the greatest NBA players ever, and a variety of regular stats and advanced stats (i.e. gravity measurement) reflect that. It's why guys like him, Harden, and Dame make 1st team all NBA - the pressure they exert on defenses is insane.

BlackJack··on Yann LeCun, Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio win Turing Award
Maybe for the general public, but I'm sure the HN audience knows much better given the amount of people who studied computer science or are in tech.
BlackJack··on [dead]
Just went to facebook.com and saw this notification
BlackJack··on When India Kicked Out Coca-Cola, Local Sodas Thrived
I smiled reading this. Where are you going to wash and machete open your own coconuts when traveling somewhere?
BlackJack··on The Rest of Us Always Knew Churchill Was a Villain
My point was not that Churchill wanted fascism or communism. The point was that Hitler was a genocidal leader and that the British/Victorian government during the 20th century also perpetuated genocide, directly or through inaction.

Hitler didn't take a "peacetime situation." There was hyperinflation in Germany post WWI, and a massive arms and military-industrial build up all the way through the invasion of Czechoslovakia. Furthermore, Hitler didn't want to "abolish democracy everywhere" - his objectives were to make Germany self-sufficient and in control of Europe. He was certainly anti-democracy in terms of slowness, and believed in stronger centralized power, but I don't think he cared if South American states for example were democratic or not.

The British Empire didn't "dissolve" itself in India - there were decades of non-violent protest, including strong political pressure after WWI (Britain promised to give India independence after WWI, but didn't). Millions of lives were lost in this process both due to colonial brutality as well as 1MM+ dead due to the partition of India and Pakistan and it's aftermath.

Look up books like Late Victorian Holocausts [1], which make the exact argument of how British and other colonial governments created or at least prolonged famine situations across the world.

Happy to discuss further if you want to.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Victorian_Holocausts

BlackJack··on The Rest of Us Always Knew Churchill Was a Villain
The article says:

"Thanks to Churchill’s personal decisions, more than 3 million Bengalis died of hunger in a 1943 famine. Churchill deliberately ordered the diversion of food from starving Indian civilians to well-supplied British soldiers and even to top up European stockpiles, meant for yet-to-be-liberated Greeks and Yugoslavs. “The starvation of anyway underfed Bengalis is less serious” than that of “sturdy Greeks,” he argued. When reminded of the suffering of Bengalis, his response was typically Churchillian: The famine was the Indians’ own fault, he said, for “breeding like rabbits.” If the suffering was so dire, he wrote on the file, “Why hasn’t Gandhi died yet?"

People argue it wasn't Churchill's fault. Specifically [1], which says that the fall of Burma to the Japanese cut off Indian import sources and the wartime element meant "tough decisions" were made. It argues that in peacetime things would be different.

That really doesn't make sense. If you look at the history of famine's in India under British rule [2], over 35MM people died due to famines, and the majority of those are due to imperial mismanagement. In democratic governments, you can vote out people who aren't solving the problem. Not so in colonial societies.

This source [3] puts it clearly:

"Throughout the autumn of 1943, the United Kingdom's food and raw materials stockpile for its 47 million people - 14 million fewer than that of Bengal - swelled to 18.5m tonnes.

In the end, Mukherjee writes eloquently, it was "not so much racism as the imbalance of power inherent in the social Darwinian pyramid that explains why famine could be tolerated in India while bread rationing was regarded as an intolerable deprivation in wartime Britain".

To us Indians, Winston Churchill is Hitler and what happened in Bengal is an Indian Holocaust. It is appropriate to call it "revisionist history" because the Indian and more generally Eastern perspective is not present in modern history. That is slowly changing thanks to modern scholarship and I think we will view Winston Churchill very differently in 50 years.

All men are flawed. Churchill did some very good things for England, and some very very bad things for India, Kenya, etc. Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin, etc. very all very charismatic and had strong leadership characteristics, but you cannot praise them publicly for "their good parts." It is crazy to me that we still do that with Churchill.

I was glad when Obama sent the bust back to England.

[1] https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/in-the-media/churchil...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_major_famines_in_I...

[3] http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/soutikbiswas/2010/10...

BlackJack··on The highest paid workers in Silicon Valley are product managers (2016)
I'm sorry to hear that, but something is wrong if the PM is that unaware of the state of the product.
BlackJack··on Ask HN: Move to product management at 35?
One thing to think about - are you looking to transition in your current company or in a new company?

I'm a PM at Google. One thing that works here is having eng do 20% PM projects or do a PM rotation for a few months to get a taste for the life before committing fully. I don't know how it works at your company but you could look into taking on some PM responsibilities before making the move.

A certification may explain more about the role and give you background knowledge, but it wouldn't help in skill development IMO. The best way to learn PM'ing is to do it. And if you're interviewing for a PM role, it's much better to talk about actual work than certifications.

Lastly, age is not an issue and it's probably better if you have more industry experience before moving to a PM role.

Of course, these are my opinions and not that of Google, etc.

BlackJack··on Crime in New York City Plunges to a Level Not Seen Since the 1950s
OP was making a joke that Wall Street bankers are criminals :-)
BlackJack··on Strategy: How to Develop, Structure and Shape a Winning System
This is a nice and ambitious post. A few thoughts:

1. There are great insights in Clayton Christensen's The Innovator's Dilemma. The focus of that book is on Disruptive Innovation, where a new upstart with some new tech/angle crushes your business. A lot of your notes/principles here are captured in that book concisely.

2. One thing that is useful for employees to understand is how their company creates and executes on a strategy. It's crazy to me how many guides there are on strategy when most individuals do 0 strategy setting. The result is that you think of a great strategy, get shot down for whatever reason, and just grumble about how the "execs don't get it". It's much more fruitful to understand how the big dawgs are setting their strategy and what models they're using, and then you can figure out how to operate and innovate in that context.

3. Your comments on insight and research reminded me of Charlie Munger's talks on Mental Models. The basic idea is that you learn from a bunch of disciplines and your brain starts to tie things together and you'll produce insights. Shane over at Farnam Street (https://www.farnamstreetblog.com/mental-models/) has a great guide and intro.

Overall, I enjoyed reading your post and am impressed by the level of research. Great job.

BlackJack··on The East India Company, the original corporate raiders
Thanks for educating me. I updated my post.
BlackJack··on The East India Company, the original corporate raiders
The Mughal's did bad things too, but some of their kings like Akbar at least tried to integrate society and not cause religious strife. The Mughal Empire did a lot of bad things in India, especially nutcases like Aurangzeb, and Indian people recognize those bad things.

The problem, as I understand, is that a lot of British people don't know all the bad things the Empire did, or don't learn about it the way German people learn about the Holocaust and the Nazi's. Same thing might apply to Belgium - I was appalled to visit Brussels and see a park called "Leopold Park" [1] in the center of the city.

Edit: Turns out this park is named after King Leopold I, the first king of Belgium, and before the Congo atrocities. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15314232 for the person who educated me :)

On a more personal level, as an Indian person who grew up in the US, I always thought Churchill was a badass dude and a good wartime leader. It wasn't until Middle School that I learned about the WW2 famines and all the stuff he said about Indian people. He hated Indians and was extremely racist. His decisions directly lead to the death of millions of people in India. He's no better than Hitler or any of those dictators in my view, and it's mind boggling that people idolize him as the Lion.

Tangent aside, a lot of people did bad things (globally), but saying the Ottomans are bad or the Belgians are bad doesn't absolve the British Empire of its crimes. I don't think we need reparations or blame anybody today, since we all understand bad things happened, but more people should be educated about what happened and how to make sure it never happens again.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leopold_Park

BlackJack··on Credit-card-rewards guru Brian Kelly says we’re in a “golden age” of travel
He's talking about willingness to pay (WTP), which is the right way to value travel imo. A biz flight might be $4k, but the economy option might be $800. If I buy economy but would pay ~$1500 for business, but no more, then the miles are effectively worth that to you. If an airline was selling fares at $1500 you'd buy them, but since they're not, you won't be buying at $4k.

In your hotel example, you should look at the WTP for a room. I might pay $150 for a room, and up to $250 for the high end room. So even if the sticker price is $500, it's value to me is closer to $250, so I'll calculate my CPM that way.

BlackJack··on Credit-card-rewards guru Brian Kelly says we’re in a “golden age” of travel
Would you have paid $18K to fly to Japan though? The "cents per mile" is high but it's better to measure your WTP (willingness to pay).

BTW, you can regularly get west coast to Japan in business class for ~$3-4k/pp. ex. https://goo.gl/flights/BDTu. If you wait for deals, there was Vancouver - Japan/Hong Kong/SE Asia for ~$2k in business class for a while. Business class prices have been consistently dropping transatlantic (TATL) and we're seeing that transpacific (TPAC) too, albeit more slowly.

I think what you did was smart, but there's really no way to continue to get that kind of value from your miles. You could get the other Amex cards (~150k MR?), and other Chase cards (~150k UR?), but hard to repeatedly get big bonuses like that :P

Totally agree though that keeping one or both of those cards is great for the right kind of spend. It's just not like a free trip to Europe every quarter like it used to be.

BlackJack··on Credit-card-rewards guru Brian Kelly says we’re in a “golden age” of travel
I'm well versed with this world, and actually blog sometimes too. Here's some observations:

1. Lots of people use credit card points and frequent flyer miles to buy premier hotel and flight experiences. For example, you can fly from the US to Europe in business class round-trip for ~120,000 points and ~$200 in taxes/fees. Buying a business class roundtrip would cost $2000-7000, depending on which airlines and which times you fly.

2. You can earn points by flying, but the fastest way is by credit card bonuses. Recently the Chase Sapphire Reserve (CSR) had a 100K point bonus if you spent $4,000 in 3 months. You could transfer those Chase points to United and nearly have enough for round-trip business class tickets. To earn 100K United miles by flying would require you to spend $9k+ dollars on united tickets (if you're top tier elite), or fly business class between US-Asia 3 times on their partners or ~6 times in economy. It's waaay faster to use credit card sign-up bonuses to earn points.

3. There are lots of bloggers. boardingarea.com is full of them. Many cards give you referral bonuses for customers, so they just use their affiliate links. They're generally trying to push the links when they can. If you're a bigger blogger, you can get a deal with a bank to get cash per referral as opposed to the "max 5 referrals per year" deal that most people get.

4. The Points Guy (TPG) gets lambasted for using referral links that have the best referral bonuses instead of what's best for the end user. For example, the CSR above (100k/$4k spend), did not give a referral bonus. It's little brother, the Chase Sapphire Preserve (CSP), gave a 50k point bonus for $4k spend, but did give the referrer a bonus as well (10k points, or some cash depending on the deal). TPG regularly linked to the CSP even when every other blog was linking to the CSR.

5. The "golden age of travel" has transformed. In the past, frequent flyer programs were very beneficial, and cards had awesome sign-up bonuses. People would "churn" cards i.e. apply for a card every 90 days to get the sign up bonus and then never use it again. After a few years it wouldn't hurt your credit score, but you can read-up more online. reddit.com/r/churning is generally a good source.

6. Nowadays you still have big card bonuses but they tend to be more for the premium credit cards ($450+ annual fee) instead of no-fee or low-fee cards. In addition, banks are tighter about how often you can apply for those cards.

7. Airlines are much stingier with their award space. Even if a business class flight is supposed to cost 55-60k miles, you need availability from your origin and destination. The airlines can simply limit availability and render your points less useful. American is notorious for this - good luck finding business class awards from the US to anywhere. United is the best because Star Alliance has a ton of partners and usually sufficient availability. Delta has variable awards so sometimes a flight will cost 50k miles and other times it will cost 100k or even 300k miles for the same flight. A real PITA :(

8. You'll notice that I am consistently talking about business class awards. That's because economy fares have become very cheap nowadays that it's better value to just buy them. If you follow Scott's Cheap Flights, you can get notifications of fare deals. You can regularly get $300-400 flights from US-Europe or $500 US-Asia flights. These flights would cost 60-70k miles roundtrip, but with CSR you can "buy them for 1.5 cents per mile," so you can use 25K chase points to buy a $375 flight, and earn miles on that flight. Conversely business class tickets usually go for $2-4K, so using 100K miles is a way better "redemption", if that's what you're interested it. Ultimately it depends on your willingness to pay - some people stretch miles to economy as much as they can.

Hope that helps as a quick primer. Happy to answer any questions. Miles & points is an interesting world but it has gotten less rewarding. Nowadays I just see them as a nice to have but not something I'd go out of my way for.

BlackJack··on 40% of foreign students in the US have no close American friends on campus
Is there an alternative article you would recommend for this topic?
BlackJack··on The jobs that really smart people avoid
The article neglects to mention that 15-40% [1][2] of graduating classes at elite schools go into finance. That's a staggering number.

Sure the top students are going into research careers/PhDs, but the banking/consulting/tech recruiting engine is very strong for the rest. I think there are many people who could have productive roles in science/engineering/teaching/etc without getting PhDs who end up in tech/finance instead due to the strong recruiting pressure and great job perks/prestige.

[1] https://www.marketplace.org/2014/03/20/education/top-student.... [2] https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/12/21/out-of-harvard...

BlackJack··on Fat-fueled brain: unnatural or advantageous?
Lyle McDonald: http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/research-review/meal-freque...

Probably the best and most researched article on this.

Bullet point 4 here: http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debun... has an article reference.

Basically, you can certainly go into starvation mode, but not in any reasonable amount of time. Skipping meals or even fasting for a whole day will not cause "starvation mode". Prolonged calorie restriction can affect hormones like Leptin and affect energy expenditure.

BlackJack··on Rural Indian Girls Chase Big-City Dreams
There's a saying that whatever your impression is of India, you can find it there and also find the exact opposite.

That being said, I've never heard of this custom.

Overall, I thought this was a fantastic article.

BlackJack··on Walmart Canada stops accepting Visa cards
"To keep prices low we continuously assess opportunities to lower our operating expenses...

Customers will continue to be able to use...American Express."

Thought this was funny given that Amex must have the highest interchange & fees. Their statement still makes sense because Walmart is saying Visa fees in Canada are too high compared to their rates in other markets.

Maybe Target will win some market share, but I doubt it. I think customers will switch cards or go cash. Walmart is too good at what they do.

BlackJack··on Ivy League economist ethnically profiled, interrogated for doing math on AA flt
"Perhaps she couldn’t differentiate between differential equations and Arabic."

A math class could've avoided all this, though obviously wouldn't fix the root cause.

BlackJack··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (May 2016)
Same, I've upvoted everyone who provided a salary estimate. I saw this in action last month and think it's a great principle so I encourage others to do the same.
BlackJack··on Show HN: WrapAPI: a tool to build APIs and bots on top of any website
Looks neat, how does it work? Also, you guys should make the Chrome extension more prominent as that seems to be very neat.
BlackJack··on The netscape dorm
Is there a link to what the original said? I remember reading the 2011 jwz doc in college and it was a huge topic of discussion in our CS community.
BlackJack··on Cutting Back Sugar Improves Obese Children's Health in Just 10 Days
I think the result is still interesting. There's a whole lifestyle called "IIFYM" or If It Fits your Macros which suggests that the macronutrient breakdown (% carbs/fat/protein) is the main factor in growth/health, and that you can eat whatever IIFYM.

This study contradicts that by showing health improvement while maintaining macronutrient breakdown, albeit in obese kids. Is this replicable in adults and/or normal weight people? Who knows? Still a pretty interesting result IMO.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →