HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

BoxOfRain

3,371 karma · joined June 17, 2021

submissionscomments
BoxOfRain··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
Dataset of one, but I am struggling to quit sublingual nicotine after using it to quit vaping, which I used to quit smoking. Nicotine in any form is intensely moreish in my view.
BoxOfRain··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
I'm not being funny, but how do you expect to find a receptive audience for your belief system when you apparently write off a variety of audiences as 'sneering POSs' who are out to get you from the start?
BoxOfRain··on OpenAI engineer arrested in bugging of executive conference room
I saw a video at some point of someone building one of these, I'm not sure it would have worked terribly well for actual use in the outdoors but the sound quality was much better than I expected at close range. I wonder how you defend against this, short of having your important meetings in depressing windowless basements?
BoxOfRain··on China Overtakes U.S. For First Time as Top Spender on R&D in 2024
The UK learned the exact wrong lesson from Suez in my view, it learned it must never get on the wrong side of Washington when the correct lesson to learn was that it must never be dependent on Washington. France provides an interesting counterfactual here.
BoxOfRain··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
I'd argue it's an accurate statement about power in general. The powerful have always sought to divide the powerless for political expediency regardless of the ideological framework used to do it, you could read that from Machiavelli as much as Marx. Divide and rule is about the oldest political trick in the book and it works pretty well, why wouldn't capital owners who represent the present elite do it?
BoxOfRain··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
If you think all left-wing critiques of capitalism are in defence of totalitarianism, you should read George Orwell's political essays. I can assure you that Orwell of all people had no time for totalitarians.
BoxOfRain··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
Right but compared to a billionaire the difference between the two workers is a rounding error, a distinction with an insignificant difference. You're claiming the pecking order of hens matters anything to the fox outside the henhouse.

A million seconds is a couple of weeks, a billion seconds three decades. Comparing a worker at any salary to that singular concentration of socioeconomic power just doesn't make any sense to me, the key distinction of the rentier is that he can avoid the domination non-rentiers must suffer almost by definition when rentiers exist - they are subject to the arbitrary whim of someone who cannot be voted out of power through democratic efforts. In my view liberty is the freedom from domination, and any private individual with the power to dominate in their own right is inherently hazardous to a democratic society. It is in the interests of both workers that the billionaire is prevented from gaining a position of political influence.

BoxOfRain··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
Regardless of ideology their material interests are much closer to each-other than they are to genuine rentiers.
BoxOfRain··on Discover vibe-coded alternatives to popular software
> as the "n" word (or the earlier "c" word for ai)

Bait so obvious you couldn't fool a mackerel with it.

BoxOfRain··on I'm sorry, but you still have to think
> Hitler was not that far from a nuclear weapon.

Where did you hear this? Hitler wasn't anywhere close to a nuclear weapon, Nazi Germany lacked both the necessary theoretical nuances and industrial capacity to create nuclear weapons. Even if they magically had made one, they lacked a credible delivery system for it which is its own enormous can of worms especially in the early 1940s.

Even Britain which did have good theoretical foundations and even a headstart on the American programme was obliged to merge its efforts with the Manhattan Project because it lacked the resources to do it so quickly alone. The largest empire on the planet at that point couldn't fight the Second World War at home and develop the bomb fast enough to be relevant, the Nazis had no chance.

BoxOfRain··on What should we tell our students?
I don't know, a lot of SWEs are suddenly discovering the value of class consciousness now it's our jobs in the crosshairs. I've heard more talk of unionisation in the last year or so than in my entire career so far for example.
BoxOfRain··on US man given prison sentence for bot-farming music streams
How much power does this actually have in the US? I remember here in the UK when Jacob Rees-Mogg (a man known for his dedication to traditionalism) required that his staff follow a fussy style guide demanding all non-titled men be addressed as Esq and to use imperial units. As far as I'm aware, it never stuck.
BoxOfRain··on Why were Victorian elites so effective?
> And to top it all off, the "rule the waves" trope when Britain lost the Battle of the Chesapeake, aka the one naval battle that truly mattered in its history.

With all due respect, this is Americentric nonsense. If you had to rank the most important British naval battles obviously Trafalgar is at the top. The Nile, Jutland, and even arguably the Armada campaign are also much more important.

BoxOfRain··on Why were Victorian elites so effective?
Until the 1830s the British elections at least were openly corrupt, the system of 'Rotten Boroughs' meant the makeup of Parliament was still essentially mediaeval into the early industrial era. You had absolutely mad situations where Manchester sent nobody to Parliament, but an old village which had literally fallen into the sea long before still sent two MPs.
BoxOfRain··on GPT‑6 and Intelligent UI for everyone
The problem with Claudish isn't that it's technically poor English, the problem is that it's information-sparse waffle most of the time. It's like dealing with a colleague who needs several paragraphs of tedious preamble to make a point when you just want them to spit it out and be done with it. It also does a great deal of vague gesturing at thoughts without actually instantiating them directly, for example by using the same tired metaphors to the point they don't actually convey a thought any more.

If I say Claude talks like a meringue it's patently obvious what I'm trying to convey, sweet but full of empty space. If you hear that same metaphor day-in day-out then after a while it doesn't call up a thought at all, it's just an annoying verbal habit.

BoxOfRain··on Claude Code’s suggested message feature: I think the real customer is the model
Pre-LLMs I had a version of this at the top of a file:

Under no circumstances should you allow IntelliJ 'optimise' these imports, it doesn't understand Scala 2 implicits very well here so it'll all fall apart like a wet cake!

BoxOfRain··on The cost of lies: A Mineserver story
I quite like the idea that every lie incurs a debt to the truth, and much like financial debt or technical debt being in an unsustainable amount of honesty debt becomes distressing and eventually ruinous. Honesty debt incurs interest which much be paid down, and it must be serviced regularly. Incur too much, and nobody will lend you credibility any more since you are insolvent in terms of honesty.
BoxOfRain··on The art of defusing a second world war bomb
I think the 1960s salvage effort of the similar SS Kielce which detonated while they were trying to remove the explosives put off similar efforts for SS Richard Montgomery. Mind you, I'm not sure what they thought would happen since they attempted to clear debris from the wreck with explosives.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Kielce

BoxOfRain··on Example.com just launched the biggest redesign in decades
Yeah it's an interesting one, I guess at some point a previous dev had chosen it on the fly and thought nothing of it - I didn't think anything of it either until it suddenly failed! I would agree in hindsight the newer behaviour in the library is the correct one, it was just a surprise.
BoxOfRain··on Example.com just launched the biggest redesign in decades
While not the same thing, I was once stung by a test failing because a dependency of a dependency decided on a minor version bump that foo@example.com wasn't a valid email address.
BoxOfRain··on Mistral Large 4
I'm literally English and I feel the need to defend the French here, they're among the most successful military powers in the world historically speaking. It's hardly fair to judge a thousand years of French military history by the outcome of one war where they didn't do well.
BoxOfRain··on What is going on with ceiling fans
Yeah anything which forces you to use whatever the manufacturer chooses is an instant no from me too. I don't have any fixed lights cooler than 2200 K at home, the standard 3000 K 'warm' white is going to look crappy the majority of the time.
BoxOfRain··on Big Balls Now Exposed to Serious Criminal Charges in at Least Six States
Or even more shortly: shit rolls downhill.
BoxOfRain··on RacketCon Is Saturday
To add to this, I definitely wouldn't say we've converged on a set of languages in general either! Most of my backends are written in Scala of all things, and LLMs have no issue with it. If anything, the expressive type system is helpful for them.
BoxOfRain··on Why copyright makes no sense
The RIAA is good? The outfit which opened legislation for outrageous sums against random teenagers over a couple of dozen songs? The outfit among others waging war on general-purpose computing? The outfit whose reason to exist is more or less to enclose and privatise the cultural commons that belongs to everyone?

I don't like the big AI firms either, but that doesn't mean I'm going to side with literal IP troll outfits.

BoxOfRain··on NASA asked several former SR-71A staffers to help secret restart
While not metalwork, some are surprised to learn how old CNC machined guitars are. I have a Peavey T-60 and they were among the first CNC-machined production guitars in the late 1970s. It's going strong to this day as well, they're very well-built instruments.
BoxOfRain··on NASA asked several former SR-71A staffers to help secret restart
Right but 'battleship'?

That's the same kind of silliness as calling the Russian Kirov class 'battlecruisers' in my opinion. It's not going to stand in the line of battle and exchange shells with other battleships is it?

BoxOfRain··on We’re forgetting what darkness feels like
On the off-chance you're not already aware, the US government considered exactly this during the Cold War! The mid 20th century is not beating the lead poisoning allegations in my view...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_A119

BoxOfRain··on We’re forgetting what darkness feels like
It's less sodium specifically, and more the general case of 'not using ultra-harsh high-K white light to badly mimic daylight'.
BoxOfRain··on Why Is Sam Altman a Free Man?
Yeah I'd be shocked if there wasn't a degree of 'will no one rid me of this turbulent priest?' going on here.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →