HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CGMthrowaway

4,446 karma · joined March 30, 2025

submissionscomments
CGMthrowaway··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People (2016)
> Premise 2: The brain is an ordinary configuration of matter, albeit an extraordinarily complicated one. If we knew enough, and had the technology, we could exactly copy its structure and emulate its behavior with electronic components.... The mind arises out of ordinary physics.... If you are very religious, you might believe that a brain is not possible without a soul. But for most of us, this is an easy premise to accept.

This is the premise I rejected immediately and, if you agree with me, it takes down the whole house of cards. Let me explain. The rationale has nothing to do with "quantum shenanigans."

I have been called religious but will readily concede that of course a physical brain is possible without a soul. What is impossible is to replicate a soul with purely physical matter. Therefore we may understand that "superintelligence" is possible, and maybe inevitable on the long thread of time, but - crucially - it will never be able to approach that supernatural element present in us (the spark of the godhead) and therefore never be able to replace humanity.

In that sense it is like any other natural disaster that threatens to make us extinct, but it is not some "superhuman" nor anything close.

CGMthrowaway··on 'Backrooms' Stuns with $81M Debut
I remember reading Project Hail Mary years before the movie was announced, and thinking "this is written, if not exactly as a screenplay, in such a way to make it SO easy to adapt to a screenplay that given this is from the Martian author there is no way this will not be made as a movie"

I enjoyed both the book and the movie btw

CGMthrowaway··on 'Backrooms' Stuns with $81M Debut
Same thing happened with music and CDs vs streaming
CGMthrowaway··on Cars collect a startling amount of data about you
GM didn't sell anywhere close to half of those cars in California
CGMthrowaway··on Cars collect a startling amount of data about you
> With cars, networked computers are encroaching on privacy from two sides: the computers inside the car sharing sensor data and the computers outside the car sharing camera data from known points on the road.

There are cameras inside the car as well.

CGMthrowaway··on Confidence Scores for Exam Questions
A system like that seems especially appropriate for a practice where the foundational principle is "do no harm."
CGMthrowaway··on Citing 'severe' math deficits, UC faculty demand a return to SAT tests for STEM
What is your issue with redirecting funding from sucky schools towards ones that deliver results, while allowing school choice for students at the same time? I may be naive but that sounds fairly good
CGMthrowaway··on Private equity bought America's essential services
Government jobs, yes. Of which there are more and more every year. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USGOVT
CGMthrowaway··on That Methyl Methacrylate Tank
World's largest Outstanding Service Award.
CGMthrowaway··on 'Major chemical explosion' kills, injures multiple people
A pressurised tank (110 to 165 psi) ruptured, causing the accident. The chemicals involved are NaOH and sodium sulfide (white liquor) which is what is used to turn wood chips into pulp - and the source of the H2S smell that comes from paper mills
CGMthrowaway··on Is "colorectal cancer" rising in "young people"?
FYI there are other options besides a full scope for screening now, especially if you are low risk
CGMthrowaway··on Memory has grown to nearly two-thirds of AI chip component costs
You're making the point for him. Undersupply in a boom, store cash to ramp up capacity in a downturn. Presevres capital and avoids overcapacity during the turning
CGMthrowaway··on Seattle Shield, an intelligence-sharing network operated by the Seattle police
That may be true however today it is 2026 not 1961, LRH fell off the earth in 1980, and it is feasible that after the raids in 1977 and/or upon gaining tax-exempt status in 1993, some sort of deal was cut with the US state/intel apparatus to co-opt the church for another purpose
CGMthrowaway··on An OpenAI model has disproved a central conjecture in discrete geometry
How do you even get an LLM to try to solve one of these problems? When I ask it just comes back with the name of the problem and saying "it can't be done"
CGMthrowaway··on Disney erased FiveThirtyEight
>cbs, the ny times, and the washington post have all shifted rather noticeably rightward

As the Overton window or activist left moves further left on issues like identity politics, crime and free speech (1619 Project era at NYT, staff revolts etc), steady coverage can appear "righter" by comparison without actually changing

CGMthrowaway··on Pentagon walks away from Canada-U.S. defence board
Calling it irrational doesn’t change the reality of the strategic shift underway
CGMthrowaway··on Pentagon walks away from Canada-U.S. defence board
US is shifting foreign policy to increasingly treat alliances as conditional and transactional.

Canada can no longer assume historical goodwill or that shared institutions will automatically anchor the relationship.

It's up to Canada to strengthen its own defense capacity.

We are in a post-, post-WW2 environment. Time to realize that. As well, fifth gen warfare (information warfare), gray zone warfare etc are now the name of the game across the world, not just US. Economic, military and diplomatic issues are inevitably intertwined. Forget about what you knew. Canada has to think more holistically about how its economic and security policies intersect

CGMthrowaway··on Magical Realism: “Northern Exposure” 25 Years Later (2015)
Agree. It's so wholesome, uncontroversially values driven but doesn't feel shoved down your throat like a recent episode of Law & Order might.

If you like Northern Exposure I recommend the other shows that were basically reboots of it: Hart of Dixie (which I prefer to the next) and Virgin River

CGMthrowaway··on Roman Letters
Had to look up "sow's matrices."

> A "sow's matrix" (or vulva in Latin) is a dish from ancient Rome consisting of the uterus of a sow (a female pig), often specifically from one that has never farrowed or that was slaughtered shortly after farrowing. It was considered a delicacy among the wealthy elite and was a common dish served at lavish Roman banquets and dinner parties, often used as a sign of luxury, wealth, and status.

CGMthrowaway··on High dimensional geometry is transforming the MRI industry (2017) [pdf]
fMRI is a step above dowsing rods. It's plugging a multimeter into an outlet and guessing what type and brand of appliances you are running in your house.
CGMthrowaway··on High dimensional geometry is transforming the MRI industry (2017) [pdf]
Sounds more like the point is that math research has high ROI compared to most federally funded research
CGMthrowaway··on USDA Projects Smallest US Wheat Harvest Since 1972 Due to Plains Drought
IDK how many people in China are laser focused on agweb.com for their geopolitical negotiations.

The data comes from USDA's WASDE report which is released every month, between the 8th and 12th. There is no "timing," and people were talking about the expect wheat harvest this season for weeks ahead of Tue's report anyway

CGMthrowaway··on The Original 1965 Gatorade Recipe
There is a viral trending brand of powder now that is pretty close to the original recipe with no added garbage.

https://sport-drink.com/

CGMthrowaway··on Googlebook
Googlebook dot Google.

Pixelbook.

Chromebook.

Google Pixel.

What's next? Nestbook? Drivepad? Geminiphone?

CGMthrowaway··on The Struggle Is Gone
I feel like there is room for a "Slow Movement" in the age of AI/online these days.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_movement_(culture)

CGMthrowaway··on Singapore introduces caning for boys who bully others at school
Men bear greater physical risk (war, dangerous labor etc) and boys/young men have always been subject to violent "rites of passage" that prepare them for this.

Girls and women receive greater physical protection, as required to manage reproductive capacity and long‑term demographic stability.

CGMthrowaway··on A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous
> headset

Half- vs. full duplex. Headphones is all you really need, though of course a directional mic and/or one closer to your mouth will yield a clearer audio recording as well.

CGMthrowaway··on What causes lightning? The answer keeps getting more interesting
Why don't we do this on the norm and somehow harness the energy?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvesting_lightning_energy

CGMthrowaway··on SocialCrawl – search what people are saying across Reddit, X, TikTok, and 25
The average age of Congress vs. Congressional approval rating would like a word
CGMthrowaway··on SocialCrawl – search what people are saying across Reddit, X, TikTok, and 25
At least a third of military intel officers are under 30, why are you want to discount them?
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →