HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CPlatypus

392 karma · joined February 13, 2010

submissionscomments
CPlatypus··on Android on a Netbook - an Eee Transformer Review
I was going to type this on my own Transformer, even got several paragraphs in, but I'm finishing on my Mac. See point 8 for why.

(1) The battery life really is awesome. I get a full day of near-continuous use - including video and such - out of the internal battery, plus another out of the battery in the dock. On the downside, the USB charging cable is non-standard with respect to both form factor and voltage.

(2) The trackpad really is useless.

(3) The task switching is just as bad as the author says. Each time I start Firefox, I have to guess whether it will have my old tabs or a clean slate. It's impossible even to know whether it will show up in the app switcher. Usually, if one application (e.g. twitter/email) invokes another (e.g. a browser), the second will disappear from the app switcher until you explicitly go back to the first, or else you have to go back to the home screen and launch from there. Even that broken behavior's not consistent, though.

(4) The built-in email program sucks, and K-9 is almost as bad.

(5) There's no decent ssh client. I have two - one which does tunnels but has atrocious keyboard handling, one which has semi-decent keyboard handling (Ctrl actually works and I can simulate the missing Esc) but doesn't do tunnels. Unfortunately they're incompatible with one another in some weird way, so using both simultaneously is a bit tricky.

(6) I haven't found a program to create/edit slides. I've tried for Android office apps, and as many online apps including Google's own. None could handle so much as a simple bullet list properly. Most couldn't even put the cursor in the right place half the time.

(7) Text selection and cut/paste sometimes work (inconsistently across applications) and sometimes they don't. Cursor keys sometimes work and sometimes they don't.

(8) Stuff on the web can be very flaky. Text-entry boxes (e.g. here) often don't scroll properly as you type, so you have to scroll manually. Sometimes you lose the ability to reposition the cursor either by pointing (see point 6) and never had it via cursor keys (point 7). That's why I'm on the Mac now, after two rounds of that. On other sites (e.g. Quora) text-entry boxes fail to keep up with typing and just randomly set you back to the start every couple of words or so.

That's a lot of glitches and complaints, huh? I must hate this thing with a burning passion, right? Actually I love it. For video, games, and passive content consumption it's pure awesome. It's light, the screen is a joy, changing orientations on a whim is incredibly handy. As soon as I try to do or make anything with it, though . . . well, then it becomes a big sack of awful. It's an amazing complement to a real computer, but certainly not a replacement for one.

CPlatypus··on Riak 1.1 Released
There's little relationship between Dynamo and S3. Riak is based on the former but not the latter.
CPlatypus··on How Target Figured Out A Teen Girl Was Pregnant Before Her Father Did
I just wonder which data-mining-software company paid Forbes to copy this from NYT.
CPlatypus··on DotCloud adds FUSE support and shared filesystems
Are you planning to use map/reduce within dotCloud? I ask because, otherwise, there'd be no reason to use HDFS instead of something with real filesystem semantics, comparable performance and better availability. Once such option is mentioned in the OP.

Disclaimer: I'm on the GlusterFS architecture team and advisory board, so I'm totally biased.

CPlatypus··on The 'Undue Weight' of Truth on Wikipedia
Nobody's talking about interpretation. I was referring to mere verification that the source exists and says what it's claimed to. That can and should happen in an encyclopedia.
CPlatypus··on The 'Undue Weight' of Truth on Wikipedia
The "no original research" policy is fine when it prevents self-citation, but when it prevents citation of little-read but thoroughly credible third-party sources such as court transcripts that's a different matter.
CPlatypus··on The 'Undue Weight' of Truth on Wikipedia
Comparing primary sources is indeed not straightforward, but this is primary vs. secondary. If a book makes a claim that is directly contradicted by the author's own source then not much expertise is required to see that preferring the "child" over the "parent" would be absurd.
CPlatypus··on The 'Undue Weight' of Truth on Wikipedia
There's nobody I'd trust less than a Wikipedia editor to act as the arbiter of truth, but they could still do better. Wikipedía could adopt a policy of preferring primary sources over secondary, which would still keep out the "teach the controversy" cranks who are the obvious reason for the "undue weight" criterion without affecting well researched rebuttals of conventional folly. They consciously choose to do the exact opposite, preferring popular opinion to actual verifiability, and IMO that's wrong.
CPlatypus··on The Management Team - Guest Post From Joel Spolsky
"very nice to the line engineers but hard on people VP-level and above"

That makes me wonder about a "sandwich" model of management - a leader at the top who has a lot in common with engineers at the bottom, together putting the squeeze on management (who still wield most day-to-day authority) in the middle. Looked at another way, authority does mostly flow downward as in the traditional model, but then you "close the loop" by joining those at the bottom back up to the person at the top so that nobody's left without recourse when they think things are going awry.

I'm not really sure where to go with that idea, but it seems to bear thinking about. I'll bet somebody smarter than me already wrote a book about it.

CPlatypus··on Happy Family, Successful Start-up. Impossible?
Let's do the math on that. 60 hours is twelve hours a day, plus three more with your daughter. Add a couple of hours for showering and dressing, food prep, and general housework. That's seventeen hours a day, leaving seven for sleep plus zero for exercise, recreation, social life, career development, etc. Oh yeah, and interaction with your wife too. Maybe that's working out for you, but I know where it would lead for most people: physical, mental, and emotional exhaustion in only a few months. Even if that three hours a day with your daughter is merely being in the same place but doing other things, the weekends - which you claim you spend with her as well - wouldn't be enough to recharge.

Of course, that's the optimistic case where you have a spouse who does many of those things you apparently don't even think about, and who is willing to accept your devotion to company above family. In reality, that's not likely to last long and you'd be single in short order. Some would say that proves the point about startup/family incompatibility right there, but let's say you overcome the strong anti-male bias in our family-law system and become the custodial parent so you still have a family (sans wife). Now you'll need to spend even more time on food prep and housework, plus other tasks related to school or general care and feeding of a child. Also, many of those tasks will need to be done at particular times, not at leisure. Even if you slept a mere four hours a night, you'd be hard pressed to spend three hours a day of real time with your daughter.

In short, then, I just don't think your example proves your point very well at all. Maybe you're superman, the one in a million who could sustain such a schedule. That still says nothing about whether others can.

CPlatypus··on Forget Stealth Startups. We Have a New Issue: Stealth Blogs
Maybe some people just don't have an infinite appetite for self-promotion. I've had a blog for over a decade - nearly 1700 articles worth. I refer to my posts sometimes when it's strictly in context for a particular conversation, but I don't make a habit of posting links on Twitter and Google+ and HN and Reddit and FSM knows where else just because I think a post is so awesome that everyone I know (and even more that I don't) must read it immediately. If they find it in their RSS feed, that's great. If they hear about it from a mutual friend, that's great too. If somebody else wants to repost it, that's fine too; at least it means one person besides the author thought it was worth that. Otherwise, I feel that I'd be demanding too much of my friends' attention by making sure they see links to the same damn thing in a half-dozen places before its quality has been vetted by a single other soul. I'm hardly humble - I do have a blog after all - but I'm not that much of a narcissist.

There is no problem with people who are "too quiet" about their blogs. Au contraire.

CPlatypus··on Silicon Valley’s engineering salaries are finally getting fair. Thank Facebook
As Silicon Valley salaries rise, they will eventually reach the point where more employers will decide to spend their personnel dollars elsewhere. Engineers in Austin or Ann Arbor or Cambridge (either one) can work out of local offices, or straight out of their homes, and produce more lines of useful code per dollar than their peers in Palo Alto, Mountain View, or Sunnyvale. Go ahead, call it "inshoring" and look down your nose at those cheaper programmers if you like. They'll still be taking your jobs, and you'll be left living in a very expensive place after the salary bubble collapses.

The only question is when. I think the process has already begun. Some might predict another year or two. Nobody sane would expect the ride to last longer than that before supply and demand reassert themselves over mere fashion.

CPlatypus··on Stack Exchange: How does noise affect programmer productivity?
Right, the difference became more pronounced, but that doesn't really tell me what I as a planner would want to know. Consider two possible explanations.

(1) Some workers who had previously produced defect-free code started producing code with defects as the noise level increased.

(2) Some workers who had always produced code with defects started complaining about the noise as well.

In one of these cases, keeping noise levels down would make a difference. In the other it would not, and the numbers as given don't tell us which scenario applies. They also don't tell us the relative numbers of noise-tolerant vs. noise-intolerant programmers. If those affected by noise are a small minority, then an employer might make the choice to maximize office density and let those affected "select themselves out" by going elsewhere. OTOH, if just about all programmers are affected, that's not much of an option. If the authors reported that the number of programmers producing defect-free code went from X% at 20dB to Y% at 50dB to Z% at 80dB, then that would be much more useful. Similarly, these studies don't seem to measure time to task completion or ability to complete multiple tasks per day, which would be other factors in such decisions.

BTW, this is more than a theoretical issue for me. I'm working at home today because the noise level in my office - due to high density and low partitions - has become utterly intolerable. Just about everyone wears headphones all day, presumably because they feel likewise. I'm a bit disappointed that one of the most-cited studies in this area does not really support any useful conclusions that can be brought to management.

CPlatypus··on Stack Exchange: How does noise affect programmer productivity?
Unfortunately, this result might just mean that there's a correlation between noise tolerance and performance. It would have been better if they had studied objectively measurable noise levels instead of subjective acceptability of noise levels.
CPlatypus··on The ongoing fight against GPL enforcement
The "2010 and later" section is empty. I guess it's possible that they stopped building new products which use GPL code in 2009, but somehow it seems unlikely that they stopped updating or patching old ones at the same time. If it takes them two or more years to ship the source, after they're already shipping the binaries, are they in compliance?
CPlatypus··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
"doesn't this mean that there are perhaps tens of thousands of engineers who are on average producing $1m/year in revenue?"

No. Just because total revenue divided by total headcount comes out to a million doesn't mean every engineer is contributing a million. For one thing, a lot of that revenue is return on investment - in the code, in customer relationships, in the "brand" generally - in previous years, nothing to do with current headcount. For another, the distribution is exponential. A few people contribute many times that million, while the majority contribute less, and many of those at the high end aren't engineers. So yes, engineers who contribute a million dollars to the bottom line do exist, but they're a very small minority. I've even been one myself, but not every year. Everyone in SV seems to think they're firmly established in that elite category. 99% of them are wrong.

"If one of these $1m revenue/year ("1MRPY") engineers starts a company with n 1MRPY engineer friends, is it so crazy to suggest that they might produce $x * n million worth of value over x years?"

It's not totally crazy, but it's very unlikely. Such engineers are rare enough, and in such high demand, and self-directed enough, that you're unlikely to get more than a couple of them to follow one vision even if you're friends. Then you have to find people with non-engineering skill sets who are as good in their respective fields, and convince them to join you. Then you'll probably still fail due to factors other than the quality of your personnel.

What we're facing here is the compounding of two errors. Everyone thinks they're in the top 1%, and that being in the top 1% for one skill set is enough to ensure success. In reality, most startups have average teams and many non-technical obstacles to overcome. I've been in nine startups myself. I'd hardly discourage anyone from trying, but overconfidence can prevent people from doing what they really need to, and overconfidence seems to be California's most abundant crop.

CPlatypus··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
Well put, although I'm not quite sure "optimism" is the right term. Is it optimistic or egotistical for every SV engineer to believe that they are capable of creating a company worth a nine-figure IPO or acquisition - or, alternatively, that they can personally increase an established company's bottom line by a million a year? Somewhere in between, I'd guess. Partly it's overestimation of the market, partly it's overestimation of the self. Either way, it does seem to be a difference between SV and elsewhere. SV entrepreneurs believe they can succeed because it never even occurred to them to believe otherwise and of course nobody else would suggest such a thing. Entrepreneurs elsewhere are generally more aware of doubts and concerns, but consciously intend to prove the nay-sayers wrong.

Is one approach or mindset better than the other? It's tempting to say that the financial success of SV validates that approach, but I don't think that success occurs in a vacuum. Could those SV companies get where they are without past contributions from MIT or Bell Labs, current ones from Austin or Seattle? I don't think so. An army needs more than one kind of soldier, an industry needs more than one kind of company, and just because SV seems to hog all the glamour doesn't mean other places are somehow lacking.

CPlatypus··on Today Apple, Google, 5 Others Battle “No Poach” Conspiracy Case
Thank you for (belatedly) having the balls to engage instead of just downvoting. "All over the map" doesn't count, or else half of the threads on HN would have zero comments, and "doesn't add to the discussion" is absurd. The very fact that it took you three paragraphs to explain the nature of your objection indicates otherwise. I added far more to the discussion than the downvote-cowards had up to that point (and probably ever). Your "everyone everywhere else" strawman is even more risible. Stick to claims I actually made, or be dismissed as a dishonest coward.

I was certainly never confronted with the "fact" that SV engineers "certainly" do create proportional value. I was confronted with a bunch of bad math that proves nothing. Did you miss the part about the target ratio not needing to be 1:1? Or the part about developers' contribution during a year not being the only (or even main) determinant of revenue during that same year, which makes division of revenue for all by salary for some utterly ridiculous? Where are these engineers who drive the bottom line by 10x their burdened cost (not just salary BTW)? I've been one myself, I've met others, but for every such person I've also met dozens who contributed 10% or less over their cost. You need to stop assuming, and start measuring.

OK, on to the point about whether SV engineers are worth more than those elsewhere. Let's forget Bengaluru for a moment. Consider Boston or Boulder. Brisbane or Birmingham. Engineers there are every bit as good as those in SV. Sure, there are costs involved in having developers who are elsewhere, but that's balanced by the extra cost of building out offices etc. in one of the most expensive markets in the world. Buy some decent teleconferencing gear, provide a generous travel budget, and you'll still come out ahead even in these relatively high-salary locations. Now consider a place like Bengaluru. I haven't worked with everyone here, nor have I worked with everyone in SV, but I've worked with enough to be skeptical of the assumption that the average SV engineer can deliver enough to be worth several times the salary. Some can, most can't.

That's two strikes against you. Let's go for three. Should the free market determine wages? Absolutely. Do these no-poaching agreements subvert the free market? Again, absolutely. Does that add up to a conclusion that a bidding war would be a good thing? Absolutely not. CDNF. A temperate amount of poaching would be a good thing, but I don't think that's likely to happen. What's more likely to happen comes back to your statement about "a net loss or wash at best" because at some point that does become true. I personally think it has already become true at many companies. Those newly hired engineers are going to count against this year's budget; their contribution to revenue won't show up until next year's. The extra cost of hiring that first developer of the year has to be made up somehow. Part of it will be made up by reducing capital costs and travel budgets and such. Part of it will be made up by hiring nine new developers instead of ten (wherever they are) or by giving smaller raises to current employees (including developers). Maybe that "rock star" you just hired away from Google will pay off next year, but this year (and probably the next couple) their bidding-war premium will exert downward pressure on everyone else. A bidding war is not only bad for developers elsewhere, or for non-developers. It's bad for other developers in SV besides the few who win the lottery.

The problem with the no-poaching agreements is that they've created pent-up demand. Now, like soda that has been shaken, the newly opened bottle is going to fizz all over the place. Those making the agreements should have been prosecuted years ago, because waiting has created an even bigger mess. The absolute least likely outcome is an efficient short-term reallocation of resources. More likely is that some companies without deep pockets will be starved out of the market.

CPlatypus··on Today Apple, Google, 5 Others Battle “No Poach” Conspiracy Case
I'd appreciate it if the downvote-abusing coward(s) would explain their objection to that comment. It's quite factual, and relevant, and IMO importantf for people to consider. Do you seriously believe that revenue for all employees divided by salary for some tells you anything meaningful? Do you believe that availability of a better ratio by hiring someone else doesn't mean you're overpaid? Come on, let's have some actual debate instead of bullying.
CPlatypus··on Today Apple, Google, 5 Others Battle “No Poach” Conspiracy Case
"In proportion" merely means an optimal or expected ratio, which might be considerably greater than 1:1. Therefore, even if the value:salary ratio for that Silicon Valley engineer is 10:1, if a 20:1 ratio is possible somewhere else then that Silicon Valley engineer's salary is still out of proportion.

Also, dividing revenue per employee by salary for a subset of employees doesn't really give you the right ratio. A lot of corporate revenue is not directly tied to developer contributions, and it's a rare employee who actually moves the bottom line by 10x their salary. At best you could divide the revenue attributable to that year's development by the salary paid during that time, but even that's a weak approximation.

CPlatypus··on Today Apple, Google, 5 Others Battle “No Poach” Conspiracy Case
If developer salaries grow out of proportion to the value they create (which IMO has already happened), that creates downward pressure for everyone else in the value chain - non-technical employees, suppliers, etc. Also, when the bubble inevitably bursts it will affect lots of people who never benefited from the inflation in the first place. Bidding wars and speculation are not always good in the long term.

[edit] Allow me to expand on that in a very specific way. I'm currently sitting in Bengaluru, surrounded by some excellent developers. What effect does wage inflation in Silicon Valley have on people here? Every time a Silicon Valley engineer's salary gets inflated by US$20K, how many people here are affected by reduced job prospects or raises? From that perspective, what's hard to see is how a bidding war among SV employers could possibly be a good thing.

CPlatypus··on Every Linux screen locker bypassed with a keypress
I tried this on my very recently installed Fedora 16 desktop at home, and it worked. All of my applications were accessible, alt-tab and other selection methods worked, etc. The only thing that was missing was the panel at the top, and I couldn't be bothered figuring out how to bring it back so I just rebooted. Good thing I don't rely on that feature too much.
CPlatypus··on Building the next generation file system for Windows: ReFS
Dedup isn't quite the same as sparse files. If the filesystem is unaware of dedup, then it still has to allocate its own structures corresponding to the dedup'ed space, seeking to the next hole or next allocated block won't work (not that many applications are smart about holes or that MS didn't already suck in that area), etc. Dedup - even in its most absolutely simple form of just detecting zero blocks - does at least avoid the fatal problem of allocating actual disk space uselessly, but sparse files are still basically a filesystem problem and need to be treated as such.
CPlatypus··on Building the next generation file system for Windows: ReFS
I agree that it's a strange set of choices. Eliminating quotas and compression might be OK for something positioned as a basic filesystem, but for something billed as a "next generation" filesystem it seems odd. Eliminating extended attributes is an even bigger step backward, because they're such a useful building block for other OS features (e.g. look at their use to in Linux to support ACLs and security labels).

Failing to support sparse files, though . . . man, that's just insane. That would relegate ReFS to the status of a toy in most filesystem developers' minds, even before you consider their increasing usefulness when storing virtual-machine disk images in a shared filesystem to support migration, etc. It's hard to imagine that none of the many people who must be involved in this at MS raised the red flag. What seems more likely, from what I know of MS culture, is that some people did raise it but then some idiot dictator with a reputation built on some long-irrelevant project ignored or dismissed their objections.

CPlatypus··on WordPress has left the building
My first inclination is to agree with you. The OP should never have used WordPress as a multi-tenant CMS in the first place. OTOH, he does raise some issues that affect WP use even in its original blogging context. I use WP, I like it, I don't have immediate plans to change, but if I ever personally hit a "this was obviously never tested" case like he did I'd probably change my mind pretty quickly.
CPlatypus··on PyCon US 2012 Conference Schedule
Am I the only one who suspects this is an epic case of sour grapes?
CPlatypus··on Holographic source code
The other comparison I'd make is to normalized vs. denormalized databases. Normalization has been pushed for decades to reduce anomalies that are not dissimilar from those that occur in copied-and-pasted code. Yeah, wonderful, but that same normalization can pose problems when the data gets sharded across many servers and even simple queries end up requiring many connections. Similarly, centralizing logic can become a problem when that logic becomes a contention point for competing patches etc. Sometimes you really are better off with several less general versions of the same thing instead of one highly general version.
CPlatypus··on Mayor Bloomberg Will Learn How To Write Code In 2012
So will I, but only if I can check out his code on github and ask him a whole bunch of puzzle questions first. ;)
CPlatypus··on How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body
"simple postures and more importantly breathing"

+1

I'm no yoga expert, but I've dabbled at two separate points in my life. While I've forgotten practically all of the postures, the breathing stays with me. I still consciously use different types of breathing depending on whether I need to increase/decrease alertness, relax the body, etc. IMO everybody should learn these important life skills even if they have no interest in anything else yoga-related.

CPlatypus··on Why 37signals Doesn't Hire Programmers Based on Brainteasers
Thanks for the steawman. I was explicitly referring to a mentality, not to github itself. I use github. I don't share that mentality. It's not github's fault that some users treat them as an oracle, but it does happen. I have on multiple occasions heard people say that they won't hire people unless they can check out their work on github - github specifically, and no qualification or allowance for exceptions. Every time, the speaker was exactly the kind of hipster idiot that I just described. I suppose that could just be a coincidence, or it could be that people who follow one stupid trend often follow others as well. In any case, that one stupid trend is sufficisnt to make working with them unappealing, and since there are plenty of sensible employers out there it's unnecessary as well.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →