9,141 karma · joined July 9, 2014
I'd guess there should be a few people Uber is bascially allocating unlimited AI spending to and a large swath they're giving basically nothing.
But personally I love when agents do things like this and appreciate the help. Last thing in the world I want is for them to nerf the models.
MCP is essentially just JSON RPC with a few special fields that must be included. I have reservations about JSON RPC, but there needs to be some 'service discovery' layer for LLMs to interface with.
It needs to be available in places like websites, desktop applications, backend services, etc. The CLI is only one place that these systems interface with.
Whatever you replace MCP with will be in a similar shape even if you specify a different communication protocol or different fields for tool discovery.
I grew up playing chess but my grandfather always insisted that pawns could only be promoted to captured pieces so when I played him we had to play a that variant.
I suspect this came from players not having extra pieces with their chess sets.
I'm working on a similar problem in computer vision and we're quickly approaching the point where our pure vision work is better than our Lidar supported track because we've had to deal with the constraints instead of having a crutch to lean on.
1. They have a wide range of difficulties. 2. They were curated (Erdos didn't know at first glance how to solve them). 3. Humans already took the time to organize, formally state, add metadata to them. 4. There's a lot of them.
If you go around looking for a mathematics benchmark it's hard to do better than that.
You aren't buying a digital good, you're buying a limited license to use that digital good.
> Can you find the girl who did a bunch of posts critisizing David Graeber's Debt? I thought it was really well done
> I saw a comment on hackernews a while ago about the optimal amount of credit card fraud being higher than zero because of game theory dynamics, can you find it.
In both cases it turned up the exact posts I was looking for in like 30 seconds which would have taken me much longer using traditional search. I've had similar success looking for technical documentation. It's downright magical how they're able to turn my vague idea of what I'm looking for into a pointer to the exact thing.
If social media platforms started banning images with these watermarks seems like they'd be stripped out overnight.
I have my phone, I'm going for a walk, what app am I opening?
The problem I encounter is the inability of the LLM to look stuff up and respond to me. "What's that name of that database table?" "What are all the services that call this endpoint?" "Are there any open PRs for this repo right now?"
Once information can flow in both directions not just one it will be a gamechanger for me.
One thing to consider is that Van Riper summoned assets unrealistically he used small boats to avoid detection but then attributed load outs that they couldn't realistically carry.
He also moved information unrealistically assuming that his units could communicate as efficently with paper moved by hand as they could with radios.
There are real, valid criticisms of the lessons we should have learned from the exercise, but it's not as simple as most analyses make it out to be.
That's what the jury found against - they said he was reasonably informed enough to have brought the suit earlier and thus the 3 year clock should start ticking in 2020 not 2023.