HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CapricornNoble

1,420 karma · joined May 28, 2018

Defense industry consultant.

Information management, knowledge management, C4ISR systems, electronic attack, command & control, operations research, modeling & simulation, amphibious warfare, joint operations.

submissionscomments
CapricornNoble··on My $0->$100M->$0 in 5 years story
This makes for frustrating reading, coming from an industry where "Organizational Design" can have extremely serious consequences: the military.

A brief case study: Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The argument has been made (and I agree) that much of their early failures stem from not understanding/implementing Unified Command. They didn't have a Joint Task Force Commander who was responsible for the entire Area of Operations. They didn't have an Air Component Commander subordinate to the JTF to ensure all air operations achieved synergy with, and were in support of, the ground scheme of maneuver.

Most field-grade officers who have planned and/or executed a major multi-service or multi-national training exercise are familiar with Command Relationship org charts and understand WHY they are important (if that stuff isn't clear, responsibilities get fuzzy when edge cases arise, and then in the resulting confusion/friction....people die). It's also just as important to understand how much of that "big DoD" cruft you can peel away when you are doing small, localized training with a developing nation with....austere practices, shall we say.

So I could see adding "Organizational Design" to my LinkedIn....unknowingly putting myself in the same bucket as "hot-air no-nothing ex-FAANG managers". And then no one cares what digital signal processing stuff I could do for them as an IC... :(

CapricornNoble··on It doesn’t take much public creativity to stand out as a job candidate
>a good blog or a good Github doesn't account to anything more than a few pleasant sentences at the beginning of the interview

But it may contribute to you getting an interview in the first place, no?

CapricornNoble··on The Rise and Fall of the Chief Diversity Officer
I was enlisted in the Army, and an officer in the Marine Corps. No organization is perfect but by-and-large, yes, I found even the officer ranks to be reasonably meritocratic. If anything the organization's biases were caused by your career background: Infantry Officers rule the Corps as a whole. Fighter pilots rule the Marine Aircraft Wings; every other professional specialty is definitely a second-class citizen.
CapricornNoble··on The Rise and Fall of the Chief Diversity Officer
> As a gay man, if I have 2 similar job offers, one with a company that shows they are accepting and dont accept prejudice, and another that says nothing. Which one do you think I’ll choose?

As a contrarian data point, as a black man, when I see a company or other organization hit all the DEI talking points about embracing minorities, etc....I throw up in my mouth a little bit and head in the opposite direction. I prefer blind meritocracies, which is what both the Army and Marine Corps used to be when I joined them. Now....even the Marine Corps is looking to staff a DEI Officer in the National Capital Region (seriously).

CapricornNoble··on Shopify employee breaks NDA to reveal firm replacing laid off workers with AI
> the vast majority of poverty reduction in the last century has been in China, a non-capitalist country

Can't it also be said that the vast majority of poverty reduction has been in China...once they began to adopt capitalist economic principles in the last 40 years ?

CapricornNoble··on Swig – Connect C/C++ programs with high-level programming languages
That was exactly my experience writing custom GNU Radio blocks for my master's thesis: swig mangling my C++ variables. I have nothing positive to say about it.
CapricornNoble··on US Army Physical Fitness Test: Normative Data on 6022 Soldiers (1994)
PDF Link: https://www.fitness.marines.mil/Portals/211/Docs/PFT_CFT/PFT...

Minimum score is 1 minute 10 seconds, max is 3:45, gender/age neutral.

CapricornNoble··on US Army Physical Fitness Test: Normative Data on 6022 Soldiers (1994)
I knew a short stocky SNCO who just struggled with crunches, no matter how much effort he put into them. I found crunches easy because I have long arms and a short torso, so the distance I had to travel to do a technically-correct crunch was minimal. But I've always struggled with pull-ups....because those same long arms make the pull-up distance feel like I'm free climbing the Dawn Wall.

I also think doing sit-ups in the Army on stupidly-hard surfaces (parking lots, etc...) before I switched to the Corps is one of the main sources of my lower back pain.

CapricornNoble··on US Army Physical Fitness Test: Normative Data on 6022 Soldiers (1994)
Correct. It's still 3 miles @ 18:00 for max score until you get over 40 years old. We recently replaced crunches with planking though.
CapricornNoble··on Threads hits 30M users a day after launch, putting Musk’s Twitter on notice
The only reason I've heard of Threads is due to complaints of "conservative censorship" already...

https://opoyi.com/technology/is-threads-app-censoring-conser...

Tim Pool's take: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AV9gTTBD5Lk

I already avoid Facebook like the plague, barely touch Instagram or Twitter, so I don't plan on using Threads regardless...

CapricornNoble··on Sony just spilled confidential Playstation information because of a Sharpie
I'm contemplating a Starfield pre-order as well. Last game I pre-ordered was perhaps Hearts of Iron 4. I STILL haven't bought Cyberpunk 2077; until a game hits 75% off on my Steam Wishlist it doesn't exist. If that means I don't play it until 5 years after its release...that's ok.
CapricornNoble··on AMD CPU Use Among Linux Gamers Approaching 70% Marketshare
Linux Gamer here. My primary machine, built around 2015 or so, runs Void Linux and an Intel CPU (an old i7-4770S + 1060 Ti 8GB). My next one, however, will definitely be an AMD Ryzen, probably 5600X. Will still stick with nVidia for GPU, likely a 4060 Ti 16GB.
CapricornNoble··on Twitter Is DDOSing Itself
In some previous HN thread, I dialed in on a recommendation for "Designing Data-Intensive Applications" by Martin Kleppmann, which I honestly still haven't gotten around to reading so....YMMV. Maybe if you search HN for that book title, it might lead you to other useful discussions?
CapricornNoble··on US Congress doubles down on claims of illegal UFO retrieval programs
> The US military is better than the next top three militaries combined.

Partially due to institutional experience and economies of scale (for certain capabilities). We probably still exceed what the next top 3 powers (China, Russia, India, BTW) are spending in PPP terms, so it shouldn't be that surprising.

> The Ukraine war is showing the superiority of decades old Western tech.

For every video of HIMARS blowing up a Russian ammo depot, there's a video of Ka-52 helicopters popping M2 Bradleys from 5+ km away.[1] M777s were lauded for their accuracy....until they broke. [2] Ukrainian brigades have been lavishly equipped with Western armored vehicles and they've bounced off a brick wall of positively-ancient minefields and artillery, very similar to the defense-in-depth that the Soviets used to defeat the Germans at Kursk ...in 1943.[3]

This conflict is so complex in terms of difficult-to-measure soft factors that are influencing the battlefield (training, maintenance, corruption, NATO ISR support, information operations/propaganda, etc.), that drawing conclusions about the merits of individual technical systems or especially the overall tech base of the two main powers (Russia vs "the West") as a whole is....unwise.

[1]https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/ukraines-armor-appears...

[2]https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/25/us/ukraine-artillery-brea...

[3]https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/26/world/europe/ukraine-coun...

CapricornNoble··on Sony just spilled confidential Playstation information because of a Sharpie
Maybe I'm an outlier because I play tons of games that are 10+ years old, but...

Skyrim w/mods is totally viable to me as an open-world RPG for years to come. I skipped Fallout 4, but if I had a refreshed (optimized, less-buggy, Linux-friendly) version of Fallout: New Vegas I wouldn't be concerned about getting another FO entry anytime soon either.

Hugely excited for Starfield though, it scratches an itch I've had for years: blending Mass Effect, Deus Ex, Fallout, and Elder Scrolls.

CapricornNoble··on A Love Letter to Driving Alone
>>crucially you don't need to pay attention during the commute

1. This isn't about "commuting". 2. I'd say "paying attention" is part of the point.

I had a phenomenal experience driving more-or-less this route ( https://goo.gl/maps/iuYPD2oRLwdvZsS36 ) solo very early on a Monday morning while listening to the audio book of Cal Newport's Deep Work. It's a demanding drive if done even a little aggressively (narrow road and a TON of corners). In anything sporty it's an absolute blast, and a great way to enjoy some personal time with no human along to distract you.

CapricornNoble··on ‘There Were Fists Everywhere.’ Violence Against Teachers Is on the Rise
> as a large, physically confident man, I would hate to have a job where I'm required to occasionally wrestle with people

Sure, that's fair. Not everyone wants to be a bouncer. But nightclubs recognize that they need bouncers, because sometimes patrons get unruly. The school system hasn't grasped that having enforcers on site is a useful symbol to ensuring everyone has a quality experience. I'm saying it's better to have the standby enforcers be of the Sheepdog archetype [1] and serve as regular teachers, than to have security guards fill the role. Now I agree with your next point:

> I think when you've got to the point where your wrestling ability is a relevant criterion as a teacher, the system is already completely dysfunctional, and we need to take a broader look at the problems that young people face.

I'd argue that these problems start in the home/family life of the children. Single-mother households produce a disproportionately high fraction of juvenile delinquents, and we've had a marked increase in those per capita.[2][3] Even asking serious questions about why we have a bunch of single-mother households is outside the Overton window of many mainstream organizations. Usually the only answer put forward is "more government spending".

[1] https://www.mwkworks.com/onsheepwolvesandsheepdogs.html

[2] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258200285_Race_Gend...

[3] https://www.statista.com/statistics/252847/number-of-childre...

CapricornNoble··on ‘There Were Fists Everywhere.’ Violence Against Teachers Is on the Rise
> If you want them to value competence, then your idea is absolute garbage.

If an instructor cannot maintain sufficient control of their charges that facilitate an effective learning environment, I would argue they are not competent. They are failing to accomplish their assigned task.

> Obviously, some really hide-bound institutions like the military haven't completely internalized that, but then, that could be why militaries underperform. Russia, for example, has a very macho military, and (surprise!) it sucks.

The Russian military is underperforming for a ton of reasons beyond machismo. Corruption being the biggest, IMO. And your hypothesis fails when tested against almost any other machismo-laden western military force, in particular the almost-entirely-male and heavily testosterone-fueled US special operations community.

But the sibling comment highlights the nuance that perhaps my post was lacking: respecting the authority of the females in the organization is a worthy objective but it needs SOMEBODY to enforce it when challenged. It's apparent from TFA that isn't happening.

CapricornNoble··on ‘There Were Fists Everywhere.’ Violence Against Teachers Is on the Rise
>a guy who 'might uppercut me' sounds like a great male role model

On average, men are more likely to aspire to be Thor or Captain Marvel than they are to be Rick Moranis's character in Ghostbusters. They are more likely to take guidance from a larger, stronger, and more assertive man than otherwise. The military has already figured this out, just look at the stereotypical Drill Instructor for an extreme example of the concept. Do you dispute this, or are you simply speaking of what works/doesn't work for you as an individual? A single anecdote doesn't really tell us much about what society-wide initiatives we should pursue.

Also, Andrew Tate is already out of jail and currently under house arrest.

CapricornNoble··on ‘There Were Fists Everywhere.’ Violence Against Teachers Is on the Rise
> Good luck trying to administer corporal punishment to a young man who is bigger, fitter and stronger than you

Why are teenage boys bigger, fitter and stronger than the teachers? Maybe because ~75% of teachers are women? There's value in the ability of physically-capable adult males to quietly intimidate adolescents. There's value in well-rounded men who can provide classroom instruction but maybe also coach the boxing/powerlifting/wrestling teams. The next time Mr. Smith puts some bass in his voice and tells you to sit down and stop disrupting class, there should be a voice in the back of your head that says "I should do that, because he just might uppercut me into the stratosphere". I suspect that students aren't learning the principle of "Fuck Around and Find Out" from ANY authority figure in their daily lives. Our society as a whole seems to have forgotten the importance of male role models IMO...

CapricornNoble··on How to quit cars
> There’s tons of work todo > hustle culture and bloated adminispheres seems so normal

A lot of useful work that could be done is building better stuff, physically improving the local infrastructure and environment. That requires tradesmen doing hands-on labor. Giant portions of our labor pool wouldn't be caught dead doing that kind of work. That's why we have a flood of bullshit jobs where people shuffle paper in air-conditioned offices, float around to conferences, stay at business hotels, etc...

CapricornNoble··on How Tokyo became an anti-car paradise
Yeah I'm including those too. My total outlay for an afternoon at the LTO/insurance office almost never breaks 5 man yen, even with a ~15 year old 300-plate sport sedan.
CapricornNoble··on How Tokyo became an anti-car paradise
I generally hold up Japanese cities as examples of ideal multi-mode transportation solutions. It's weird to me to call Tokyo ANTI-car though. The city has one of the most robust car cultures on the planet. And I wouldn't say the cars are "invariably tiny, quiet". I feel I see luxury sports cars and higher-spec German performance offerings (BMW M models, AMG Mercedes, etc.) in far greater rates than I see kei cars in Okinawa, for example. Most residential streets having little or no traffic is accurate, though.

>>>Life expectancy overall is 84 years old, one of the highest levels of any city on the planet. A good part of this has to do with the lack of cars. Air pollution is considerably lower than in any other city of equivalent size anywhere in the world.

This is a huge claim for which the otherwise-reasonably-sourced article doesn't cite a reference.

>>>Even a well-maintained car can cost 100,000 yen to inspect (or around $850).

Emphasis on can. I take my lightly-modified 2008 Evo through the inspection line myself and it typically costs me less than 50,000 yen. Double that is if you have a mechanic shop do it, AND there's stuff that needs to be fixed like replacing your brake pads.

>>>To be allowed to purchase a car, you have to be able to prove that you have somewhere to park it. This approval is issued by the local police, and is known as a shakoshomeisho, or “garage certificate.” Without one, you cannot buy a car.

Note: this isn't a nation-wide requirement, it's basically by city. Major urban areas have it. Often low-density rural areas do not.

The lack of street parking is definitely accurate and a huge boon to the livability of Japanese city environments, agreed on that one.

>>>wealthy friends of his owned a top-end BMW, which they replaced every few years, because they were car nuts. But because they did not have anywhere to park it near their home

They are wealthy enough to replace their M cars frequently but somehow can't get a condo with parking, or a house with a garage? That's.....odd to me. I think this anecdote is quite an outlier.

I like the overall observations about how to successfully build rail-centric development though, especially the point about rail companies building up the commercial/residential real estate immediately around their rail stations to drive profitability AND convenience for the population. I'm in favor of things that get "average commuters" off the streets, it makes driving a more enjoyable experience for the car aficionados too! And I'm okay paying a mild premium for car ownership to support all of that.

CapricornNoble··on Americans ‘surprised’ by what they saw inside the T-90A tank
Part of it is consuming extremes from both sides and figuring out the Venn diagram of the truth based on what both parties are acknowledging. You can also look at a variety of commenters who are reasonably middle-ground in their analysis. On YT, for me, I consume Perun (pro-Ukraine but largely factual analysis), WillyOAM, Military History Visualized, and History Legends (comes across kinda pro-Russia). I also like the ( https://old.reddit.com/r/UkraineRussiaReport/ ) subreddit, which has Russian-leaning mods, oddly making it perhaps the least-biased subreddit on the war (everywhere else is a DEEP pro-Ukraine echo chamber, including r/combatfootage). For general reasonably-non-biased news, avoid r/worldnews and visit...... r/anime_titties (note the underscore). Seriously, that's a news aggregator subreddit.
CapricornNoble··on Hit Man: A technical manual for independent contractors
>>A white man in a turban or a giant crow costume will attract no attention anywhere.

Funny you say that. There's an interview on YT with retired Delta Force Sergeant Major nicknamed "Shrek". He mentioned how he used to do solo reconnaissance missions in Afghanistan, dressed as a local. When asked how he pulled this off, being a large white man with a weak command of the local languages, he replied: "Pretend to be a retard, and just grunt/mumble responses when stopped at checkpoints. You'd be surprised how NOBODY wants to deeply interrogate and anger a retard carrying an AK-47."

CapricornNoble··on Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping
>> When they see their hard work resulting in porn, gore, gross-out or hate material, it is very discouraging. It’s not material they want to collaborate on.

This seems like a fundamental failure to understand humans. One of my favorite Renaissance artists arguably produced gore/gross-out material for his time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Triumph_of_Death

CapricornNoble··on Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping
Another example of how these two countries get pissy about naming things:

We were using Agile Client as our Common Operational Picture tool during a joint exercise with the ROK Marine Corps. The default map layer in Agile has labels on bodies of water in white text built into the imagery. The body of water between Korea and Japan was labeled "Sea of Japan". The Koreans were ADAMANT that we either remove the text or change it to "East Sea". I think we dropped a blue rectangle layer over the text and then another text layer with "East Sea" on top of that. But they repeatedly pestered us about this seemingly-small detail. We're about to get our asses chewed by flag officers for not executing the Commander's Update Brief in timely manner, while also struggling to manage the info flow about the battlespace, but the #1 issue to you is the damn text label on the map mentioning Japan?!?!

CapricornNoble··on Borderless Vigilantism: The Nativist US Militias Entering Mexico
Pattern of life analysis + SIGINT.
CapricornNoble··on Borderless Vigilantism: The Nativist US Militias Entering Mexico
Shouldn't Mexico's security forces prioritize using their limited man-hours to defeat the narco-terrorists instead?
CapricornNoble··on Keys to winning high intensity conflicts
Yes it's called "gain of function research".
← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →