623 karma · joined March 28, 2019
Alternative interpretation: It wasn't a problem that you needed solving, but others may have had a different experience.
"after listening to one of their anchors going after the 538 guy as if he and his industry were fully responsible for Trump's election, and demanding some sort of apology".
I'm sure Nate Silver wasn't actually blamed for election results and I'm sure no one actually demanded an apology. Can you smooth the hyporbole a bit and explain what they actually said that made you feel that way?
I guess my main point -- phrased a bit more aggressively than needed -- was that if you have a huge community-sourced pile of data from multiple people in multiple parts of the country, relating to complex and chaotic situations that are unfolding as we speak, and all you need to dismiss it out of hand is finding a couple of things that you find suspect... well then you're always going to dismiss it.
Identifying, discussing and removing data points that don't belong is absolutely useful and fair. Taking a glance at a mountain of data, pointing out a couple pieces that you don't like and implying that the entire pile is rubbish is neither useful nor fair to me.
And I'm sorry for calling you dishonest, or at least heavily implying it. That was stupid and rash of me.
Of course. I don't believe you honestly think that I am advocating for inaccurate sources of data.
However, finding and discussing sources of different quality among hundreds is one thing.
Saying that you only looked at two of them, expressing skepticism towards those two, and then stating that the whole thing is "filled" with "random junk to inflate the numbers" is another. That doesn't seem like the interpretation of someone who's honest about their intentions.
If I read two sentences from your thesis, find issue with them, and then claim that you have clearly filled it with random junk to inflate the word count... yould you characterize my position as believing that some parts of your thesis are "slightly inaccurate and this to some degree impugns its legitimacy"?
What I read is: If you want to create a list for this cause, at least make it perfect and unassailable in every possible way. Because I only need to point skeptically at one thing to dismiss the whole lot.
> This post is day 04 of my #100DaysToOffload challenge. If you want to get involved, you can get more info from https://100daystooffload.com.
I find that the intent behind publishing any piece of content is an incredibly accurate predictor for its usefulness in my experience. When you can ascertain that of course. But essentially, my rule of thumb is that if the chain of events looks like this:
1. I really want to write a blog post
2. What should it be about?
then I won't find much useful in it, regardless of the topic. But if it's the other way around:
1. I really want to share this idea of mine
2. What medium should I use to deliver it?
then I often find it useful to me, again regardless of the topic.
Funnily enough, the title of the author's next blog post in this series captures this idea well: "Writing With SEO In Mind"
That's very hard to answer because the cops have censored or lied about most of the report, as well as making claims about knocking and introducing themselves -- holding a no-knock warrant -- which is apparently disputed by witnesses.
But then again I don't think it's very helpful to try to identify the one and only Bad Guy™.
I believe Dr. Fauci is advising the administration because he is the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, and been an advisor on epidemics to every president since Reagan.
Can you clue in the rest of us here? These are very chaotic times and I'd really like to know what the future holds.
I support the protests. What can I change in my behavior to stop creating this dangerous environment?
But not in any structured way, but rather in random human behavior that we might never be able to correct, right?
Why are you putting your own characterization in quotation marks as if you're quoting someone else? Or did I miss something and this is a quote from the the health professionals in question?
Care to tell us about these easy solutions?
Isn't this way below the HN discourse bar?
Who is "they"?
True, but it tends to be quite easy to separate the real from the disingenuous like yours. So that's there I draw the line at least.
So reversing and apologizing is still taking the wrong steps? Is this one of those situations where no positive descriptor must ever be uttered about someone?
> That's nothing to be proud of or rewarded for.
Good thing I never said that. I don't think we're speaking the same language here.
Don't think it's quite as dramatic as you imply here, and I don't think anyone is deliberately fabricating slide decks in order to trick you.