HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Chinjut

3,384 karma · joined June 23, 2014

submissionscomments
Chinjut··on Leo's first encyclical attacks technological messianism
What's stupid about the disclaimer?
Chinjut··on WH proposes rules giving political appointees final approval on research grants
Very sad to see Hacker News discussing science funding. This has nothing to do with the hacker ethos of maximizing corporate profit.
Chinjut··on Please Use AI
Hypocrite didn't even use AI to write this lovely poem.
Chinjut··on Can we have the day off?
That's fortunate for you that what you enjoy doing and get meaning from is capable of providing you a living via market income. That's not true of many others. I try to make time for what I enjoy doing and get meaning from. But for me as for many, it does not provide income.
Chinjut··on Can we have the day off?
Many of us do not particularly enjoy the work our employer has us do, nor believe in what the company we work for is trying to achieve. It's not like we get to choose its aims, and it's not like we have alternatives where we get to do so either. Our lives are spent working on someone else's goals.
Chinjut··on Can we have the day off?
There's always a comment saying "Don't ask for better, because someone else had worse". Fuck that. I want better and I want everyone else to have it too.
Chinjut··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
Silicon Valley bigwigs supported this administration vocally. I am starting to doubt that their interests and morality align with mine.
Chinjut··on Everything in C is undefined behavior
But surely the more natural approach than making this undefined behavior would be making the computation of a[i] take place in 64-bit pointer space rather than 32-bit int space? Why does the compiler need the freedom to emit nasal demons?
Chinjut··on Everything in C is undefined behavior
How is undefined behavior necessary for this transformation?
Chinjut··on X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day unless they pay
Apparently, even paying users are being prevented from posting.
Chinjut··on X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day unless they pay
The implementation is buggy. Very many users report being banned while being nowhere near the usage limit: https://devcommunity.x.com/t/your-request-looks-like-it-migh...
Chinjut··on Math Jokes in Alice in Wonderland
These links' mentions of quaternions are about a different part of the book (the tea party). Furthermore, even regarding that different part, your first link explicitly debunks the second link and disavows the quaternion connection the latter alleges. Your first link's whole point is to conclude "it is indeed very unlikely that Dodgson had the quaternions in mind when writing the tea-party chapter."
Chinjut··on Math Jokes in Alice in Wonderland
I'm a mathematician, and my reaction here is somewhat different.
Chinjut··on Math Jokes in Alice in Wonderland
Why would you need to presuppose some inexplicably shifting number base to get the result of "four times [n]" always equaling n + 7? What does that get you over just more simply observing "For Alice, four times [n] has come to be n + 7"? Shifting number bases are a pointless supposition here. They don't explain anything better than what is already happening without them.
Chinjut··on Math Jokes in Alice in Wonderland
Re: "The multiplication that does not work", nothing in the quoted text seems to indicate that each multiplication should be interpreted in a different base, or anything like this. Certainly not that "four times [n]" should always have its result read in base 3n + 3 specifically.

It seems more likely to just be an absurd joke where Alice finds herself with an altered version of multiplication where 4n is interpreted as n + 7, causing multiplication to grow more slowly than normal, causing her to exclaim "I shall never get to twenty at that rate!" (a common exaggerated but non-literal use of "never", similar to "This is taking forever!" meaning "This is taking a long time!", not "This will literally never end").

The idea that we're instead supposed to think Alice thinks "four times 13 (decimal)" is to have its output read in base 42 (decimal), thus as "1A", considered distinct from "20", the latter being what would be "twenty", and thus she will literally never get to "twenty"... This just doesn't seem well-supported by anything in the text.

Chinjut··on Fun with polynomials and linear algebra; or, slight abstract nonsense
I don't want everything to be images and pictures. Often, I enjoy words for communicating math.
Chinjut··on Unsigned sizes: A five year mistake
I see. That is fair, thank you for pointing this out to me.
Chinjut··on OpenAI's o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER patients vs. 50-55% by triage doctors
I still don't quite understand, after skimming the paper. How does it achieve high scores without access to the images (beating even humans with access to the images)?
Chinjut··on Unsigned sizes: A five year mistake
I'd trust you a lot more if you actually pointed out something wrong with my statement.
Chinjut··on Unsigned sizes: A five year mistake
Signed ints are no more and no less truncated 2-adics than unsigned ints. Signed ints and unsigned ints are isomorphic as rings; they are both the ring of integers modulo some 2^n. It is only on other operations (ordering comparisons, or the / and % of C) where they differ, and in neither case do these operations have anything to do with 2-adics.
Chinjut··on Unsigned sizes: A five year mistake
Signed ints are also integers modulo 2^n, as concerns +, -, and *. Both unsigned and signed ints have the exact same modular arithmetic structure, for +, -, and *. It is only for other operations (ordering comparisons, or / and %) where they differ, and on these operations, neither signed nor unsigned ints have any convenient algebraic structure commonly encountered elsewhere.
Chinjut··on Unsigned sizes: A five year mistake
The fixed-size signed types of C etc are no more the actual integers, and no less modular arithmetic, than the fixed-size unsigned types. They both implement the exact same modular arithmetic for +, -, and *. It's only for other operations (ordering comparisons, or / and % which in turn are defined in C in terms of ordering structure, as in rounding towards zero) where they differ. And in either case, that ordering structure is not one commonly encountered anywhere outside of the context of fixed size computer arithmetic.

Ask an ordinary person what 3 * (1/3) or 3 * (-1/3) should come to, and they aren't going to say any of the results that you get in C for either signed or unsigned int types.

Chinjut··on Russia Poisons Wikipedia
What about it?
Chinjut··on “Why not just use Lean?”
You mean intuitionistic logic, not "intuitive logic".
Chinjut··on Meta tells staff it will cut 10% of jobs
Again? Haven't there been waves of mass Meta layoffs already?
Chinjut··on Category Theory Illustrated – Orders
Well, group theory is a special case of category theory. A group is a one object category where all morphisms are invertible. You do group theory long enough and it leads you to start thinking about groupoids and monoids and categories more generally as well.
Chinjut··on Ask HN: Who is your favourite Entrepreneur/Visionary?
Where can I find these allegations of him committing sexual assault?
Chinjut··on The beginning of programming as we'll know it?
Yes, "An LLM is just a new higher level programming language", sure. A new programming language with no tractable guarantees about the behavior of any particular program, including in practice no guarantees that the same source code (in this new programming language) will reliably produce the same behavior. This is very different from traditional programming languages and how we can reason about them.

(Yes, one can write C programs with undefined behavior, but C does also have many well-defined properties which allow people to reason about well-defined C programs logically reliably.)

Chinjut··on The beginning of programming as we'll know it?
A programming language with no tractable guarantees about the behavior of any particular program, including in practice no guarantees that the same source code (in this new programming language) will reliably produce the same behavior. This is very different from traditional programming languages and how we can reason about them.
Chinjut··on I am definitely missing the pre-AI writing era
The C-suite are barely human, so robot-speak appeals to them.
← PreviousPage 3 of 32Next →