HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Chinjut

3,384 karma · joined June 23, 2014

submissionscomments
Chinjut··on The Bitter Lesson Is Misunderstood
But diamonds don't denote multiplication. That never happened. That was just you misreading.
Chinjut··on Where's the shovelware? Why AI coding claims don't add up
For what it's worth, this response is explicitly anticipated in the article.
Chinjut··on The Bitter Lesson Is Misunderstood
What diamond symbol?
Chinjut··on Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts
A scary (if not particularly original) thought: If people become utterly reliant on LLMs and no longer embrace any new language etc for which there is insufficient LLM training, new languages etc will no longer continue to be created.
Chinjut··on The Little Book of Linear Algebra
Why do you say it's practically impossible to motivate matrix multiplication? The motivation is that this represents composition of linear functions, exactly as you follow up by mentioning.

It's a disservice to anyone to tell them "Well, that's the way it is" instead of telling them from the start "Look, these represent linear functions. And look, this is how they compose".

Chinjut··on Welcome to the Technocracy: Dreams of forgotten movement from the 1930s live on
What makes WhatsApp revolutionary compared to SMS or ICQ (or AIM or gchat or Facebook Messenger or...)?
Chinjut··on Petition to stop Google from restricting sideloading and FOSS apps
I agree, but under the current administration, the FTC isn't going to do anything to impede a megacorporation's profits. We're fucked, at least for the time being.
Chinjut··on Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sway midterms
The election where the billionaire prominently campaigned for by the richest megabillionaire in the world won proves that money plays little role in politics.
Chinjut··on How many paths of length K are there between A and B? (2021)
Note that the article describes this Berlekamp-Massey approach as involving a step of complexity on the order of EV, which is V^3 in the worst-case. So this is only beneficial for sparse matrices. It does seem like Berlekamp-Massey is used to efficiently but non-guaranteedly compute determinants for sparse matrices, as described at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Block_Wiedemann_algorithm
Chinjut··on How many paths of length K are there between A and B? (2021)
Any recurrence that holds on the matrix also holds on each individual element (and vice versa, in that a recurrence holds on the matrix just in case it holds on every individual element).
Chinjut··on How many paths of length K are there between A and B? (2021)
Odd to use Berlelamp-Massey to recover a linear recurrence, when Cayley-Hamilton already directly gives you a linear recurrence whose characteristic polynomial is that of the matrix.
Chinjut··on Prime Number Grid
My one quibble with the comment I linked is about asymptotics. By the Prime Number Theorem, asymptotically, the density of black squares should approach zero and the density of red squares should approach 100% (including among the left diagonal which is entirely black in the displayed window, and including losing the regular appearance of rows that are entirely black except for their last cell. These black line patterns in the displayed window are both small number phenomena caused by (1 - 1/ln(R))^100 being nearly zero for small R, which stops and then goes the other way for large R.)
Chinjut··on Prime Number Grid
Your description here does not quite match your linked code, in that it is not that the N-th pack contains integers spaced out by N. Rather, packs on the N-th row contain integers spaced out by N. For example, the third pack does not contain "every third integer", but rather draws alternating integers just like the second pack, because it is on the second row. The second pack contains (first cell of the second row) contains {101, 103, 105, ..., 299} and the third pack (second cell of the second row) contains {102, 104, 106, ..., 300}.

With this in mind, the seeming patterns of the figure you link to are explained by https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17106193

Chinjut··on AI's changed (is changing) college education
If I wanted to read an LLM-generated comment, I'd go to ChatGPT myself.
Chinjut··on Derivatives, Gradients, Jacobians and Hessians
You're thinking of situations where you are able to see a whole object at once. If you were dealing with an object too large to see all of, you'd have to start making decisions about how to explore it.
Chinjut··on Why LLMs can't really build software
I don't want a computer that's as unreliable as a child. This is not what originally interested me about computers.
Chinjut··on GPT-5: "How many times does the letter b appear in blueberry?"
One can use https://platform.openai.com/tokenizer to directly confirm that the tokenization of "b l u e b e r r y" is not significantly different from simply breaking this down into its letters. The excuse often given "It cannot count letters in words because it cannot see the individual letters" would not apply here.
Chinjut··on GPT-5: "How many times does the letter b appear in blueberry?"
Presumably you are referencing tokenization, which explains the initial miscount in the link, but not the later part where it miscounts the number of "b"s in "b l u e b e r r y".
Chinjut··on Programming with AI: You're Probably Doing It Wrong
It claims at the bottom to be hand-written. But one can manually write slop too.
Chinjut··on Nine households control 15% of wealth in Silicon Valley as inequality widens
Middle class people are forced to work at jobs doing what some boss tells them to do instead of what they like with the majority of their waking hours. In that regard, they live lives far from as pleasurable as those of kings.
Chinjut··on Features of D That I Love
There is no documented instance of your "full quote" prior to the 21st century. It's certainly not the origin of the phrase "Jack of all trades, master of none".
Chinjut··on When will tech workers start creating Unions?
For the same reason, the entertainment industry will never unionize.
Chinjut··on AI-first – We're just 6 months away from AGI
Just use the right prompt. Just use the right model. Just roll the dice correctly.
Chinjut··on Sci-Net
Are these papers returned back into sci-hub? I don't quite follow why it seems like there's now two different repositories of papers.
Chinjut··on Remote workers more likely to start their own business
What does it mean to "abuse" compensation?
Chinjut··on On loyalty to Your Employer
They won't.
Chinjut··on Ask HN: Share your AI prompt that stumps every model
Does this have a nice answer? It seems quite ad hoc.
Chinjut··on Cursor IDE support hallucinates lockout policy, causes user cancellations
I understand not wanting to use LLMs that with no correctness guarantees that randomly hallucinate, but what's wrong with ordinary LSPs and autocompletion? Those seem like perfectly useful tools.
Chinjut··on U.S. and El Salvador Say They Won't Return Man Who Was Mistakenly Deported
Flagged. Paints the administration (and thus Elon Musk and other Silicon Valley bigwigs by association) in a bad light.
Chinjut··on Stop using e for compound interest
A lot of the commentary suggests that this motivation for e in terms of continuously compounded interest is introduced for misguidedly contrived pedagogical reasons. But this is historically the way e was first discovered. e was first discovered precisely through Jacob Bernoulli wanting to understand continuously compounded interest.

Of course, the arithmetic laws of exponential growth of money are exactly the same as the arithmetic laws of exponential growth of anything else. And there is no reason that, just because a topic is historically discovered in some fashion, that must be the way it is taught, or even is a good way to teach it.

But it's not some made up conceit by teachers to connect e and continuously compounded interest. That is historically how e came to be investigated.

← PreviousPage 5 of 32Next →