HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Chinjut

3,384 karma · joined June 23, 2014

submissionscomments
Chinjut··on Ghoti
As with so many things attributed to Mark Twain, this was not written by Mark Twain. According to https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mark_Twain:

Actual source: A letter to The Economist (16 January 1971), written by one M.J. Shields (or M.J. Yilz, by the end of the letter). The letter is quoted in full in one of Willard Espy's Words at Play books. This was a modified version of a piece "Meihem in ce Klasrum", published in the September 1946 issue of Astounding Science Fiction magazine.

Chinjut··on Meta staffers reportedly spar with Mark Zuckerberg after mass layoffs
Why not? Have you seen how much Mark Zuckerberg makes?
Chinjut··on My employer is reneging on its remote-work promise
Case in point: Hollywood actors are all in a union.
Chinjut··on Tech CEOs Should Be Held Accountable, or Even Fired, Amid Layoffs
What you are responding to is a proposal to change the system.
Chinjut··on How likely is losing a Google account?
Out of curiosity, in what way was the account screwed up after you recovered it?
Chinjut··on Steve Wozniak's Letters
ChatGPT is not some magic oracle that uncovers correct answers to all questions. I see little reason to imagine ChatGPT being useful here at all.
Chinjut··on Modulo of negative numbers (2011)
When do you ever want that symmetry?
Chinjut··on An intutive counterexample to the axiom of choice
As others have noted, this has little to do with the Axiom of Choice per se. The Axiom of Choice is not needed to prove that one can make a choice from a single inhabited set, where this boils down to the tautology "If a set has at least one element, then it has at least one element". The Axiom of Choice is only needed for making infinitely many choices at once.

(There IS a sense in which what is going on here is the distinction between what category theorists call "internal" and "external" Choice, but I'll not get into that for now since I think the following is more important to point out first.)

The result/paradox here has more to do with Tarski's indefinability theorem, under which no suitable formal language is able to define the concept of definability in that same language.

See also https://mathoverflow.net/a/44129/3902 for more discussion on what goes wrong in attempting to formally prove that "undefinable" numbers exist by this common but naive argument from uncountability.

The gist of the above MathOverflow link and of Tarski's indefinability theorem is that we must keep in mind that Cantor's famed diagonal argument for uncountability is a constructive argument. Given any function from N to 2^N, it defines an explicit element of 2^N not in the range of that function. So there would be something paradoxical in concluding that this explicitly defined value is not definable.

Chinjut··on Rational Trigonometry
This works perfectly fine with complex numbers. Consider Gaussian integers or Gaussian rationals (complex numbers of the form a + b i, where a and b are integers or rationals). Like complex numbers in general, these amount to the combination of scaling by some magnitude and rotating by some angle. If we only care about the angle, we can consider two Gaussian rationals to be equivalent if their ratio is a positive real number.

Any angle with a rational tangent or cotangent has some representation as a Gaussian rational (usually requiring a non-unit magnitude, though), and these angles are closed under addition and subtraction (corresponding to multiplying and dividing these Gaussian rationals). And given a Gaussian integer or rational, we can readily take its squared magnitude (a^2 + b^2) to get an integer or rational, and we can in the same way take the squared cosine or squared sine of its angle (a^2/(a^2 + b^2) or b^2/(a^2 + b^2)) to get a rational.

Chinjut··on If you like startups you should love anti-trust
You mock leftists as having futile aspirations, thanks to your tax dodging abilities. But we do have progressive taxation as a rather strongly entrenched policy in the United States and most of the rest of the world, so in that sense, you are the one with a futile task ahead of you, in your aspiration to eliminate it. Good luck!
Chinjut··on If you like startups you should love anti-trust
Out of all the possible ways you can persuade me, refraining from even providing an argument is easily the least effective.
Chinjut··on If you like startups you should love anti-trust
Your advocacy for a wealth tax on unrealized capital gains is compelling. Let us adopt that.
Chinjut··on If you like startups you should love anti-trust
Why are you playing games to avoid that number? There's no big difference in being slightly above vs slightly below that number. Indeed, it's slightly better to be slightly above.
Chinjut··on If you like startups you should love anti-trust
From your original post, you seem to feel progressive taxes requires some sort of absurdly different treatment for people who make $999,999/yr vs $1,000,000/yr, or at whatever threshold, but that is not at all how they function. Even with discrete jumps in marginal tax rates (as in the current system of progressive income tax in the U.S.), post-tax income is a continuous monotonic function of pre-tax income. Making a little more pre-tax income always results in making a little more post-tax income.
Chinjut··on Things they didn’t teach you about software engineering
Because I need money to exchange for goods and services in order to live, particularly in order to maintain housing and healthcare.

I would love to be paid to pursue my passions full-time, but that opportunity has not yet arisen. So I split my time accordingly between doing what earns me a living and doing what I actually enjoy in life.

Chinjut··on Seattle Public Schools sues TikTok, YouTube, Instagram over youth mental health
What is the manner in which social media is causing you and your wife of nearly 30 years to have to battle divorce?
Chinjut··on A Curious Integral
Induction is one way to prove something for all n but hardly the only way.
Chinjut··on Musicians wage war against evil robots (2012)
What's the difference between whether my money is individually given to the artists I personally listened to and similarly for all other subscribers, or whether all subscribers' money is pooled and then re-apportioned out based on the cumulative listening tallies of all subscribers? Aren't these the same results in the end?
Chinjut··on Dinner for one: A little-known British comedy famous in Germany
Your parents loved it when they were 3 in the 60s? The article suggests it only became a regular part of German New Year's Eve celebrations starting in 1972.
Chinjut··on Interview with George Dantzig (2001)
What notion of optimization had you expected?
Chinjut··on Reverse engineering yet another eBook format
What expression? What was the original context?
Chinjut··on Ask HN: Is the industry saturated with data scientists already?
Perhaps what is holding you back is phrasing it as "a Master's degree in AI/DS"!
Chinjut··on 24-core CPU and I can’t move my mouse (2017)
Don't MacOS and Unixes have the equivalent of registry hell with a million configuration files hidden away in /etc/ or /usr/ or wherever, and then having to check where environment variables are set and so on? Ideally, almost all of a program's configuration settings would be stored in the same folder as the program, readily discoverable, and you could just pick these things up and move them easily, but in practice, it seems to be a pain everywhere.
Chinjut··on A non-constructive proof of the Four Colour Theorem
Put another way, it actually is important here that the set of colors we are talking about is finite. It's NOT the case that just having every finite subgraph be C-colorable entails that the entire graph is C-colorable, when C is infinite. For example, if G is the complete graph on an uncountable set of nodes and C is a countably infinite set, then every finite subgraph of G is C-colorable, but G itself is not.

So somewhere in the argument, the finiteness of C must play a role. This is in ensuring compactness.

Chinjut··on A non-constructive proof of the Four Colour Theorem
Yes, but invoking Zorn's lemma on that poset does nothing useful. This just proves the trivial fact that the big graph exists. How do you prove that a coloring of the big graph exists?

And if we take the poset to be partial colorings ordered by inclusion, it's not the case that a maximal partial coloring must color the entire graph. Some partial colorings have made choices which prevent them from being extended any further.

[To be clear, whenever I say "coloring", I mean from a fixed set of colors. E.g., a 4-coloring.]

Chinjut··on A non-constructive proof of the Four Colour Theorem
What poset should we set up on which to invoke Zorn's lemma directly? Anything I can think of does seem to me more easily understood via compactness/the ultrafilter lemma, but that may just be a fact about my own psychology.
Chinjut··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
"50% chance within the same gender"? What about all the other chromosomes? Wouldn't they have to match too?
Chinjut··on Twitter suspends pg's account [fixed]
What do you all think would happen if you mentioned Verizon while on an AT&T phone?
Chinjut··on Paul Graham is leaving Twitter for now
Paul Graham has now been banned from Twitter: https://twitter.com/paulg
Chinjut··on Promotion of alternative social platforms policy
There's no need to defend Elon here. Clearly what will happen is highly capricious enforcement based on who he personally likes and dislikes.
← PreviousPage 9 of 32Next →