How many figures of damage did Aaron Swartz cause?
3,096 karma · joined September 2, 2012
How many figures of damage did Aaron Swartz cause?
but it's you throwing around the term. e.g. "economically speaking, that's an art market" - in what sense? How do you define an "art market"? It all seems very tautological.
> aesthetics-driven pursuit
aesthetics can usually biased by utility, to the extent of being a proxy for it. You can find the aerodynamics of a aeroplane or hummingbird wing beautiful, but there is still functionality driving it.
aesthetics is not the opposite of instrumental value; perhaps affective value, or sentimentality is?
> would I pay extra for an artisanal, organic, free-range, hand-coded app
what is artisanal code? I think talking about ux design conflates things, consider only backend code.
Can you define art/artist? If software is art, then what profession isn't?
Software still has value, specifically utility, it's just cheaper to produce, its market value is lower.
How is that comparable to the arts?
> convince or to inform. It's literally the pretext for all communication
ok, so what does a dirty novel, or some other pulp fiction convince or inform you of?
scapegoating isn't really legally viable. corps who outsource their development haven't outsourced their liability.
Implies a process requiring no expert knowledge or understanding. That doesn't seem to match common experience of professional agentic development.
You are describing vibe coding, which is without human design, review or direction.
Models are getting better at this, but it's not yet clear how practical they will be. They often fail on uncommon tasks, or get increasingly more expensive as the code-base grows.
I think things will change, as the technology develops; problem is corps are acting like we are already there, encouraged by ai-providers.
I'm optimistic about ai, pessimistic about the fallout of ai hype.
because to me this:
"Something simple like adding reactions, adding read receipts ... The LLM easily excels at the task and yet I didn’t have to do it."
Implies to me code gen.
That aside, are you a 'DidntUseIt' sockpuppet, given there are lots of green accounts responding on their behalf..
You joined 2 days ago..
The agents are building all these small features, up to a full SaaS; and all the code is excellent?
How much time do you spend in code review?
Isn't it fair use, like training data?
You have the option to pass on such a tax burden, as do any other home/land-owner(s), which is relevant to the conversation.
What point are you making relevant to that?
You call it non-reproduceable, but money is literally created.
You're the one who started this tangent..
Palestine Action was a legal organisation.
Nearly a year later, the government of Keir Starmer declared it a
terrorist group – the first time in British history that a non-violent
direct action organisation has been proscribed.
-- https://substack.com/home/post/p-184498793AFAIK, they rammed their van through a front shutter, without knowing who might be on the other side; and as police tried to arrest them, one of them hit a female police officer in the back/spine with a sledgehammer.
Doesn't sound non-violent to me..
I can't see any other comment on this post mentioning AI, did you just make this up?
I though (when I tried to understand it) that some part of the HE inflates some component of the result?
As an aside: The computation might also not be the same e.g. ever-changing hidden pre-prompts, security/safety checks blocking or degrading responses, unavoidable verbosity to simple questions, watermarking, collection of prompt data to build user profiles for the purpose of advertising - and we haven't even seen in-response adverts, or sponsor-biased responses yet, but no doubt it's coming.
> "we literally cannot read your period data."
If the purpose is aggregated data for statistic, then surely the only per-user data they need centrally can already be aggregated (to some degree) on the device, e.g. send back only statistical-distribution variables of the personal data, for distributions over the 3-4 months? And at some point, does the service need to keep collecting data, once the model is good enough (at predicting ovulation etc)?
Another concern would be: If they are building a model, using user data, why should they own the model and thus monetise it (i.e. sell it back to its users) when users get no compensation for supplying that data in the first place.
A flow-tracking app should just stick to that, and purchase the model (for a fee) from a third party. The third party should concern itself with how to get the data without being able to leverage its position as a flow-app maintainer to trick or mislead the majority of its users into giving them free data.
> we cannot monitor how these distilled models are used or prevent misuse
which is fine since they are none of your (their) business..
I think the only possible concern is using their models name - making it clear it's a new model merely trained in another one should fix that.