3,096 karma · joined September 2, 2012
Successfully?
They ported the LGPL version. There's no obligation to port any other, unless "MPL 1.1 or LGPL" is itself some kind of singular licence.
If the old owner gives their key to the new owner, then they should be on the hook for it. I was thinking of this yesterday, as I think this is also how domains should work.
Any notes system gets too large, and hence too complex as Is have to check a large dataset frequently. An AI could perhaps do that though..
First few minutes free, lower tariffs for 5-10 mins (or maybe fixed charge at those limits?), then like 1 euro per minute after that.
further, if intent would be a possible defence, I already mentioned that archiving everything looks better than only having links when there are paywalls, active or otherwise.
from a moral position, I don't think HN moves the needle wrt enabling bypassing - most if not all HN users are likely fully capable of using archiving sites themselves, if not automating the process themselves.
The premise was that this is so obvious that my naivety is funny. But no, you don't want to debate that point - Why would you care to consider otherwise, it's not you losing face if correct.
Here's an uninvited counterpoint anyway:
https://blog.archive.org/2024/03/01/fair-use-in-action-at-th...
You'll also notice that the link in this post (https://archive.is/TajtJ) shows a 'log in' button, implying that log-in credentials where not used (or abused) to get/share this snapshot.
You don't think phrasing like "There's a thing called 'copyright'", as if I'm not aware of what copyright is, isn't condescending?
Now, either of you relate that concept to a suggestion that HN link to archive.org
It's also IMHO a misplaced or false criticism, per my other comments in this thread.