HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Chris_Jay

83 karma · joined March 3, 2017

submissionscomments
Chris_Jay··on Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation
Nocoiners seem to pingpong between an attitude of sour grapes and one of schadenfreude, depending on valuations. Perhaps it's a natural reaction to being too risk-averse to invest in something that's been profitable for people one considers intellectual inferiors.

It seems far more reasonable to assess technology this nascent by the quality of teams working on it than anything else. Unfortunately, that's difficult to do in a rigorous fashion.

Chris_Jay··on 'We're doomed': Mayer Hillman on the climate reality no one else dare mention
just recalling what a professor said on the subject - in the short term, those areas that gain a suitable climate for agriculture will take decades to build soil up to what agriculture requires. Places where it was too cold to grow crops won't have had enough wild biomass to build a strong soil base, so there will be a 'gap' where many places that had a climate suitable to producing a lot of biomass no longer do but places that gained a climate suitable for producing a lot of biomass don't yet have the right soil ecology.

Of course, human activity could speed up the transition for these areas, but soil building is a quirky technology that's hard to scale up.

Chris_Jay··on The Myth of 'Learning Styles'
yet another phenomenon plenty of people experience subjectively being 'disproven' by experiment. It's no wonder the stock of so-called experts is diminishing...
Chris_Jay··on MIT's student newspaper criticizes MIT's convenience-based ethics
I think it's fair to say that designing weapons that others will use is always an ethical quandary with unknowable complexity. If someone errs on the side of causing no harm - a commonly accepted default if discussions of the Trolly problem are anything to go by - then designing weapons is difficult to justify because it's just impossible to ensure that they'll be used in a way the designer would sanction. I don't necessarily disagree that it's naive to opt for inaction when faced with an ethical quandary of unknowable outcome, but it does seem to be the default position and that does count for a lot.

What I find interesting is that in some cases, the broad outcomes of a particular weapon being designed are predictable. Gunpowder is widely credited with destabilizing the feudal social order because it put military supremacy in the hands of the peasantry. Modern drones could well be used to sustain a new social order much in the way that heavy armor and stirrups sustained the feudal one. Whether that's a good thing of course depends on other ethical considerations, but if I had the opportunity to work on a weapons system, I would think much more about those kinds of implications than who would be using it - it seems best to assume the answer to that question is, "everyone".

Chris_Jay··on Why Jewish History Is So Hard to Write
Assessing which historical sources are factual is not a trivial problem.
Chris_Jay··on Craigslist takes personals sections offline in response to FOSTA
Your comment brings to mind this article: https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-blathering-superego-...!

I recommend giving it a read if you'd like your attitude challenged.

Chris_Jay··on Craigslist takes personals sections offline in response to FOSTA
both of those statements can be true.
Chris_Jay··on Google News Initiative
I wonder whether you got downvoted for your choice of words. I'll try using bigly in a sentence when it can happen organically and see whether the same happens to me.
Chris_Jay··on Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s After Year Spent in Space
Epigenetics are fascinating. In my D&D headcanon, the reason Drow Elves are so obsessed with spiders is because they picture DNA as a three dimensional web whose spatial arrangement is central to gene expression.
Chris_Jay··on Technological Unemployment: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
My bad.

https://sites.google.com/view/virtuouscycleinvestment/projec...

Chris_Jay··on Technological Unemployment: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
oops, thanks for the heads up.

https://sites.google.com/view/virtuouscycleinvestment/projec...

Chris_Jay··on Technological Unemployment: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Funnily enough, my own (long term) project is aimed at addressing the problem you're pointing out. Given the possibility of remote work, there's no insurmountable reason why the only land worth living in should be concentrated in a few urban centers.

https://sites.google.com/s/0BzzRwqIB2K0dSWhkTXBSTTltTDg/p/0B...

Chris_Jay··on Like Peter Thiel, Tech Workers Feel Alienated by Silicon Valley ‘Echo Chamber’
Your attitude justifies Goldbloom's law.
Chris_Jay··on Plunging costs make solar, wind and battery storage cheaper than coal
To be fair, Norwegians might be more anti anything government if the Norwegian regulatory system was as Byzantine as in the US.
Chris_Jay··on The Rise of German Board Games
My favourite by far is defenders of the realm. Apparently it's very similar to Pandemic (which I've not played), but with an '80s D&D theme. In my experience it really sparks the imagination.
Chris_Jay··on Ask HN: How might the crypto economy redefine the world economy?
I'm getting to be a bit of a broken record on this, but here goes:

blockchain can automate the trusted third party. A records clerk in the land registry office who must be trusted to not alter a document no matter the bribe can be replaced by an algorithm. So can a person counting ballots. Or a bank paying me money to pool my savings into an investment fund. Or an NGO guaranteeing that my donation reaches the people in need.

Trusted third parties aren't seen as an industry because they're typically seen as the cost of doing business - That cost is about to drop precipitously.

Chris_Jay··on South Korea justice ministry prepares to ban cryptocurrency trading
The dot-com period was just the latest example of what happens when a new technology is widely adopted. Automobiles famously went through a similar period early last century. Many new entrants crowd into the field, there's a free-for-all as everyone tries to make the killer app, then through a weird alchemy of vision, execution, and luck a few brands eventually buy up or force into bankruptcy enough competitors to dominate the field. In recent history at least, explosion and consolidation of new players is the norm when a new technology is introduced.

As to your second question - which I would rephrase as 'why would this technology be widely adopted?' I would say, if the role of a trusted third party can be automated, it will be because nature abhors inefficiency. And trusted third parties aren't a niche field - not just banks but also a large part of any civil service can now replace humans with algorithms. That's a lot of disruption.

Chris_Jay··on South Korea justice ministry prepares to ban cryptocurrency trading
I would liken it to Apple myself. First mover advantage does count for quite a bit in software.
Chris_Jay··on South Korea justice ministry prepares to ban cryptocurrency trading
As a self-identified HODLer - I like to think it's because holding isn't nearly as easy as it sounds. Ignoring what 'Mr Market' is offering you for your property on any given day and overruling your herd-following instincts is not easy, else Warren Buffet wouldn't be such an outlier.

And yes, the HODL mantra is a way of reminding myself that I shouldn't make emotional decisions in the heat of the moment.

Chris_Jay··on NSA’s top talent is leaving because of low pay, flagging morale, unpopular reorg
Would intolerance to a level of risk typically encountered in civilian life not make someone unable to function there?

My own experience in the public service was not so much of people unable to do their jobs but people unmotivated by them. My welcoming speech included the warning 'don't get attached to outcomes', and this was in a department disliked by the elected party where a lot of people had already been forced into early retirement.

Chris_Jay··on The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of the Market
I would say that wealth concentrating in a small number of hands is not a surprising outcome, nor is it a dynamic anyone with libertarian leanings can really be uncomfortable with. I'll admit I'm unpleasantly surprised by how quickly it happened.

I would say that cryptocurrency has one advantage over traditional systems of money in that it governs with the consent of the governed - if the richest 4% of the cryptocurrency world become too aggressive and stifle innovation to protect their status, cryptocurrency's nature makes it very easy for the other 96% to take their ball and play elsewhere. There have been several 'hard fork' moments already (Bitcoin Cash, Ethereum Classic, etc) and what the majority of people went with was mostly determined by who inspired their confidence. I don't think Greenspan or Yellen could have gotten the majority of miners to switch to their system, that takes the confidence of the majority.

So to answer your last question - I would expect the experiment to lead to a more brutal and cutthroat competition than we are used to, but I also expect the rules to be more fairly enforced, and the incentives of the rich and the rest to self-correct if they begin to diverge.

I can't speak for other libertarians, but for me, finding that tradeoff worth it is what it means to be a libertarian. How clear-eyed I am about the costs I couldn't guess.

Chris_Jay··on Student Loan Debt Is Now as Big as the U.S. Junk Bond Market
I agree, but only if everyone is motivated to be an active participant - looking back on my own high school days, the kids who had trouble mostly had no incentive to be there.

It's probably utopian, but I still think a lot of problems could be solved by paying kids for marks. There are lots of arguments made about intrinsic motivation to learn being enough, but learning is also difficult and uncomfortable. Some extrinsic motivation to develop a functional learning style might be exactly what those currently underachieving are missing.

Chris_Jay··on Motel Living and Slowly Dying
The trouble is that in the US, it is controversial.

It is entirely possible UBI could leapfrog a lot of the profit-taking industries that have built up around the US social safety net the way cell towers leapfrogged telephone lines in the developing world.

Chris_Jay··on Facebook users in Romania see content related to street protests reviewed
Interesting - I hadn't known the history behind the term, I thought it was a neologism. I do prefer the term identity politics myself, but the tendency of right wing groups to call everyone they dislike communists doesn't appear to me any more ridiculous than the frequency with which they are called Nazis. There seems to be an effort in that camp to shift the Overton window to exclude communism with the same prejudice currently reserved for Nazism, and from that perspective 'baiting' the opposition into being too loose with either term is probably an effective strategy.
Chris_Jay··on Facebook users in Romania see content related to street protests reviewed
I agree with 90% of what you said, but must take issue with your characterization of cultural marxism. Cultural Marxism as I've encountered the term is simply what critics of Intersectional Feminism call Intersectional Feminism, and as political slurs go that seems rather reasonable. Intersectional feminism really does have a lot in common with Marxism if one replaces 'the proletariate' with underprivileged groups like sexual, ethnic, or cultural minorities.

I don't disagree the rhetoric by people who use the term is often overblown, but the basic fact of the critique - that Intersectional Feminism is similar to Marxism - not only seems fair but would probably elicit no disagreement from the people so characterized.

Chris_Jay··on Facebook users in Romania see content related to street protests reviewed
The choice isn't a binary between corporate monopolies or a non capitalist alternative, there is a very wide spectrum of possible 'topias between those two extremes.

Methinks public discourse is overdue for a revival of good old fashioned Aristotelian Virtue Ethics.

Chris_Jay··on Ask HN: We have a great team and capital but can't find a good idea
It sounds like you're spending too much time in focus mode and not enough time in diffuse mode. A lot of people are suggesting your team is just incapable of diffuse thinking, but I would say it's a skill like any other.

Travel, read fiction, daydream, write down ten bad ideas right after waking up... play a bit looser than you're used to, and some new connections should form.

Chris_Jay··on Ask HN: We have a great team and capital but can't find a good idea
I would really like a simple NLP algorithm that combs candidate profiles and identifies undervalued candidates.
Chris_Jay··on Inadequacy and Modesty
Granted, but it would still seem rational for everyone to prioritize aligning our short- and long-term incentives so that this sort of tragedy doesn't become worse than it has to be.
Chris_Jay··on Monsanto Attacks Scientists After Studies Show Trouble for Its New Weedkiller
It seems that farming with Monsanto seed is just a slower death sentence.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →