HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Claudus

792 karma · joined January 25, 2012

submissionscomments
Claudus··on FBI: Hillary Clinton Didn't Know 'C' in Emails Meant Classified
Very rarely did I see anything marked confidential. The assumption was that all work related documents and information was to be protected. As far as I was concerned, removing any work related data, email, or other information from the site was grounds for immediate termination and likely charges being brought.

I don't know the practices at the state department, but for my section, the guideline was, "Just assume everything is sensitive, protect it, and you won't have any problems."

Compiling a list of networked computers by IP and OS, that data would be considered sensitive, and obviously not to be removed off site, but would not be marked in any way.

From a practical perspective, the "not marked as classified" doesn't really make sense to me, it may have some legal merit, but I couldn't speak to that.

Claudus··on FBI: Hillary Clinton Didn't Know 'C' in Emails Meant Classified
I made some updates to my post regarding classification.

Being marked as classified was not something I would expect, instead you should operate as if all information is sensitive. Act as if information must be white-listed for public release. Much how the FBI is handling the data, each piece of information must be reviewed before release.

The excuse of "not marked as classified" is akin to a thief using "not marked as don't steal" to justify theft.

Claudus··on FBI: Hillary Clinton Didn't Know 'C' in Emails Meant Classified
I've been in the computer security industry for decades, 20 years ago I did intrusion detection and computer network security for a large government location as part of a team of about 12 people. I referred people to the Inspector General for prosecution when they attacked our networks.

I am really shocked at the level of incompetence here. Even 20 years ago we had 300,000 to 450,000 probes and hack attempts on that one network alone, on a weekly basis. It seems almost certain that her emails were compromised.

Destroying them is inexcusable, at the very least those records could have been used to determine what data had been potentially compromised.

I can't imagine what went on at the State Department where this kind of thing could happen. And, it isn't just Hillary Clinton who is guilty here.

I remember the first day after my security clearance and background checks completed, they spent several hours explaining security policies to me; that felony charges would be brought against me if I walked out the gate with so much as a hard copy of an internal email. I only had the lowest level of clearance for "classified" of "confidential" and even then only as was relevant to performing my job. There were entire buildings in our complex that had "secret" data, and only certain members of our team could investigate those systems for potential intrusions.

Even at that level, when you work with potentially classified material, the default behavior is to act is if all information is classified. If you want to published, or release information, it needs to checked and approved, even if it's not sensitive, just to be sure.

The only excuse I can possibly imagine, is that the clintonemail.com server was actually an elaborate ruse to leak misinformation to foreign actors.

Claudus··on Un-Facebooked
I think your analogy is flawed on several levels.

It's not an analogy, it's a comparison between technologies. The underlying principle of unrestricted communication is what is important. If I were to use an analogy, I'd say telling people to use obsolete methods to communicate is like telling a radio station to broadcast in analog to a world with only digital receivers.

removing stuff that's not supposed to be endorsed

This comment, among others you made, is exactly the kind of ideology I find disturbing.

Claudus··on Un-Facebooked
I find it very disturbing to see these allegations of censorship directed at large tech companies like Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, and even Google.

I thought that the Internet was the greatest empowerment of free speech in history. Now that so much communication happens through private services, it seems like free speech is effectively being damped.

Can you imagine decades ago, the phone company revoking your phone number because they didn't like what you said to your friends over their wires?

Claudus··on Did Google Manipulate Search for Hillary? [video]
This is really concerning, and disappointing if true.

I'd be less concerned if they were also cleaning up autocomplete for the other candidates, but it appears they are not.

Claudus··on Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]
Judge Davis retired May 15, 2015

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonard_Davis_(judge)

Claudus··on FBI Makes Official Its Decision to Keep Apple iPhone Hack Secret
Not to be a conspiracy theorist, but maybe they don't actually have a hack. Maybe they just want people to think they do.
Claudus··on Our preoccupation with gender identity is a cultural step backwards
As a free thinker I tend to reject social constructs.

If sex is biological expression, and gender is a social construct then I acknowledge sex and reject gender.

Claudus··on Don't use the greater than sign in programming
I spotted the incorrect one instantly. Why? Because there are two good ways to write this correctly, and he chose to not use one, and to use the other incorrectly in in his example.

5 < x && x < 10

10 > x && x > 5

Both seem equally readable to me.

His argument also seems predicated on the assumption that numbers are always increasing.

If x > 10 relax() else countdown(x) // easier to read "if timer is greater than 10, relax, otherwise, countdown"

If 10 < x relax() else countdown(x) // harder to read "if 10 is less than timer, relax, otherwise, countdown"

Claudus··on Media misreports study showing women code better than men. Here’s what’s unsaid
I remember being drawn into the world of computers decades ago. Online your physical characteristics were irrelevant, your words and ideas were all that mattered.

When I read articles like this, it makes me think that some people don't like that.

Claudus··on An Ancient, Brutal Massacre May Be the Earliest Evidence of War
I wonder how accurate the millennium approximations are, it would put this event about 2000 years before the 1 in 17 males reproducing for every female at the dawn of agriculture.

https://www.reddit.com/r/history/comments/2zkgq5/8000_years_...

Claudus··on Schwarzenegger: I don’t give a damn if we agree about climate change
1. "WHO estimates indoor air pollution was linked to 4.3 million deaths in 2012 in households cooking over coal, wood and biomass stoves."

If the majority of the "7 million" die from indoor cooking, It seems like it would be better to focus our resources on developing infrastructure in SE Asia so that every household has electricity and modern cooking appliances.

Claudus··on Ellen Pao: The Trolls Are Winning the Battle for the Internet
I've been following the Ellen Pao debacle on Reddit, and her misuse of the term "troll" in the article illustrates her ignorance of Internet and Reddit culture that led to her stepping down as CEO.

I'm sure there were many offensive, harassing, and vitriolic comments and directed at her, however they were a result of her incompetent actions and failure to understand the culture that caused the problem, not due to trolls or trolling.

Claudus··on How Can There Still Be a Sex Difference, Even When There Is No Sex Difference?
The reason that is important for group differences to be studied and known is because the group level is where discrimination (and accusations such) seem to be studied.

If someone wants to hire the tallest 50% of the population to be fruit pickers and fairly evaluates every member of the population resulting in a 90% male workforce, how can they defend themselves against accusations of discrimination? In such an instance, it would be important to understand the height differences in male and female populations.

What about the most intelligent 5% of the population being best suited for STEM fields? With fair evaluations would that result in even splits across sex (or race, for that matter)?

Even with self selection, people are going to select into roles they are best suited for.

Does the Jamacian ACTN3 gene variation result in more Olympic gold sprinters, or is it a result of racial discrimination?

Articles like this on HN and the interest in studying differences between different groups is at least partially a direct result of pressure and accusations of discrimination based on sex/race distributions of groups.

I agree, ideally evaluating each person should be done on an individual level. I also think evaluating issues of discrimination should be done on an individual level.

Claudus··on Sexism in Tech: Don’t Ask Me Unless You’re Ready to Call Someone a Whistleblower
Referencing Wikipedia in specific technical instances like this is ill advised. Wikipedia is good for summarizing sources, but if you actually read the sources, I don't think you'll find any of them [1][2][3][4] make any mention of "abuse of authority" pertaining to rape.

Rather than reflecting "the lowest common denominator of what most people agree on", it seems more likely this is what one specific individual with a less accepted definition of rape who cares enough to edit the wiki and fight off all dissenters wants you to believe is the default definition of rape.

Claudus··on How north ended up on top of the map
A pointed needle can be magnetized to point either North or South. But you definitely want some way of distinguishing between the two ends, and making one end pointed seems like the easiest way to do so. Maybe the magnetization just happened to result in the needle pointing North the first time and that set the standard.

Really interesting article on making a compass. http://www.wildwoodsurvival.com/survival/navigation/rbimprov...

Claudus··on Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen
Theft can happen under any form of government, I'm not sure why you would think otherwise.
Claudus··on San Francisco's guerrilla protest at Google buses swells into revolt
I'm sure Texas would be more than happy to have Google offices in any of the major cities, and there's plenty of space.
Claudus··on The hardest computer game of all time
I actually quit playing SpaceChem because the difficulty of the puzzles progressed to the point where I felt I should be getting paid to solve them.
Claudus··on US tech firms make eleventh-hour attempt to halt tax avoidance reforms
Personally, I'd rather that Google keep as much of their money as possible and continue to spend it as they see fit.

I believe that society benefits far more from a company like Google having and spending the money than any federal government.

Claudus··on What You Get When 30 People Draw a World Map From Memory
That appears to be something he'd rehearsed in advance.
Claudus··on Turing Drawings
Here are few good ones:

http://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#4,3,1,2,1,1,1,1,1...

http://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#4,3,3,2,2,2,2,2,0...

http://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#4,3,3,2,1,2,1,1,3...

http://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#4,3,2,2,2,3,1,3,1...

http://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#4,3,1,2,2,2,2,3,2...

Claudus··on The Next Revolution in 3-D Printing: Disposable Panties
Or you could just use hydrogen peroxide to get the blood stains out of fabric.
Claudus··on Short film set entirely on a teen's computer screen
Yeah, I thought the same thing...

And of course, there's also "Welcome To Teh Scene". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scene_%28miniseries%29#Paro...

Claudus··on Loneliness Is Deadly
I think this is why some very high iq people aren't more productive... it's not easy to find high quality relationships.
Claudus··on What advice would you give your 16 year old self?
Don't waste time in grad school unless you want to be a professor.

Work out a little, girls like muscles.

Claudus··on Firefox 22 released
I was hoping they'd restore the old "split" Inspect Element UI, instead they added the option to dock it on the right side of the browser.

Not what I was looking for, I wanted the Rules on the side in a column, and the inspector along the bottom like it used to be.

Disappointed.

Claudus··on “Star Trek Continues”: Fan-made episodes carry on the five-year mission
I'm really curious to know how this ties in to Star Trek New Voyages... are they alternate timelines, or are they overlapping?

http://www.startreknewvoyages.com&#x2F;

Claudus··on Detroit's Decaying Old Train Station Has 5 New Windows and No One Knows Why
One would assume the mystery could be solved through city permit records, but according to Todd, there are no permits, even though there should be. "For that kind of work and the dollar amount that would come with it, yes, permits would be required," says Todd.

Wow, you need a permit in Detroit to put glass into a window?

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →