HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Closi

9,073 karma · joined May 10, 2020

submissionscomments
Closi··on MacBook Neo
The counter however is that lots of schools are on 365, which doesn’t work so well on a Chromebook but works great on a mac.
Closi··on The United States and Israel have launched a major attack on Iran
I think we can safely assume that OP was picking a bit of a ridiculous hypothetical example to make a point that it’s possible for something to be deadly and transmissible, although in nature Baculovirus in Caterpillars has a similar mechanism (encourages their host to eat a lot, then climb to the top of a plant so when it turns to ooze it infects others) or cordyceps although both of these aren’t as highly transmissible as they hypothetical explode virus.

But the Black Death mixed high contagion and high mortality as an actual example that shows they aren’t mutually exclusive.

Closi··on The path to ubiquitous AI (17k tokens/sec)
Better models already exist, this is just proving you can dramatically increase inference speeds / reduce inference costs.

It isn't about model capability - it's about inference hardware. Same smarts, faster.

Closi··on I want to wash my car. The car wash is 50 meters away. Should I walk or drive?
Because humans always say 'bread' if you ask them what you put in a toaster.

And humans will always deduce that you should switch doors if you are in a hypothetical gameshow and they show you a horse behind one of the doors.

(All I mean is - an example of an LLM answering illogically is not proof that LLMs can't really think logically, as you can equally find examples of humans answering illogically and also find examples of novel questions that LLMs get right)

Closi··on I want to wash my car. The car wash is 50 meters away. Should I walk or drive?
Let's not forget that Einstein almost got a (reasonably simple) trick question wrong:

https://fs.blog/einstein-wertheimer-car-problem/

And that many mathematicians got monty-hall wrong, despite it being intuitive for many kids.

And being at the top of your field (regardless of the PHD) does not make you immune to falling for YES / EYES.

> humans without credentials are bad at basic algebra in a word problem, ergo the large language model must be substantially equivalent to a human without a credential

I'm not saying this - i'm saying the claim that 'AI's get this question wrong ergo they cannot be a senior software engineer' is wrong when senior software engineers will get analogous questions wrong. If you apply the same bar to software engineers, you get 'senior software engineers get this question wrong so they can't be senior software engineers' which is obviously wrong.

Closi··on I want to wash my car. The car wash is 50 meters away. Should I walk or drive?
Humans aren't immune to getting questions like this wrong either, so I don't think it changes much in terms of the ability of AI to replace jobs.

I've seen senior software engineers get tricked with the 'if YES spells yes, what does EYES spell?', or 'Say silk three times, what do cows drink?', or 'What do you put in a toaster?'.

Even if not a trick - lots of people get the 'bat and a ball cost £1.10 in total. The bat costs £1 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?' question wrong, or '5 machines take 5 minutes to make 5 widgets. How long do 100 machines take to make 100 widgets?' etc. There are obviously more complex variants of all these that have even lower success rates for humans.

In addition, being PHD-Level in maths as a human doesn't make you immune to the 'toaster/toast' question (assuming you haven't heard it before).

So if we assume humans are generally intelligent and can be a senior software engineer, getting this sort of question confidently wrong isn't incompatible with being a competent senior software engineer.

Closi··on Europe's $24T Breakup with Visa and Mastercard Has Begun
I suspect they aren’t doing this (just) to avoid fees - it’s more about national security in a world where the US might stop being a reliable ally, and in a world where the US has used withdrawing Visa / Mastercard as a strategy to weaken enemy economies.
Closi··on FDA intends to take action against non-FDA-approved GLP-1 drugs
I think we have a different definition of free riding.

If you and me both buy the same car, but i'm better at negotiating than you and get a lower price, I'm not free riding because you 'funded the design of the car with the extra money you paid', you are just bad at negotiation.

Closi··on FDA intends to take action against non-FDA-approved GLP-1 drugs
> The rest of the world is free riding.

The rest of the world isn't free riding - the USA has just setup a market where there is very little bargaining power for consumers because of how the US medical market and insurance works.

Novo and Eli are still making plenty of money in Europe where these drugs cost a fraction of the price, and where there aren't other significant suppliers for GLP-1's like is being implied.

Closi··on LLMs as the new high level language
> It's not a programming language if you can't read someone else's code, figure out what it does, figure out what they meant, and debug the difference between those things.

Well I think the article would say that you can diff the documentation, and it's the documentation that is feeding the AI in this new paradigm (which isn't direct prompting).

If the definition of programming is "a process to create sets of instructions that tell a computer how to perform specific tasks" there is nothing in there that requires it to be deterministic at the definition level.

Closi··on The Codex App
It's about consistency - you want to build an app that looks and functions the same on all platforms as much as possible. Regardless of if you are hand-coding or vibe-coding 3 entirely separate software stacks, getting everything consistent is going to be a challenge and subtle inconsistencies will sneak in.

It comes back to fundamental programming guidelines like DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself) - if you have three separate implementations in different languages for everything, changes will be come harder and you will move slower. These golden guidelines still stand in a vibe-code world.

Closi··on Euro firms must ditch Uncle Sam's clouds and go EU-native
> Isn’t the more fundamental question why Europe has not been as successful as the US or China in building a native tech industry despite having a huge market? What are the barriers to creating startups and how can you lower them and preserve the enviable European social model? Solve that and you’ll solve the problem of a native cloud.

IMO here in the UK we are good at starting tech startups, we are just bad at not selling them to overseas investors early in their life, or having a tax framework that is advantageous to them growing in the UK.

In the UK see Google Deepmind, ARM, Deliveroo... Elevenlabs being incorporated in the USA, Dyson moving to singapore etc - Even outside of the tech space, Cadburys, Sainsbury's, Jaguar Land Rover... If the UK kept hold of everything that the UK created, we would be great!

Even our infrastructure we sell to the French, Chinese, Germans etc just for short-term gain, despite that we are cutting our nose off if we look forward 10 years.

Closi··on Tell HN: Amazon has deactivated my seller account
> What is so wrong with writing refills can be purchased on our website.

> Probably gonna share this story online more. I mean I didn't expect the situation to be this extremely bad.

Yes it's bad, although I want to emphasise that I have changed the details significantly here - it was something like this, but this was not the infraction because I don't want the company to be identifiable by anyone. I’m also not sure if my example is an actual policy violation - but it was in a similar vein.

To be honest, the surprising thing wasn’t the ban on a policy violation (because they had violated a policy), it was how automated the internals of Amazon were and how slow it was to overturn.

Closi··on Tell HN: Amazon has deactivated my seller account
I used to work for a large Amazon Seller (>$100m per year revenue) who got automatically deactivated with no warning and it took them a week to get re-activated.

We are talking a very minor infraction - It was something like one of their marketing copywriters putting 'refills can be purchased on our website' on one of their thousands of listings, and Amazon delisting their entire account on the basis that this was moving customers off their platform. No warning - permenant ban that took over a week to remove - c$2m revenue loss (I've changed the details here significantly to avoid disclosing the company - this was not the exact scenario so please treat with a pinch of salt)

They had an account manager, but Amazon is so automated and huge that even at that scale it was a nightmare to resolve. It seemed like account managers couldn't automatically reactivate accounts or anything, they can just fill in forms internally but it seemed like they were getting automated responses back, or it was going to faceless teams etc.

Closi··on Tell HN: Bending Spoons laid off almost everybody at Vimeo yesterday
What if there isn't a feasible path for expansion and growth? Vimeo already has contracting revenue, it's either in the maturity or decline phase.

Some customers will churn, some will stay, Bending Spoons are the masters of this model so will have made an assumption on how revenue will change across the next 5-10 years+, but I would assume that they aren't forecasting extreme growth, and instead are calculating that net profit can be changed from c$30m to c$139m within existing revenue, so if they can keep revenue at/near current levels without growth, they can end up with a much more profitable business.

Bear in mind that same revenue doesn't necessarily mean the same number of customers - it can also mean raising prices and having less customers. Bending Spoons might estimate that if they double prices, half their customers might leave - this would still be BRILLIANT for profit, as while revenue would stay the same, some costs would half, and thus profit might jump from c$140m to c$250m based on some napkin math!

Closi··on UK consulting on bringing in social media ban for under 16s
This was an argument that was used to not ban smoking for kids in the UK back in the day. From the parliment debate...

> [banning smoking would] afford a direct encouragement to children to smoke. Most boys of a tender age who might be seen smoking in public places did so, not because of any attachment to tobacco, but because they considered it a practice in advance of their years, and something moreover which their elders told them not to do, affording them, therefore, the added pleasure of disobedience which was so dear to boys of their age.

https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1908-10-13/debates/6aa...

Perhaps it does make it cooler - but undoubtedly the restrictions reduced availability and reduced the number of children being addicted.

As for the actual age cut-off, it's always going to be fairly arbitrary, or a 'balanced judgement'.

Closi··on We put Claude Code in Rollercoaster Tycoon
They are 100% different and yet kind-of-the-same.

They can function kind-of-the-same in the sense that they can both change things written in a higher level language into a lower level language.

100% different in every other way, but for coding in some circumstances if we treat it as a black box, LLMs can turn higher level pseudocode into lower level code (inaccurately), or even transpile.

Kind of like how email and the postal service can be kind of the same if you look at it from a certain angle.

Closi··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
In practice, this is managed by:

1) Making the application small enough, and breaking it apart if needed (e.g. I've refactored my old 'big' app into 10 micro-apps).

2) Selecting an architecture that will work, looking after the data modelling and architecture yourself rather than delegating this to the LLM (it can implement it - but you need to design it).

3) Trusting that the LLM is capable enough to implement new requirements or fixes as required.

If requirements change so substantially that it's not possible, you can write new software as requirements change - as per point 1, you will have made your application modular enough that this isn't a significant concern.

Closi··on Claude Cowork exfiltrates files
For day-to-day coding, why use your own half-baked solution when the commercial versions are better, cheaper and can be customised anyway?

I've written my own agent for a specialised problem which does work well, although it just burns tokens compared to Cursor!

The other advantage that Claude Code has is that the model itself can be finetuned for tool calling rather than just relying on prompt engineering, but even getting the prompts right must take huge engineering effort and experimentation.

Closi··on TimeCapsuleLLM: LLM trained only on data from 1800-1875
A human is effectively turning complete if you give the person paper and pen and the ruleset, and a brain clearly stores information and processes it to some extent, so this is pretty unconvincing. The article is nonsense and badly written.

> But here is what we are not born with: information, data, rules, software, knowledge, lexicons, representations, algorithms, programs, models, memories, images, processors, subroutines, encoders, decoders, symbols, or buffers – design elements that allow digital computers to behave somewhat intelligently. Not only are we not born with such things, we also don’t develop them – ever.

Really? Humans don't ever develop memories? Humans don't gain information?

Closi··on Show HN: DevicePrint – device fingerprinting without cookies
It also has a 99.5% confidence that it has uniquely fingerprinted me, and says I have had 677 visits to the site, including Vietnam & Sweeden...

I think the 'unique' part of fingerprinting here isn't working unfortunately.

Closi··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
Try learning to vibe code on something totally greenfield without looking at the code and see if it changes your mind. Ignore code quality, “does it work” and “am i happy with the app” are the only metrics.

Code quality is an issue you need to ignore with vibe coding - if code quality is important to your project or you then it’s not an issue. But if you abandon this concept and build things small enough or modular enough then speed gains await!

IMO codebases can be architected for LLMs to work better in them, but this is harder in brownfield apps.

Closi··on Show HN: I used Claude Code to discover connections between 100 books
I guess the lies were useful until she got caught?
Closi··on SQL Studio
Looks like the pricing is free or $4 per month - sounds reasonable?
Closi··on Pipe Dreams – The life and times of Yahoo Pipes (2023)
Thanks! It's in a very narrow domain (Handset UI flows in Warehouse Management Systems) so i'm hoping that helps, but it's very domain specific and certainly not anything mainstream.
Closi··on Pipe Dreams – The life and times of Yahoo Pipes (2023)
My personal sense is business logic which involves processes with lots of steps rather than data transformation.

I’m unconvinced that code is the best way to describe business logic, so here we are! :)

(Code is probably the best way to encode business logic, but most users can’t read it or edit it, which makes it bad)

Closi··on Pipe Dreams – The life and times of Yahoo Pipes (2023)
Let's see! I'm actually working on a node-based programming LLM paradigm for an app I'm building.

The idea is that you can write the 'nodes' in plain english rather than pre-written blocks, and then the arrows indicate the flow but don't need to absolutely encode everything (closer to a flow chart). The process of writing the flow chart helps define and document the business logic, and the flows are totally clear because everything is encoded into a state machine.

Closi··on Show HN: I built a universal clipboard that syncs realtime on multiple devices
100% agree - If this app gets any traction at all, it's only a matter of time before someone's crypto wallet gets leaked and emptied.

If you want to be handling peoples secrets, you have to make sure you know what you are doing and build something bombproof (bombproof from a mathematical perspective, rather than relying on your server being secure)

Closi··on Show HN: I built a universal clipboard that syncs realtime on multiple devices
I've posted elsewhere, but I still have lots of issues personally:

* Your deletion policy says you delete images instantly and via the UI in settings, but I've checked and they are retained in the object store. You need to update these policies to be honest and say that the images aren't deleted, and that you currently retain them and just delete the reference to them.

* Your privacy policy says you can't see user content, but you clearly can (as you have both the data and the encryption keys). You might not have developed the functionality to read it yet - but it is trivial to do. Just be honest and say 'your data can technically be accessed by us, but we promise not to look at it'.

* Your privacy policy only limits your access to 'what is allowed by law' - which is clearly the absolute minimum!

I think your policies currently say how you would like it to be, rather than how it is. You need to be honest with users about how their data is actually processed.

Closi··on Show HN: I built a universal clipboard that syncs realtime on multiple devices
On the site:

> So while the image URLs aren't encrypted, they're still secure. Only you can access your images.

This isn't true though - and presumably you know it isn't true?

You would be able to access and download all the images if you wanted to.

> But we can't read the actual content of your encrypted items without your encryption key, and we don't have a reason to try.

This is also misleading - because you do have the encryption key, so you can read the content if you want to. "We won't read the content even though we could, because we don't currently have a reason" is the actual state of affairs.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →