HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Closi

9,073 karma · joined May 10, 2020

submissionscomments
Closi··on Show HN: I built a universal clipboard that syncs realtime on multiple devices
Extra further finding!

Deletion policy says:

> 2. How to Delete Your Account and Data You have several options to delete your account and all associated data: Through the App: If you are signed in, you can delete your account directly from the Settings page. This will permanently delete all your data including [...] all uploaded images and files

... Although I've confirmed that the reality is that it only deletes the reference to those files from your account, and the actual files are still sitting on the server (I've just saved the url and checked the file still exists after deletion).

Even after it throws a message saying everything has been permanently deleted...

This thing is an absolute security and privacy nightmare - I would not rely on any information on the website about how they handle your data, considering they said it was e2e and that was not truthful, and they have said they delete the images and that isn't true. How can anything about this be trusted after repeated untruths about how our data is handled?

Also the app seems to send several MB of data back/forward every minute when doing nothing across a socket connection which is another red flag.

Closi··on Show HN: I built a universal clipboard that syncs realtime on multiple devices
I think the challenge is that you are potentially storing some of the most secret things for users here - passwords copied from password managers, bank details copied and pasted into forms, private photos, corporate secrets and designs, medical records... And even your revised model shows a completely careless approach to security and is entirely insufficient considering the data stored.

Encrypting images is too slow too? Poor excuse - it probably takes milliseconds. If you are asking people to trust them with their nudes and photos of bank documents, you need to store them in a way that you can’t see them.

You having access to all user data stored with a tiny privacy policy that basically boils down to “we can use your data as long as it’s not illegal for us to use it” is not sufficient!

I wouldn’t be this harsh on the security of another startup or app just because most startups don’t start asking users to store their secrets with them - because you will be storing secrets, that puts you into a category of people who need to be careful and not careless - at the moment you are demonstrating the latter.

It’s entirely possible to do everything end to end by the way (imo this is the only way this should be done considering you will be storing passwords) - see how 1password does it and copy them if nothing else: https://1password.com/files/1password-white-paper.pdf

Closi··on Show HN: Use Claude Code to Query 600 GB Indexes over Hacker News, ArXiv, etc.
This is true, although maybe if an “AGI” invented us, it might say “It’s strange how these humans are so good at driving, but so bad at protein folding and playing Go”

Very abstract, but I think it’s important to remember that human intelligence also has jagged edges.

Closi··on Show HN: Use Claude Code to Query 600 GB Indexes over Hacker News, ArXiv, etc.
I think your definition of it being 'human level' is sensible - definitely a lower bar to hit than 'as long as people can do work that a robot cannot do, we don't have AGI'.

There is certainly a lot road between current technology and driving a car through a construction zone during rush hour, particularly with the same amount of driving practice a human gets.

Personally I think there could be an AGI which couldn't drive a car, but has genuine sentience - an awareness of being alive, although not necessarily the exact human experience. Maybe this isn't AGI, which more implies problem-solving and thinking rather than sentience, but in my gut if we got something sentient but that couldn't drive a car, we would still be there if that makes sense?

Closi··on CEO of health care software company sentenced for $1B fraud conspiracy
In the 'purely rational' crimes, it's going to be some sort of function of both right? The expected benefit, the risk that you get caught, and the severity of the punishment.

While I agree that people conducting corporate fraud think they will get away with it - I don't agree that the long sentences won't act as a deterrence. If you set the sentence for these sorts of crimes to 1 year rather than 15+, that completely changes the risk profile for people who think there is a 90% chance they will get away with it.

Closi··on Show HN: Use Claude Code to Query 600 GB Indexes over Hacker News, ArXiv, etc.
Completely disagree - Your definition (in my opinion) is more aligned to the concept of Artificial Super Intelligence.

Surely the 'General Intelligence' definition has to be consistent between 'Artificial General Intelligence' and 'Human General Intelligence', and humans can be generally intelligent even if they can't solve calculus equations or protein folding problems. My definition of general intelligence is much lower than most - I think a dog is probably generally intelligent, although obviously in a different way (dogs are obviously better at learning how to run and catch a ball, and worse at programming python).

Closi··on Show HN: Use Claude Code to Query 600 GB Indexes over Hacker News, ArXiv, etc.
Just comes down to your own view of what AGI is, as it's not particularly well defined.

While a bit 'time-machiney' - I think if you took an LLM of today and showed it to someone 20 years ago, most people would probably say AGI has been achieved. If someone wrote a definition of AGI 20 years ago, we would probably have met that.

We have certainly blasted past some science-fiction examples of AI like Agnes from The Twilight Zone, which 20 years ago looked a bit silly, and now looks like a remarkable prediction of LLMs.

By todays definition of AGI we haven't met it yet, but eventually it comes down to 'I know it if I see it' - the problem with this definition is that it is polluted by what people have already seen.

Closi··on Show HN: Mysti – Claude, Codex, and Gemini debate your code, then synthesize
Anecdotal experience, but when bugfixing I personally find if a model introduces a bug, it has a hard time spotting and fixing it, but when you give the code to another model it can instantly spot it (even if it's a weaker model overall).

So I can well imagine that this sort of approach could work very well, although agree with your sentiment that measurement would be good.

Closi··on CEO of health care software company sentenced for $1B fraud conspiracy
> There is no research I’m aware of on people for whom the prospect of punishment did act as a deterrent (i.e. people who decided not to commit the crime).

Surely this can’t be true - as a trivial example I would be surprised if removing parking fines wouldn’t increase parking violations, or if Singapore stopped punishing littering that it wouldn’t affect the amount of littering etc

Maybe the difference between a 10 year or 20 year sentence for murder doesn’t make much difference, but if murder had no punishment at all I would be very surprised if that wouldn’t raise the murder rate!

Closi··on CEO killed at industrial site by worker operating forklift
> The combination of coincidences is striking

It would only really be a striking coincidence if each of these elements is a rare occurence - although if the site has a poor safety culture and this sort of stuff is happening all the time, it becomes less of a coincidence and more of an inevitability.

In the UK for example sites generally mandate hi-vis vests, establish pedestrian walk routes, ensure visitors can't walk straight into the warehouse without supervision or training, and ban using mobile phones when using any form of MHE - so if sites had good safety standards and enforced all this, then the chance of it happening would be much smaller than a site that didn't enforce all this (Just saying this is how it is in the UK as my experience all this is less common in the USA - although no doubt many sites operate the same).

If a site lets people wear what they want and does not stop MHE operators from using phones and lets a visitor freely walk around the warehouse... I don't know if a person getting hit at that stage is a coincidence IMO (regardless of the eye patch).

Closi··on What Is Generative UI?
The concept of recording a macro (telling a computer the steps you want it to do, and then it repeating it) is very different to telling the computer the outcome you want and it working out the steps.

Going back to the 'help me calculate the financial implications of a house purchase' example - making a macro might make your work repeatable, but doesn't avoid users needing to learn excel or needing to put in the effort to build the spreadsheet.

Closi··on What Is Generative UI?
It's not bugs that is the barrier here. Maybe functionality is the wrong word as I'm talking about something higher level than individual features, and maybe 'user stories' better represents what I'm getting at...

What I mean is that 'old' software has focussed on giving users lots of tools for users to complete their tasks, and when we talk about UI's we are talking about how to arrange all those tools in a way that is easy for a user to navigate. Users usually have to learn about all the tools that are there, so they know which ones to use (and over time the ones that learn about the existence of all the tools become 'power users').

But 'new' software might be more about completing users tasks for them, and these higher level tasks are the ones that are hard to define because there are so many permutations of what a user might want to do. As the software is helping users more, end-users might not ever need to know about the existence of all of the tools as they are abstracted away.

Closi··on What Is Generative UI?
I would argue the opposite - the premise actually accepts that software developers and product owners can't always know how their software will be used by end users.

Besides, HCI will inevitably change because after 30 years of incremental user interface refinement, your average person still struggles to use Excel or Photoshop, but those same users are asking ChatGPT to help them write formulas or asking Gemini to help edit their photos.

I don't accept the premise that the interfaces were ever actually that good - For simple apps users can get around them fine, but for anything moderately complex users have mostly struggled or need training IMO. Blender as an example is an amazing piece of software - but ask any user who has never used it before to draw and render a bird without refering to the documentation (they won't be able to). If we want users to be able to use software like blender without needing to formally train them then we need a totally different approach (which would be great, as I suspect artistic ability and the technical ability to use blender are not necessarily correlated that strongly).

Closi··on What Is Generative UI?
I think you are right in the 'current paradigm' of what software is at the moment, where users are using a fixed set of functionality in the way that the developer intended, but there is a new breed of software where the functionality set can't be defined in an exhaustive way.

Take Claude Code - after I've described my requirement it gives me a customised UI that asks me to make choices specific to what I have asked it to build (usually a series of dropdown lists of 3-4 options). How would a static UI do that in a way that was as seamless?

The example used in the article is a bit more specific but fair - if you want to calculate the financial implications of a house purchase in the 'old software paradigm' you probably have to start by learning excel and building a spreadsheet (or using a dodgy online calculator someone else built, which doesn't match your use case). The spreadsheet the average user writes might be a little simplified - are we positive that they included stamp duty and got the compounding interest right? Wouldn't it be great if Excel could just give you a perfectly personalised calculator, with toggle switches, without users needing to learn =P(1+(k/m))^(mn) but while still clearly showing how everything is calculated? Maybe Excel doesn't need to be a tool which is scary - it can be something everyone can use to help make better decisions regardless of skill level.

So yes, if you think of software only doing what it has done in the past, Gen UI does not make sense. If you think of software doing things it has never done before we need to think of new interaction modes (because hopefully we can do something better than just a text chat interface?).

Closi··on What Is Generative UI?
There is a trade off with simplicity though - usually it requires being highly opinionated about which software features make the cut. Users or sales teams often want more features, but if you included every one the app would become a mess.

But there is a possible world where you can have both - every 'feature' your users would ever want without overwhelming complexity or steep learning curves, but with the possible downside/cost of reducing consistency.

Closi··on Can Dutch universities do without Microsoft?
It's still better than anything else and the de-facto standard so you need it.

Clients will send you their PowerPoint template and want you to use it. They will send you their complex spreadsheets riddled with VBA macros and you will need to fix them. They will invite you to a Teams site because that's where their project updates go. I just don't see how you can avoid it as a consulting company!

For things like Excel - We can say it's 'bad' but I've not seen anything do the job it does better. And besides, even if it was bad, it doesn't matter - as a consultant you need to use it because your clients probably want your workings as part of the deliverables, and if it's on Google Sheets they often won't want that.

Closi··on Can Dutch universities do without Microsoft?
You can run a logistics consulting business without windows, but you will struggle without Excel and PowerPoint, and 365 with SharePoint is basically needed for collaboration in any consulting business.

Im also a logistics consultant… try to parse a multi-million line orderlines extract in Google Sheets compared to excel.

I’m also on Mac but to be honest it’s a challenge - there are still enough industry specific tools that are windows only so I have to run a parallels VM to get by.

Closi··on Ilya Sutskever, Yann LeCun and the End of “Just Add GPUs”
> we reach to a safe and eventually perfect system by deploying it in public and iterating over it until optimal convergence dictated by users in a free market

Possibly... but also a lot of the foundational AI advancements were actually done in skunkworks-like environments and with pure research rather than iterating in front of the public.

It's not 100% clear to me if the ultimate path to the end is iteration or something completely new.

Closi··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
Terrence Tao seems to think it has it's use in finding solutions for maths problemms:

https://mathstodon.xyz/@tao/115591487350860999

I don't know enough about maths to know if this classifies as 'improving on existing results', but at least it was a good enough for Terrence Tao to use it for ideas.

Closi··on UK's first small nuclear power station to be built in north Wales
I'm just going on the fact that most energy experts say a diversified mix is what you usually want - although my lay assumption would be that if you have a portion of your energy need covered by a stable base load, you need less batteries per wind turbine etc and it lowers overall energy risk.

e.g. lets pick two overly-simplified hypothetical scenarios where you can have a 50/50 nuclear/wind mix, or 100% wind mix.

And then lets say in a shortage scenario you can: - Suppress demand / demand shift (say you can reduce/shift demand 10% hypothetically)

- Import energy, up to 20% of your total requirement

In this simple scenario, in a 100% wind scenario, you would need to cover 60% of your energy need with batteries (every 1% of wind needs 0.6% of batteries), but in the 50/50 mix scenario the 50% of wind only needs to cover 10% with batteries (i.e. every 1% of wind needs 0.2% of batteries)

In reality there will be other things, like you might also have burst-gas power etc.

I'm not saying the numbers above are correct - just trying to show in theory that a mix / base load can still help reduce the level of batteries/storage required and make the energy mix more economic.

Closi··on UK's first small nuclear power station to be built in north Wales
> You can see on the map at the bottom of this page that almost all the batteries are in areas that already have high amounts of renewables:

It could be - but the battery investments map also align with the map below which shows that these states (Texas & California) are also states suffering from blackouts.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/power-outag...

So while this could mean that storage is cheap, it could also mean 'Texas's mix and grid is unstable, particularly as it's not connected to the national grid, and this has opened the opportunity to profit from higher levels battery arbitrage that doesn't exist in a better balanced grid'

Closi··on UK's first small nuclear power station to be built in north Wales
> Net result renewables currently save you money until ~80% annual electricity supply. At which point adding more batteries and generation to cover overnight demand is cheaper than adding nuclear to the mix.

Assume you mean more expensive than nuclear in the second point?

Agree with your point although it's about wind in the uk rather than solar, and about being able to last a few weeks if there is calm weather rather than a day without sun, which is when having a nuclear baseload makes sense.

Closi··on UK's first small nuclear power station to be built in north Wales
> This is shortsighted because [...] electricity renewables are cheaper than nuclear

This is an oversimplification - Renewables are cheaper than nuclear, but they are also less reliable than nuclear in the sense that when the wind stops blowing, power stops being generated. Also if you include the cost of energy storage to survive a week or two without substantial wind, suddenly it's not the cheaper anymore.

A mixed nuclear + renewables grid would reduce the total cost because nuclear can provide a stable base load which isn't affected by seasonality. Modern plants can also ramp up/down to some extent to balance the overall system.

That's why you need an energy mix rather than just putting all your eggs in a single source.

Closi··on Nano Banana can be prompt engineered for nuanced AI image generation
To be honest this is the sort of thing Nano Bannana is weak at in my experience. It's absolutely amazing - but doesn't understand left/right/up/down/shrink this/move this/rotate this etc.

See below to demonstrate this weakness with the same prompts as the article see the link below, which demonstrates that it is a model weakness and not just a language ambiguity:

https://gemini.google.com/share/a024d11786fc

Closi··on Codemaps: Understand Code, Before You Vibe It
> AI will never know the why behind the architecture, it will only take it at face value.

There is no reason to believe that at some point in the future AI will know the business context for apps when they are vibecoded (because the prompts should contain the business context).

Closi··on J.P. Morgan's OpenAI loan is strange
Amazon?

https://www.seattletimes.com/business/amazon-pays-off-its-hi...

Closi··on J.P. Morgan's OpenAI loan is strange
Also 5% would be a ridiculously low rate for this sort of corporate finance. You would expect more like 8-12% I think?

Plus the post seems to only include 1 year of interest.

Unless we know the terms, I don't think we can necessarily calculate EV from JP Morgan's perspective. I would say that they aren't usually carelessly giving away money though... They probably have terms where they can get out early if OpenAI's position weakens etc.

Closi··on Most users cannot identify AI bias, even in training data
I don't know if I agree in this instance. While I agree that Black people completely have a shared identity and culture - the article is clearly talking about skin colour and it's doing a comparison between how AI represents two skin tones, so I would assume that by your definition it should use lowercase in both cases.

If it's comparing a culture vs a 'non-culture' then that doesn't sound like for like.

Closi··on Bots are getting good at mimicking engagement
That depends - scrapers are currently annoying and temperamental and you have to maintain them. Also the idea of allowing some random person from Fiverr to write some code you are going to have running in your infra that has access to your webshop, ERP and the open internet isn't usually that palatable to most IT teams.

A simple and reliable API? That's different.

Closi··on Bots are getting good at mimicking engagement
The counterpoint is 'Why hand your competitors data on a silver plate'?

Sure you might be willing to build the bot to scrape it... but some other competitors won't go to this effort so it still means a bit of information asymmetry and stops some of your competitors poaching customers / employing various marketing tactics to exploit short term shortages or pricing charges etc.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →