HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Closi

9,073 karma · joined May 10, 2020

submissionscomments
Closi··on Hacking the Humane AI Pin
While I agree it was ultimately flawed, I think it's likely that the core team at Humane genuinely thought this was the future of computing, and clearly put in a lot of effort.

... And maybe something like this is, it was probably just too early.

Closi··on America is getting an AI gold rush instead of a factory boom
I know, that’s not what I was saying :)
Closi··on America is getting an AI gold rush instead of a factory boom
> Chinese people aren't stupid, they have been spending a fortune on automating as much of their manufacturing as possible!

Slight nuance - they have spent a [reasonable amount of money] automating production.

The trick to automating something that ‘isn’t a car’ is often to put in small bits of low-cost and flexible automation that can be moved around and repurposed. IMO this is often what we are bad at in the west - companies can/do setup massive automated sites at huge expense, but there aren’t the skills/infrastructure to do this at the lower end of production (eg if you want to deploy one AMR in the west the AMR companies don’t want to talk to you, and there isn’t really an easy way to get one yourself without talking to an integrator which will charge tens of thousands which will wipe out the benefit, and we don’t have the skills within most small production companies to get a small robot arm/AMR working without external integrators - but a one-AMR deployment might be a more common scenario in China).

Closi··on Oxford loses top 3 university ranking in the UK
I think they are referring to:

> Durham University improved by 30 places year-on-year in its students’ evaluation of teaching quality, which was the main driver in securing its third place in the overall university league table

Which isn't quite the same as 30 places in ranking as OP suggests, however I agree with their point that moving 30 places on that metric could be fairly suspicious.

For example - when I was at university in the UK we got a speech telling us basically that we were going to get sent a survey from the times, and the higher we ranked the university, the higher the universities ranking would be, and that would make our degree more valuable. If the main reason they jumped from 7th to 3rd could be a metric that is potentially 'influence-able' by the university, it could be more of a change in comms-strategy than actual university quality.

Closi··on Bringing fully autonomous rides to Nashville, in partnership with Lyft
Very true, although even at 2 or 3 drivers it’s still more than months.
Closi··on Bringing fully autonomous rides to Nashville, in partnership with Lyft
> maybe they are at around $200k/vehicle? That would be pretty easy to pay for a with a few months of rides.

The 'few months' bit doesn't seem quite right - the cost to get a human to drive a car would maybe be $50k per year, so i'm not sure how a $200k vehicle can pay itself off in a few months vs a $50k car + $50k per year driver.

I'm aware that the cost / ride is higher for Waymo, but it doesn't sound like that would be enough to cover the extra $200k and not certain that scales to other geographies outside of SF.

I mean to pay off a $200k vehicle in a few months you would need each car to be clearing $3k a day in revenue or something like that.

It's probably a few years per car if they are at $200k. If they are 'in the black' or not will probably depend more about their accounting rules (i.e. depreciation) more than anything else.

Closi··on iPhone Air
IMO the benefit of a local LLM on a smartphone isn't necessarily compute power/speed - it's reliability without a reliance on connectivity, it can offer privacy guarantees, and assuming the silicon cost is marginal, could mean you can offer permanent LLM capabilities without needing to offer some sort of cloud subscription.
Closi··on Are OpenAI and Anthropic losing money on inference?
I'm not entirely sure the analogy is fair - Amazon for example was 'ridiculed' for being hugely unprofitable for the first decade, but had underlying profitability if you removed capex.

As a counterpoint, if OpenAI were actually profitable at this early stage that could be a bad financial decision - it might mean that they aren't investing enough in what is an incredibly fierce and capital-intensive market.

Closi··on Mark Zuckerberg freezes AI hiring amid bubble fears
Exactly this - people that understood the field well enough to add new knowledge to it has to be a pretty decent signal for a research-level engineer.

At the research level it’s not just about being smart enough, or being a good programmer, or even completely understanding the field - it’s also about having an intuitive understanding of the field where you can self pursue research directions that are novel enough and yield results. Hard to prove that without having done it before.

Closi··on Why LLMs can't really build software
> All the other things he mentioned didn't rely on breakthroughs, LLMs really do seem to have reached a plateau and need a breakthrough to push along to the next step.

I think a lot of them relied on gradual improvement and lots of 'mini-breakthroughs' rather than one single breakthrough that changes everything. These mini-breakthroughs took decades to realise themselves properly in almost every example on the list too, not just a couple of years.

My personal gut feel is that even if the core technology plateau's, there's still lots of iterative improvement to go after on the productisation/commercialisation of the existing technology (e.g. improving tooling/ui/applying it to solving real problems/productising current research etc).

In electric car terms - we are still at the stage where Tesla is shoving batteries in a lotus elise, rather than releasing the model 3. We might have the lithium polymer batteries, but there's still lots of work to do to pull it into the final product.

(Having said this - I don't think the technology has plateau'd - I think we are just looking at it across a very narrow time span. If in 1979 you said that computers had plateau'd in 1979 because there hadn't been much progress in the last 12 months they would have been very wrong - breakthrough's sometimes take longer as technology matures, but that doesn't mean that the technology two decades from now won't be substantially different.

Closi··on What's the strongest AI model you can train on a laptop in five minutes?
I guess different small models will have different points/goals, but you can still have a small model with lots of training effort or a large model with little training effort.

I think the point of most (frontier) small models is usually to provide the best answer possible given small inference resources, rather than to reduce training time.

This is more of a toy model, so fun and an interesting project but it doesn't necessarily tell us what the art of the possible is for small models.

Closi··on What's the strongest AI model you can train on a laptop in five minutes?
I don’t think we should use an AI trained in 5 minutes on a laptop to infer what small models are capable of…

Sure they still have massive problems with hallucination, but this article doesn’t give us any more insight into that I don’t think!

Closi··on Why LLMs can't really build software
I assume you don’t use these models frequently, because there is a staggering difference in response quality from frontier LLMs compared to GPT 3.

Go open the OpenAI API playground and give GPT3 and GPT5 the same prompt to make a reasonably basic game in JavaScript to your specification and watch GPT 3 struggle and GPT 5 one-shot it.

Closi··on Gemini 2.5 Deep Think
> Suppose it can't. How will you know?

By finding and testing problems that o3 can't do on Deep Think, and also testing the reverse? Or by large benchmarks comparing a whole suite of questions with known answers.

Problems that both get correct will be easy to find and don't say much about comparative performance. That's why some of the benchmarks listed in the article (e.g. Humanity's Last Exam / AIME 2025) are potentially more insightful than one person's report on testing one question (which they don't provide) where both models replied with the same answer.

Closi··on Gemini 2.5 Deep Think
It's not particularly interesting if Deep Mind comes to the same (correct) conclusion on a single problem as o3 but costs more. You could ask gpt 2.5 and gpt4 what 1+1= and would get the same response with gpt 4 costing more, but this doesn't tell us much about model capability or value.

It would be more interesting to know if it can handle problems that o3 can't do, or if it is 'correct' more often than o3 pro on these sort of problems.

i.e. if o3 is correct 90% of the time, but deep mind is correct 91% of the time on challenging organisational problems, it will be worth paying $250 for an extra 1% certainty (assuming the problem is high-value / high-risk enough).

Closi··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
I’m not saying autopilot was a bad business decision - autopilot has fuelled sales and no doubt has been a great success and is amazing tech for being in consumers cars at fairly low cost.

I’m saying if the goal is to invent true robotaxis (because that’s the market you are going after) then I think waymo’s approach of following what works and cost-optimising later gets you there faster if you have enough funding.

Closi··on How Tesla is proving doubters right on why its robotaxi service cannot scale
Tesla Robotaxi is a classic case of premature optimisation - with Waymo they decided to deploy whatever technology worked best and did not cost-optimise at the start. Each Waymo vehicle is much more expensive than a Tesla, and has much more expensive sensors and compute.

Tesla on the other hand started with a load of constraints - smaller amounts of compute, cheaper sensors, needs to hit a price point as it will be installed in every vehicle sold - can't be $50,000 of dedicated self driving hardware per vehicle.

There are some scenarios where constraints lead to breakthroughs, but often for true-moonshot projects it is the opposite (see: Space shuttle, System/360, the manhattan project, LHC etc)

Closi··on Show HN: Kan.bn – An open-source alterative to Trello
Not a bug necessarily, but one of the key features of trello is multi-user editing which doesn't seem to work.

i.e. if I open two tabs, and edit one tab, the other tab doesn't update and visa-versa until refresh.

Closi··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
Maybe - but it will still probably be less than a junior dev.

You could probably hammer the most expensive cursor API all-day every-day and it would still be a fraction of the cost of a junior dev.

Closi··on Show HN: Kan.bn – An open-source alterative to Trello
oop found a security issue - you can abuse profile pictures to upload any file (e.g. to host malware if you were a bad actor!)

IMO don't think this is ready for production use in the slightest - but cool project!

Closi··on Show HN: Kan.bn – An open-source alterative to Trello
A few other trivial bugs I have found:

* Can create multiple workspaces with same name which then ticks both * Invite user seems to not work randomly or will not send the email * Cards with special characters like @ will just not be created, and won't show error messages.

Closi··on Show HN: Kan.bn – An open-source alterative to Trello
Just as a heads up, that roadmap you linked is broken.

The formatting looks all off for me on chrome mac (black bars) and then if I click on a card it opens a window but then doesn't load any data.

Also it looks like a bug that if you filter by some tags, then click a card, the filter gets reset.

This is 5 secs of testing on the one board you have publicly shared, so there might be a few bugs to iron out!

Closi··on AI is not our future
More cynically, they probably also know that the AI path is one that they can't win.
Closi··on Claude 4 System Card
> Given the cited stats here and elsewhere as well as in everyday experience, does anyone else feel that this model isn’t significantly different, at least to justify the full version increment?

My experience is the opposite - I'm using it in Cursor and IMO it's performing better than Gemini 2.5 Pro at being able to write code which will run first time (which it wasn't before) and seems to be able to complete much larger tasks. It is even running test cases itself without being prompted, which is novel!

Closi··on AI in my plasma physics research didn’t go the way I expected
I think this seems to be veering off into some specific ethical viewpoint about milk supply chains and production rather than an analogy for product vs process.

But personally I can't see how the popularity of oat and almond milk in indepenent coffee shops tells us that much about how people perceive the inner workings of chatGPT.

Closi··on Veo 3 and Imagen 4, and a new tool for filmmaking called Flow
I think this is a strange take - Technological advancements aren't mutual funds.

Of course it's an indicator of future performance - Not a guarantee, but certainly a indictator.

Closi··on AI in my plasma physics research didn’t go the way I expected
I like your analogy, but I don't think people even go "the cow gave this milk" - I think they tend to just go "mmmm yummy yummy milk"

People usually see the product rather than the process.

Closi··on Veo 3 and Imagen 4, and a new tool for filmmaking called Flow
Bill Gates saw computers and extrapolated that there would be one in every home, Gordon Moore produced Moores Law which literally extrapolated compute in the 60s and almost still holding, and you can extrapolate that GPT-5 will perform better than GPT-4, and that there will probably be a GPT-6 that will be even better than that.

Extrapolating that technology will get better in the future when it has got better in the past isn’t a sure bet, but it’s a reasonably reliable one.

Closi··on Veo 3 and Imagen 4, and a new tool for filmmaking called Flow
I don’t get how someone can look at these videos and think “wow there’s lots of flaws and it’s sloppy and no storytelling” rather than “holy smokes this stuff is improving fast!”

In 2 years we have moved from AI video being mostly a pipe dream to some incredible clips! It’s not what this is like now, but what will it be like in 10 years!

Closi··on AI in my plasma physics research didn’t go the way I expected
Totally agree.

Also the term 'LLM' is more about the mechanics of the thing than what the user gets. LLM is the technology, but some sort of automated artificial intelligence is what people are generally buying.

As an example, when people use ChatGPT and get an image back, most don't think "oh, so the LLM called out to a diffusion API?" - they just think "oh chat GPT can give me an image if I give it a prompt".

Although again, the term is entirely abused to the extent that washing machines can contain 'AI'. Although just because a term is abused doesn't necessarily mean it's not useful - everything had "Cloud" in it 10 years ago but that term was still useful enough to stick around.

Perhaps there is an issue that AI can mean lots of things, but I don't know yet of another term that encapsulates the last 5 years advancements in automated intelligence, and what that technology is likely to be moving forwards, which people will readily recognise. Perhaps we need a new word, but AI has stuck and there isn't a good alternative yet, so is probably here to stay for a bit!

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →