HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Closi

9,073 karma · joined May 10, 2020

submissionscomments
Closi··on AI in my plasma physics research didn’t go the way I expected
I think AI is a useful term which usually means a neural network architecture but without specifying the exact architecture.

I think Machine Learning doesn't mean this as a word, as it can also refer to linear regression, non-linear optimisation, decision trees, bayesian networks etc.

That's not saying that AI isn't abused as a term - but I do think a more general term to describe the latest 5 years advancements in neural networks to solve problems is useful. Particularly as it's not obvious which model architectures would apply to which fields without more work (or even if novel architectures will be required for frontier science applications).

Closi··on Getting AI to write good SQL
Sure, but everyone knows humans end up bringing down the database too by writing an innocent looking test query nobody else blinks at, which is why you end up needing a testing strategy for ANY SQL before YOLO'ing into prod.
Closi··on Getting AI to write good SQL
If that’s the scenario, I would be asking why the testing pipeline didn’t catch this rather than why was the AI SQL wrong.
Closi··on OpenAI's Stargate project struggling to get off the ground, due to tariffs
I think there is a world where you have both - a portion of research sitting under constraints, and also massive computing capability to help build the next big model.

Put another way - I doubt OpenAI would have built GPT-3 faster if they had less compute.

Closi··on OpenAI's Stargate project struggling to get off the ground, due to tariffs
It’s not an either/or - it can be both!

If you have the best foundational research, but then find yourself blocked by compute, that’s a bad place to be in.

At the moment compute is a constraint too (at least for the smaller shops, maybe not OpenAI!)

We don’t necessarily know that the next AI breakthrough will need less compute either! A breakthrough that gives 5x performance for 20x training compute and 2x inference cost would still be a giant breakthrough and need a lot of hardware! Although this sort of breakthrough is unlikely, and it’s likely to be smaller steps forward - but I think it might be the case that models continue to get more computationally expensive even if there are breakthroughs that make models more efficient because we will want higher capability.

Closi··on Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans
Why can't it? I think you may have slightly misread my post in terms of the single cell aspect.

> First to file would not allow Ocado to have patented the concept of the robot sitting above a cell/tote

Ocado patented the concept of a robot sitting above a single cell/tote, not the concept of the robot sitting above a cell/tote.

AutoStore's initial system was the first to have the robot sitting above a stack of totes, however the robot sat above two cells in it's original design (a 'cantilever design'). The settlement actually means that AutoStore cannot develop a robot sitting above a single cell/tote (note that their blackline robots sit across a 'tote and a bit' because of this - see image https://www.prnewswire.co.uk/news-releases/autostore-sues-oc...).

There is lots of historical complexity as with all patent cases, but the AutoStore loss in court doesn't mean that Ocado didn't copy them - it just means that Ocado have been judged to be legally allowed to copy them IMO :)

> Ocado would be the poster child [for being] an unscrupulous licensor "stealing" an invention from the actual inventor.

They absolutely are the poster child for this in the material handling world! This is widely known in the logistics industry.

Closi··on Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans
I think the story is probably something like:

* AutoStore sold a solution to Ocado

* Ocado started modifying their own installation. AutoStore gave them the rights to do this naively thinking it was for their own use.

* Ocado started aggressively patenting their own modifications.

* Ocado then decides it’s going to build everything themselves, and also start selling their own version of the solution and compete directly with Autostore.

* Then the legal battle begins!

Broadly the main thing in contention is that Ocado patented the concept of the robot sitting above a single cell (ie tote). Autostore thinks this is obvious and shouldn’t have been allowed - their main reason for usually implementing a lower robot that sits across two cells is that it’s more reliable (lower centre of mass, simplified mechanics) but that they have now been blocked from just doing a smaller design of their original invention.

Autostore were probably naive at the time (they were still reasonably new to the automation market) and Ocado definitely had better patent lawyers - or at least as they were UK based had a better grip of UK patent law.

Closi··on Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans
Ocado's first automated warehouse installation was also purchased from Autostore (before they built their own solution, and now market/sell it)
Closi··on Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans
AutoStore losing a patent dispute doesn't mean that Ocado didn't copy them. Just looking at the patent dispute ignores that the first automated Ocado distribution centre was actually purchased from AutoStore, who had been selling their robot-digging tote system since 1996.

Ocado's initial patents as well were actually modifications of Autostore's robots, running on an Autostore grid, and Autostore manufactured the robots to Ocado's specification before Ocado decided to build the whole thing themselves.

So hard to argue that it wasn't a copy.

IMO I think the UK patent victory was a bit of a joke... Ocado's innovation of the robot above a single cell is both obvious, but also has it's own obvious downsides.

Closi··on Amazon's Vulcan Robots Now Stow Items Faster Than Humans
Not sure why Ocado gets so much credit for the latter though, they just copied AutoStore which has a fascinating history!

They purchased an AutoStore, then reverse engineered it, made a few changes, and claimed it as their own invention.

Closi··on Evolving OpenAI's Structure
It depends what you count as learning - you told it something, and it then applied that new knowledge, and if you come back to that conversation in 10 years, it will still have that new knowledge and be able to use it.

Then when OpenAI does another training run it can also internalise that knowledge into the weights.

This is much like humans - we have short term memory (where it doesn't get into the internal model) and then things get baked into long term memory during sleep. AI's have context-level memory, and then that learning gets baked into the model during additional training.

Although whether or not it changed the weights IMO is not a prerequisite for whether something can learn something or not. I think we should be able to evaluate if something can learn by looking at it as a black-box, and we could make a black-box which would meet this definition if you spoke to a LLM and limited it to it's max context length each day, and then ran an overnight training run to incorporate learned knowledge into weights.

Closi··on Evolving OpenAI's Structure
I'm not sure humans meet the definition here.

If you took the average human from birth and gave them only 'the most primitive first principles', the chance that they would have novel insights into medicine is doubtful.

I also disagree with your following statement:

> Right now we're trying to essentially train on the entire corpus of human writing. That is a defacto acknowledgement that the absolute endgame for current tech is simple mimicry

At worst it's complex mimicry! But I would also say that mimicry is part of intelligence in general and part of how humans discover. It's also easy to see that AI can learn things - you can teach an AI a novel language by feeding in a fairly small amount of words and grammar of example text into context.

I also disagree with this statement:

> One fundamental difference is that AGI would not need some absurdly massive data dump to become intelligent

I don't think how something became intelligent should affect whether it is intelligent or not. These are two different questions.

Closi··on Retailers will soon have only about 7 weeks of full inventories left
Why not tax the negative factors then, rather than the country of origin?

i.e. If the price is supposed to be a lever for labor conditions, why just tax China heavily and not Bangladesh?

Why tax more fuel-efficient European cars instead of American-Built Jeep Grand Cherokees?

And if reducing plastic waste is the priority, why would Trump's day include unbanning plastic straws?

Answer: It's not actually about reducing negative externalities, it's about geopolitics, otherwise it wouldn't be so negatively weighted towards a single actor.

Closi··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
Well AGI can write unit tests, write application code then run the tests and iterate - agents in cursor are doing this already.

Just not for more complex applications.

Code review does often find bugs in code…

Put another way, I’m not a strong dev but good LLMs can write lots of code with less bugs than me!

I also think it’s quite a “programmer mentality” that most of the tests in this forum about if something is/isn’t AGI ultimately boils down to if it can write bug-free code, rather than if it can negotiate or sympathise or be humerous or write an engaging screen play… I’m not saying AGI is good at those things yet, but it’s interesting that we talk about the test of AGI being transpiling code rather than understanding philosophy.

Closi··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
Why do human programmers need code review then if they are intelligent?

And why can’t expert programmers deploy code without testing it? Surely they should just be able to write it perfectly first time without errors if they were actually intelligent.

Closi··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
Although I think if you asked people 20 years ago to describe a test for something AGI would do, they would be more likely to say “writing a poem” or “making art” than “turning Xunit code to Tunit”

IMO I think if you said to someone in the 90s “well we invented something that can tell jokes, make unique art, write stories and hold engaging conversations, although we haven’t yet reached AGI because it can’t transpile code accurately - I mean it can write full applications if you give it some vague requirements, but they have to be reasonably basic, like only the sort of thing a junior dev could write in a day it can write in 20 seconds, so not AGI” they would say “of course you have invented AGI, are you insane!!!”.

LLMs to me are still a technology of pure science fiction come to life before our eyes!

Closi··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
You presumably understand the posters underlying point though - that the definition of 'general intelligence' does not need to be 'at above-average human level' and humans can be intelligent without being able to use a computer or do some sort of job on a VM.
Closi··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
This is an incredibly specific test/definition of AGI - particularly remembering that I would probably say an octopus classes as an intelligent being yet can't use outlook...
Closi··on GPT-4.1 in the API
The hallucination quantity and severity is way less in new frontier models.
Closi··on GPT-4.1 in the API
It's the whole answer being correct that's the important thing, and if you compare GPT 3 vs where we are today only 5 years later the progress in accuracy, knowledge and intelligence is jaw dropping.
Closi··on GPT-4.1 in the API
In comp sci it’s been deterministic, but in other science disciplines (eg medicine) it’s not. Also in lots of science it looks non-deterministic until it’s not (eg medicine is theoretically deterministic, but you have to reason about it experimentally and with probabilities - doesn’t mean novel drugs aren’t technological advancements).

And while the kind of errors hasn’t changed, the quantity and severity of the errors has dropped dramatically in a relatively short span of time.

Closi··on London's Heathrow Airport announces complete shutdown due to power outage
> Not denying it

Your original post did though!

Heathrow undoubtedly does the most air cargo. Sure express often comes into EMA on dedicated flights, but lots of freight comes in the hold of passenger aircraft, and that’s where Heathrow is king. The lack of passenger traffic is undoubtedly a key reason why EMA only does 1/5th of Heathrow’s air cargo, as as you have noted it’s ideally located to serve a lot of the UK.

Closi··on London's Heathrow Airport announces complete shutdown due to power outage
> 99% of air cargo to the UK does NOT come to Heathrow.

Not even slightly true - Heathrow carries over 50% of air freight and is a major hub.

(https://www.heathrow.com/company/cargo)

Closi··on Apple M4 MacBook Air review: I have no notes
Dragging downloads into the applications folder is 100% amazing imo!

It's because conceptually everything is supposed to be a standalone executable.

The windows alternative is random installers that put files all over your machine and then questionable uninstallers that still leave half the files discarded everywhere.

Closi··on Apple has locked me in the same cage Microsoft's built for Windows 10 users
Operating on battery power is usually a pretty crucial requirement for a tablet.
Closi··on Apple has locked me in the same cage Microsoft's built for Windows 10 users
As soon as I'm running virtualization to get an app to run the OS has already lost IMO.
Closi··on Apple has locked me in the same cage Microsoft's built for Windows 10 users
Windows OS is bad for a tablet compared to iPadOS.

iPadOS is bad as a laptop compared to Windows.

Nobody yet has been able to fully square the two different paradigms.

Closi··on Microsoft's new Dragon Copilot is an AI assistant for healthcare
This is Nuance, Microsoft acquired them in 2021 :)
Closi··on Launch HN: Roark (YC W25) – Taking the pain out of voice AI testing
Again though, verifying identity before sharing sensitive info shouldn’t be down to the LLM following its prompt - it should be enforced by design.
Closi··on Launch HN: Roark (YC W25) – Taking the pain out of voice AI testing
It looks great! Although the demo shows horrible security practices...

Clearly authentication shouldn't rely on prompt engineering.

Particularly when at the end of the demo it says "we have tested it again and now it shows that the security issue is fixed" - No it's not fixed! It's hidden! Still a gaping security hole. Clearly just a very bad example, particularly considering the context is banking.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →