HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ClumsyPilot

18,721 karma · joined November 3, 2017

submissionscomments
ClumsyPilot··on The missteps that led to a fatal plane crash at Reagan National Airport
This sounds very strange:

- What combat situation will require a military aircraft to be flying 30 meters from civilian jet doing routine flights?

- i don’t believe that there really is no technical solution to provide awareness to civilians of the presence and location of military aircraft without altering the pilot’s experience

- if it had told the Blackhawk crew a plane was way closer, the crew would still be alive. That’s like the whole point.

I have no expertise or n the area, but I can’t share the feeling that decision making is extremely poor, and sometimes it actually takes an outsider, who is free from groupthink and cope, to see that a decision is stupid.

ClumsyPilot··on Reports of the death of California High-Speed Rail have been greatly exaggerated
> me 0% chance of ever buying a home where I currently live

The housing crisis is the Everything Crisis. It’s destroying competence of government services, as no one ambitious will accept this fate.

It destroyed competitiveness of our industry because you can’t pay a worker less than it costs to rent.

It’s causing apathy and rise in extremist views among younger population as they realise they have no path to dignified future.

I am hoping that China does well for itself and one day we can just consider them as an example of competent and coherent governance and sort out our shit.

ClumsyPilot··on Reports of the death of California High-Speed Rail have been greatly exaggerated
> has been quietly shouting

That’s one hell of a contradiction

ClumsyPilot··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
You guys are basically on the path to be coming Russia.
ClumsyPilot··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
Is that a serious thesis anyone serious is entertaining ? Would that mean that you can defraud or kill a tourist with no consequences?
ClumsyPilot··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
You are basically saying that everybody has to help ICE for free and on occasion do the job of ICE for free. That’s very totalitarian.

At the same time, it is settled law that a police officer cannot be held liable for not protecting citizens or not arresting someone. So you have more obligations than a police officer yet getting none of the pay or legal protections

Imagine you were a private tutor, in a private school on private land. ICE barges into the class trying to arrest one of the kids, but their paperwork is not in order so they promised to come back in 20 minutes

Do you imagine it will be possible to continue with the lesson as normal after such an event?

It is your discretion, when to start or stop a lesson, you work for yourself.

Do you imagine you should be obligated as a teacher to continue the lesson as if nothing has happened?

And if children want to leave to hold them by force?

why is it your problem That ICE isn’t competent and can’t get their shit right the first time?

ClumsyPilot··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
No one is obligated to do ICE’s dirty work for them. Even most totalitarian countries don’t go that far.
ClumsyPilot··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
I am still waiting for a “corporations are people” to get death penalty
ClumsyPilot··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
> bill of rights only applies to citizens.

I could argue that it’s inhumane, contradicts all the values US claims to stand for, or could be used as a back door to harass citizens.

But ultimately fundamental issue is this - if you want to be a seat of global capital and finance, a global reserve currency and the worlds most important stock exchange, that is the price. Transnational corporations, their bosses and employees have to feel secure.

That is the only reason (often corrupt) businessman take their money from Russia, China, and other regimes that do not guarantee human rights and bring it to the west.

ClumsyPilot··on The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2
But we aren’t car business, am we are in joker business.

When was the last time producer of an app was held legally accountable for negligence, had to pay compensation and damages, etc?

ClumsyPilot··on Librarians are dangerous
This is both a non-sequitor and a confabulation.

Kids that don’t grow up with their parents do not learn them as first words. Kids that do grow up with their parents, often still learn something else as their first words.

Learning X as your first word does not prove that X is a foundational unit of society, it simply does not follow.

ClumsyPilot··on Librarians are dangerous
> if your father and a police officer give you conflicting orders, who do you obey?

This goes to show that you, along with many other commenters here, do not grasp the concept because it’s so different from your experience.

Extended family would often raise your kids, I know a person that was taken away by extended family as a child because the father had anger management issues.

They are not functionaries like police, they actually share responsibility. In case of conflict, loyalty is highly situational. And if your mother dies, they would be expected to take you in, even if your father is alive and well.

ClumsyPilot··on Librarians are dangerous
This is mostly a fiction.

Nuclear family has never had primacy - look at wild, dangerous places, primacy is held by extended family, clans, tribes or mafia.

‘Nuclear family primacy’ exists only In carefully crafted stable and safe societies, and another authority must exist to organise military-age men for matters of war and survival.

Thus nuclear family can only exist as we know it, in a partially undermined condition.

ClumsyPilot··on The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2
Yeah, about that, businesses are pushing and introducing code written by AI/LLM now, so now you won't even know what your own code does.
ClumsyPilot··on The Web Is Broken – Botnet Part 2
> Have you audited this code?

Wrong question. “Are you paid to audit this code?” And “if you fail to audit this code, who’se problem is it?”

ClumsyPilot··on I passionately hate hype, especially the AI hype
Blockchain provides more utility to people living in sanctioned countries, countries with unstable currencies and to criminals than AI ever could.
ClumsyPilot··on I passionately hate hype, especially the AI hype
I like this approach, the challenge us that without a good grasp of finance it is really hard to leverage these opportunities
ClumsyPilot··on Snapchat is harming children at an industrial scale?
That’s the same geofencing by another authority
ClumsyPilot··on Snapchat is harming children at an industrial scale?
Perhaps, but my point is it's not 'humans communicating freely', the strange thing I see is not my choice.
ClumsyPilot··on Snapchat is harming children at an industrial scale?
It sounds like extremely convenient offloading of responsibility for a toxic product
ClumsyPilot··on Snapchat is harming children at an industrial scale?
> Let humans communicate freely, some of them will do bad things.

That’s just normal phone calls - no one is complaining about those.

But social networks have algorithms that promote one kind of content over another.

I keep getting recommended YouTube videos of gross and mostly fake pimple removal, on Facebook AI generated fake videos of random crap like Barnacle removal, and google ads for an automated IoT chicken coop.

I have never searched for these things and no living person has ever suggested such things to me. The algorithm lives its own life and none of it is good.

ClumsyPilot··on Snapchat is harming children at an industrial scale?
> CEO’s and founders just moan that it isn’t possible to regulate

Surely if a CEO with a billion dollar budget can’t regulate it, neither can a parent?

ClumsyPilot··on Snapchat is harming children at an industrial scale?
Don’t we geofence sale of alcohol and tobacco around schools?
ClumsyPilot··on Google is illegally monopolizing online advertising tech, judge rules
> One where the market maker is taking up the cost of providing a market

Does a landlord on a literal physical market take 30% of revenue? I find that unlikely.

How did we arrive here, where supposedly ‘efficient’ digital marketplace is a form of rent higher than actually building physical rent, and expenses on wages and materials for a typical business?

ClumsyPilot··on Scientists pioneer chemical process to repurpose rubber waste
Don’t we already have bioplastics?

It appears we should be able to make appropriate compound if that were our top priority. It just sint

ClumsyPilot··on AI used for skin cancer checks at London hospital
> Do all cases in the UK start with a GP?

yes, and in the entire GP practice they do not have a single device invented in the 21st century. All the tools they have are a stethoscope, oxymeter, otoscope, blood pressure monitor, basically stuff you might have at home

They can't, for example, do a rapid antigen test or a lateral flow test, ultrasound or anything else you may consider a sign of modern medicine and diagnostics. Stuff countries in Eastern Europe and East Asia have already adopted.

Their diagnostic conclusion is heavily influenced by a spreadsheet that lists statistic probability of illness for different demographics, as advised Mckinsey.

If you happen to have a serious condition but fall into a group that is 'suppose to be' healthy (young man with Pneumonia) you will be bounced and told to go home until your condition deteriorates.

They will gatekeep you from getting an X-ray. When your condition deteriorates and is incontrovertible you will be taken seriously, but now you need serious treatment instead of a quick round of antibiotics.

Popular opinion in Britain is that the NHS is great, but it's overburdened. But it's fallen behind - management practices are archaic, diagnostics is poor, and there is lack of accountability and first reaction to medical errors is to brush off the patients / victims.

Over the past few decades, the first reaction of NHS management is to cover up their mistakes.

Just read the Wiki page about Great Ormond Street Hospitalk, the hospital that treats the country's most severely ill children:

> Great Ormond Street Hospital was involved in a scandal regarding the removal of live tissue and organs from children during surgery and onward sale to pharmaceutical companies without the knowledge of parents in 2001

Or the case with bone surgeon Yaser Jabbar, at the same hospital, who caused severe harm to 22 children and the hospital fought the parents and brushed issues under the carpet. Issues like removing wrong organ and getting length of a foot wrong by 20 centimeters. He operated on 700 children before someone put a stop to it

ClumsyPilot··on Supervisors often prefer rule breakers, up to a point
> nobody is required to help you, even the government

Seems very convenient, what am I paying taxes for then?

ClumsyPilot··on How to distrust a CA without any certificate errors
What are you trying to say?

A company only exists as legal fiction created by government bureaucrats.

Governments regularly issue documents about these companies, I.e. certificate of incorporation.

How is this any different?

ClumsyPilot··on Portugal Drops Plans for F-35 Citing U.S. Political Uncertainty
Russia/ukraine war shows that quantity and availability of equipment is ans important as features/quality.

Suppose that 4 grippers can be bought for the price of 1 F35. That will be more combat missions andgreater contribution to defence

ClumsyPilot··on First ammonia-fueled ship hits a snag
This risk factor sounds less like a normal chemical substance and more on the level of uranium
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →