HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CrackerNews

90 karma · joined September 18, 2019

submissionscomments
CrackerNews··on Czech president signs law criminalising communist propaganda
Banning the promotion of authoriarisnism and all forms of hatred is vague and could blowback onto the original writers of this legislation.
CrackerNews··on Czech president signs law criminalising communist propaganda
The state exists in the first place because it has a monopoly on violence. Doesn't matter whether it is democratic republic, fascist, or Marxist-Leninist. For MLs, violence is wielded on behalf of a state capitalism that constitutes itself of local governments based on local workplaces.

Money historically is a substitute for a form of violence through blood debts. The USSR believed money could be replaced with restricted labor vouchers to get rid of profit incentives and better direct economic flow more efficiently. However, this central planning approach failed to integrate itself in the rapidly growing pace of global trade, leading the Soviet bloc to be outpaced by the first world.

The example of democratic socialism or Israel has a nuance because state capitalism by nature cannot extract profits and surplus value as well as private enterprises, but they must exist alongside them and compete instead of existing in a wholly separate economy like the Soviet bloc did.

CrackerNews··on The United States withdraws from UNESCO
There are several reasons. First, developers are threatened by foreign competition and that third feels that Trump would protect them. Second, this presidency represents a change from previous DEI policies and that third may benefit from it. Third, they feel previous administrations were too soft on crime around their neighborhoods, and their tolerance for permissiveness ran out. They want action done to benefit them at any cost.
CrackerNews··on Nintendo Switch 2 account bans continue: warning after buying old copy of Bayo 3
Can this claim be verified?
CrackerNews··on Trump says both Iran and Israel violated a ceasefire
Why don't you simply say sociopathy instead of Asperger's, which has been merged with autism?
CrackerNews··on How long it takes to know if a job is right for you or not
I wonder what society would look like once it becomes common to trust your gut instincts. It used to be that you never judge a book by its cover, but now that is increasingly never the case.

I think we'd find a broken society that becomes even more broken without anyone wanting to fix it. It'd more profitable to destroy and rebuild under a new regime.

CrackerNews··on RAG Is a Fancy, Lying Search Engine
This, to me, reads more like an issue with the fundamental LLM technology rather than RAG in particular.
CrackerNews··on Discord Considered Harmful
When was Discord not considered harmful?
CrackerNews··on "Make in India" Relies on "Made in China"
With the example of the USSR and China, central planning excels for an initial industrialization. The state of Indian industry now is that where China has difficulty outsourcing to the region.

I remember an article linked on this site praising India for not relying on electricity for industrial labor, but that is a sign of underdevelopment of infrastructure. Infrastructure is something that is usually invested in by the state.

Culture is a major reason, and cultural revolutions were a method to reorient the population to a new societal goal. An Indian mentality can be summed up as "doing the needful" without questioning what it is.

CrackerNews··on That $5 McDonald's value deal might not be cheap enough
As they say, the customer is king and McDonald's sales slumped for the first time since 2020.
CrackerNews··on The Deep and Enduring History of Universal Basic Income
I think if you follow where the money goes, that will be whether UBI causes inflation or not. In the best case, it results in a virtuous cycle where growth is created and sustained. In the worst case, it further inflates the value of low supply goods. This will most likely be up to market conditions along with business models/strategies and productive capabilities of various industries and marketplaces and how they will weigh out.

In the example of housing however, I don't think UBI will help because the business model is dependent on inflating prices of homes as investment vehicles. The price must go up one way or another. What actually bring home prices down would be something like a market crash where investment expectations are muted.

Cheaper labor however comes from offshore countries that have a lower standard of living. If average wages go up, then domestic workers will expect that as a baseline. A business can pay above the average for above average workers, and vice versa. The expectation of hiring cheaper immigrant labor is getting the same level of expertise for cheaper. This does not always go to plan, which is why there is still some demand for domestic workers and their expertise. Automation may have a similar effect but without the same virtuous cycle to offshore countries as before. (Not to mention that the difference between revenue and cheaper labor cost is incentivized to be kept as business profits, which doesn't mean that prices go down since demand and supply now expects higher prices as the market baseline.)

CrackerNews··on The teen mental illness epidemic is international (2023)
Someone's suffering a problem? Sounds like they should pull themselves up by their bootstrap. /s
CrackerNews··on IT employment grew by just 700 jobs in 2023
This is ignoring that there's profit driven enshittification replacing talent with overworked and cheap overseas workers. Increasingly higher salaries are being replaced by cheaper salaries, and the results show in quality.
CrackerNews··on Why Socialism? (1949)
I find the subjective argument too abstract for practical use. All the subjectivity in the world must come to head with reality and how it can be enforced in reality. I am of the opinion that logistics wins wars, and labor theory of value, with its flaws, is able to provide a sense of direction for me to act on. Maybe I can bet on an asymmetry of needs with someone wanting to raise a family with me if I was unemployed and they did all the work, but I have the impression that a partner would appreciate me being able to help with the work too.
CrackerNews··on Why Socialism? (1949)
I thought value wasn't price? The way to salvage labor theory is really to turn it into macroeconomics where the labor value is amortized, which does restrict it as an applicable theory.
CrackerNews··on Why Socialism? (1949)
Yet there are drug and mental health crises, and there are families whose quality of life hasn't improved since the last recessions. I don't believe that progress is so neatly linear, and the Hegelian philosophy behind Marx attempts to capture that, IMO.

Labor theory of value does have issues, but I don't think it can be so neatly dismissed either as alternatives appear to have vague criteria for what contributes to value.

CrackerNews··on Why Socialism? (1949)
I would say that Marx and labor theory of value are still relevant as mechanisms for understanding capitalism. According to Marx, Capitalism is a mode of economics that has unleashed the productive forces, but its internal contradictions give rise to increasing crisises. There is a constant downward pressure on labor costs versus rising costs of living.

Crisis has been averted multiple times, and the productive forces continue to be unleashed. To prevent total collapse, concessions like welfare have been made.

However, there is a real possibility of potential growth being stifled by self interests of powerful economic actors. This bleeds out now into identity politics as people view the liberal system as incapable of providing the growth and future they thought would be delivered. Either unprivileged groups want to be paid high wages or the privileged groups want to protect their high wages from being cut down. This is a form of class warfare that isn't too different from what Marx observed in his days.

This still is far away from achieving the socialist mode of production where the workers become the planner and rulers of the economy to further unleash the productive forces.

CrackerNews··on How South Korea’s birth rate dropped below Japan’s
It's arguable that Japan helped South Korea industrialize by offloading industries it could no longer afford due to rising wages.

This article is about analyzing the comparison raised between South Korea and Ukraine, but it is largely about analyzing how South Korea industrialized from Japan's assistance.

https://eventsinukraine.substack.com/p/the-ukraine-south-kor...

CrackerNews··on Secret Pakistan cable documents U.S. pressure to remove Imran Khan
Kind of hard to argue for the least bad when there's been pro-US death squads cracking down on their opposition.
CrackerNews··on Secret Pakistan cable documents U.S. pressure to remove Imran Khan
For one, Ukraine used to have Russian business interests but now that's considered poison, there is room for US businesses to move in. Blackrock, for example, is helping out with war reconstruction.

https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/28/zelenskyy-blackrock-ceo-fink...

CrackerNews··on Secret Pakistan cable documents U.S. pressure to remove Imran Khan
Speaking of cables, there were leaked US diplomatic cables warning about instability in Ukraine if it were to join NATO.

https://www.businessinsider.com/wikileaks-russia-cable-2014-...

Not to justify the invasion, but the concerns were known back in 2008.

CrackerNews··on Twitter’s Rebrand to X Could Be a Trademark Nightmare Thanks to Microsoft
He is successful but there has been questionable decisions made at both SpaceX and Tesla, such as the recent launchpad destruction or the issues with self driving. In both of these examples, Musk has decided to move fast and break things despite objections. The media started exposing these issues when their feud with Musk started, IMO.
CrackerNews··on Why Men Get So Few Matches on Dating Apps [video]
There are different interpretations on equality, and I would say that the inequality in dating markets are a result of the markets as opposed to "nature."

Marriage used to be a familial tool for economics and politics, but it has shifted to being for "love." Did "nature" change or is it culture? However, "love" is ambiguous but some of its reasons seem to have roots in the old ways, such as money, power, or prestige. A person can be good looking and charming, but they need to be capable of providing for their partner. It would be rational for women to select for the best fit, and the imbalance of salaries could influence the imbalance in the dating market.

CrackerNews··on French Police Will Be Able to Spy on People Through Their Cell Phones
This is overly reductive and ignores any other possible contributing factors. There is still the unresolved discontent behind the previous riots before the current ones.
CrackerNews··on Americans have quit quitting their jobs
I don't even make that much as an engineer in my 30's. Poor people can technically get by, but there are a lot of sacrifices involved. It's understandable that a lot of people aren't willing to make them.
CrackerNews··on Americans have quit quitting their jobs
So unions are "rent-seeking" from the shareholders who want to profit from extracting surplus value from their labor. Should labor not be able to use their surplus value in the free market?

The collapse of American manufacturing and industry could also be traced to outsourcing abroad, which devastated American labor and unions and resulted in profits for the shareholders from the reduced labor costs.

There is also the financialization of industry as represented by a shift of management techniques away from industry to finance in order to boost share values. Eventually industry runs into reduced returns in growth, but finance provides new schemes to create profit based off of speculation on the future.

CrackerNews··on North Koreans speak secretly to BBC from inside closed country
I think the article has mistaken markets, trade, and side hustles for capitalism. These things existed before capitalism and may still exist after. Capitalism is private ownership over the means of production, and I am not sure how much ownership common people can have in a country that owns everything.

What is present here is that NK is supposedly centrally planning the economy, but there are gaps which are filled by the black markets.

CrackerNews··on North Koreans speak secretly to BBC from inside closed country
Capitalism is best described as both progressive to the past and regressive to a better future it prevents. The tension of NK running a revolutionary and ideological state and surviving in global geopolitics led them down this path. The more ideological would see this as biding their time for their enemies to collapse under the weight of their contradictions. However, the people in this article want to live a better world now. Unfortunately, the world and realpolitik is messier than fulfilling human desires.
CrackerNews··on North Koreans speak secretly to BBC from inside closed country
There is still a benevolence angle when it comes to things like providing free healthcare, but even here food supply has been a problem.
CrackerNews··on North Koreans speak secretly to BBC from inside closed country
The harsh reality is that NK defectors could end up being second class citizens in the South or wish to return back [0].

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/apr/26/forever-strang...

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →