HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CrackerNews

90 karma · joined September 18, 2019

submissionscomments
CrackerNews··on North Koreans speak secretly to BBC from inside closed country
Countries like NK view foreign aid with skepticism over possible espionage, unfortunately.
CrackerNews··on Apple Vision Pro: The MVP for AR
I remembering reading about a 90 degree FOV which if true, will limit its use for AR and wearing it all the time.

The Glasshole style remarks probably won't go away with the Vision Pro either. Not to mention the potential of being robbed of the headset in public.

CrackerNews··on Apple Vision Pro: The MVP for AR
This could end up being like the Post-PC paradigm that the iPad was supposed to herald in. My last experience with the iPad a couple years ago was mostly interacting with iPhone apps with few iPad apps fully taking advantage of the platform. Vision Pro could end up in a similar boat with respect to the spatial computing paradigm.
CrackerNews··on Apple Vision Pro: The MVP for AR
My question is how easily portable a laptop experience is to Vision Pro? At the very least you might have to be tethered to a Mac, and that seems like barely scratching the surface compared to porting iPad apps to visionOS.
CrackerNews··on Ex-ByteDance exec: Communist Party had ‘God credential’
Arguing about surveillance oppression Olympics in who has it worst and downvoting each other over it is like missing the forest for the trees.
CrackerNews··on Ex-ByteDance exec: Communist Party had ‘God credential’
An opaque process of secret courts with secret decisions may be different legally, but in spirit it does not seem that significantly different to me in terms of preventing overreach and abuse.
CrackerNews··on Ex-ByteDance exec: Communist Party had ‘God credential’
The difference is more like the US is held by corporate business interests while China is under firm control by the Party. They both however end up having opaque government apparatuses for surveillance and control (with differing characteristics of course).
CrackerNews··on 10 years after Snowden's first leak, what have we learned?
To me, it appears that Glenn Greenwald is calling out the politicization/weaponization of trans rights by powerful political and corporate interests. This is where he finds a common footing with the fringe right and gives pause to people in the institutional left, which may rely on these interests for funding.
CrackerNews··on Elon Musk says ‘get off your work-from-home bullshit’
On the flip side, capitalism can enable greed to a global level never before seen, and communism (as in communist states as opposed to "True Communism") can enforce a level of fairness given the limited resources. The former can dominate entire countries and create banana republics, and while the latter can inflict misery, it is not on the level of complete failed states where senseless violence roam the streets.
CrackerNews··on Elon Musk says ‘get off your work-from-home bullshit’
Prioritizing profits is a part of capitalism. Capitalism is simply the private ownership of the means of production, but the interests of the capital owner are to use capital to accumulate wealth, which leads to exploitation of labor being a method. This is especially so versus the falling rate of growth as an industry matures. The tendency of capitalism then is to consolidate into an oligarchy of major dominant corporations and conglomerations, which is that aforementioned cancerous growth.

Capitalism won out over previous modes because it outcompeted them. Granting laborers some economic power (as opposed to slavery or serfdom) turned out to be an enabler for economic growth.

In the example of WFH, markets could end up winning out in the end as new telework industries outcompete the prior office commute industries. This could end up enabling innovation to be untethered and accelerate.

CrackerNews··on Fall of the Berlin Wall on Usenet (1989)
East Germany has continued being economically weaker than the West, which would make them more prone to more radical ideologies in the absence of the prior far-left one. If anything, a historical gradualist Deng Xiaoping figure would mean acclimation and full development towards a finding a self-sufficient niche in a globalized market economy, not a wind down from hardline pro-Russian party apparatuses (who apparently were responsible for a post-unification far-right party?). Many dissatisfied East German youth would support the Euroscepticism of the AfD because they haven't experienced the full promises of prosperity from the collapse of the DDR and the victory of the West-led order.
CrackerNews··on Dr. Mengele, USA Style: Lessons from Human Rights Abuses in America [pdf] (2022)
I agree. People confuse imperialism with Nazism too easily. It's not necessarily that society is controlled by Nazis, but that imperialism is considered (by Lenin) as the highest stage of an economic system driven by the continual growth of capital.

To tie things back, the OP cites a liberal empire as a possible solution to the problem of US-style Dr. Mengeles, but I see the empire overriding the liberal in the first place.

The focus on "the Nazis", absent of serious analysis of the philosophical context that gave rise to them, can end up ignoring what made people believe in the ideology in the first place. There's a particular mythological victimhood for Nazis where the only way to break free is to create their own empire to subjugate (and exterminate) who they viewed as parasites. This ends up being highly problematic when people groups are viewed essentially only as good as their stereotypical economic function.

A liberal empire isn't concerned with rectifying people's economic function outside of markets and incentives. This leaves wiggle room for exploitation that lead to the US-style Dr. Mengeles experimenting on poor people (which also has a racial element since minorities can tend to be poorer.)

CrackerNews··on Privacyguides.org – The guide to restoring your online privacy
I don't know how much spite is behind a complete communication breakdown between the founder and the team that joined him.

The founder felt unhappy about working with his team and ceased all communication. The team felt concerned about this bus factor and wanted to retain the fruits of their labor.

I would say it's understandable that the founder missed being solely independent and that the team wanted to make sure that their organization is more durable. A separation was inevitable and inevitably full of drama. At least both sides roughly ended up with what they wanted.

CrackerNews··on Privacyguides.org – The guide to restoring your online privacy
I would like to know more about the Signal issue too.

If these issues are that much of a concern, then perhaps they could be brought up. Privacy Guides seems transparent about the discussions they have behind their decisions, unless I am mistaken.

CrackerNews··on Vacations in the Soviet Union
It's the "intellectual junk food" behind the USSR and China turning from backwards peasant conditions to rival global powers. Orthodox Marxist theory States that society must be advanced enough to reach a socialist phase. The nature of the class-based Hegelian dialectics that leads to communism is nebulous and unclear IMO, but I interpret it as something like the fall of feudalism.
CrackerNews··on Vacations in the Soviet Union
At this point it's about a desire for rational economic planning versus a capitalist system that they view as increasingly incapable of addressing broader 21st century problems such as climate change.
CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
The ideological stupidities were motivated by the goal of economic development. Stalin thought kulaks' economic interests were holding back the centralizing industrialization of agriculture through collectivization. Mao wanted to move from a peasant-based economy to industrial-based through the great leap. (The cultural revolution was a populist cudgel to make the Western educated intellectuals adapt and submit to the local Chinese conditions.)

---

I wouldn't lean on wartime subsidies too much because they are extraordinary circumstances. The USSR focused on self-sufficiency to the point of foreign trade only being 4% of GDP in 1985. China started opening up after Nixon normalized relations.

CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
The goals of communism are to resolve class contradictions, which "naturally" happened in the case of feudalism ending. Communist states attempt to accelerate and resolve them through stages. This is where they can seem "unnatural".

On the flip side, there may not be anything to inherently prevent capitalism from doing similar things too. The USSR tried to have a much more planned and state managed version of capitalism to progress through the stages of socialism. The central planners decided where profits went instead of private property holders. If these property holders were to have control of a political system, then there is the potential they could enforce similar things.

CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
The political system was democratic centralism where there are levels of indirect democracy starting from the local levels of factories and villages, which elect up to a legislature, which elects an executive top command. Power is indirect granted bottom-up but decisions are wide-spreading from top-down. Ironically, there's a level of decentralization in China that's tolerated as long as they meet government goals. (I'd say at times it's too decentralized, so bad behavior is too tolerated as long as it achieves economic directive goals.)
CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
If you really want to get into details, it's Marxist-Leninism. Much of the Soviet-style political system came from Leninist theories of achieving Marxist goals. Lenin said it himself, it's state capitalism. (Stalin then called his implementation first stage of socialism.)
CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
In the USSR and China, the large scale deaths were linked to failures during economic development. Despite the failures, there were improvements in quality of life. (The CIA factbook about USSR nutrition being on par or better than the West being one example.) They end up being a class ahead of the poorest of the third world. The issue was that the USSR did not catch up to the leaps the West made. China is catching up using their illiberalism to enforce protectionism and national economic development. If anything, this seems to emphasize that economic development requieres global trade, and this was an issue with the USSR and early China.
CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
Part of Mao's enduring legacy was his concept of the party line adapting to the will of the masses, and the sparrow extermination campaign was a failure in adapting the party line to this farmer discontent too well.

Mao did change Chinese culture, but it was by purging Western-style intellectuals and promoting mass organization to take command from the bottom-up, because he saw people on the ground being more correct than intellectuals who might not apply their learning to the actual conditions.

The successors after Mao adopting Deng Xiaoping's liberal attitudes towards economic development can be seen as a Party rebuke of Mao's policies. Yet they will still uphold Mao's legacy.

CrackerNews··on Killing sparrows led to famines in China
While there are dangers to bad top-down management, the criticisms laid out in this thread can still apply to the CPC and Chinese mainland society today, but they don't suffer from famines on the same level anymore.

I don't think they disagree with the goal and intent of rapidly industrializing China from peasant-based into urban workers. They will still uphold Mao's legacy even if they disagreed with his excesses and failures. They are about economic development because it is a required stage for their goal of achieving socialism and communism. Economic development is their longterm planning and "working science."

CrackerNews··on People with severe mental illness have been failed by a dysfunctional system
It would come down to the law to dictate who has the final say in sending someone to a hospital. Or else the people making the decision they shouldn't be making open themselves up to being subject to legal punishment. (Which opens up another question of who can afford to...?)

The free market could incentivize bad faith operators even more because of the greater potential of the profit motive. Free market doesn't necessarily mean greater transparency or ethics.

CrackerNews··on Yes, it's OK to be mad about crime in San Francisco
I'm assuming low levels of trust and being scared that they could be next.
CrackerNews··on American IQ scores have rapidly dropped, proving the 'Reverse Flynn effect'
There's also a "Marxist-Leninist society" where it is a transitional one to socialism and communism like the USSR and China.
CrackerNews··on American IQ scores have rapidly dropped, proving the 'Reverse Flynn effect'
To make a long complicated story short, Marxism is the study of how class contradictions resolve themselves. Using Hegelian dialectics, it poses different classes against each other and theorizes what the synthesis would become. It could be said that this (and branching philosophies like critical theory) is the ultimate end result of Western philosophy, hence the leftward tilt of the humanities.

In an ideal sense, Marxist theory should be capable of updating itself to match actual conditions. In a degenerated dogmatic sense, it can be used to force actual conditions to fit within a narrow and false theory.

There is no end to the different interpretations of Marxism and the arguments and debates between them, because there's only so many real world examples that could be tested and examined.

Compared to an engineering problem, Marxist theory ends up touching so many fields and variables on a global scale that the problem space ends up being orders of magnitude greater. There's too much to examine and make sense of, so interpretations end up being strategies on how to navigate through this problem space and how to achieve Marxist theories and goals, either orthodixcally or heterodoxically.

In the example of that anthropologist, it does not go into detail with what the Marxists disagreed with. However, I think a Marxist argument could be made for the wars over women in that their society is of a more primitive stage where stealing women was a part of their socioeconomics. Their system works out so that a population equilbirum is achieved.

In works like Engel's On the Origin of the Family..., there is a Marxist interpretation of how humans orient themselves accordingly to the Marxist theory that the base economics form the superstructure of the culture and society. In more advanced societies, they went through agricultural revolutions that vastly increased the population and reshaped how societies must function to keep order.

Another example of Marxist theory gone wrong could be the USSR, and you have Marxists either defending or condemning it for various reasons. It could then be said that the Chinese Marxists learned from the USSR to create their own branched off lineage to prevent similar collapse and to forge their own path towards the Marxist stages of socialism and communism. (And of course you have Marxists condemning China too. Tl;Dr: the arguments are largely either China must develop before being advanced enough for socialism or China must advance to a socialist stage or else it will gravitate back towards complete capitalist control.)

Edit: That being said, while STEM has rigorous methodologies to verify truths, the fields can also be swept up by orthodoxies and heterodoxies and different interpretations. There's always been the derisive websh*t meme for fads on Hacker News. Or there's the unsolved problems in physics with different interpretations to resolve them. The scientific process did have its roots in philosophical developments after all.

CrackerNews··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
I have an issue with that sentiment because people do not directly vote for policies. They indirectly vote for a representative to enact policies, and the viable ones are backed by mass party apparatuses. Here, the Party's interests overrides the People's and dominate the political discussion. The Party is backed by a large network of corporate lobbyists. It's really that corporate personhood gets the government they deserve.
CrackerNews··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
Why not both? The governance could be horrible because its serving the political philosophy of the resident unequally rich to assuage their guilt over their unequal position in society while keeping their unequal position.
CrackerNews··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
California would be "I got mine, but we can make things more fair for you by lowering your standards and giving you measly benefits so the feudal stratification is okay."
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →