90 karma · joined September 18, 2019
Another way to look at it is home ownership becoming more of a pipe dream for newer generations. More investment will be needed in order to participate and reap from the housing market. This is over a basic human need of shelter.
There is a kernel of truth in that communism could not have existed so far, which is why communist states have went for a transitory approach. They could not leap to communism but they tried to work towards it and failed in many places.
For the Jewish Question, he shared some antisemitic views towards Judaism with his peers. The difference is that he advocated for their incorporation into society as opposed to being second class citizens. He believed that the transition from capitalism into communism would reform Judaism away from what they were antisemitic about.
I agree that Twitter was bloated with benefits, but this was the industry's rewarding of their labor aristocrats. It's unfair against anyone who couldn't make it there (like me too) but this is how the industry retained talent so far.
Now these benefits are being taken away. This may be fair to everyone else in the industry, and this is something big tech was already looking to cut during this economic turmoil.
Now this is the real point of contention with Elon Musk. Anyone who's left after morale exhausting job cuts is going to be worked to the bone. They have been enjoying benefits that they don't have anymore, but the wider industry also does not work people this hard.
Is it fair that the best companies should work their people this hard? At the very least this may return results quickly in the short-term to pay off the debt from buying Twitter, but how sustainable is this? Amazon Warehouses are the best in delivering packages quick, but they churn through workers through harsh conditions and they are running out of a labor pool to recruit from. Would Twitter be able to retain talent in the long run? Should the entire industry be run like this?
This then gets to the broader question of the recent societal trend you have been seeing. It's really a collective response to the question of whether society is taking care of the people working for keep it going. The answer for a lot of people is that society has been taking more and more from them. Their wages largely haven't been keeping up with increases in productively. Newer generations are being less economically involved than older ones. A foreign adverse nation does not have to be involved when the nation is already rotting from the inside and people can smell it.
The issue in countries where "socialism" (arguably indirect democracy state capitalism) took off were that they faced backwards conditions compared to the first world. ML provided the command economy to quickly divert investment for creating the nonexisting infrastructure necessary to be able to achieve more advanced modes of capitalism. This capitalistic step is necessary to build up the conditions for socialism according to a Marxist timeline of development. The Stalin model attempted to reinterpret a state control of capital as a socialism since it was in theory held responsible to the worker masses as opposed to private individual capital holders.
Perhaps, the fall of the USSR inro capitalism for better global trade and investment and the fall of Maoism into Dengism were rebukes of the Stalin model in being unable to sustain growth without global trade that first world capitalism benefits from. China however maintains the ML party control over the state and economy in order to maintain control over how capitalists invest and develop their country more for the Chinese benefit rather than the foreign country interest.
This is not as free and bottoms up as alternative models of socialism, but from a game theory perspective its hard to compete against a top down system of private capitalists and their democratic representatives without another top down system unless the economic circumstances do rapidly shift (perhaps in a Marxist manner where the economic forces destabilize the upper classes and the lower classes are empowered to grow the economy in a new way)
Whether the peasants would be oppressed is another can of worms topic, but I think it would be best expressed by growth rates of the USSR and China compared to their peers in similar conditions of industrial development.
My post is rather about that the invasion is the final nail in the seam between the pro-West and pro-Russia interests tearing apart, when I don't think that it had to happen. Of course, Putin is responsible for that final nail. His threat of invasion has long been known in a leaked Wikileaks cable, and I think that history could have followed a different path. I think it's similar to how the balance of power shifting quickly has led to blowback like the Iraq War leading to the creation of ISIS where the former generals of Saddam were disenfranchised and resorted to violence to establish an independent state and reclaim political power.
Of course there is the human cost of such rapid change, but I wonder if the swiftness was compacting human immiersation into a tighter time frame rather than having it evened out over a long period of time. Perhaps the huge economic disruption led to more overall immiseration? Or did the planners think that rapidness would have resulted in less overall immiseration like a trolley problem? If South Korea was an example, students depised the pro-industrialization military dictators, but later generations have started to appreciated the fruits and sacrifice of pro-industrialization.
Interestingly as a side note, North Korea has a more corn based agriculture out of necessity to adapt to the poorer agricultural conditions of the north versus south, which was traditionally the farmland of Korea.
However, I think that the decline of the USSR was in how they failed to capture the advantages of international trade (like Cuba or North Korea remaining in economic statis). The Chinese in the Deng faction instead chose to partake in international trade even if it meant that they had to become the sweatshop of the world. After that industrialization, they now under Xi can be pompous and choose to push their weight around given the power of their trade and autarky.
Holodomor (and the Chinese famine too) are of course tragedies to be wary of. I think one reason they occured was due to the planners being unaware of the economic incentives and effects on individual actors of their rapid industrialization plans. This resulted in the USSR then launching a war on kulaks and the Chinese launching a war on Westernized intellectuals to make them comply with their plan.
There's also a parallel in Russia with the post-Communist shock therapy leading to a new level of corruption. This led to Putin coming to power to reign in corruption (under his control) and bring about some stability against the shock therapy. Even now against the punitive sanctions for the Ukraine war, he's managing to keep the ruble stable and even increased its value.
I think US leaders like Trump will be the first among those who want to strongarm stability even if it dampens a liberal economic model. He reoriented the US economy towards a trade war with China as opposed to free trade, which did incentivize domestic development as opposed to outsourcing to China.
The US is about checks and balances instead, but it seems like in this gridlock that the Supreme Court is the de facto lawmaking body with it being able to make the recent sweeping political decisions of the US. There's also the rise of "Trumpism" (for the lack of a better word) where people want a strong leader to bend the rules and get things done with the most radical supporters acting extrajudicially. There are also radical anarchists on the other side acting extrajudicially too. I'm not too certain about how stable this system can be with the recession /inflation on top that's clawing away economic and financial gains of ordinary people that may end up radicalizing them.
With Arabs struggling to buy food, they may be wanting to replicate the economic success and rapid growth of the Chinese model as the end of the article says may happen in the uncertain future.
I think this also paints a potential future for other countries as economies become ravished by recession and inflation and war, with people wanting a strong authoritarian alternative against the usual democratic politics.