HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Czarnian

149 karma · joined October 5, 2011

submissionscomments
Czarnian··on Richard Stallman's Computer Setup
And how many of those things would be around if they weren't generating revenue for someone?

He's a living, breathing demonstration of the limits of free software. A world where progress slows to a crawl because the only people who have the time to write code are hobbyists and people who can get paid to lecture about how everything should be free.

That's the main issue I have with his ideas, they are thoroughly disconnected from reality. Not in a "Everyone should be nice to each other all the time way," but a "I'm going to ride my dragon to work," way.

Free software is a nice sentiment, but impotent. Nothing that has happened in the past 10-15 years in computers happens without a profit motive. Without a profit motive you may get a spreadsheet program, but no one motivated enough to get it distributed.

Free may get you on the path, but it doesn't get you very far down the road.

Czarnian··on Richard Stallman's Computer Setup
These days, if you ask someone for a phone and you are more than a few feet away from a landline, you're asking for a cell phone. To say otherwise is being disingenuous.

To me, it demonstrates a far less altruistic motivations.

Czarnian··on Richard Stallman's Computer Setup
Don't get them wrong: these people are not fanatic, they are just living and breathing a cause they started for a good reason.

AKA Fanaticism. He's become an inflexible, computerized hermit. His dogmatic adherence to a demonstrably untenable principal of "freedom" has relegated him a permanent state of pre-1995 digital stasis.

He's not principled, he's dogmatic. At best, he's a cautionary tale demonstrating the state of the world if he had his way.

Czarnian··on Dear business people, an iOS app actually takes a lot of work
You're right. The APIs don't need to be implemented, just documented.

I'll go you one further. It's better to work without a functioning API. With stubs and dummies, you can tightly control inputs and test way more effectively. If you're developing against an active api, you add a whole level of complexity that makes it that much harder to debug. I don't know how many hours I've wasted trying to find bugs that turned out to be outside the scope of what I was working on.

Czarnian··on Judge: Fifth Amendment doesn't protect encrypted hard drives
I was thinking along the same lines, but instead of wiping the file, it changes the password to a randomized 20 character string.

If you're doing anything that risks getting pinched, it's probably better to take the obstruction rap than whatever it is you're being investigated for.

Czarnian··on Piracy - You can't have your cake and eat it
So if I break into a theater when it's closed and make a reel-to-reel copy of a movie with my own film stock, then I didn't just steal it?

Good to know.

Czarnian··on Piracy - You can't have your cake and eat it
Refusing to move to the back of the bus. Sitting down in the middle of the street to block the movement of troops from point a to point b. Walking from Montgomery to Selma. Downloading the Inbetweeners.

One of these things is not civil disobedience. In fact, trying to cast piracy as a form of civil disobedience is insulting to the people who actually got arrested, beaten by police, attacked by dogs, had the firehose turned on them, were tear-gassed, run over, and suffered any number of real consequences as they publicly defied laws and a society that were unquestionably wrong.

To cast content piracy as civil disobedience, one must accept that the act of murder is an act of civil disobedience because the murderer believes the law against it is unjust.

Czarnian··on Piracy - You can't have your cake and eat it
Do me a favor, wouldja? Please cast this particular tenet of your moral code into the form of the golden rule. Exactly what are you doing to others that you would have them do unto you?
Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
The supply and demand curves are independent variables derived from distinct data sets.

From Wikipedia: . . . supply is determined by marginal cost. Firms will produce additional output as long as the cost of producing an extra unit of output is less than the price they will receive.

. . . demand curves are determined by marginal utility curves. Consumers will be willing to buy a given quantity of a good, at a given price, if the marginal utility of additional consumption is equal to the opportunity cost determined by the price, that is, the marginal utility of alternative consumption choices. The demand schedule is defined as the willingness and ability of a consumer to purchase a given product in a given frame of time.

In my experience, the pro-piracy argument from economics is at best an imperfect understanding of supply and demand and at worst, the person making the argument just heard the words "supply and demand" and filled in the rest from his own imagination. The "Law of Supply and Demand" is not an actual thing. It's the juxtaposition of "Law of Supply" and the "Law of Demand"

Supply (as opposed to the supply curve) is dictated by demand, not the other way around. If the demand for a good rises, then supply will be increased to meet the demand. If demand for a good drops, supply will be decreased to the level of demand.

To your question, the entertainment companies are under no illusions that the demand curve for any particular product is going to stay the same. They expect that over time, the demand for any given thing will decrease. They know that Britney Spears new album will sell a shit-ton of copies for the first week after it drops and by the same time the following year, everyone who wanted it will have it and sales will be virtually non-existant. Their business model is geared toward a limited lifecycle for any given product, which is why they make continual investments in new products.

Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
You probably shouldn't have skipped the day when they talked about market saturation. Infinite supply does not imply infinite demand.
Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
When exactly are you supposed to do these shows and performances if you have a day job?

Copyright is one of the things that allows artists to get in a position to go on the road and do these shows.

Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
Your premise doesn't seem terribly strong for a few reasons.

1) Artists have memories. When I was much younger, I worked as a telemarketer. It was probably the worst job I ever held in my life. It was soul-crushing. Even though I am now a reasonably successful software engineer, I still remember how difficult it was to go to work knowing that unless I was lucky, I was going to be rejected all day long. Even though I've been with my partner for more than a decade, I remember how chaotic, foolish, and frustrating the dating scene was. Anyone with a few years under their belt knows that a bad memory can jump out at you and make you feel exactly the way you did when it happened.

2) An artists music evolves over time. Look at the Beatles. "With the Beatles" is an astonishingly different album from "Abbey Road." Just because you start out as one thing doesn't mean you have to be that thing for the rest of your career.

3) Look at artists like Johnny Cash, Bruce Springsteen, John Mellencamp, and even Billy Joel to some extent. No matter what your opinion of their music is, it's hard to argue that they are not iconic representations of the "everyman" in music. Most of their output was produced while they were some of the highest paid performers in the world. Even a guy like Jay-Z hasn't been poor or street for a very long time, but if he puts out another record, you can be damned sure that there will be millions of people who buy it because he knows how to write songs that relate to the kind of person he used to be.

Don't put too much stock in the idea that you have to be street level to write good music.

Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
Is it really that bad if somebody who needs a bed uses mine without permission while it lies unused, provided it isn't harmed and is returned to its initial condition?

Exactly. It's YOUR choice to allow someone to let themselves in when you aren't home and take a nap. BTW, can you post your address and schedule? Just in case anyone reading this thread needs a place to crash for a few hours.

Giving me the right to not have strangers wander into my house while I'm gone does nothing to prevent you from letting strangers wander into your house. By making it ok for people to wander into my house without my permission, you obliterate my property rights.

Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
They won't be taking their balls and going home out of pique, they'll be doing it because they have to go to work.

Every hour an artist has to spend at a day job is an hour they can't spend creating. It's an hour they can't spend practicing. It's an hour they can't spend raising awareness of their work.

Czarnian··on Why I'm a Pirate
Leaving aside the rather obvious question of what makes you think your taste in music is superior to anyone else, how much MORE of that great, great, great music would get created if the artists didn't have to wash dishes for 10 hours a day to make rent and eat?

Every hour you have to spend working a day job is an hour you can't spend creating.

Czarnian··on Uncloaking a Slumlord Conspiracy with Social Network Analysis
They didn't really get into to much detail, but what usually happens with these situations is that all of the LLCs are just funneling the proceeds into the same bank accounts, no matter whose name is on the LLC paperwork. In this case, it appeared that the patriarch's bank accounts were the ultimate destination for the money regardless of which LLC owned a building at any given time. The twist on this case was that the mastermind was also in a position to facilitate better terms for each subsequent sale.
Czarnian··on How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body
When teaching yoga, the instructor needs to know and understand the limits of the human body. And then, at the very least, need to make sure their students know not to exceed those limits.
Czarnian··on How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body
The difference is that when I go to my regular trainer, he is very specific about not letting me exceed my physical limits. He's also very conscientious about making sure I know my physical limits so I don't hurt myself when he's not around.

In a yoga class, the instructor can regularly instruct people to do things that are inherently dangerous (even if they aren't painful.)

Pushing the risk onto the students is not particularly helpful. The student has placed (or misplaced, depending) their trust in the instructor not to hurt them. It's the instructors job to make sure they don't get hurt, including not having them do inherently dangerous things.

You'd be surprised how much science understands about how the body works.

Czarnian··on How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body
Also, there are some limits that should not be exceeded, period. Like the cases in the article where they exceeded the operating tolerances of the neck and gave themselves strokes.

Yoga certifications really ought to include a basic anatomy and physiology component.

Czarnian··on The case for old entrepreneurs
Mark Twain didn't say this. His father died when he was 13.

Not necessarily a bad sentiment, just not a Mark Twain thing.

Czarnian··on The case for old entrepreneurs
Never said there would be. Just saying that the problems are going to be increasingly obscure and harder to solve.
Czarnian··on The case for old entrepreneurs
That is a horrible way to play baseball.
Czarnian··on The case for old entrepreneurs
What they're looking for is people with under-developed bullsh*t detectors.

I suspect the reason IT applications are sometimes being pioneered by younger people has more to do with immersion in the technology from an early age that can provide novel insights into how people will use technology. But as the years roll on and the low-hanging fruit (like facebook) is picked clean, the young folks are going to find it increasingly harder to uncover problems to be solved.

Czarnian··on Always have 18 months of cash in the bank
That's true. The general rule I go by is carry between 3-5 months worth of expenses (debt service + living expenses) in cash and the rest goes into various investments to make more money. The cash is my emergency fund and the investments are my savings.

If you leave 18 months worth of cash in a savings account, you're losing value to inflation.

Czarnian··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
Wouldn't even have to go that far. Seasteaders are already paranoid enough that you can just play on the fears they already have.

"Nice seastead you have here. It'd be a real shame if some country decided to come out and take your strategically worthless, resource barren, unstable platform from you."

Then sit back and collect a paycheck.

Czarnian··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
Off the top of my head, the only things of value on a seastead are the salvageable materials, which would be a hassle to collect and sell, and the net worth of the various residents. They have no strategic value, it would cost a lot to keep them supplied, and you're in the middle of the ocean. To me, it would be much easier to to just bill them 10 mil a month for protection against a low-risk to non-existent threat until they can't afford it anymore.
Czarnian··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
If that's the question you wanted answered, it should have been the question you asked. Instead, you asked which goodies are provided by a society with a complex government structure.

Leaving aside the direct governmental involvement in the creation of the internet. Leaving aside the governmental influence in promoting the widespread use of electricity in the early 20th century. Time Warner and ConEdison don't exist without the complex governmental structures that define a corporation and provide the framework for them to operate.

There is a reason why corporations don't exist in places like Somalia. There is a reason why corporations who incorporate in places like Bermuda don't actually do anything in those places. It's no coincidence that the most technologically advanced nations on the planet are also the ones with the most complex governmental structures. They are inextricably linked. Without one, you simply don't have the other.

There's also the matter of the impact complex governmental structures have in protecting your private property. The little old lady at the county records office provides far, far more protection for your property than any gun ever will. Your private property exists because the government provides the framework for it to exist. Without things like car titles and property deeds, how long do you think it will be before someone just comes along and drives you out of your home so they can have it?

If libertarians ever really thought about how much of their comfortable existence relied on the government they hated so much, their heads would explode.

Czarnian··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
Because you have to pay a shipper a lot of money to send a ship somewhere that doesn't have any exports to ship back.
Czarnian··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
Importing isn't the problem, exporting is. A seastead will necessarily pay a steep premium on imported goods, even basic ones.

The cost of shipping is mitigated by goods going both ways. When you are shipping to a zero-export entity such as a seastead, the receiving entity is expected to bear the cost of the return trip with empty holds.

Czarnian··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
If nothing else of value exists on the seastead, there will be a bunch of rich folks with families in rich countries willing to give the invaders lots of money for the promise of their safe return.

Pirates are not picky about how they get their money.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →