HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DabAsteroid

266 karma · joined August 31, 2008

submissionscomments
DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
it specifically quoted a critic as saying that fusion was desirable

...Which is an absurd thing for that critic to say when even fusion's proponents admit that even if it could be made to work, it would not likely be economically competitive.

DabAsteroid··on Risky, we-can't-fail, all-or-nothing science
It also does not come close to the investment originally made into fission power production and continually made to produce next generation reactors.

The difference is that there is no place in the market for fusion reactors. In light of the existing half-billion-year [Edit: half-trillion-year] fuel supply for fission reactors, the drive to create fusion reactors is nonsensical.

DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
Males drive more miles than females.

...Yet another reason to charge insurance by the mile and/or minute.

  .
By the way, this is interesting (though I don't know how accurate it is):

http://christianparty.net/womendrivers.htm

Women Drivers: Hidden Health Risk To Men

Women drive only 30% of miles driven but are in 37% of the fatal accidents ...

NHTSA data suggests that ... if only women drove:

There would be 23,879 more traffic fatalities each year.

There would be 7,674 more women killed each year.

DabAsteroid··on I've watched the economy for 30 years. Now I'm truly scared
Financial institutions lent money to borrowers who could not afford the loan they were given.

I don't think they were doing their jobs well. The same goes for insurers.

One reason the insurance industry is so poorly run is that tax incentives are given to businesses to offer generic health-insurance to their employees. Discrimination according to individual cases is needed, and that is not what has been happening. And when they do individually discriminate (both lenders and insurers), they (being conservative, incompetent, scientifically-illiterate, etc.) ignore well-established important factors such as IQ and the various personality factors -- factors that are known to be determinative of social outcome, and more predictive than past-performance (credit-ratings, etc.).

If they are unable to do their jobs any better than that, then the market should be allowed to have its way with them, just as it did the dozens of second-rate silicon-valley VC firms -- and their, in-turn, poorly-discriminating limited-partners -- that created the internet bubble. Why? Because it makes way for the more-competent.

[Edit: Anamax just pointed out that there was government "encoruagement" in these lending decisions, and that other institutions then took on these poor-risk loans. I think the general principals apply: 1. where the government distorts the market, it causes problems; 2. wherever there is freedom in market decisions, whomever finds himself holding the bag has no-one but himself to blame.]

DabAsteroid··on I've watched the economy for 30 years. Now I'm truly scared
Bankers don't create wealth

This is a common fallacy. Bankers manage risk in lending, reducing overall risk. This is valuable, i.e. it creates wealth.

If any given Bankers were not performing risk-reduction service for society, they would be outcompeted in the market by their competitors. Therefore, to say that bankers do not create wealth, would be to imply that bankers are in conspiracy to distort the lending market.

DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
I was referring to the Tesla's wide torqueband -- "its whole 1 gear thing". It is not an exclusive feature. A ZR1 can also be driven in 1 gear only and still achieve both 0-60 in 4 seconds and a top speed over 100 mph.
DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
the Tesla only has 1 gear, which doesn't like going much past 100mph.

It is a 2-speed car. Tesla is planning on performing a recall to upgrade the transmissions of all of the delivered 1-speed cars to 2-speed.

http://www.teslamotors.com/media/press_room.php?id=803

DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
Yeah ... it's neat with its whole 1 gear thing, instant torque

...The same as a Corvette ZR1 (and also the same price) in third gear.

http://www.digitalcorvettes.com/forums/showthread.php?t=9212...

2009 ZR1 . Max rpm 6500 . Tire Dia 26.4 . Tire Circumference 6.9115' . Rear End 3.42

  Gear  Ratios  Max speed(mph)
   1     2.29        65.2
   2     1.61        92.7
   3     1.21       123.4
   4     1.00       149.3
   5     0.81       184.3
   6     0.67       222.8
DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
The 2008's are being delivered in 2009 because Tesla is so far behind schedule.
DabAsteroid··on I test drove a Tesla
And, in Seattle, runs off hydro power.

...Nuclear, largely, if the charging is done at night.

http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/nuclear/page/at_a_glance/states...

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
Glassmaking was one of the reasons given. Is it more likely that in their hearts of hearts the colonists believed that:

1. They were going to be able to manufacture, and export to Europe, glass from the New World at a lower price/quality than that from European glass manufacturers.

or

2. They wanted to believe that, while possessing deeper motives involving change-of-scenery.

  .
Do you believe that you would have been able to make and ship glass cheaper in the New World than to make the same in England? Does nothing sound fishy to you about that?
DabAsteroid··on Google backs gay marriage
A "moral calculus" is not something that one "does". Dictionary definition of calculus:

a system or arrangement of intricate or interrelated parts <the calculus of forces in world affairs — Martin Mayer>

  .
A moral calculus is a moral system. The moral calculus is the moral system.
DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
You're welcome. Here is the 40-minute version that includes Elon Musk's post-launch address to the SpaceX employees in Hawthorne, California, and post-launch interview:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FQhtMrUQlE

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
I think Mr. Bigelow has the right idea. And Vectran is a great material for space-inflatables.

http://www.google.com/search?q=bigelow+vectran

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
Satellite launch failures alone can cost in the hundreds of millions of dollars

Satellite costs are driven partially by launch costs. If launches are expensive, then satellites need to be highly reliable. If launches are cheap, then satellites need not be so reliable, and therefore can be cheaper.

Insurance averages out the costs of launch failures.

Dropping the costs of satellites improves the market and introduces the possibility of mass-production, further dropping the costs and further increasing demand, which further drops the costs through economies of scale, etc.

  .
We know what can happen, economically, because we have experience with mass-launchings in the form of the V2.

http://www.google.com/search?q=v2+rocket+%2413000

A Rocket a Day Keeps the High Costs Away

Then, starting with the US$13000 marginal cost of a V2, we arrive at a cost of ...

One analogy in particular regarding V2 rockets, Nazis, and ignoring the use ... The recurring cost was $13000 a launch for those vehicles. ...

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
The capsule is on top of the stack. Unlike the case of the Space Shuttle, if a SpaceX rocket blows up, the capsule on top can simply jetison away and deploy a parachute.
DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
There were colonists, and there were investors. These were not the same people. There was no more economic opportunity for the colonists in the new world than there was back home. There was the opportunity to die prematurely and painfully. Perhaps that was an attraction to the adventurous.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamestown,_Virginia#Challenges_...

The settlers who came over on the initial three ships were not well-equipped for the life they found in Jamestown. In addition to the "gentlemen", who were not accustomed to manual or skilled labor, they consisted mainly of English farmers and "Eight Dutchmen and Poles" hired in Royal Prussia.[6] Many suffered from saltwater poisoning which led to infection, fevers and dysentery. As a result of these conditions, most of the early settlers died of disease and starvation.

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
Jamestown was a money-hole until John Rolfe developed a special, sweet strain of tobacco that became the basis of an export economy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamestown_Settlement

Due to the aristocratic backgrounds of many of the new colonists and the communal nature of their work load, progress through the first few years was inconsistent, at best. By 1613, six years after Jamestown's founding, the organizers and shareholders of the Virginia Land Company were desperate to increase the efficiency and profitability of the struggling colony.

  .
The investors had been tricked into believing that it would be a profitable venture.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia_Company#The_London_Com...

To the disappointment of its investors, the Virginia Company of London failed to discover gold or silver in Virginia.

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
Freespace is easier to get to and from, and offers full-g, zero-g and everything in-between.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_habitat

Freespace also can offer low data latency -- low-enough even for realistic telepresence (e.g. sub 400 ms) (http://www.google.com/search?q=%22400+ms%22+conversation+lat...).

The moon probably would not be very popular, except for mining crews.

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
Historically, people have colonized just for the change of scenery.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamestown,_Virginia

DabAsteroid··on SpaceX launches 1st commercial rocket into orbit
Video (09:59):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=To-XOPgaGsQ

DabAsteroid··on Google backs gay marriage
It is about fundamental human rights.

What are fundamental human rights?

http://www.google.com/search?q=nonsense+on+stilts+natural+ri...

DabAsteroid··on Google backs gay marriage
you can see how it wouldn't really work to designate 6 people as having the right to determine whether you stay on life support.

Actually, this is done all the time.

  .
http://www.google.com/search?q=%22board+of+directors%22+star...

BondBook's Backers Pull the Plug, Citing Lack of Critical Mass ... The board of directors reached this decision because current market conditions in the ...

After fifty years of futile funding, it’s time to pull the plug. ...

I would send this business plan to my board of directors for approval with my .... We pull the plug when we find that the startup is not going as per the ...

rounds of financing while reserving the option to pull the plug if the experiments ...

DabAsteroid··on Carbon nanotechnology in a 17th century Damascus sword
over and over until something works

Indeed. ...Until something accidentally works.

  .
Lower animals tend more to learn by accident. They might memorize or ritualize what works, but they do not resonate with why it works. Higher animals tend more to learn by developing mental-resonance with natural processes (i.e. they do resonate with why things work), saving the effort involved in accidental-discovery learning techniques such as trial-and-error.

The main indices of intelligence in animals are the speed of learning and the complexity of what can be learned, the integration of sensory information to achieve a goal, flexibility of behavior in the face of obstacles, insightful rather than trial-and-error problem-solving behavior, transfer of learning from one problem situation to somewhat different situations, and capacity to acquire abstract or relational concepts.

(Arthur Jensen. Bias in Mental Testing. http://www.amazon.com/Bias-Mental-Testing-Arthur-Jensen/dp/0... From the section "Animal Intelligence".)

  .
Perhaps trial-and-error should be classed as a subset of accidental discovery -- e.g. there would be myriad ways of accidentally discovering, one of which would be the motivation-driven trial-and-error.

Place a chicken on one side of a limited-length chain-link fence, and food on the other side, and the chicken will use the sheer force of its hunger-drive to discover how to get to the food. It has a motivation to get to the food, but it cannot mentally-resonate with the spatial processes -- the distance, the fence, gravity, etc. -- that are keeping it and the food separate. It therefore applies its motivation to accidental discovery -- sepcifically, the motive-driven accidental-discovery technique of trial-and-error. E.g., it will scramble around in a panic until it accidentally discovers one of the two routes to the food -- a few feet to either side of its original location. This process might take many minutes or hours. The chicken might even die of hunger without discovering that walking a few feet around the fence will get it to the food.

In the same test, a dog will mentally-resonate with the spatial processes involved, and simply walk around the fence.

The chicken applies the accidental-discovery technique of trial-and-error. The dog theorizes, i.e. mentally-resonates, i.e. applies science.

DabAsteroid··on Tom Perkins's (of KP) Giant Yacht Sails to San Francisco
...So does Tom Perkins.

http://www.symaltesefalcon.com/submarine.asp

DabAsteroid··on Poll YC: Mandatory Replies.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=297260

ericwaller 21 days ago | link | parent | flag

It'd be interesting if a down vote were actually a special case of reply and required an explanation.

  .
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=57134

aswanson 374 days ago | link | parent | flag

You could make down votes more expensive by forcing someone to type a rationale of why

DabAsteroid··on Carbon nanotechnology in a 17th century Damascus sword
I suspect it wasn't so much accidental discovery as a trial and error refinement

Trial-and-error = accident.

We use science because it is more efficient than brute force (trial-and-error; accident).

DabAsteroid··on Tom Perkins's (of KP) Giant Yacht Sails to San Francisco
There are people starving in this world, dying of illnesses that could be treated, and Mr. Perkins is sitting in his empty mall of a boat.

Tom Perkins said the same thing in the CBS interview link (video and text-transcript, Page 2) that Jonknee posted in this thread.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/11/01/60minutes/main3442...

Asked how much the Falcon cost Perkins, he tells Stahl, "The rule of thumb, Lesley, is that a big yacht costs about a million dollars a meter."

The Maltese Falcon is 88 meters long.

"I know it cost more than $88 million," Stahl remarks. "I've heard about $150 million. But I've also heard $300 million."

"No, not $300 million," Perkins says. "That's too much."

"Why don't, why won't you tell us? You've told us everything else. You don't seem to be embarrassed about everything else?" Stahl says.

"I'm embarrassed about that," Perkins admits.

Asked why, Perkins says, "There's the homeless and charity and there's lots of things you could do with that money that would improve the world, right?"

"Oh, good point. That you bring up yourself?" Stahl asks.

"Yeah," Perkins says. "So, you know, 'How selfish is this guy?' is, I guess, is the criticism. So the answer's pretty selfish, but I'm just not gonna put a number on it."

Why did it have to be the biggest boat?

"Lesley, I could give you some technical reasons on why it really has got to be big to work right. But I just wanted the biggest boat. Let's admit it," he says.

"It’s ego," Stahl remarks.

"Do I have an ego? Yes," Perkins admits. "Is it big? Yes."

DabAsteroid··on Tom Perkins's (of KP) Giant Yacht Sails to San Francisco
Their crew is 20 people!

http://www.google.com/search?q=%22tom+perkins%22+yacht+crew+...

mostly, as Perkins says, "to keep the hotel humming.

DabAsteroid··on Poll YC: Mandatory Replies.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=298768

Charge money for voting. For example: every 2 votes costs 1 Karma point.

There are lots of other interesting Karma suggestions in the main Requests thread:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=363

← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →