HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DarkNova6

2,109 karma · joined December 29, 2022

submissionscomments
DarkNova6··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
From what I read no further EPRs are planned and they fully want to go ahead with a streamlined EPR2 design.

I think the problem of the Finns was that they really wanted energy independence and tge inly ones that were on the market were the french. No doubt the frenched used much diplomatic muscle to attract them as a first experiment.

DarkNova6··on 'That's so AI ' What gen Alpha's biggest insult tells us
I've seen the same thing in my family and relatives across all age groups, I doubt they understand it either.
DarkNova6··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
But is this the intended maintenance duration, or the actual one? Because the construction of every EPR project has been a disaster. Construction took 20 years in Europe and 9 years in China.
DarkNova6··on Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy
Not to detract from your point, but France had a good run with nuclear energy throughout the 70s, no? They built them on mass, built them reliably and quickly, learned from project to project and had economies of scale.

And if I am not mistaken then for a long time energy prices in France were smaller than that of neighbouring countries.

But to be fair, it is difficult to tell what "profitable" means because a primary motivation has always been the development of nuclear weapons, so the true amortization is across industry and national security.

DarkNova6··on 'That's so AI ' What gen Alpha's biggest insult tells us
I am more and more convinced that young people have a much better understanding of technology and especially its impact on society.
DarkNova6··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
You are not wrong, but I was just saying that the possibility is there. And especially for people who are despairing over bad math education I see this as a game changer. Seeing equations used to make me angry and powerless for over a decade because I felt absolutely hopeless during my studies.
DarkNova6··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
They don't parrot if you know what to ask for. You can name for examples, name your own thoughts and observations and these things will often quote something related or the fact that a famous mathematician has also made this observation some point in time which then lead to the study of something else.

I am not going to study a whole book just so I can find the answer to a couple things I might never need. I like to focus on a few areas, learn everything I need to understand it, know if there are any dependencies and see what is there to discover and then move on.

I know many people get joy from learning knowledge that is not directly applicable and might never be applicable. And I know that the academic spirit would be to learn these things. But my time is seriously finite and I am not using math in my life in any fashion whatsoever other than occasional curiosity.

DarkNova6··on Disney+: New user agreement allows ads before movies in all subscriptions
It's like paying for cable back in the day but you also get ads. The sheer audacity they think they can get away with because they consider themselves having a monopoly.
DarkNova6··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
I think LLMs are the single best things that were invented to make mathematics accessible.

I loved mathematics when I was young and wanted to be good at it, but I got burnt so many times by teachers who could not explain even if their life depended on it.

Asking an LLM and discovering how different theories belong together and what are genuinely open questions, along with different philosophical interpretations has been a wonderful gift.

I have long accepted that Mathematics is a language where you must go "all in" because for the most parts institutions are fundamentally unable to explain it in an intuitive way. There are people who "just get it" and are blind to the struggle of people who need a different approach in learning it. There's something about the field where a generational survivorship bias has created an environment where math is mostly taught to likeminded people, who then don't see why anybody could not see the difficulties learning it.

I know this is not true everywhere, but the only reason I could finish my studies was because there are some genuinely excellent online lectures on youtube, along with massive support from friends who have already been through the ordeal.

If I had had access to an LLM, I could have actually taught myself from scratch and be more playful in learning it. And no, I am not willing to learn lots of math "for fun", I can think of better "for fun" things that actually help my profession and cater to my actual interests and not just some academic ideal.

DarkNova6··on Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of labor in human history'
If there is no legal guarantee that human creativity can pay off we are starving art and humanity from its inception. If ordinary people cannot participate in the act of creation, you get exactly what hollywood has become.

Sorry, but this reads like a mouthpiece exactly from those companies that benefit the most from having no copyright and I doubt your have thought this actually through.

DarkNova6··on EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Member'
Believe it or not but the american system isn’t exact a blueprint for actual democracy. Many democratic systems don‘t make the election of the president a vote.
DarkNova6··on Java 27
Yeah. Why use a statically typed reliable language with a good ecosystem if I can also vibecode in Python.
DarkNova6··on Value Classes Still Need Compiler Sympathy
Project Valhalla is not a JEP, it's a collection of JEPs and this is just the very first one.

Flattening has been the goal from the start, but it's simply not something that's delivered in this JEP. But even so, people should not overestimate the effect of values and flattening.

The biggest advantage will come from specialized libraries (stuff like OpenCV), and overall library enhancements (Tuples not requiring a dedicated indirection).

DarkNova6··on Value Classes Still Need Compiler Sympathy
The tradeoff being that tearing is what enables flattening. So if you truly want the best performance (cache lines etc.) you must enable it.

But whether your data’s integrity can be broken by such must be decided by the class author.

DarkNova6··on Value Classes Still Need Compiler Sympathy
Yes, this was the idiom in the 90s, but Escape Analysis has not proven to be powerful enough to optimize away identity.

And looking at all the edge-cases and possible data-races via tearing, declaring something as a value must be an explicit design decision that cannot be inferred by a compiler or optimizer alone.

DarkNova6··on Value Classes Still Need Compiler Sympathy
Good technical overview, and I fully agree with the conclusion's sentiment at the end:

``` Declaring a value class is first and foremost a semantic decision. It tells our fellow programmers that its instances are defined entirely by their state and do not need identity. That clearer model is valuable in itself! The JVM’s additional freedom to optimize how those values are represented is a welcome bonus. ```

Many developers seem to think that "go value go broom", but the truth is much more nuanced and the idea should not be to think about "but performance" but to think about the nature of your underlying data. At the very least this integrates some core DDD lessons directly into language. I'm glad tearing isn't turned on by default exactly for this reason.

Java was always a language that geared itself towards making libraries easy to use, putting much faith in the library author and strong encapsulation. Now, experts can gain significantly more performance from the JVM, while more humble programmers are avoided from creating bugs they will not expect.

DarkNova6··on Where did all the public bathrooms go?
Which EU countries do you talk about? Because I've never seen anything like this
DarkNova6··on Rethinking Database Programming
I was hoping for an alternative to PLSQL or stored procedures. But this isn’t about „Database Programming“, it’s a SQL replacement…
DarkNova6··on Rethinking Database Programming
It looks like the HN hug of death has found a new victim
DarkNova6··on Deutsche Bank becomes first foreign yuan clearing bank in Europe
At this point it is not a question of whether this will happen but only when. Next to digital currencies and the yuan, Trump has successfully killed the Petrodollar.

The free influx of money, and particularly investor money that gave the US an evergreen advantage will seize. Slow at first, then more and more as time moves on.

DarkNova6··on Beef and dairy drive 41% of biodiversity damage linked to global farmland
"Most of us" is a pretty bold claim.
DarkNova6··on Beef and dairy drive 41% of biodiversity damage linked to global farmland
This is bullshit. The vast majority of CO2 is created by energy production.

The problem is systemic and blaming other people for their lifestyle choices is neither effective nor helpful and just leads to further division. It's exactly this sort of division that helps fossil companies to destroy the planet and keep making money.

DarkNova6··on Beef and dairy drive 41% of biodiversity damage linked to global farmland
I never understood this argument. With Oil & Gas you release green house gases that have been sealed away back into the air.

For methane produced by farming all components remain in a cycle. Everything released by animals eventually finds its way back to plants, which get eaten, which become exhaust of animals, etc.

This sounds to me more like a spin by big oil to finger point at another industry.

DarkNova6··on Retire the Abstractions
I'd say: A good abstraction is a formal and abstract statement about the nature of the underlying (sub)system. It is self consistent and allows an easier way to reason and interact with greater complexity underneath.

And the more you see an abstraction as a "wad of API calls and functionality", the more leaky the story gets.

Some systems are notoriously difficult to get this statement right because they are volatile and prone to changes. But I think as in live or in academia, our aspirations should be to strive for a better abstract understanding and keep building better abstractions.

DarkNova6··on Oracle bans AI-generated code from OpenJDK
The problem is primarily social. When code is cheap and entry barriers don't exist, how do you filter what is valuable?

For private projects, being able to code things quickly is a godsent. Also for professional environments with clear rules and mutual respect, this can be solved. But on the internet, with people you don't know? You must have some hard barriers.

DarkNova6··on What I love about Django
Having basic defensive programming, some simple classes instead of dicts everywhere and avoiding n+1 is a "different world"?
DarkNova6··on What I love about Django
You misunderstand. And that is exactly the problem.

We did do that and that's why our queries ended up being several lines long. But if you missed just one model? You openly walk a knife again.

It's a mess and it only gets longer and longer. I ended the project with having some proper aggregates, only for that to be thrown out of the window by the guy after me.

DarkNova6··on What I love about Django
I seriously don't get why Django ORM is using the Active Record pattern. This is such a stupid footgun that trivially causes horrible performance and BEGS you to cause n+1 problems.

Never in my life did I have a problem with lazy loading causing unbearable performance until I joined a Python Django team. I really tried to find sympathy for the "dynamically typed" folks (please spare me saying Python is technically statically typed), but coming from writing apps and backends in Java, Swift, C#, Objective-C and PHP, Python with Django was the worst experience bar none.

I worked on the project for 10 months, could at least refactor the project to something semi-sane where obvious mistakes (which would not be possible in other languages) could not happen. Then along comes a "good Python dev" and threw it all out of the window and start doing SQL queries all over the place (typically 3-6 lines long), remove the domain objects and cause the same problems I started with to begin with. But his approach was saying that the other developers were "not good enough".

Yeah, have fun with schema changes going forward. Good riddance.

DarkNova6··on Mistral's Shieldstral: 3B open-weights model for multimodal moderation
I'm referring to the formal usage of the term "distillation", instead of the informal one that refers to training it on any data as a whole.

https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/nlp/what-is-llm-distillation/

DarkNova6··on Mistral's Shieldstral: 3B open-weights model for multimodal moderation
You mean the asian models which just distilled American ones? I'm happy Mistral is doing their own ground up research. SOTA frontier models are a commodity with little room for second places.

Mistral is playing the smart money on vertical products rather than horizontal ones. The former requires finesse, the latter brute strength.

← PreviousPage 2 of 27Next →