HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DarkNova6

2,109 karma · joined December 29, 2022

submissionscomments
DarkNova6··on Rust-lang/rust is adopting an LLM policy
I don't understand this obsession with clear cut categorization. Systems always have a human component and while we like to collectively deny this fact from a tech-sphere, there are always humans that will make the final call and if anything we should encourage the use of human trust and judgement.

We have focused so much on technological advancement, but our understanding of human systems and building an environment of trust that is not eroded by perverse incentives atrophies.

DarkNova6··on Stateless MCP has recaptured my interest
I don't get it. I thought the advantage is that you have a client as a library with integrated auth & other tech stuff handled so you can just focus on using the API? Because otherwise you could just use REST with basic endpoint code.
DarkNova6··on The US is not a democracy but an oligarchy, study concludes (2014)
This sounds like a more elaborate version of Whataboutism.
DarkNova6··on The US is not a democracy but an oligarchy, study concludes (2014)
I'd like to think that it's twice as good as a one-party system.
DarkNova6··on The Dunning-Kruger effect may just be a data artefact (2020)
Indeed. The true irony behind the Dunning Kruger Effect is that the pop culture understanding of it is essentially describing itself. Showing overconfidence in areas that you have little clue about.
DarkNova6··on JEP 401: Value Objects (Preview) merged to OpenJDK master
I think it keeps going back to "preserving type invariants". Turning an object into a value can have surprising constraints on the integrity of the type. These include: forced empty constructor (for bulk initialiation in arrays), violation of cross-field invariance (think of a Range-type where "end" value is suddenly smaller than the "start" due to a data race), etc.

Java always had a focus on enabling library authors over empowering call-site users. And I think approach has proven its dividend.

DarkNova6··on SwiftUI After 7 Years
I left Swift and SwiftUi behind be 5 years ago when I switched jobs. I had fond memories and always eyed going back.

What were the emerging problems that you talk about? I am actually curious because I was quite fond of the DevEx

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
Right? It strikes me that the vast majority of people complaining genuinely don't understand the difference between law and code, content and art or can think of anything beyond what they are facing in day to day work realities.
DarkNova6··on EU rules on AI models become enforceable. What's going to change?
This being downvoted speaks saddens my heart... and proves the exact intent of the message.
DarkNova6··on EU rules on AI models become enforceable. What's going to change?
Thanks, now I don't need to even read the article!
DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
You are not wrong, but here's the catch:

"Even I - with all my years of experience and knowledge - fell into the trap of hallucinations. I summarised reports using AI tools and worked from those summaries, trusting they were accurate.

He used an LLM to perform research instead of using it as a mere writing tool. I think large language models are great at formatting text, formatting, structuring and giving a stylecheck. But the last pass and review must always be a human. Everything posted by an LLM under your name is still under your name and you are liable for every single word. It's about the outcome and everybody who uses it is responsible for it.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
I'd argue that if a satire or parody is strong enough having a small watermark will not detract from its statement.
DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
You completely disregard practical implications.

Can you manually create images that were done via AI? Of course you can.

Can you create AI fake content and misinformation as easily with human labor as you can with AI? No.

Understanding this distinction answers whether you see the implications AI has on the future of democracies or not.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
If anything this an argument _for_ clearly labelling manipulated photos and AI generated depiction of supposedly real life events.
DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
You will have to tell me how "labelling machine additions" is applicable at all as an example here. Unless your argument boils down to "computer doing things does not require labelling".
DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
So what are journalistic texts if not docs? At this point, an LLM is just another evolution from the typewriter.

You are still responsible for your work. What is important are the semantics and statements of the text. Less so how the exact arrangement of letters came to be.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
More authentic because of what, a missing watermark? It still has 2 positive outcomes:

1: It gives legal leverage against vectors of misinformation. Misinformation is tricky to combat legally and this is a first obvious measure that can be taken.

2: Reputation will become more important in the future, and if you are found to have repeatedly posted AI content claiming it is not it will damage you. Not to mention that users can point out the obvious discrepancy.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
I don't see how these are contradictory. The battle for reality will only worsen and you likely need multiple failsaves.
DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
The non thinking ones have voting power too and they will burn this shithole down because they think some powerful people in nice suits act on good faith and should be given all the decisionmaking and resources.

This way of thinking is a very efficient way of destroying your culture and civilisation.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
There's creativity and there's the creative process. I like to dictate documentation in long form monologue, and then give instructions how to structure it. Then I give it a final pass with manual adjustments and the end-result is exactly how it would have looked if I had written it from scratch but without the bsywork.

Don't be stupid enough to let machines do your own thinking, treat them as a dishwasher.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
An obvious start would be that any such technology needs to have its own clearly visible watermark and removing it constitutes a crime.
DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
I'm surprised by the sentiment.

With enough money you can already buy attention and presence. Now you can even facilitate a fake discourse to claim legitimacy and steer manipulation into entirely new realms. If this is not counteracted not only will rogue nations destroy democracies even faster, but powerful corporations and rich individuals will also use this to increase their power further and damage simple consumers.

Nothing about this concerns any creative process.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
> It won't work.

Maybe. But the rest of your post doesn't have anything to back this up.

> I'm also curious, what about AI assisted media? If a company writes a full article, then uses AI to edit it a bit, does that need to be labeled?

Why would it? The threat is mass generation of articles without any human oversights, and realistic looking images claiming occurrence of events that never hapened. Nobody cares about an AI typo and stylecheck.

DarkNova6··on EU will mandate labels on authentic-looking AI content starting August 2
Nihilism is the path to death and destruction. Thinking this will makes you powerless and cedes control with those who have the most resources.

It's easy to take yourself out of this equation, but it only makes everything worse. The trick is that they make you think that it couldn't get worse. But this is always false.

DarkNova6··on JEP 401: Value Objects (Preview) merged to OpenJDK master
Because?
DarkNova6··on Golang proposal: container/: generic collection types
I totally get that. Java is my favorite language for exactly that reason. They are a deliberate "late mover language" and adopt what other languages have proven right.

But looking at how adamant Go used to be on the whole "No Generics" stance and the path and the troubles they are having... it all seemes so preventable?

DarkNova6··on Golang proposal: container/: generic collection types
Step by step, Go is now learning the hard lessons every other language has learned over the last 20 years. The fact that despite their best efforts, their propositions look like everone else is a surprisingly refreshing affirmation of status quo.
DarkNova6··on JEP 401: Value Objects (Preview) merged to OpenJDK master
Indeed. At this point you’d need to bring the size of the string into the type system (C++ Templates we meet again!) but then you look at a solution worse than the problem…
DarkNova6··on JEP 401: Value Objects (Preview) merged to OpenJDK master
The Java way was always to let library designers decide how a type is used. I personally think this is the sensible one.
DarkNova6··on JEP 401: Value Objects (Preview) merged to OpenJDK master
I think it really highlights how important it was to have atomicity and integrity by default because even here people will handwave away any such concerns as if they don’t exist.
← PreviousPage 3 of 27Next →