HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Dave3of5

1,216 karma · joined October 24, 2019

submissionscomments
Dave3of5··on Game Boy SM83 CPU Core
Not just Game Boy but much much more:

https://www.analogue.co/pocket

Dave3of5··on Ask HN: How to avoid being a pragmatic programmer?
If you are working for a company doing SCRUM then you will only just work on stories.

That's it.

If you want anything else from your programming career then you'll need to do it yourself.

Dave3of5··on 'I have worked from home in 78 different countries'
How do these people stay out of the constant meetings per day. Sitting with a "glass of wine" whilst working would get me fired also. It must be a fairly liberal job, maybe a freelancer with rigidly defined scope or self employed.

I can't imagine running a business whilst never being in a fixed time zone must be a nightmare for your employees that want to get a hold of you.

Personally for me staying in AirBnB's / hotels almost all year round sounds like torture. I like my own bed and I don't sleep well when on holiday.

Dave3of5··on 81% of IT teams directed to reduce or halt cloud spending
All pricing in AWS is usage based and you'll find it's your usage that is variable.

An example of this is s3 storage. You tend to find your storage cost will increase over time as you put more stuff into s3. S3 also charges per api call so you'd have to somehow fix that.

You have egress fess also which you're not in control of so variable customers usage will net a variable cost.

In terms of reserving compute power (a popular answer) you can also achieve fixed price with on demand if you don't auto scale. So reserving here doesn't remove that variability. Reserving just make it cheap if you have constant use. So you can reserve you DB server as it's always on and you'll save over on demand.

Many of the small cloud providers offer much less variability for their services with things like fixed networking cost. I tend to use those as I want a fairly fixed bill. The only thing that's variable on my cloud bill is backup storage and GBP to EUR exchange rate. The backup fee's are < 5% of the total cost at the moment.

Dave3of5··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
Question for all those who are pro Copilot in this argument and are claiming fair use. Do these same rules apply if I manually copy someone elses copyrighted code into my codebase ?
Dave3of5··on GitHub Copilot, with “public code” blocked, emits my copyrighted code
> How responsible should Microsoft be for someone's badly licensed code on their platform?

That's actually a very real problem that mega money has been spent on. The same legal problem appears on sites like YouTube around fair use and copyright. In terms of fair use that doesn't apply here see:

https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/1217...

Regardless platforms are partially responsible for the content that their users upload into them. Most try to absolve themselves of this responsibility with their terms of service but legally that's just not possible.

Personally I'm an advocate for fair use but I'm also an advocate for strong copyright laws and their enforcement. In the short time the internet has been available to most people in the world there is a habit of stealing others work and claiming it as your own. Quite often this is for some financial gain.

Dave3of5··on Kim Jung Gi has died
That's rather personal but it is non zero.

It's clear to me you've made up your mind and you feel that spending the money is a waste for something that's so low risk so I don't see any point in continuing this conversation. If you do still work in an office I hope it never happens to you.

Dave3of5··on Kim Jung Gi has died
Nope ...
Dave3of5··on Kim Jung Gi has died
> Insurance would probably pay them out nicely

I wouldn't have bet any money on that. The dude was unwilling to pay £1100 for a life saving device what makes you think he would buy insurance that would pay upon employee death.

I know for a fact I didn't have any of that cover as my current company does pay death in service and it's like 4 times my yearly salary to my wife. So if he had anything like that he would have said so.

He's was just a cheap fuck. Companies often cheap out of safety gear to make a quick buck happens everywhere all the time.

Dave3of5··on Kim Jung Gi has died
The lifespan is 10-15 years depending on the model. Most people were at moderate risk, unfit, drinking alcohol, poor exercise, high stress job ...etc. For moderate risk 10-15% is the stat over a 5 year period. Most where moderate a few, 2 I think, were low and we had a few high and one very high risk given he'd possibly already had a small heart attack.

Also note that you didn't take into consideration that the device is used for all in the office so over the 5 years it's cost must be divided by the number of employees it will cover which in this case was around 12.

Again your Meteor comparison was extremely poor. You are comparing something that is very common, a middle aged person having heart attack, to something extremely uncommon a similar demographic being hit by a meteor. Also to note that you can't say it it £250 to protect from a meteor strike it would likely be extremely expensive to protect an office from that versus the insanely cheap £1100 to almost guarantee that any of us survive a heart attack.

I've eddited to show the actual lifespan of the AED which is 10-15 year

Dave3of5··on Kim Jung Gi has died
The individual likelihood is not <1%. It's probably more like 10-15% per person. some would be low some much higher. But I wasn't the only employee there there was around 12 employees in that office. There were several who were > 50 years old and in the high risk category which could put them up to 25%.

So given this plus your statement about the £1100 for a brand new one divided by the lifespan which I think is 5-10 years for each £110 per year I would say the value my life < £1000.

The CEO himself was very high risk and had actually been in the hospital recently for a suspected heart attack (a small one that didn't require intervention).

> Imagine if there was a meteor shield the company could buy for £250

The chance of being hit by a meteor is several orders of magnitude smaller than having a heart attack so this comparison is invalid.

A better comparison is being in a car crash and yes if they didn't spend £250 per 5 years to drastically improve my chance of dying in a car crash my life is worthless to them.

The company never listened to me on any of my suggestions so I think they were not listening and just denied my request the same as ever other request of mine they denied. I once asked for a new mouse and they denied that as well some CEOs are just like that.

Dave3of5··on Kim Jung Gi has died
> I was recently taught in first aid class that the survival rate of an out-of-hospital heart attack is about 10-12%.

In my first aid course we were taught that the speed in which an AED is applied is the main contributing factor. Giving that most workplaces/homes/restaurants ...etc don't actually have an AED you would normally get one when the ambulance arrives.

Someone in the NHS had worked out the graph for distance from ambulance and % survival. He gave us all our % chance survival if our office didn't have and AED based upon the average rate from our work places and that we needed to wait for the ambulance. This was under the assumption that someone would start CPR almost straight after the arrest.

In our office this % without an AED was < 10% something insane like 6% chance survival. With an AED survival is much higher. He gave the figure of 95%+ survival rate for offices that had AED in them.

I brought this up in a company meeting with all staff there and the question was how much is an AED. I had already asked this and it was £750 for an older second hand one and £1100 for a brand new one.

Never bought the flipping AED.

So from what I made out my life was worth < £750 to the CEO.

Dave3of5··on Ask HN: So you moved off Heroku, where did you go?
Nice strawman. I never said you can't operate more efficiently.

Every service on AWS charges egress fees that's my comment. There are other cloud operators that do not. I can safely run some static compute / storage / network at a fixed cost, you can't do this on AWS.

If too many people come to my website it won't wipe out my credit card. The site might go offline but I'd rather take that than a huge bill.

Dave3of5··on Ask HN: So you moved off Heroku, where did you go?
Eek what a hot take.

He's talking about the pricing model not the way to operate it. AWS bills for egress data. You can't operate it in any different way to stop that.

Dave3of5··on Companies are paying huge sums to show their ads to bots
> If you are paying any bill for ads, make sure you only pay for conversions

Others have already pointed out that this is actually impossible. The big ad platforms charge on impressions you can setup any targeting you want but they charge on impressions that's it.

Dave3of5··on Why modern software is slow
For big companies (like microsoft) software is ultimately controlled by the product teams. They prioritise the work that is to be done not the dev teams. Think of SCRUM for example the priority of the backlog is PO's responsibility not the devs.

Software is slow because it's not devs who make it all by themselves it's now a team and often team members are ambivalent or ignorant of performance. Requirements come first then perf later when often requirements and perf are the same.

Example you can't have a page that shows 100 million pieces of data (a requirement) and be fast. You have to pagination, lazy load ...etc. Those are requirements just as much as the fact you are showing 100 million bits of data.

Good teams have non-tech people that understand this. Bad teams (most teams tbh) don't and so insane slow shit gets put out to customers.

Dave3of5··on What Figma plans to do inside Adobe
Do you mean HTML/CSS/JS ?

If so that's a very very difficult task to do.

Dave3of5··on Mcmaster.com is the best e-commerce site I've ever used
Eek I'm going to go against the grain here a little. That site is useful when you already know what you are looking for. For someone who's just browsing for something interesting to buy it's terrible.

Obviously it's been made for exactly that purpose and does it well but for general e-commerce it's bad. The retailers are looking to send you to an area of their website with "stuff" you are interested in. For example you like toys because you're a parent who's buying your kids stuff for x-mas. The site wants to know that sort of thing and send you to the toys for x-mas section.

What Mcmaster.com looks like to me is an old fashioned mail order company that's converted their old mail order catalogue straight to a website, perfection.

Also note with Bezos tinkering with every pixel on the website is very old news, this doesn't happen anymore.

P.S. I'll eat the downvotes.

Dave3of5··on Show HN: Figr.app – a multi-user, notepad style calculator (desktop app)
Looks interesting, what makes this different from using a Google Sheet ?
Dave3of5··on Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B
N̶o̶t̶ ̶o̶p̶e̶n̶ ̶s̶o̶u̶r̶c̶e̶ ̶l̶i̶k̶e̶ ̶B̶l̶e̶n̶d̶e̶r̶ ̶b̶u̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶A̶f̶f̶i̶n̶i̶t̶y̶ ̶s̶u̶i̶t̶e̶ ̶i̶s̶ ̶p̶r̶e̶t̶t̶y̶ ̶c̶h̶e̶a̶p̶ ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶d̶o̶e̶s̶ ̶a̶ ̶f̶a̶i̶r̶l̶y̶ ̶g̶o̶o̶d̶ ̶j̶o̶b̶ ̶a̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶s̶e̶ ̶s̶o̶r̶t̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶n̶g̶s̶.̶

Ok it is the multiple user editing that people liked so much about figma. Ok that makes sense. Ignore me.

Dave3of5··on Increase: Banking API
Yes you are correct there are many rules I can't list them all here. The point is they are fixed rules and one is transaction amount.

> Very large number of transactions on personal accounts is also one of those rules.

Yes I suspect 1000's of trx on the accounts is what flag the whole thing to the bank.

> That sounds like fraud, not money laundering rule.

You have to take what I've said in context with the whole comment and not take a single part out of context.

As I said for money laundering you'll get consistent large transactions that don't make sense (say £250k each week from a pizza shop). Banks already know how to spot these large weird transactions so a method to hide them is to split them down into smaller transactions. My example with paying the kitchen was to show that the banks wouldn't notice the £500 transactions rather than the single £5000 transaction.

Dave3of5··on Increase: Banking API
> I don’t see how splitting to 1000 transactions and sending money to yourself helps with money laundering or undercover money sending

Banks rely on a fixed set of rules to trigger an investigation for money laundering. One of these rules is the value of the transaction. I worked in retail whilst at Uni in the UK and we often had people who had lot's of money in their accounts unable to make large purchases due to these checks. Their payment would be automatically blocked and you would get a phone number they had to call to be able to make the payment. It was for example when buying a £5000 kitchen (I worked in the equivalent of home depot in the UK). If they could have split that transaction down to say 10 payments of £500 it wouldn't have triggered anything on the bank side.

Overall these banks process a lot of transactions and so heavily rely on these rules to keep them within the law. They don't always work as can be seen here and the bank noticed that users were able to circumvent their crappy ruleset by split big transactions down to lots of small transactions.

Not sure about sending money to yourself I suspect they mean transferring money between two accounts you control which is different in the banking for from sending money to yourself. If you are in control of both accounts you are laundering the money by transferring it to another account when you secretly control both. It's a basic way people like the mafia and such have laundered money for decades. They will do it through facade companies or suchlike. So they have one of the gang be legit and "clean" setup a shop who deposits cash into their bank account from "sales". The shop is a real place that you could technically buy stuff from. They then transfer their profits to this other account that is the gangsters account. The gangsters is part owner and they are receiving money as they "own" the shop and the shop has made money from sales. The sales though are actually the gangster giving money to his own shop and them claiming that as sales to the bank. The bank doesn't know that the money is actually from selling drugs or robbing stores or w/e illegal stuff they have done. The result is that you have taken "dirty" money i.e. money that has came from some illegal activity and with this strange process you have made it into "clean" money that's come from some legal activity.

So basically all money laundering will be transferring money to "yourself" but it will be via a third party that probably takes a small cut for helping. It's worked like this for years and is super common.

The fixed set of rules they have in bank is because it used to be that making money movements was hard so the criminals would transfer say £250k in a single transaction as sales revenue. So banks could easily spot this and take action. Making money movements easier means they can bypass this check.

Dave3of5··on Increase: Banking API
> To be honest, I don't think money laundering is real, or significant.

Heard it all now time for me to get off this site I think.

Dave3of5··on Increase: Banking API
Ah yes the old BAI format which is totally not a CSV file with a bunch of insane rules that differ per bank and are passed around via sftp server that are on the internet.

I'm glad I quit that job. The only problem is when I tell people how the bank actually move money they don't believe me.

Dave3of5··on Work is work, in which returns diminish (2020)
Reads like a lot of Uni material.

We actually had a course at our Uni to stop us writing in this style. The Professors had become sick of reading white papers that said something straight forward in this strange Academic language.

I'd be willing to bet this person is very well educated or has maybe has worked in Academia.

Dave3of5··on The potential of mobile housing
Eek what a hot take. This sounds particularly like a US centric view of the education system. In Scotland we were taught a lot of the things you have mentioned although:

* fundamental electric and plumbing know-how

I disagree, these two things are dangerous when done incorrectly and are regulated industries in most countries. People with a little knowledge are dangerous. If you want to understand electrical you need to be full time on that for a while. School is for foundational things like can you read and do Maths.

> Why the fuck are we teaching them worthless things like calculus and programming and world history

How are these things "worthless" says a lot about you if you think world history is worthless ...

> Their time would be far better served being taught how to crunch and file their annual taxes

Again this is very much a US centric viewpoint in UK for example you don't need to know this as the government does it for you.

> How to operate a car so nobody gets runover

There is a whole industry that you pay money to do this. Operating a car is a dangerous activity and must be taught correctly. It also requires you actually drive in a car the practicality of teaching a whole school this just isn't there.

> How financial debt (read: loans and credit cards) works

You do get taught this at school I remember going through these types of examples.

> How to clean their own clothes and bedsheets

We had a course that everyone had to attend called "home economics" which taught this sort of thing. I think the name has changed. It also covered basic cooking.

> How to fix a leaky faucet or a faulty electrical appliance

Not sure you've thought that through but an incorrectly repaired electrical appliance can burn your house down and an incorrectly fixed leaky faucet can flood your house.

> Britons were once taught how to wire their electrical gadgets in school

They still are! In Scotland it was called technical studies and taught things like basic woodwork with handtools and how to wire a plug that sort of thing.

Dave3of5··on Europe’s energy crisis hits science
> currently storing only slightly more than Belgium for example

Your site is confusing and actually lists UK as 100% full (which it's not) which is the highest in the list.

Dave3of5··on Europe’s energy crisis hits science
Has this actually happened due to the pandemic? I don't believe there was any mothballing of power plants in the UK during the pandemic.
Dave3of5··on Europe’s energy crisis hits science
> but if there's no fuel or staff, it's going to be idle

That would indicate that there is a gas shortage in the UK right now which isn't true. In terms of staff the daily operations of a plant only requires a handful of people. There was I think only 2 control room operators on duty at the 1200 MW plant I was working in near Bristol (Seabank power station). So I suspect it's not that he's referring to.

Given that he was a scientist at Oxford he must have data to back this up but I'd like to see what plants shutdown.

Edit: Actually I'm wrong the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies looks like some thinktank that props up oil and gas. The board of directors tell you what you need to know about them. I think this whole article is garbage.

Dave3of5··on Europe’s energy crisis hits science
> Power generators that had been shut down could not ramp up in time to meet renewed demand

Not disputing this but can someone give a source on what power generators in the UK where shutdown during the pandemic and could not ramp back up ?

I've worked in a power plant and the gas combined cycle one I worked in could be shutdown and re-started in about 10 minutes (I know this as I actually shut one down by mistake).

The only power plants I think that work like this are nuclear which must continuously run once started albeit they can be run at a lower level if demand is low.

Edit: It's looks like for nuclear all I can find is Sizewell B was reduced to 50% for a few months but I can see it's back up to 100% now:

https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-fu...

https://www.edfenergy.com/energy/power-station/daily-statuse...

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →