HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Dave3of5

1,216 karma · joined October 24, 2019

submissionscomments
Dave3of5··on Ask HN: Cloud vs. Dedicated Hosting
5 VM for each dev ? That sounds a bit strange given that you only have 2 prod VMs.

Ignoring the weird dev VMs. The setup you have at the moment is tiny so cost isn't the issue here. In terms of dedicated you'll likely have to buy that for a least a year and so I don't think fully dedicated is the correct move here.

There are smaller cloud providers that'll give you those 2 prod VMs at a fraction of the Azure price but again price really isn't much of a factor here so I think staying on Azure is the right move.

I think personally you should look at moving those 5 dev VM's locally i.e. not in the cloud. It's really strange to have that many dev VM's.

Dave3of5··on Job interviews that go too far
I've actually seen "free ample parking" as a benefit.
Dave3of5··on Job interviews that go too far
Having just been through the recruitment hellscape last year the take home tests are absurd. Some companies are asking for whole weekends worth of work before you even get to speak to anyone.

Needless to say if a company is asking for an 8 hour take home, you bet your ass they don't respect you as a candidate and won't respect you as an employee.

I hoped that if we collectively stopped doing these then they would go away but there are a lot of people who like doing these and believe they are a net positive for some reason.

Dave3of5··on Many software companies are a joke
I agree that the tone of the article is off but I don't agree with this statement:

> Obviously there are inefficiencies with big companies, but complaining about needing to do documentation, or basic project management?

This sounds like you've never been in a big org where you write more word docs than you do code. I have. It was terrible for a few reasons:

* Those docs go out of date with the code very quickly and so are not a good reference to what the code actually does

* They eat up a lot of project time and so projects tend to become late. As the documentation is what you have to write first by the time you get to the code you have much less time to actually write the dam code

* Extreme documentation actually reduces code quality. I've worked on many code bases where the code actually references page numbers and sections rather than what it actually doing. This is often the case with contractors that are only on project for a short amount of time and thus translate the docs directly into code. Also if there are and errors when creating these docs they are often translated into the code often into performance / non-functional problems

* Docs written after the fact end up being rather pointless / unusable as you'll have to describe all the weird things you done to make it work properly / fast ...etc

* Non technical people will read what you've written not understand it, because it's highly technical, misinterpret it then use that strange idea of things they've got all over the place. Like someone that doesn't know what a Foreign Key is but seen it once and sticks them on every column in the DB. Then you'll have to have a fight with them as "it says here on this doc"

I could go on but I suspect what I've written here is quite unpopular so I'll end by saying that documentation is very hard to write correctly you need specialists who know exactly how to describe what's been done in the system to others. You also need to balance the amount of docs you create vs the actual work on creating the thing.

Again on Project Management you described it as "Obviously there are inefficiencies with big companies" that sounds like you've never been in a full 8 hour days worth of meetings getting 0 coding done and just explaining to 10 different managers what needs to be done. Some of these big corporates are so colossally inefficient that people have been quitting on mass during the pandemic to get away from it. It's a serious problem not just to be swept under the rug like oh well that's just what big companies do. I heard someone either on reddit or on here defend a 3 hour long "daily standup" meeting because it was good to know what the devs are doing. Like yeah there are in you meeting for 1/2 of the day.

Now I don't condone 0 project management but companies seriously need to cut it back. Tools like Jira have made working hell for some programmers.

Dave3of5··on Cities with Nice Weather
There is no qualitative way to work this out. Your graphs and numbers here are meaningless.
Dave3of5··on Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring
Oh dear wtf is going on at twitter HQ right now. Be interesting to see what happens when the dust settles.
Dave3of5··on The saddest “just ship it” story (2020)
> I started building an app on 01.01.2018. It was New Year's Eve and we just had the crappiest night ever. Yes, imagine a night so bad that at midnight you decide "you know what, fuck it, I'm gonna work on WEB DEVELOPMENT". That bad.

Am I the only one that actually enjoys development ? I do development for fun in my free time, often with things that are completely throw away.

Dave3of5··on EU Commission is planning automatic CSAM scanning of private communications
The message here is a private message. The title of this post contains the words "private communication" same for the title in the actual post.

Have you not actually read anything about the post ?

Dave3of5··on Many popular websites see what you type before you hit submit
That's what I said ...
Dave3of5··on Many popular websites see what you type before you hit submit
It would be really inefficient to store this as a full HD video for thousands of users.

If you store and mouse movements, scroll events, clicks ...etc and you know what the website looked like then you can replay these to produce something that looks like a video. The bonus points is that you can run mathematically analysis on the clickstream to get things like most clicked area and suchlike.

It's actually the same data that's used in the heatmap just a different visualisation.

Dave3of5··on Many popular websites see what you type before you hit submit
> I'm having trouble understanding the value prop

It'll be for abandoned signups.

If someone is literally on the signup page but end up not clicking the submit button you want to find out what stopped them and coerce them somehow to actually clicking the button.

The more data you gather about the process the more you can adapt the signup page to actually get them to click the button. It's really important for startups as one of their KPI's will be new signups per X. Companies like slack, facebook, youtube ..etc have teams of people who are working on this type of thing.

Note: I do not condone this type of invasive analytics but I'm telling you why they do it that's all.

Dave3of5··on Many popular websites see what you type before you hit submit
Btw it's worse that this.

Most popular website are tracking your mouse movements and clicks on their website. It's called a user heatmap and it's meant to be used to see what users are actually clicking on when they drop into your website i.e. everyone highlighted this word on you copy or stopped scrolling after this section that sort of thing.

It's been happening for many years. If you don't want to give websites this data block javascript in your browser by default.

Dave3of5··on Show HN: 1,900 remote company profiles with tech stacks and employee benefits
Yes you're correct also local labour laws. One countries generous holiday package may be below the legal minimum for another.

Most companies I know that operate internationally have subcompanies in each company they have employees in. Any FTE is employed by the sub company for taxation and legal reasons. That's a high admin burden for a 10 person start-up easier just to employee people in the same country.

Dave3of5··on Show HN: 1,900 remote company profiles with tech stacks and employee benefits
One big point about remote companies is that most companies even if they are remote still want employees that are in a similar time zone. So if you're in Japan it's unlikely a European company will hire you as the times zones are so different you essentially never be able to communicate with each other in real time.

This means that you should have something on this job board to indicate where they want to hire people from otherwise it's completely useless.

Dave3of5··on Eve Online fans cheer Microsoft Excel features at annual Fanfest
I have recently. It's OK not a brilliant game but good.

In terms of the spreadsheets in space that's only one aspect. I bought a little package for £5.99 which has skill boosts and some plex. All in all that setup my FTP character to be able to do whatever I want. So you can ignore this entirely and just play the game the way you want tbh.

Dave3of5··on The Problem with Slack at Scale
Yeah a lot of orgs and employees are pretty toxic and Slack and teams makes it very easy to be like that. I wonder if there is a tech solution to this or if it's something that has to be handled outside of the tool.
Dave3of5··on The Problem with Slack at Scale
I'm actually really interesting in this. What are the top 3 things you could change in slack / teams that would make you switch. I'll go first:

* Notifications settings are annoying I'm either swamped with notifications or miss them. I want to be able to switch of notifications for short periods

* I want to group discussions about certain things. I.e. if we are discussing a JIRA issue I can select the message and group them into something that I can attach to the issue we are discussing

* Too many private chats - I'd like to ban private chats as I find there's some great info in these which are often not shared to the group

Dave3of5··on Agile and the long crisis of software
I suspect with your comments you've been out the game a while. Most devs that I interact with hate SCRUM. Your Gantt chart is still there btw it's just not shown to devs but product are still creating all that but overlaying SCRUM over it.

Your 6 month project now has to be finished every 2 weeks now working shipped bug free in 2 whole weeks. The scope has been reduced for sure but now everything you do has to be in 2-3days at tops.

Dave3of5··on Agile and the long crisis of software
Just as a note to the author what you saw the engineers do was SCRUM not agile. Most argue that SCRUM is agile I'm not 100% sure of that.

SCRUM was a framework that one of the original agile proponents built to make money off developers. It gained popularity not from engineers but from project managers and the like which meant suddenly every project started to use SCRUM. The main reason was that they sold a course which gave a certificate and if there something that a project manager like more than micromanaging it's certification.

Dave3of5··on Ask HN: Why can't I learn anymore?
I'd ape the burnout diagnosis. You have classic syndromes.
Dave3of5··on RAD Basic – Compatible with Visual Basic 6 projects
Problem with VB6 was that for small projects it was fine but for medium to large projects it gets out of hand very quickly.

For example when you drag and drop toolbar items onto your form it automatically gives them a boilerplate name. You can rename these but you tend to find devs would forget so after a while just looking at the code you started to get Label1.Text = "blah". I seen that in just about every project and one I remember done by a Chinese dev with poor English he left all the controls with the boilerplate names and so it was impossible to reason about what was happening.

Componentisation was also a problem in that you tended to have all your code connected directly to the form. So if you had a large form that done complex stuff it wasn't unusual to have a multi thousand line long form file.

Separation of concerns was a problem in that again the code was attached to a form so you found UI code mixed in with proper business logic. This becomes very messy over time and tends to create very large event handlers the more a project grows.

It was basically impossible to unit test which makes refactoring very risky. On large projects what generally happens then is that no one is willing to refactor anything as they don't really know all the scenarios. Over time this leads to code rot.

It only ran on windows, while I'm sure there are ways to make it run under linux the main support was for windows and most orgs stuck to that. This ties in with the fact that you had to install the thing on your P.C. businesses hated this and still do. Things like people uninstalling it or problems locally with permissions and suchlike were rampant. Similarly updating was a pain on large projects you have to have something central install and do the update.

Scalability was problematic on large projects especially since the forms app would often directly connect to the database. That meant the more user = more connections which on large project meant problems. The "solution" was some service or api which the app talked to but at that point it's no longer vb6 doing the heavy lifting and it's just become a UI.

Small little tools or prototype apps was were vb6 shined brightly.

Dave3of5··on Heroku Security Notification
> I’m interested in peoples experience with this and if it’s relatively true.

My personal experience is that AWS is always more expensive. You don't use AWS because of the cost saving you use it because:

* Top of the line h/w * Always the first to bring out new features * Very high availability of resource, like seriously I've never had a time even during the pandemic where they struggled with resource availability * Resilience of AWS systems are very high * Very good support

There was an article a few months back where a teams tried moving from Heroku to AWS to save money and ended up spending nearly 3x the amount. Heroku give more resource than you actually pay for by default and it turns out they were using the extra resource during normal operation. When they done their calcs for a switch to AWS they used the quoted resource that Heroku say you get and there system died due to being under resourced. They had to up the resource which pushed them well over their budget. I'll try and find the article.

Please Note: Heroku servers are on AWS already

Dave3of5··on Software Engineering at Google (2020) [pdf]
> Google doesn't have a behavioral interview

Huh? That's absolutely false. FYI this dude wasn't just ex-google he was ex-facebook and ex-google (worked at both). He was a Product Manager and then I think some VP of something. He was like a VP at the the parent company of the company I was interviewing for.

FAANG stand for: "Facebook (now Meta), Amazon, Apple, Netflix, and Google (now Alphabet)".

Looking at the questions I suspect these came from facebook but were altered. I even asked the next interviewer (the one I was actually told I was being interviewed by) that I found the questions strange and he agreed and said that the guy was kind "out there".

Dave3of5··on Microsoft 3D Movie Maker Source Code
Ahh the big old 9000 line long files way of developing code.

There are surprising few files but those that are here are massive.

Dave3of5··on Tailscale raises $100M
Crazy how people can raise these sums of money, it's all about who you know.

I also notice they have a careers page so I had a gander. A 6 stage interview process! Good lord tech companies really have gone down the shitter

Dave3of5··on Bits of advice I wish I had known
> Do you require a full-blown argument for every piece of advice or information you ever hear?

There's a lot of misinformation and opinions stated as facts on the internet. So yes for opinions / advice given online I tend to require an explanation. This list has some questionable advice an example:

"Dont purchase extra insurance if you are renting a car with a credit card"

This is false in the UK. Over here that's wrong advice to think you CC provider gives insurance. If that's in the US then it's not always true as well and even then comes with caveat's.

I think in general that's true about almost everything on this list.

Dave3of5··on Software Engineering at Google (2020) [pdf]
I've interviewed with an ex FANNG employee and it was an intense / chaotic interview. A wholly unpleasant experience that felt a little like what happens to people when they get involved in a cult.

Lots of personal questions about attitude, what you do in your spare time, how you feel about things that bordered on the illegal.

I was personally intimidated by the process and in the end they never even bothered to contacted me back.

I think if I see this again I will pass but unfortunately I was never told this chap was going to interview me until I was in the office shaking his bloody hand. Maybe they wanted to keep it secret for this exact reason.

Dave3of5··on Bits of advice I wish I had known
I agree it's most banal nonsense and none of these are backed up with an explanation which is actually the interesting part.

You learn as a person when you understand why you should do something not just blindly following a list of advice.

Dave3of5··on Bits of advice I wish I had known
Misbehave != tantrum. Normal child misbehave way more than they have tantrums (source: I have 2 children myself and my wife is a trained nursery nurse).

Regardless with a tantrum you wait till they are calm then speak to them and explain to them what's the correct thing to do in that situation.

Dave3of5··on Airbnb’s design to live and work anywhere
This will get a lot of comments because it's AirBnB not because of the actual content.
← PreviousPage 8 of 13Next →