HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DesiLurker

1,192 karma · joined September 10, 2016

submissionscomments
DesiLurker··on Economics of Orbital vs. Terrestrial Data Centers
this does not makes sense from dollars pov to me, I ran a back of napkin session with claude & gemini on this and the short of it is you need a magical weightless radiator for cooling and even then it wont work because the launch costs need to be sub $100 before this can be feasible. this does not even factors the 5y amortization and LEO orbit drag correction.

It then occurred to me that they (all major AI companies) know all of these facts but still pushing for it so there must be another reason. Then I recalled the offhand statement from the openAI lady about govt backstop for infra, which was strongly opposed by public and AI czar. this might be be a backdoor way of injecting that backstop capital in terms of subsidies now for results in 5 years or so. and needless to say after pilot programs those will fail spectacularly.

DesiLurker··on macOS 26.2 enables fast AI clusters with RDMA over Thunderbolt
does this means an egpu might finally work with macbook-pro or studio?
DesiLurker··on Id Software devs form "wall-to-wall" union
Did you miss the last sentence or had your mind made up already by then?

the reason I don't want a typical union is because they work out well where there is a clear separation of labor & capital. labor get paid wages & capital makes money off the invested assets. problem with tech is that in a tech ventures labor is a part owner and capital too (engineer equity). introducing a 3rd party (unions & union leadership) in these situations will likely have the worst effect on the capital portion of labor & possibly eroding the incentives altogether. Imagine having a set of union rules to follow when distributing equity to early stage engineers? how do you decide equitable when by definition you are on cutting edge of tech & innovation. & if you think that wont happen you are mistaken, that is where the biggest pie is and unions arent exactly 'shining beacon of honesty and integrity' either. Look all I want is just some basic labor laws are followed and tech employees dont feel the panic when they hear slack-chime on a weekend night.

there are other mechanisms like state level enforcement of labor laws and punitive fines. you know the good old law enforcement. its really not so hard if you actually want to do it.

DesiLurker··on Id Software devs form "wall-to-wall" union
As a non gaming engineer, I dont want a union, what I really want is solid (really, harsh) enforcement of basic common sense labor rules for exempt workers like weekly working hour limits, no after hours scheduling or minimum notice/severance period for layoffs & many other abuses. Problem is tech industry does not wants to give an inch and workers don't complain because of higher pay and 'lottery ticket' effect.

I fear the time for fixing this is passing fast. Its because within a decade AI will have enough of labor displacement that labor wont have any negotiating leverage against capital. If this happens with union, so be it.

DesiLurker··on NVIDIA frenemy relation with OpenAI and Oracle
to me bigger problem emerges if you assume all those companies in the 'circular financing infographic' as one conglomerate. then essentially all you are left with is real demand for AI & I just dont really see much of it besides Hype and FOMO. that falls away the moment CFOs get 'permission' to ignore the AI growth story. besides that I only see coding bot and openAI's consumer subscription business. I dont see that becoming $1T business anytime soon. so what gives? I think Burry is right but I am not sure of timing because they just need one funder to extend and pretend for a few more quarters & DJT can do it under guise of datacenter jobs etc.

Circular thing is bad too but from a different angle, Imagine if the whole TPU vs GPU thing erodes Nvidia's moat and its profit margins compress. if that happens how long it can keep feeding the same unproductive 'pets.AI' type startups? one break in the narrative and tragedy of commons strikes. will it happen soon? anybody's guess but given Trump is at helm and there is going to be new Fed chief, I doubt it would be anywhere near soon. Definitely not before mid-terms are locked in.

DesiLurker··on 1D Conway's Life glider found, 3.7B cells long
yes you are right the question was ambiguous. WHat I was really looking for is if there is a way to physically derive PI out of some basic cellular automata operations. that does not necessarily have to involve circles etc. much less so about representing digits of PI itself. just that an pattern that evolves into ever more accurate values of pi (or a quantity derived from pi). this definitly must not be encoded or somehow preprogrammed into the GoL's initial condition. In fact I dont even care if the evolution rules of standard GoL are followed. just that SOME set of rules automatically produce PI-derivative.

the reason it would be cool is because then we've taken a most fundamental geometric constant and derived it from purely graph update type of mechanics. if you could do that then likely you can do a whole set of other things like physical laws.

DesiLurker··on 1D Conway's Life glider found, 3.7B cells long
I think I've read it or maybe a portion of it, was not very captivating. will try again.
DesiLurker··on 1D Conway's Life glider found, 3.7B cells long
if you find that fascinating then you'll be blown away by something called 'Wolfarm physics project'. it basically is trying to recreate entire physics using such baseline 'graph update' rules like 'Game of Life'. So far no predictions yet but very interesting.
DesiLurker··on 1D Conway's Life glider found, 3.7B cells long
makes me wonder if its possible to get natural numbers like pi/e using a geometric structure in GoL. it would be interesting to derive them from an emerging order based on fixed set of automata rules. If possible it might lead credence to simulated universe hypothesis.
DesiLurker··on Using AI to negotiate a $195k hospital bill down to $33k
and imagine doing that to earn just $300M thats like a dollar per citizen.
DesiLurker··on Using AI to negotiate a $195k hospital bill down to $33k
thank you for this comment, learnt a new defensive trick today.
DesiLurker··on $19B Wiped Out in Crypto's Biggest Liquidation
there were a couple of reasons

1) there is a lot of circumstantial evidence of insider trading before the timing of presidential tariff announcement. further the accounts that traded on hyperliquid DEX were funded 24hours before even the first tweet by the president indicating fore-knowledge.

2) crypto exchanges have a feature called auto-deleveraging which closes long and short positions to 'preserve the solvency & integrity of exchange'. apparently this got kicked in when some of the thinly traded coins just didnt have a market maker & basically floor fell out of price.

3) looks like some screwup happened (likely intentional unknown atm) with the price reporting oracle between decentrralized exchanges like hyperliquid and Centralized exchange used (binance). people are claiming intentional sabotage by binance because they have a competing dex called aster. who knows.

4) leverage play, everybody was levered up because of up-tober expectations. so even small movements wiped out peoples saving.

DesiLurker··on SkiftOS: A hobby OS built from scratch using C/C++ for ARM, x86, and RISC-V
thats a strawman, here's a summary of ownership from google: Be Inc. => Palm => PalmSource => ACCESS Co.

this is ho many times they moved it around or sold it. each one of these times they had to do due diligence before same as you do with any ip acquisition. okay if you dont want to do full opensource, how about taking a few modules and just bsd-3 or MIT-ing them. it shows Intent, how many time any VC has done this in last 20 years? none that I recall. this is the problem, big do-gooder talk about changing the world, but at the end of day they are out to JUST make money.

DesiLurker··on SkiftOS: A hobby OS built from scratch using C/C++ for ARM, x86, and RISC-V
apologies for offtopic rant, but why cant they (palmsource/??) just open source BeOS codebase? what possible gain they can have by holding onto 20yo codebase just out of licensing spite. honestly for all the do-gooder talk in VC community this is the easiest thing to achieve. have a funding clause that if your company dies then all rights of unfinished works goto investors and by charter opensource it for benefit of other startups. we could have had greatness many times over.

rant over!

DesiLurker··on What does Palantir actually do?
but to sell you as serfs.
DesiLurker··on Blood oxygen monitoring returning to Apple Watch in the US
right, just learn to outrun the chubby guys when the bear chases.
DesiLurker··on Blood oxygen monitoring returning to Apple Watch in the US
yes, and ribcage should be mesh-gridded if it did not want to be knifed, Right?
DesiLurker··on Efficient Computer's Electron E1 CPU – 100x more efficient than Arm?
I recall Mathstar's FPOA (field programmable object arrays) have had similar architecture. it seems they have done a mixture of stack computer, this and some async programming to get this level of optimization. The other one I had seen with pretty good on chip fabric was Tilera who were using something like a packet switch to interconnect tonnes of on-chip cores.

My first reaction watching this video was that they are just shifting the problem to compiler, which is actually worse and also does not works for dynamic code with tonnes of branches. Also, didnt Intel burn a lot of money trying to do this with Itanium?

Overall, interesting idea but I filed it under 'solution looking for a problem' desk.

DesiLurker··on Grok: Searching X for "From:Elonmusk (Israel or Palestine or Hamas or Gaza)"
I agree it is horrible but the point I am making is this type of stuff is more common than we'd think. So almost anyone with power would have some 'skeletons in the closet'.

think about it, we lost al franken as senator but still have DJT as president (& many more if you think DJT is unstoppable).

DesiLurker··on Grok: Searching X for "From:Elonmusk (Israel or Palestine or Hamas or Gaza)"
I am convinced that the whole 'sexual abuse' thing is very common in upper echelons and make for a convenient excuse to take down someone now towing the line.

I almost always look for 'root cause' when I hear a sexual abuse scandle taking down someone in power.

DesiLurker··on Proton joins suit against Apple for practices that harm developers and consumers
nice strawman, first google honeypotted the smartphone-os sector with their AOSP (android opensource project). now when they killed every other option except apple & effectively became a monopoly for all smartphone vendors, they are using their monopoly power to prohibit companies from using aosp piecemeal. they are explicitly telling vendors if you make any device with google services then you cannot make an ungoogled device at-all. this is exact opposite of the open source spirit and highlights that they were never interested in opensource, they were doing pretty much what MS did in 90s, release a bundled shitty version of a popular app with OS so you can kill them and maintain dominant monopoly. they just weaponized oss with AOSP to kill off any contenders.

take a moment to think why amazon has no google services on their table and/or an amazon branded basic android smartphone, it would be super easy for them to do it (leave aside firephone .. for reasons).

How is this not monopoly abuse? if Lina Khan had any balls this is what she would have gone after.

edit: chatgpt explanation: https://chatgpt.com/share/686350ce-47dc-8008-8c30-14c6298d75...

DesiLurker··on Proton joins suit against Apple for practices that harm developers and consumers
google with their android anti-fragmentation-agreement is pretty predatory. basically release any/all android devices with google services and pay us cut or release none and use pure aosp. it is some next level shit.
DesiLurker··on A CarFax for Used PCs; Hewlett Packard wants to give old laptops new life
HP is circling the drain! if they have to resort to rentseeking crap like this then they are already out of high ROI revenue streams.
DesiLurker··on Show HN: Zeekstd – Rust Implementation of the ZSTD Seekable Format
great I can use it to pipe large logfiles and store for later retrival. is there something like zcat also?
DesiLurker··on V-JEPA 2 world model and new benchmarks for physical reasoning
possibly with their investment into AR/VR and gaming they may see a pathway to creating 'physical intelligence' and tap into a much bigger untapped market. I mean isn't Robotaxi the main carrot Musk's been holding in front of tesla investors for decade or so. physical robots may provide a more 'incremental fault tolerant' path to application of AI.
DesiLurker··on Tesla shows no sign of improvement in May sales data
seriously just put door handles like a normal car, both inside and out, wtf is wrong with this guy. also drop the freaking wind doors for X, they are tacky, annoying and full of issues.
DesiLurker··on Indian court orders blocking of Proton Mail
people will get stuck on 'good govt china..' but I get what you mean. moving on to core message. Indian courts are some of the dumbest, red-tape laden, corrupt entities out there. for westerners, its common for basic things like property disputes or even divorces to run for decades (yes -s plural). In India the legal process is itself a punishment. plus there is no consistency in case law or precedent. people often perjure themselves and walk around like its nothing. it really is free for all with Indian judiciary so I am not surprised at-all that they will do something stupid like this.
DesiLurker··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
my 2c on this is that if you interact with any current llm enough you can mentally 'place' its behavior and responses. when we truly have AGI+/ASI my guess is that it will be like that old adage of blind men feeling & describing an elephant for the first time. we just wont be able to fully understand its responses. it would always be something left hanging and then eventually we'll just stop trying. that would be time when the exponential improvement really kicks in.

it should suffice to say we are nowhere near that and I dont even believe LLMs are the right architecture for that.

DesiLurker··on ICE director envisions Amazon-like mass deportation system
more like 'I got mine, F U' to anybody else including their own kids.
DesiLurker··on Refutations to Roko's Basilisk
I've always viewed roko's basilisk as 'pascals wager for the nerds'. problem is that its a constructed narrative fit to target a desired outcome. reality is not tunneled into final state, it incrementally evolves. as I always say humans are ultimately analog but the pascals wager or any such 'do X or else' type setup tries to turn us into digital beings at some fundamental level. It does not works and just ends up distorting human behavior.

even for Roko's basilisk it does not works if you apply some non-standard thinking like what happens if you apply second derivative basilisk as in would the super-super intelligence punish super-intelligence for bad behavior leading up to its own creation. IMO basilisk (& pascals wager for that matter) are cheap attempts to scare masses into submission, self censor & divide us into factions. they are pretty much targeting the worst impulses in humanity.

BTW if you are going to take a model for (mass) compliance I'd say Hindu concept of reincarnation (as in do-overs with random levels .. think Netflix platform movie) is probably a better one than 'pascals wager derivatives'.

← PreviousPage 2 of 28Next →