HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DilipJ

306 karma · joined March 7, 2010

just a guy with an idea
submissionscomments
DilipJ··on Why Finland’s schools are great (by doing what we don’t).
Right, but a majority of those non-English speakers in Canada are in Quebec speaking French. I can't imagine there's that much of an IQ difference between French- and Anglo-Canadians...
DilipJ··on Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs
It takes real balls and vision to turn down that much money. The thing is, without having the confidence to be able to turn down millions, it's unlikely one will ever be able to build a product worth millions. Those in it for the quick buck usually will fold under the slightest bit of trouble.
DilipJ··on Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs
Dropbox is YC backed. It is probably the greatest thing to come out of YC (from a monetary standpoint).
DilipJ··on Why Finland’s schools are great (by doing what we don’t).
Canada is far less diverse than the US. Canada is about 90% white, the US is about 68% white. And most minorities in Canada are screened for education/intelligence before arrival, whereas in the US most minorities are a byproduct of the transatlantic slave trade/illegal immigration
DilipJ··on Why The 99% Should Protest Against Y Combinator
I think they are both right (or both wrong). Or maybe they are not talking about the same thing.

I think O'Neill believes Monsanto to be a far worse company than pg (or I, for that matter) do. It's an agrochemical company that does engage in strong-arm legal tactics, but at the same time, it's not on the level of IBM working with the Germans in the 1930's. O'Neill does have a point in that in a free society, consumers have a right to choose which products to purchase and which companies to support, and if they want to politicize that decision it is entirely their right to do so. pg would likely agree with statement. So the only real disagreement between the two would probably come down to how "bad" a company Monsanto is, in their view. pg obviously views it in a far more benign light than O'Neill does.

the "99%" talk is irrelevant. The 99'ers focus seems to be (or should be) on the parasitic nature of Wall Street and their close relationship to the Treasury Dept. and the Federal Reserve, and not on corporate ethics in general.

DilipJ··on Steve Jobs has passed away.
Geez. I know it's not good to say anything bad about someone who died, but that plus other things he's done makes me think he's a real ----

I hope Woz gets a similar level of recognition and mourning when he passes (decades into the future, hopefully)

DilipJ··on Steve Jobs has passed away.
yeah, that's what's so crazy to me. Others would take a trip around the world or something. He was very devoted. Makes me think of that Dylan Thomas poem:

"do not go gentle into that good night, rage, rage against the dying of the light. "

DilipJ··on Steve Jobs has passed away.
When I look at what he managed to accomplish before he turned 30, it makes me feel like a total loser. But it's also a great source of motivation.

also, the Apple homepage really is beautiful in its simplicity. I hope they leave it like this for awhile.

DilipJ··on Who Owns Facebook? The Definitive Who's Who Guide to Facebook Wealth
This list is a testament to the importance of networks for startups.
DilipJ··on Why don't rich people do more awesome things?
investing in restaurants is a great way for a rich guy to become a poor guy. One case of food poisoning and you'll be dealing with lawsuits that will force you under.

plus it's not scalable, so it's difficult to make a lot of money, unless the food is so good or unique that you can franchise it. But I'm guessing the appeal of Elan has more to do with the atmosphere than the menu...

Anyway, it doesn't matter, the reason the landlord is raising the rent is because he/she assumes that there is someone willing to pay more for the space, which indicates that there is a more economically viable operation that can be run in that area than that particular restaurant.

DilipJ··on Detroit is Dying… Quickly
Detroit is the extreme. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_large_...
DilipJ··on Detroit is Dying… Quickly
For God's sake, dont buy a place in Detroit! If you want a house for cheap, go to Vegas or Phoenix, you can find a 3 bedroom home for less than 60K. Or if you want to see a mini-Detroit up close, just drive through Oakland. In 20 years, Oakland will be where Detroit is today.

Detroit is like seeing 'Atlas Shrugged' in real life. The unions drove away the business, and the blacks drove away the whites. So basically all the productive people left, and now the only professionals left are the criminals. Bing is a good mayor, but it's too little too late. Only Robocop can save Detroit now.

DilipJ··on Ask HN: I'm an unemployed programmer in SF that will work for minimum wage
Granted, but sometimes the impression that comes off to a young kid may be akin to that of Lebron/Kobe telling innercity kids that they should study and go to college because not everyone can make it to the NBA. Stuff like that falls on deaf ears, because the only thing that the kids take away is "this guy with a high school degree gets millions for dribbling a ball and that means I can too".

Perhaps YC should focus more on attracting guys in their 30's or 40's? You'll end up with candidates who are more grounded and who will have a better idea of the risks they are entering into. They might also come up with better business and consumer solutions than the youths that typically apply. It might be worth trying out, even just as an experiment,to have one of your funding rounds be set aside exclusively for those who are 30+

DilipJ··on Ask HN: I'm an unemployed programmer in SF that will work for minimum wage
Good luck! I know things are rough now, but it will get better. It can be tough feeling like the whole world is succeeding but yourself, but dont let the FUD associated with that get you down.

And if you do start another venture in the future, this experience can be an asset, and one day you will look back on this as a trial you had to go through

DilipJ··on Ask HN: I'm an unemployed programmer in SF that will work for minimum wage
Where does a fresh college grad get savings from? Who is going to hire him to consult?

The reality is, most college grads are coming out with 5 or 6 figure student loan debt. Repayment starts within 6 months. You NEED to find a job to start repaying that. If you decide to go the full entrepreneurial route and end up missing even one payment, then you can go into immediate default and fines will be added, and your credit score will be impacted. If and when your entrepreneurial venture fizzles (as most do), you will have a tough time finding a job outside the startup community, because your low credit score and possible wage garnishment issues is a red flag to the pinheads in Human Resources.

This is reality, and I think kids in their 20's who go the startup route straight from college should be made aware of the risks.

DilipJ··on Ask HN: I'm an unemployed programmer in SF that will work for minimum wage
ouch. this is why it's dangerous to read a pg essay on entrepreneurship when you're in college. He makes it look easy, and some kids just follow their dreams without building a support base first. Remember that for every guy like pg, there are 9 others just like him who went bankrupt. Coming out of college, you should always try to find a stable, legit job and try to build up a capital base. Get paid by someone else and develop a level of professional competency, build up your credit score and take out a loan and do something on the side, and only go solo once who you have some stable revenue. This is the way to do it, unless you come from money or are lucky.

So here's my steps to you for changing things around:

1) Completely revamp your resume, and to stop referring to yourself as unemployed. You were self-employed.

2) write down a list of all the competitors your startup had that are located nearby. Find out the phone numbers/emails to the higher ups in those companies through web searching.

3) phone or email those guys, and say that you are writing a freelance article about the industry. Say you want to interview them for their expertise (all guys love to have their ego's stroked: that's the way to get that introduction you want).

4) during the interview (preferably in person, or by phone), ask them some general questions about the industry, and mention that you had attempted to do a startup in the field but failed. Try to ask questions related to how their business succeeded, in order to compare and contrast with your own experiences. Ask them to give you advice on whether to pursue another startup in this field (even though you may have no intention of doing so) or look for a job in the industry.

Now at this point, it can go 1 of 2 ways. If you're lucky, the other person may see your interest for the field, and ask to see some of your work. If it's good, you will probably move to the top of the pile when a new hire is needed. If that doesn't happen, then repeat as necessary with every other company.

That's a better bet than anything else out there, don't waste your time with the craigslist blackhole

DilipJ··on Paul Graham's Search for the Next Facebook
yes, he never seems to show his teeth when people take his photo. I suspect it's because he's British?
DilipJ··on Digg freezes manual story submissions as user anger mounts
This is the problem with raising so much VC money, especially at a post-$100 million valuation (and dreams of an IPO). There's no way Digg can get the revenue necessary to repay their investors (or even be profitable with their bloated staff), without having to resort to actions like these. Having just a skyscraper ad isn't going to cut it.

By essentially allowing their sponsors to decide what's going to be on their front page, they've changed digg from a crowdsourced editorial board to a sponsored RSS feed. I can't remember the last time a .com made such a shortsighted decision....I can't see digg even being around in a few years after this.

DilipJ··on Why are so many people in their 20s taking so long to grow up?
I don't know, a lot of those aren't really the fault of baby boomers. It's more just government subsidies in these specific areas, which end up distorting prices and incentivizing certain behaviours. The Federal Government provides loans and subsidies for healthcare, education, housing and defense spending, so it shouldn't be a surprise that you end up with massive increases in house prices, tuition, healthcare and war costs.

Speaking as a 28 year who has not yet "grown up" (as defined by the nytimes), I think those of us who find ourselves in this situation shouldn't seek to blame anyone else, least of all the baby boomers. We should remember the good things that the baby boom generation in America has done, like:

- protesting the Vietnam war, which was started and heavily supported by the "greatest generation"

- pushing for Civil Rights legislation in the U.S. for women and minorities

- creating greater awareness of environmental problems, and spreading the belief that we must be proper stewards of our planet, not only for own survival but also for future generations

- developing the computer hardware, software and telecommunications industries, which has made an incredibly positive change in the lives of billions (including all of us here who have these advancements to thank for our livelihood)

DilipJ··on Is Greece entering a Death Spiral?
I think you mean inflate the currency. Deflation would make their debt burdens worse. But I agree, they are going to stagnate. The country owes its success over the last few decades to generous transfer payments from the EU. Now those transfer payments are going to the poorer former Soviet Bloc countries like Romania and Bulgaria. Greece is going to have to learn to rely more on itself, which means stripping down government expenses. Considering the strength the public unions have there, I think that's unlikely to happen.
DilipJ··on Valuable to others, or only you?
I think pg had a good essay on this topic: http://www.paulgraham.com/organic.html

basically, it says that it's better to try to create something that you want, because when you're young you will have a very difficult time understanding what someone else wants. Also, you are more likely to be motivated if you are creating something for yourself. Creating something for someone else is too much like work (without the salary)

DilipJ··on How money restricts life's pleasures
"The idea that money doesn’t make you happy is a lie spread by rich people so that the poor people don’t kill them."

-Michael Caine

DilipJ··on A World Without Intellectual Property
"We need to reward producers more and punish consumers so that Americans will produce more and consume less and rebuild our nation to its previous glory."

That's a very statist way of thinking, which is what Austrian/libertarians are opposed to. No libertarian should care about "rebuilding a nation's glory" because that's the sort of rhetoric heard from authoritarian nations.

It is natural for people to want to consume. The reason people produce is so that they can be able to consume later on. What the article states is that removing patent protection from society (which is in line with removing government interference in business) is feasible, because the originators of content/ideas would still be able to profit by branding and earlier entrance into the marketplace, as opposed to expecting a government-sanctioned monopoly.

DilipJ··on One wife for 2-3 brothers: Polyandry custom fading in India
It's very sad. In fact, the only state in India where there are more women than men (which is the natural state in most everywhere in the world) is Kerala, the state I'm from. I believe this is because the state has been run by the Communists for most of its post-independant history (which has also resulted in a 99% female literacy rate, again by far the highest in India).

Sometimes we forget about the social benefits communism has provided in certain parts of the world. I have no doubt, for example, that Afghanistan would be far healthier, wealthier and more advanced today if the Russians were not driven out in the 80s.

DilipJ··on Comments now cost 99 cents and your name.
Actually, I think this is likely the best way to deal with trolls. Having someone input their credit card gets rid (at least in their mind) of the anonymity that trolls thrive on.

The majority of the anonymous-posting news sites I have visited have been filled with trollish, often misspelled comments (on a side note: I think there must be a direct relationship between how poor a speller one is and their political leanings..). The NYTimes is the only major news source where I have found the majority of the online comments to have been written in a legible manner.

If HN grows too big or unruly to manage, I fully expect pg to implement credit card registration as well...

DilipJ··on Welcome to the Lost Decade (for Entrepreneurs, IPOs, and VCs)
Is that all we're about though? Building some silly widget, and then finding some sucker to buy it, and then laughing all the way to the bank? If that's the case, then how are we any different than the guys on Wall Street pushing credit swaps? That's not a sustainable model.

I agree that building a company to quickly flip or IPO is going to be increasingly difficult, but that doesn't mean there isn't room for growth and innovation in the field. After all, MS started during the recession of the 70's...

DilipJ··on Man claims to own 84% stake in Facebook - judge grants TRO in his favor
Yes, I think I read a story somewhere that during one of the VC rounds he was so nervous about the terms that he ended up curled up on the floor of the bathroom??

Anyway, I think he seems like an all around decent guy, and I admire anyone who has the guts to turn down a billion from Yahoo (especially at his age, and on his first business!) That shows vision and confidence, so I think he's the perfect CEO for Fb (which will likely one day have a market cap greater than Yahoo).

DilipJ··on Why Programming Isn’t For Me
Yes, I agree. It is like trying to write the Great American Novel, without knowing how to read or write English.

Now, you could get someone else to write it, and simply tell him the details and plot points you want, but without knowing how to read English, how would you know whether the story flowed right and was succinct?

DilipJ··on Conde Nast's Reddit Asks Users for Donations to Fix Site
The downvote probably came because you seemingly registered just to post a comment listing your politics. The fact that you think the downvote came because of a YC-related conflict of interest suggests that you suffer from some form of paranoia or a persecution complex.

Reddit appeals primarily (but not exclusively) to young males in their 20's and 30's. As a subgroup, they tend to lean libertarian, which is why they are more accepting of recreational drug use.

Reddit has a bright future, but maybe not with CN. They don't know how to monetize it properly, and they seem to be tethered to the glossy world of magazines. Considering the success Tina Brown has had in moving away from that via The Daily Beast, it looks like IAC would be a better fit for Reddit than CN.

DilipJ··on Conde Nast's Reddit Asks Users for Donations to Fix Site
The only reason they're begging is because they think they can squeeze money out of Reddit's loyal (and generous) userbase. The costs to improve Reddit is nothing to CN, considering the millions they must waste on Vogue parties and whatnot. The total cost to run Reddit is probably less than Anna Wintour's personal expense budget!

My guess is that this is the brilliant idea of the McKinsey guys, whom CN has asked to streamline their operations. Some bean counter MBA probably suggested that Reddit be put on an austerity program, and if CN keeps listening to them then Reddit won't have much of a future.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →