HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DmenshunlAnlsis

813 karma · joined April 12, 2018

submissionscomments
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Hackers at convention to ferret out election system bugs
Electronic banking is defrauded on a regular basis, including at the endpoint using jackpot schemes and more. It’s acceptable for banking given the amounts stolen are ultimately trivial, but not for voting.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on The cyclist behind an anti-cyclist Facebook group
A cyclist can cause a swerve and crash, or just be the one killed. You can argue in the latter case that the cyclist is the only one hurt, but fault aside, most people will be devestated if they kill someone else.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla Model 3 Is Replacing Toyota Prius as Green Car of Choice
I don't know anything about that, but if it’s not coordinated behavior then why would it run afoul of a detector? Maybe Muskies are just way more easily angered than everyone else, so their actions coordinate, but they’re doing it spontaneously?

I could be wrong, I just doubt that this adds up to more than the moderators being overworked and overwhelmed.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla Model 3 Is Replacing Toyota Prius as Green Car of Choice
As far as I can tell there are just two moderators, and this is a big website. Is it possible that they’re just focusing on what gets the most flags and not scouring every post? Maybe the pro-Tesla people flag articles critical of the brand in a way that gets moderator attention more than everyone else flags a post like this?

It seems more likely to me than any other explanation.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Musk’s Money Mystery Intrigues SEC
The article here has a lot of information that the one you linked to does not. I understand the fatigue, but this is no dupe.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Chemists discover how blue light speeds blindness
Here’s the actual study, thanks to sci-hub: http://twin.sci-hub.tw/6979/4112e16f7195f7f33cd3e861c6345df0...
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Apple Patent Turns Car Windscreen into Giant Augmented Reality Screen
That’s the POD-2, Pesky Occupant Detection. If it detects difficult friends, spouses, or in-laws a hefty dose of Versed is delivered to the passenger. Relief for the driver within minutes guaranteed!
DmenshunlAnlsis··on [dead]
Your freedom to not get vaccinated is impinging on my freedom not to die from some totally avoidable pathogen. When freedoms are incompatible someone’s freedom has to be curtailed. I vote for the irrational and dangerous freedom to be curtailed in favor of public health, in the same way that I don’t care about curtailing someone’s freedom to best me to death with a brick because they want to.

“Because freedom” isn’t an argument, isn’t a point being made, it’s nothing.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Children learn best when engaged in the living world, not on screens
Those unfortunate children would be robbed or the valuable skill set based on learning how to learn, how to seek knowledge when it’s not just a Google search away. Learning facts may seem useless, but again, it teaches you how to learn, how to study and synthesize new ideas then show you’ve learned them.

I like the glaciology bit though, and they should learn how to use Wikipedia and a library. Just don’t pithe your kids based on some wrongheaded notion of expediency or everyone else doing it.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on 3M Knew About the Dangers of PFOA and PFOS Decades Ago, Internal Documents Show
It is Magic, and a single container will last for so many rounds of popcorn you wouldn’t believe it. I found as a trick you add the falvacol to the popcorn and oil before popping, not after for the best results. Bonus? House smells like good, fresh theater corn!

Oh, and if you like buttered corn, add a teaspoon or two of clarified butter to the mix. Like kettle corn? Add some sugar to taste before popping. Like it cheesy? Buy some freeze dried cheddar and add it immediately after popping. If you’re feeling fancy, try some freshly grated parmasean. Cinnamon sugar also works well, as does powdered peanut butter, a bit of cocoa, and some confectioners sugar.

I love popcorn. :)

DmenshunlAnlsis··on 3M Knew About the Dangers of PFOA and PFOS Decades Ago, Internal Documents Show
So much better. It also lets you imitate movie theater flavors if that’s your thing, with refined coconut oil and some Flavocol. As a bonus you can find the kind of popping corn you prefer. For me, I love the smaller “hullless” varieties, they’re sweet and you don’t get stuff in your teeth.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Wikipedia bans agenda-driven editor, but punishes the messenger too
From development to widespread acceptance QM didn’t take very long, because of course it’s possible to test to a high degree of accuracy. Flat Earth was debunked many centuries (millennia really) ago, but still persists. I’m not sure how much more critique needs to be done, or what questions can be raised. Most people are aware of it, and rightly dismiss it. The only people who think it should be treated seriously are people who, believe in it.

So why entertain it? Because of some vague ideological opposition to curation? It seems to me, from experience at least, thst it usually has to do with a desire to use “universal acceptance” as an excuse to smuggle someone’s own pet crank idea into the mix. Creationists don’t seriously care about scientific inquiry or bias, they just started using those lines when legal bans on teaching evolution failed. Fascists and racists turned from trying to dominate society, to undermining it.

Once an idea has been thoroughly and comprehensively discredited it’s a waste of time at best, propaganda at worst. Yes, it can be challenging to deal with ideas on the borderline, and we should always try harder, but the solution isn’t intellectual nihilism. Ceasing to use any critical thinking because it might invite bias is a bad idea, and I think only really put forth by people who’s marginal ideas have no other hope of being heard.

After all, terrible ideas are documented, but there’s no moral, practical or intellectual reasons to document them everywhere.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla is building its own AI chips for self-driving cars
Again with the LIDAR argument... Humans drive using only eyes (computer vision) and having a sense of location (localization/3D maps).

As has been discussed in some depth here before you commented, computer vision hooked up to some ML doesn’t come close to human eyes controlled by a human brain trained for many years.

Early autonomous test vehicles used LIDARS because camera and compute tech are not at the same level they are today. It's a legacy system and more of a shortcut. In essence, Object recognition > LIDAR judging distances.

Waymo is the cutting edge if you believe what people here say on thread after thread about them, and the raw stats. I’m sure they’ll be interested to hear your view of their “legacy” tech.

Yeah it's true that a vision based system is much harder to solve. However if Tesla cracks it, it will pay dividends.

Finally, reality. Yes, if they do something they’re yet to do, and their cars stop ramming stationary objects, then maybe something else will happen. No one is contesting that, there are just doubts given the state of Autopilot vs. leaders in the field, not to mention Tesla’s dodgy PR in general, and in the face of fatal incidents in particular.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla is building its own AI chips for self-driving cars
That number always comes up, and it always needs to be said that a billion miles with driver assist and a billion miles under autopilot are not the same, and it’s a bogus figure. As to better than a human, it needs to be better than the humans who buy luxury sedans, sober, and awake. Better than a random selection of humans in a random selection of cars is no good. Conflating all vehicle deaths is like conflating all gun and knife violence; the average person on the streets of Chicago has far less risk of being shot than someone in a gang, or engaged in the commission of a felony. Yet you can make all of Chicago seem like a war zone by conflating the risks of different populations and dumping the raw statistics.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla is building its own AI chips for self-driving cars
Our eyes are incredibly advanced compared to any camera in existence, and hooked up to a real life AGI, and we still fuck up. No comparison. We meatbags are still far more sophisticated and battle tested than anything said meatbags managed to build, which is why so much of our building attempts to replicate our own capabilities.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla is building its own AI chips for self-driving cars
Just wait until they admit that they need LIDAR too... Cha Ching! Various Autopilot accidents strongly imply that whatever the computer “brain” is doing doesn’t matter if it doesn’t have sufficient “eyes” to actually see things like a fire truck, cop car, or bollard.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Wikipedia bans agenda-driven editor, but punishes the messenger too
What viewpoints do you feel are underrepresented? Personally I’m not convinced that all viewpoints require “airtime” and I’d prefer not to endure anti-vaxxer, flat earth, creationist, ariosophy, QAnon, or whatever David Icke is raving about today, in the name of “balance”.

When I go to an article about quantum mechanics, I don’t need a section on The Secret because it’s a “viewpoint” that exists. I want a curated experience, not the full hue and cry of the Internet. I also want to avoid undue bias, but that doesn’t mean a total abrogation or editorial policy.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Apple was overtaken by Huawei in global smartphone sales
If we’re calling 4 people killed a massacre, then the word has just lost all meaning. It was horrible, criminal, and infamous, but massacre is hyperbole especially when compared to the thousand+ (someone else in this thread posted a BBC article citing 10,000) killed at Tiananmen it’s not even remotely similar.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Apple was overtaken by Huawei in global smartphone sales
It’s still comparing the deaths of four people to the deaths of well over a thousand. On every level of the comparison it’s dishonest, from antecedent to impact to aftermath. There really is no comparison except thst both events are called “massacres” which really just tells you more about how many need to die at government hands in the US to achieve that status. If the government killed 1022 civilians in a comparable event in the US... honestly it’s hard to imagine. At the very least, it would be one of the most significant events of the century, and would be a lot more notorious than the already infamous Kent State shootings.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Apple was overtaken by Huawei in global smartphone sales
There’s a difference, namely that you can say “Kent State” and look it up online, read about it in textbooks, see the newspaper articles, and discuss it online without fear.

Try that with the Tiananmen Square massacre in China.

Another difference is that four civilians died in Kent state, while 1022 died in Tiananmen Square. That’s three orders of magnitude difference, and why Kent State is typically called “Kent State Shootings” while Tiananmen Square was a “Massacre”. In fact an order of magnitude more policemen and military died in Tiananmen than overall fatalities at Kent State.

They are not comparable. I’m fact more people died in Tiananmen than died protesting the entire Vietnam War in the US.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Thieves escape by motorboat after royal jewels heist in Sweden
Its not hard to imagine some Russian oligarch, Saudi prince, or American billionaire getting off on having these in their private collection.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on The Bullshit Web
Currently the price is free, and comes bundled with uMatrix, and a cookie flush. I’d like to pay the NYT for their journalism, but only with money, not the ability to track me. As a result they get no money, and no tracking.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Ask HN: Is Magic Leap just vaporware?
Yeah, but they’re delivering something so far from what was promised to get funding, and from the bulk of their patents that DNF is a better comparison. They promised the world, photonics magic, and they’re delivering a strikingly sub-par HoloLens.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on People are leaving Spotify over decision to host Alex Jones Infowars podcast
Wait, so you support freedom of expression, unless that expression pressures Spotify in this case? How do you relive that blatant contradiction in your thinking? People have a right to be intolerant of Alex Jones, unless you think his freedom to be a bloviating asshole somehow trumps other people’s freedom to be intolerant of him and any who carry him?
DmenshunlAnlsis··on People are leaving Spotify over decision to host Alex Jones Infowars podcast
In fact it’s antithetical to freedom of expression to require relay, because then you’re just dictating what a private entity can do in regards to their own expression. It comes from the same dark and ignorant place as people who want to see “Intelligent Design” taught alongside evolution. I doubt that the people who espouse this view believe it’s intellectually honest either, they just want their way and will say whatever it takes. Just like Creationists will do and say anything. (And have over 70 years) to get their way, even adopt some of the form of rational debate, without the substance.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on When Ramjets Ruled Science Fiction
Do you want Planet of The Apes? Because this is how you get Planet of The Apes!
DmenshunlAnlsis··on MH370 Was ‘Manipulated’ Off Course to Its End, Report Says
From the report, you’d seem to be totally on point.

To ascertain the probability of making calls inside an aircraft from differentaltitudes, a reconstructed flight using a King Air 350 over the said area andduring the same time when the signal “hit” happened was carried out shortlyafter the disappearance of MH370. The flight was conducted from an altitudeof 24,000 ft with step descents every 4,000 ft until 8,000 ft. The next descentwas to 5,000 ft but at 1,000 ft interval. An expert from a Telco service providerconducted the test using three different brands of phone and relatedequipment that were carried on board the King Air 350. Test call will beautomatically answered by the server in the event of connectivity. In summary, during the tests, it was found that it was difficult to maintainsuccessful call connectivity above 8,000 ft. However, one brand of phonewas able to make a call at 20,000 ft. Only one cell phone service providerrecorded the highest call attempts using their 3G network above 8,000 ft.Two service providers could only provide connection below 8,000 ft.

Earlier in the report the altitude was estimated to be between 24,000’ and 47,000’ so no cell would have worked.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on When Ramjets Ruled Science Fiction
I have never read the book, but “collapsar” was a term used before ‘Black Hole’ became popular as it is today.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on When Ramjets Ruled Science Fiction
I:was really confused for a second, until I realized they must mean Bussard ramjets, because standard ramjets are very much in use and lived up to the hype. It’s a good article, although I still disagree with some of it. In particular...

NAFAL trips mean crossing time as well as space. But that shouldn’t prevent exploration; anyone who would consider racing off that far into the future probably wouldn’t have friends and relatives about whom they deeply cared in any case.

Maybe, but subjectively a few years into your journey when tens of thousands of years have passed on Earth, and you’ve been totally forgotten, your technology is equivalent to rocks banging together, maybe you’d care? When you arrive in a subjective 30+ years and millions of years passed on Earth and people aren’t even remotely human anymore, and you’re a relic of a relic its going to be weird. Who are you exploring for exactly? Not humanity, they moved in without you, so unless it’s purely about starting a colony it’s a pointless exercise.

Even more galling would be the result you’d encounter if FTL turns out to be viable, unlikely as that seems today. You arrive in Andromeda only to discover that human colonized it a million+ years before your arrival. Whoops. Relativity is a stone cold bitch.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on The Masculine Mystique of T
I wasn’t concerned about no-brainers like grip-strength, which really in no way bears on the central claims made.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →