HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DmenshunlAnlsis

813 karma · joined April 12, 2018

submissionscomments
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who planted bombs
No Malcolm X in my history text, why's that? 'Cause he tried to educate and liberate all blacks. Why is Martin Luther King in my book each week? He told blacks, if they get smacked, turn the other cheek...

From ‘Words of Wisdom’ by Tupac Shakur, who made a very good point.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on GDPR Version of USA Today Is 500KB Instead of 5.2MB
People who say this, do you realize that if the market were left to its own devices cars would still be deathtraps without seatbelts?

The market isn’t magic, and the market we actually have is far from free.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Elon Musk, the Donald of Silicon Valley
Anonymous, crowdsourced, Sybil-prone “Truth” isn’t a good idea, and as a reaction to his own self-inflicted troubles is very childish indeed. He’s getting flack for being thin-skinned and bombastic, and that’s fair. He gets credit where it’s due too, such as SpaceX.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on A moon colony may be a reality sooner than we think
You can argue that, but of course the only non-LEO missions have all been government projects. It’s not as though Apollo missions were private endeavors after all. All of the US and European missions beyond LEO aren’t the function of the market. It’s also hard to see how the market would support long range probes and so much else that doesn’t offer a short term monetary reward.

Still, maybe you’re right, and reality is just waiting to catch up to your bold capitalist vision of market forces solving everything.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on A moon colony may be a reality sooner than we think
It’s not really a space industry, it’s a Low Earth Orbit Industry. It’s technically space, but only on the loosest sense. It’s good that we’re finally driving down the price of lifting cargo to LEO, but sad that we’ve almost given up on anything beyond that. The total world R&D budget for everything beyond LEO would impoverish a single pharmaceutical company’s marketimg budget, so we’re probably far from deserving backslapping and high fives.

Most of all, we’re far from colonies anywhere other than Earth, and barring a massive change of priorities as reflected in funding, that’s the future. Nothing about our ability to launch satellites a few hundred miles up translates to living on the Moon, or Mars.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Play-Doh’s scent is now trademarked
On that note...

A sweet, slightly musky, vanilla-like fragrance, with slight overtones of cherry, and the natural smell of a salted, wheat-based dough.

Let’s be real, it’s mostly the wheat dough.

They must be huffing Play-Doh fumes over at Hasbro legal.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Amazon device recorded private conversation, sent it out to random contact
That’s fair, but again, a smartphone fits that description too and nobody is talking about how you’d have to be crazy to let one in your house.

A lot of people talk about it, they’re just laughed or shouted down. There’s also the argument that mobile phones undoubtedly offer a number of incredibly useful tools, not the least of which is a primary phone line. I think anyone would be hard pressed to argue for commensurate utility from Alexa or similar products.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Amazon device recorded private conversation, sent it out to random contact
Trust is proportional to access. I don’t trust any third party with an always-on microphone in my house, especially one that’s networked. Malice aside, I don’t trust their competence.

Nor should anyone I think.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Should Psychiatry Test for Lead More?
A lack of definite knowledge isn’t an excuse to fantasize. Every time people have insisted that the gaps in our knowledge imply gods or ghosts, they’re rudely disabused. Every time we learn more about how things work, it turns out magic isn’t a factor at all. Meanwhile we really desperately want to believe in magic. It’s probsbly a good idea to be skeptical of God of The Gaps arguments that appeal to what we wish were true in the face of what appears to be more likely.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Bitcoin Gold Hit by Double Spend Attack, Exchanges Lose Millions
And MY point is that extrapolating too much from minimal data is unwise. If you’d like it put in historical terms, “...Let a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools of thought contend...”
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future?
I live in Belgium, so your assumptions really couldn’t fly farther from the mark.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Bitcoin Gold Hit by Double Spend Attack, Exchanges Lose Millions
Or you know, they love the idea of an immutable record that’s far from anonymous. Cash is hard to trace, a Bitcoin is easy to trace for something like the NSA. It’s a giant digital paper trail by design! Besides, Bitcoin is as likely to become a dominant currency as shells or promises. No one outside or BTC fanatics honestly entertain that idea, and only a few who do espouse it do so because they really think it’s likely. For obvious reasons hyping the currency translates directly into profit, so it’s hype all the way down.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Why Do Americans Stay When Their Town Has No Future?
The winters are also... bracing, to say the very least. If you like feet of snow, it’s great, otherwise maybe not so much. I love to visit, but I wouldn’t last a year.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Deadly Chinese Fentanyl Is Creating a New Era of Drug Kingpins
Making Ketamine harder for patients to access is going to destroy a lot of lives.

Even putting aside its use as a treatment for depression, restricting Ketamine was deemed unacceptable by the WHO, so don’t worry. It’s really really the only thing going if you need to intervene surgically and don’t have an OR.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Deadly Chinese Fentanyl Is Creating a New Era of Drug Kingpins
Fentanyl analogues are not a problem in China, hence the relative slowness in cracking down on them.

History suggests they will be. China happily exported and exports Ketamine, and are now dealing with a massive problem of heavy Ketamine addicts. It’s gotten so bad that they’ve lobbied internationally to sanction ketamine, which ran into a brick wall for good reasons.1

1 Ketamine is the only general anesthetic that doesn’t require loads of training and respiratory support to use, and as such is on the WHO lost of essentials.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on [dead]
Germany bans certain forms of expression, they don’t police thoughts. There is a difference.

@chroma: That’s a form of expression, but you’re not going to run afoul of the law for thoughts in your head, just the ones you share. I don’t mean offense, but I think you don’t actually know what a “thought crime” is. Read 1984, it’s worth it.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Comcast is leaking the names and passwords of customers’ wireless routers
You could probably find it in most peoples’ trash, reliably, intact, on a regular schedule.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Ask HN: How do I stop my neighbour flying their drone over my house?
Could you DIY something like this?

https://bgr.com/2015/10/16/drone-defender-rifle-radio-wave-g...

Or https://www.dailydot.com/debug/wi-fi-drone-disabler-raspberr...

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation
The Tesla’s stopping distance of 152 feet from 60 mph was far worse than any contemporary car we’ve tested and about 7 feet longer than the stopping distance of a Ford F-150 full-sized pickup.

That’s worrying, and almost as worrying is that Tesla says their braking is much faster. I’m sure plenty of fans will make comments about shorting stock, but this is Consumer Reports, and they have a very good reputation to protect.

I’m not thrilled by this tidbit either.

The Model 3’s stiff ride, unsupportive rear seat and excessive wind noise at highway speeds also hurt its road-test score. In the compact luxury sedan class, most competitors deliver a more comfortable ride and rear seat.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Predatory Behavior Runs Rampant in Facebook’s Addiction Support Groups
It’s very American, but not unique to America. Take for example Japan, which has an issue with homelessness like most other countries. One of the industries that’s emerged are “poverty businesses” which run private shelters as NPO’s. What they do is usually rent or buy unused corporate dormitories, put up some cheap walls and turn a double occupancy into 2-4 double occupancies. Then they get homeless people, hook them up with lawyers and help them to get their social welfare payments. So far so ok, but the end result is that they take up to 80% for room and very basic board.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Sci Hub repository torrents of scientific papers
In over twenty years of piracy, I’ve never actually met someone online who got something more than a pissy email from an ISP. It’s possible to be made an example of, but if you’re not profiting from the piracy it’s vanishingly unlikely. The only people I know of who got more than a token fine were involved in some other criminal enterprise besides just downloading something.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on In Silicon Valley, Chinese 'accelerators' aim to bring startups home
In theory, but the wallets of a few hundred families are deeper than everyone else’s combined. All it takes then, to make “vote with your wallet meaningless” is to introduce one or two major divisions in society and the elites can rest easy knowing they control lobbying as well. It would take a society-wide alliance to fight the influence of the Koch brothers, George Soros (and of course about half of the population only wants to fight one of them and not the other). When you factor in the money and power of corporations like Goldman Sachs and Exxon... well... don’t bother.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Bose's Awesome 'Magic Carpet' Suspension Is Making Production at Last
Lobbying. I can’t think of another practical reason that isn’t primarily based on fantasy. A digital speed limit could allow for a minute say, of exceeding the limit for the sake of evasive maneuvers, passing, etc. lobbying and public perception though, won’t allow it.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
Nothing about open source depends on invasion of privacy, unless what you’re open sourcing is data mining the public, in which case... blow.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on In Silicon Valley, Chinese 'accelerators' aim to bring startups home
In China the power to “reform” an issue is in the hands of a very few political elites. In the US it’s in the hands of a very few wealthy elites. It’s true that you can hope to have some influence through lobbying in a way that would be unthinkable in China, but it requires connections and vast sums of money.

If you try to challenge power structures in China directly they roll over you with tanks. The last time people em masse did the same in the US they were beaten, lynched, killed, jailed, firehosed and attacked with dogs.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-inflammatory environment
Oxidation of pectin produces a small quantity of formaldehyde as a metabolite. I’m not suggesting that you shouldn’t eat fruit or jams by the way, it’s just an example of how something considered broadly healthy still produces toxins that require elimination. Metabolism by its very nature produces energy and “exhaust” in the form of heat and metabolites. To be clear, you’re getting a lot more methanol metabolism from a drink of alcohol than an apple, so eat the fruit. No matter what we do we’re. It living forever based on diet, we should just try to avoid too much excess and accept that living isn’t a thermodynamically favorable process.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-inflammatory environment
Everything you metabolize both keeps you alive, and harms you. Like fruit? Well, pectin isn’t very good you in the long run. Metabolic activity is messy, produces toxins we need to Eli inste through urine and feces, and that’s that. We’re all dying, and no fantasy of a special diet can change that. While some diets are better for you than others, it’s not as laughably clear cut as “eating death” or whatever nonsense.

The very act of living produces toxins, period.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Bose's Awesome 'Magic Carpet' Suspension Is Making Production at Last
Yes, although I suppose it would be possible to build in some kind of exception to require it not to respond to them? Maybe you could even have “smart bumps” that would just be some location data pushed to the cloud that tells the suspension to “rumble” without the need for a real bump. Of course that would only work with very widespread adoption of the suspension.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on In Silicon Valley, Chinese 'accelerators' aim to bring startups home
While no country is perfect, the USA is still leaps and bounds ahead of China on human rights. As an example, what does the USA do that compares to this linked story?

I don’t know how convinced I am by this any more. Between the many wars, the torture, and slavery in the largest prison system on Earth it’s harder to argue. I still don’t want to live in a China, but I don’t want to live in the US either.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Physics Needs Philosophy. Philosophy Needs Physics
If physics removes itself even further from philosophy... it will slowly become a cesspool of rigid dogma, becoming blind to reality. Physics, as it is, is already lost in a jungle of abstractions, becoming more and more divorced from the real world.

That’s a strong and sweeping claim about a varied field, much of which is only concerned with experiments. Do you have anything like support for your claim? Remember that most of physics isn’t the highly popularized version of theoretical physics you may be familiar with.

Mathematical models are simply not equal to real world, even if we use models in an attempt to approximate, so that we can do useful things. Mathematics can never truly model reality.

No... shit? That’s why physics is dependent on observation and experiments, and why there is a division between physics and mathematics. We’re talking over the internet because of the concrete, useful things brought to us by physics.

The best it can do is a caricature, and not the real thing. Without solid philosophy to guide the scientists who drive the scientific institutions, the sciences fall stagnant, because it is philosophy that is the very bedrock and lifeblood of the scientific endeavour, in all fields. Without philosophy, that endless hunt and search for meaning and understanding, we lose our way.

How is philosophy in any way a cure for this imagined loss of rigor? The problem with physics according to you is a divorce from reality, and your solution is something even more abstract, less amenable to rigor, and famously fluid?

Huh?!

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →