HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DmenshunlAnlsis

813 karma · joined April 12, 2018

submissionscomments
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Hollywood Is Wrong: Netflix Is the Future of Film
My issue with theater popcorn isn’t the price, it’s the fact that it tastes like stale styrofoam covered in “buttery” oil, at least in America.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on E-waste recycler loses appeal on computer restore disks, must serve prison term
I’ve noticed that a lot of programmers I’ve met on and offline seem to think that it is, and often those kind of shallow perspectives are the basis of thought in the world of cryptocurrency as well. Is it the result of how computers and programs work, inasmuch as they just do precisely what they’re told? I’ve had to explain to so many friends that unlike the world of computers, laws are interpreted, and adapt. You can’t just find a bug and “win” because it will come back and bite you.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Death technology will allow to bring back the dead, digitally
Putting aside the philosophical implications, on a technical level this is still a complete fantasy. A good heuristic I like to apply to these kinds of sensationalist articles is to ask how much of the human brain we really understand. The answer is almost none, so recreating it in digital form, faithful to a specific person is science fiction.

What happened to Quartz? These days the articles are such crap.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Chart of the Milky Way Includes More Than 1B Stars
The majority of those planets are unsuited to anything we can imagine being alive, or only suitable for very simple unicellular life. Most of those plants are gas giants, or blazing hot gas giants. Some are rocky, but many of those are in orbits like Mercury, which would alternately bake and freeze them. Of course, part of the reason for this might be our detection methods, but as of now, we’re not finding. I hope like Earth, Venus, or Mars, while we find a lot of Jupiter’s. Maybe we’ll disocver that something like bacteria is ubiquitous, but that doesn’t imply much for our prospects of finding intelligent life. For all that we know life is common, but multicellular life is incredibly rare, or maybe it isn’t rare, but intelligent life is.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Ex-Facebook Executive: “You Don’t Realize It but You Are Being Programmed”
Human existence has always involved a lot of fighting and killing, but a single technology qualitatively changes the outcomes as a result: nuclear weapons. Even though it’s judt a more powerful bomb, it changes everything. Something can change our lives in unforeseen and devastating ways without being fundamentally new, and just a matter of degree.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on The case for hydrogen-powered cars
Hydrogen is a dream technology, but it comes with some caveats. Right now production tends to be linked to fossile fuels, either as a result of extraction, refinement, or from electrolysis powered by coal. Presently the only for this to scale and be green will be nuclear power, and the politics are poisonous around that in every way. It’s expensive to even try to build a plant, and without the political will to deal with the waste, it’s dsngerous too.

Then there’s storage of Hydrogen, which is manageable, but not trivial. Transportation is difficult, but again possible to manage given enough drive to make it work. Fuel cells also currently require expensive catalysts such as platinum. I don’t see any of these problems close to being approached, never mind solved.

This is a well written and comprehensive article, but I don’t feel it has answers to the central issues of scaling up the Hydrogen economy. On the other hand, Hydrogen can be green, while mass produced lithium batteries are anything, but.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on Airplanes that fly on electricity debut at Fresno’s Chandler Airport
I believe that you’re thinking of Helium. As @deelowe said, the issues with a Hydrogen are safe and stable storage, and the tendency of Hudrogen to penetrate metals and make them brittle. Producing hydrogen is trivial with electrolysis or water, which could be achieved using nuclear and renewable power sources. Of course burning coal to produce Hydrogen is currently cheaper and more common, and an environmental disaster.

The problem with Hydrogen is that you want to store it in big, strong metal containers, but it destroys the container and leaks out. So instead you store it in composite fiber containers, but then you have an explosive gas under pressure in a vessel that can be cracked.

This is part of the reason that research tends to focus on processes within fuel cells which produce hydrogen JIT, so you obviate the need to produce and store large volumes. The problem with that is the need for more power input than you get out, or the need for expensive catalysts like Platinum.

tl;dr

With current tech you need nuclear power to efficiently produce large volumes of Hydrogen, but that’s a political minefield.

Storing Hydrogen is a nightmare.

Hydrogen explodes, and peolle are rightfully wary of carrying and transporting it in large volumes.

The kinds of containers which are affordable and practical are made of materials Hydrogen readily attacks.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on A manufacturing process that produces long strips of high-quality graphene
Graphite is also used to make rocket exhaust nozzles; it is really thermally stable stuff. Diamond by contrast is much easier to burn. The good news is that if you want to dispose of graphene, just stick it with a lot of other graphene and make pencils. It’s not as though we worry about disposing of pencil “leads” after all.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on A manufacturing process that produces long strips of high-quality graphene
Helium is a strange bird. Every other element in liquid form will freeze if you drop the temperature enough, except Helium. You must greatly pressurize Helium for it to freeze. It is worth pointing out that while the atomic radius of Helium is smaller than Hydrogen, Helium is still the heavier element. It’s small radius and tendency to remain a gas or liquid makes it very useful in testing for leaks or as a purging gas.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Man Accused of Making 97M Robocalls
Their lobby is powerful, and the ideology of many in tech leans to libertarian and away from regulation.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Tesla switching to 24/7 shifts to push for more model 3s by June
Most of the design tolerances of the Model 3 are already better than any other car in the world. Soon, they will all be better. This is not enough. We will keep going until the Model 3 build precision is a factor of ten better than any other car in the world. I am not kidding.

I’d settle for precision beating their previous janky models with a nearly 50% recall rate.

Our car needs to be designed and built with such accuracy and precision that, if an owner measures dimensions, panel gaps and flushness, and their measurements don’t match the Model 3 specs, it just means that their measuring tape is wrong.

Right, and if their “autopilot” kills them, they were using it wrong.

There is a very wide range of contractor performance, from excellent to worse than a drunken sloth. All contracting companies should consider the coming week to be a final opportunity to demonstrate excellence. Any that fail to meet the Tesla standard of excellence will have their contracts ended on Monday.

This whole letter reads like a puff piece intended for fanboys and stakeholders to pass around and fantasize about, but three weeks of meeting goals shouldn’t give anyone a head this big. This is from the same guy who just realized he couldn’t automate everything he wanted to, and who the NTSB just booted off a death investigation. The last thing needed here is grandiose talk.

Instead of trying to leap from being marginal to the greatest ever, how about trying to meet reasonable goals, safety standards, and work with the NTSB? Instead of trying for Ferrari-esque panel gaps, just do better than the Model S and meet basic industry standards within class.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on The Boring Company raises $112M from Musk, early employees
You kinda missed the main point. Musk's business is focused entirely on improving existing, proven, old technologies.

So we’re all in agreement then, very good.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on The Boring Company raises $112M from Musk, early employees
He making his money on cars with lithium batteries, and chemical rockets. That’s where he’s spending and making his billions. He’s dropping 3.8% of his recent $2.6 billion award on this project.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Text Embedding Models Contain Bias
If those banks had to turn to the government to keep them afloat, and those banks played a large role in creating the problem in the first place, maybe you do? Maybe not, but what you definitely don’t do is set up black boxes to take the heat for centuries of prejudice and mistreatment.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on The Boring Company raises $112M from Musk, early employees
That’s all very much not what I see when I look at Tesla, it’s just the marketing. The reality is someone getting another $2.6 billion, while desperate-to-believe people cheer him on because they think it’s part of a master plan to save them. I’m not part of the Church of Musk, sorry, I’m an empiricist.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Text Embedding Models Contain Bias
It sounds like a way to set up a positive feedback loop with terrible consequences to me. I don’t know enough about ML to be sure, but I know GIGO. If you feed bias into a model then let the model guide decision making, that seems obviously flawed. You bias the model not to give loans or credit to black people, reinforcing their lack of credit, which leads to the model confirming its bias. Maybe you can claim it’s a socioeconomic bias and not racist, and in some countries it would be true, but not in America. How long ago was it that black people had to fight past mobs to integrate schools? How long since redlining? If socioeconomic are tied to a history of oppression based on race, then ignoring half of that equation isn’t honest. Correlation is not causation, but does “AI” know that?
DmenshunlAnlsis··on The Boring Company raises $112M from Musk, early employees
It’s hard to take him seriously in terms of mass transit when he talks about vacuum trains as though they’re not a terrible idea. Then you remember he owns a company that plans to ultimately replace airlines in some markets with rockets, and a car company, and a person not overly taken with his “charisma” wonders if his interest in mass transit is in scuttling it.

If he was serious about mass transit there are existing, proven technologies he could get behind with his billions, rather than hyperloop. Instead he proposes a technology that is entrancing to people who don’t know enough about engineering and physics, and that is exciting. Unfortunately the tech isn’t workable, it’s just exciting, but it could take a decade or more for that to become apparent to most people.

Wikipedia has an excellent article which lays out the history of the concept going back to the 18th century. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vactrain

I love the understatement of “prohibitively expensive” too, very droll. Any experimentalist who has worked with strong vacuums knows how absurd the idea of a hyperloop is at this point. The expense, the maintence costs, the airlocks, the pumps, all would be an incredible expense that could never be recouped in the builder’s lifetime. The actual tunneling would have to be totally revolutionary too, with incredibly long, nearly straight sections. The turning radius would have to be on the order of of a commercial airliner’s turning radius, which is absurd.

Credit to the man though, it hits that sweet spot requiring specialist knowledge to see through the hype, much like promises of nuclear fusion as a major power source within a couple of decades. The big idea is so attractive, and the problems all involve technical details. It’s not quite a con, but it’s close.

DmenshunlAnlsis··on On the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant 10,000 Year Marker System
That sign depends on the circle-cross symbol, nuclear warning symbol, and bottles all being meaningful 10,000 years from now. We have trouble deciphering symbols from less than half thst long ago. Your point about mining could be true, unless some geological event makes it more accessible.
DmenshunlAnlsis··on Publisher Gets Carte Blanche to Seize New Sci-Hub Domains
A lot of people could appeal the ruling, including the Wikimedia foundation if they were being forced to remove those links. I’m not sure, but my impression of this ruling is that it would probably be overturned on appeal.
← PreviousPage 7 of 7